Skip to content

Knowledge Lab · Plates

Teaching visuals

Original diagrams that teach structure: what happened when, how ideas divide, how institutions stack, how positions compare and who connects to whom. Each is drawn from the platform’s content, with its sources.

Five ways of drawing structure

16visuals

Timeline
2
Classification
2
Layered architecture
4
Comparison matrix
4
Relationship map
4

Index of plates

IB Diploma Programme

IB Global Politics

The key concepts and thematic studies drawn as classifications, comparisons, timelines and architectures, with a stakeholder map for a case study.

Plate 01ClassificationOriginal

Forms and theories of power

Five ways of classifying power, from Nye's hard, soft and smart power to Barnett and Duvall's taxonomy, grouped so that each classification can be read as a lens that reveals some mechanisms and hides others.

  1. 01 · 3 entries

    Nye: hard, soft and smart

    • Hard power

      Getting others to act through command: the sticks of threats and force and the carrots of payment, sanctions relief or aid tied to compliance. The mechanism decides the category, not the instrument: aid given on condition that a recipient change its vote is hard power.

      More detail

      Hard power is the easiest to count, which is why it dominates rankings, but resources do not convert automatically into outcomes. The United States held overwhelming military superiority throughout its twenty years in Afghanistan, yet the Taliban returned to Kabul in August 2021.

    • Soft power

      Getting others to want the outcomes one wants, through attraction rather than coercion or payment. Nye, who introduced the term in 1990, locates its sources in culture, political values and foreign policies seen as legitimate. It is hard to measure and largely outside governments' control.

      More detail

      India's attraction rests on the reach of its cinema, the International Day of Yoga proclaimed by the UN General Assembly in 2014 and a large diaspora, but attraction does not automatically become votes, investment or security. Nye set out the idea at length in Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics (2004).

    • Smart power

      The deliberate combination of hard and soft power so that each reinforces rather than undercuts the other. Nye treats it as a strategy, not a third kind of resource, so the analytical question is whether coercion is spending the attraction that makes cooperation cheap.

      More detail

      Pairing climate finance with diplomatic pressure is a smart-power strategy. Ukraine after February 2022 showed conversion in the other direction: international sympathy was turned into weapons, finance and sanctions on its behalf.

  2. 02 · 3 entries

    Lukes: three dimensions

    • First dimension: decision-making

      Power is visible in observable conflicts over decisions: A prevails over B in a contested choice. This is Robert Dahl's behavioural view (1957). Its strength is that it can be tested; its weakness is that it cannot see issues that never reach the table.

      More detail

      Analytical question: who won the vote or the negotiation, and against whose stated preference? Dahl's definition is that A has power over B to the extent that A can get B to do something B would not otherwise do.

    • Second dimension: agenda-setting

      Power also works by keeping issues off the agenda, so that some grievances never become decisions at all. Peter Bachrach and Morton Baratz called this non-decision-making (1962). Procedural rules such as consensus are typical instruments, because they let one actor block without ever losing a vote.

      More detail

      At COP30 in Belém in November 2025 a large coalition pressed for a roadmap away from fossil fuels, but under a consensus rule the final text contained none: the decisive act was a non-decision that a vote count would not reveal.

    • Third dimension: shaping preferences

      The most effective power shapes what people want, so that they accept arrangements that harm them because those arrangements seem natural. Steven Lukes added this dimension in 1974. Critics ask who decides people's real interests; Lukes replies that ignoring preference-shaping hides power's deepest forms.

      More detail

      Analytical question: what was never imagined as a choice? Lukes's argument is in Power: A Radical View (1974; second edition 2005). The assumption that continued economic growth is not negotiable, shared even by those most exposed to climate change, is a standard illustration.

  3. 03 · 2 entries

    Strange: relational and structural

    • Relational power

      The power of A to get B to do something in a particular interaction, the kind Robert Dahl measured. Susan Strange did not dismiss it, but argued that in the world economy it increasingly mattered less than the power to shape the arena in which bargains are struck.

      More detail

      The IB guide's examples treat alliances and collective civil movements as relational power, and membership of the UN Security Council as structural power.

    • Structural power

      The power to shape the frameworks within which states, firms and people relate to one another: to decide how things shall be done. Strange identified four structures, security, production, finance and knowledge. An actor with no edge in a particular negotiation can still prevail because it built the arena.

      More detail

      Strange's argument is in States and Markets (1988). Cutting several Russian banks off from the SWIFT messaging network in 2022 was structural power in finance; US export controls on advanced chips from October 2022, later aligned with Dutch and Japanese measures, were structural power over production and knowledge.

  4. 04 · 4 entries

    Barnett and Duvall: four concepts

    • Compulsory power

      Direct control of one actor by another through interaction: A shapes B's circumstances or actions, whether by force, sanctions or the threat of them. In Michael Barnett and Raymond Duvall's taxonomy (2005) it is the concept closest to realism's and Dahl's understanding of power.

      More detail

      A tariff imposed to force a change of policy is compulsory power. Barnett and Duvall stress that non-state actors can exercise it too, as when campaigners use shame and moral authority to compel a government to change course.

    • Institutional power

      Indirect control exercised through the rules and procedures of institutions, which favour some actors over others over time even when no one is giving orders. Weighted voting in the IMF, where the United States holds enough votes to block decisions needing an 85 per cent majority, is the standard example.

    • Structural power (Barnett and Duvall)

      Power that constitutes actors' capacities and identities through their positions in social relations, such as capital and labour. It works not by one actor acting on another but by defining what kind of actor each can be. Strange's structural power spans this type and the institutional one.

      More detail

      The position of commodity exporters in the world economy shapes what their governments can choose before any negotiation begins.

    • Productive power

      Power that works through discourse and systems of knowledge, producing the categories by which actors are known, such as 'developed', 'fragile' or 'responsible'. It is diffuse, owes much to Michel Foucault, and overlaps with Lukes's third dimension, because it shapes what can be thought and said.

      More detail

      Algorithms that decide what billions of people see exercise productive power at scale, which is why regulation of artificial intelligence can be read as a contest over who frames the technology.

  5. 05 · 2 entries

    Economic and normative power

    • Economic power

      Power resting on market size, credit, investment, resources and the capacity to sanction or reward. It is a currency that does not exchange at a fixed rate: interdependence cuts both ways, so sanctions cost those who impose them, and wealth does not automatically buy attraction or legitimacy.

      More detail

      Europe's reliance on Russian gas before 2022 showed how dependence becomes vulnerability, and concern about China's dominance of critical-mineral processing drives much of the politics of battery supply chains.

    • Normative power

      The ability to shape what counts as normal or appropriate in world politics. Ian Manners (2002) applied the term to the European Union, whose influence lies in spreading norms rather than in force. Anu Bradford's 'Brussels effect' describes EU rules adopted worldwide because firms want access to its market.

      More detail

      Critics note that the Brussels effect rests on the size of the European market, so normative and economic power are hard to separate. The EU AI Act is the course's test case.

Sources9
  1. 01International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024
  2. 02Robert A. Dahl, 'The Concept of Power', Behavioral Science 2:3 (1957)
  3. 03Peter Bachrach and Morton S. Baratz, 'Two Faces of Power', American Political Science Review 56:4 (1962)
  4. 04Steven Lukes, Power: A Radical View (Macmillan, 1974; 2nd edn, Palgrave Macmillan, 2005)
  5. 05Susan Strange, States and Markets (Pinter, 1988)
  6. 06Joseph S. Nye Jr., Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics (PublicAffairs, 2004)
  7. 07Michael Barnett and Raymond Duvall, 'Power in International Politics', International Organization 59:1 (2005)
  8. 08Ian Manners, 'Normative Power Europe: A Contradiction in Terms?', Journal of Common Market Studies 40:2 (2002)
  9. 09Anu Bradford, The Brussels Effect: How the European Union Rules the World (Oxford University Press, 2020)

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Power in global politics

Plate 02TimelineOriginal

Sovereignty from Westphalia to the present

Seventeen moments that show sovereignty changing shape: from the Westphalian symbol and the UN Charter through decolonisation and the responsibility to protect to contested recognitions in 2025, where law supplies the vocabulary and power often decides.

  1. Peace of Westphalia

    Treaties signed at Münster and Osnabrück end the Thirty Years' War. The settlement became shorthand for a system of territorial states recognising no outside authority over their internal affairs, though historians such as Andreas Osiander show that system was consolidated over centuries rather than founded in 1648.

    More detail

    Westphalian sovereignty, in Stephen Krasner's terms, is the exclusion of external actors from domestic authority. Treating 1648 as a founding date also hides how long European states denied sovereignty to the peoples they colonised.

  2. Montevideo Convention

    American states sign the Convention on the Rights and Duties of States, whose criteria of statehood are a permanent population, a defined territory, a government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. It also declares that a state's political existence is independent of recognition by others.

    More detail

    This is the declaratory theory of statehood. The rival constitutive theory holds that recognition creates a state; practice since 1945, from Kosovo to Somaliland, sits uneasily between the two.

  3. UN Charter signed

    Fifty states sign the Charter at San Francisco; it enters into force on 24 October 1945. It affirms the sovereign equality of members (Article 2(1)), prohibits the threat or use of force against any state's territorial integrity (2(4)) and bars UN intervention in domestic matters (2(7)), subject to Security Council enforcement.

    More detail

    The Charter also proclaims the self-determination of peoples (Article 1(2)), a principle that pulls against territorial integrity whenever a people within a state seeks to leave.

  4. Declaration on decolonisation

    The General Assembly adopts resolution 1514 (XV), declaring that subjecting peoples to alien domination denies fundamental human rights and that all peoples have the right to self-determination. Decolonisation universalised the sovereign state: UN membership grew from 51 founding members to 193.

    More detail

    Postcolonial critics such as Walter Mignolo argue that formal independence spread a European model of the state without ending structural inequality, so decolonisation universalised sovereignty and hierarchy together.

  5. Maastricht Treaty: pooled sovereignty

    Twelve European states sign the Treaty on European Union, in force from 1 November 1993, creating economic and monetary union. Members pool authority in supranational institutions whose law has primacy over national law; the United Kingdom's exit in 2020 showed that pooled sovereignty can still be taken back.

    More detail

    Whether pooling is a loss or an exercise of sovereignty is the core debate: states chose to join, and the UK left on 31 January 2020 under the withdrawal clause of Article 50 of the Treaty on European Union.

  6. NATO's Kosovo intervention

    NATO begins air strikes against the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia to stop the repression of Kosovo Albanians, without Security Council authorisation, which Russian and Chinese opposition made unobtainable. Supporters called it humanitarian necessity, critics a breach of Article 2(4). The dilemma led to the idea of a responsibility to protect.

    More detail

    The Independent International Commission on Kosovo later called the intervention 'illegal but legitimate', a phrase that captures the gap between law and legitimacy.

  7. World Summit endorses the responsibility to protect

    The World Summit Outcome (paragraphs 138–139) commits every state to protect its population from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity, and declares states prepared to act collectively through the Security Council, case by case, where a state manifestly fails. It created no new authority to use force.

    More detail

    The International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, set up by Canada, had argued in December 2001 that sovereignty implies responsibility; the Summit endorsed a narrower version. Brazil's 2011 proposal of 'responsibility while protecting' later sought stricter accountability for any use of force.

  8. Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples

    The General Assembly adopts the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (resolution 61/295), affirming self-determination exercised mainly through autonomy and self-government within existing states. Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States voted against, though all four later endorsed it.

    More detail

    Indigenous claims often rest on relationships to land and law that predate the colonial state, which is why they are treated as alternative notions of sovereignty rather than as demands for secession.

  9. Kosovo declares independence

    Kosovo's leaders declare independence from Serbia, nine years after NATO's intervention and a period of UN administration. The United States and most EU states recognise it; Serbia, Russia, China and five EU members do not. Kosovo has partial recognition and no UN seat, and the number of recognising states is disputed.

  10. ICJ advisory opinion on Kosovo

    Answering a General Assembly request made at Serbia's initiative, the International Court of Justice advises that Kosovo's declaration of independence did not violate international law. The Court answered a narrow question: it did not decide whether Kosovo is a state or whether international law confers a right to secede.

    More detail

    Law supplied the vocabulary, but outcomes followed consent and power: secession has succeeded where the parent state agreed or powerful states backed it.

  11. Resolution 1973 on Libya

    The Security Council authorises 'all necessary measures' to protect civilians in Libya, the high point of the responsibility to protect. Brazil, China, Germany, India and Russia abstain. The NATO-led operation that followed was widely seen, above all in Moscow and Beijing, to have slid into regime change.

    More detail

    The backlash shaped Syria: Russia and China vetoed repeated draft resolutions, including a 2014 referral to the International Criminal Court, and survivors later sought justice in national courts abroad.

  12. South Sudan joins the UN

    Five days after independence, South Sudan becomes the 193rd member of the United Nations, following a referendum held under the 2005 peace agreement with Khartoum. It remains the latest new member: since then the club of sovereigns has admitted no one, whatever claimants' effective control.

    More detail

    Secession with the parent state's consent, as here, has proved the reliable route to membership; Somaliland, Kosovo and Palestine show how far effective control, recognition and membership can come apart.

  13. General Assembly on Ukraine's territorial integrity

    After Russia annexes Crimea following a referendum held under Russian military control, the General Assembly adopts resolution 68/262, affirming Ukraine's territorial integrity and declaring that the referendum has no validity. With 100 states in favour, 11 against and 58 abstaining, the vote shows how many states avoid taking sides.

  14. ICJ advisory opinion on the Chagos Archipelago

    The International Court of Justice advises that Mauritius's decolonisation was not lawfully completed at independence in 1968, because Britain had detached the Chagos Archipelago, and that the United Kingdom is obliged to end its administration as rapidly as possible. Advisory opinions do not bind, but this one reshaped the dispute.

    More detail

    A UK–Mauritius treaty signed on 22 May 2025 would transfer sovereignty while the UK keeps rights over the Diego Garcia base for an initial 99 years. It had not entered into force by October 2026, after the UK paused it for want of US support.

  15. Russia recognises the Taliban government

    Russia becomes the first state formally to recognise the Taliban's Islamic Emirate, almost four years after the Taliban took Kabul. The Taliban control the whole country, yet as of November 2026 Russia remained the only state to recognise them, showing that effective control does not compel recognition.

    More detail

    Others engage without recognising: China accepted the credentials of a Taliban-appointed ambassador in January 2024, and several neighbours and Gulf states host Taliban-appointed diplomats.

  16. Western states recognise Palestine

    The United Kingdom, Canada and Australia recognise the State of Palestine, and France follows the next day at the United Nations. Palestine is now recognised by a large majority of UN members but lacks control of its territory and full membership, which a US veto blocked in April 2024.

    More detail

    Recognition is a political signal as much as a legal act: a state recognised by most UN members still cannot join without a Security Council recommendation, where a permanent member's veto decides.

  17. Israel recognises Somaliland

    Israel becomes the first UN member state to recognise Somaliland, which declared in 1991 that it had restored the independence it held briefly in 1960. Somalia, the African Union and several states condemn the move. Somaliland has effective government, elections and a currency, but recognition from almost no one.

    More detail

    Somalia's federal government claims the territory, and the African Union upholds the principle that borders inherited at independence should be respected. Somaliland's profile, effective control without recognition, is the reverse of Somalia's.

Sources15
  1. 01Charter of the United Nations (1945) (opens in a new tab). United Nations
  2. 02Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (Montevideo, 1933)
  3. 03UN General Assembly resolution 1514 (XV), Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples (1960)
  4. 04UN General Assembly resolution 60/1, 2005 World Summit Outcome, paragraphs 138–139
  5. 05UN General Assembly resolution 61/295, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007)
  6. 06International Court of Justice, Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence in respect of Kosovo, Advisory Opinion of 22 July 2010. International Court of Justice
  7. 07International Court of Justice, Legal Consequences of the Separation of the Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius in 1965, Advisory Opinion of 25 February 2019. International Court of Justice
  8. 08UN Security Council resolution 1973 (2011) and UN General Assembly resolution 68/262 (2014)
  9. 09International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, The Responsibility to Protect (2001)
  10. 10Stephen D. Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (Princeton University Press, 1999)
  11. 11Andreas Osiander, 'Sovereignty, International Relations, and the Westphalian Myth', International Organization 55:2 (2001)
  12. 12Axios, 'UK, Canada and Australia formally recognize Palestinian state' (opens in a new tab), 21 September 2025
  13. 13The National, 'Israel recognises Somalia's breakaway Somaliland region as independent state' (opens in a new tab), 26 December 2025
  14. 14The Tribune, 'Russia becomes first country to formally recognise Taliban government in Afghanistan' (opens in a new tab), July 2025
  15. 15Al Jazeera, 'UK-Mauritius Chagos sovereignty deal stalls amid fears of further delays' (opens in a new tab), 2 October 2026

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Sovereignty in global politics

Plate 03Comparison matrixOriginal

Sources of legitimacy compared

Weber's three types of authority, the input, output and throughput legitimacy of governance, and international recognition, compared by what each rests on, where it is found, what it does well and how it is lost.

Weber's ideal types

  1. Traditional authority

    Obedience rests on custom and the sanctity of long-established ways, so the ruler's right is inherited rather than earned. Max Weber offered it as an ideal type: real regimes mix it with other sources, as constitutional monarchies combine hereditary heads of state with elected governments.

    Basis
    Custom and inherited status: rulers are obeyed because things have always been so.
    Example
    Hereditary monarchy in Eswatini or Saudi Arabia; customary chiefs whose authority rests on lineage.
    Strength
    Deeply rooted and cheap to sustain: obedience needs little justification while the tradition is shared.
    Vulnerability
    Education, urbanisation and social change erode belief in custom; disputed successions expose its arbitrariness.
  2. Charismatic authority

    Obedience rests on devotion to an individual believed to have exceptional qualities, often in moments of crisis or revolution. Weber argued that it is inherently unstable: unless it is routinised into rules and offices, it faces a crisis when the leader dies or fails.

    Basis
    Personal devotion to a leader's perceived exceptional qualities, vision or heroism.
    Example
    Gandhi's moral authority in the national movement; Nelson Mandela's standing during South Africa's transition.
    Strength
    Mobilises followers quickly and can legitimise radical change that existing rules would block.
    Vulnerability
    Succession crises and dependence on continued success; leaders may treat constraining institutions as illegitimate.
  3. Legal-rational authority

    Obedience is owed to impersonal rules and to offices defined by them, not to the person who holds them. It is the dominant modern form, embodied in constitutions and bureaucracies, but legality is not the same as legitimacy: a law can be valid and widely rejected.

    Basis
    Belief that rules were properly enacted and that officials act within their legal powers.
    Example
    Constitutional democracies such as India, where office-holders change by election and courts review official action.
    Strength
    Predictable and transferable: authority survives changes of personnel because it belongs to the office.
    Vulnerability
    Rules seen as unjust or captured lose belief; legality without shared justification and consent is fragile.

Legitimacy of governance

  1. Input legitimacy

    Government by the people, in Fritz Scharpf's phrase: decisions are legitimate because those affected took part in making them through elections, representation and participation. National democracies score well; global bodies, whose decision-makers are distant from those affected, score poorly, the democratic deficit David Held analysed.

    Basis
    Participation and representation of those affected: free elections, voice and consent.
    Example
    Direct elections to the European Parliament; general elections in which the governed periodically choose who governs.
    Strength
    Consent survives bad years: a government chosen fairly keeps its right to rule through a recession.
    Vulnerability
    Low turnout, unequal representation and remote global institutions weaken it; majorities can still disregard minorities.
  2. Output legitimacy

    Government for the people: authority is accepted because it solves problems that people cannot solve alone, delivering security, welfare and effective policy. International institutions rely heavily on it, and so do states that lack credible elections and seek acceptance through growth and order instead.

    Basis
    Effective results: problems solved, public goods delivered, welfare and security provided.
    Example
    The WHO-coordinated eradication of smallpox; single-party states in East Asia legitimised by rapid growth.
    Strength
    Visible, measurable and available to bodies that no electorate chose.
    Vulnerability
    Performance fails in crises: economic collapse in Sri Lanka in 2022 became a legitimacy crisis for its government.
  3. Throughput legitimacy

    Vivien Schmidt's addition (2013): legitimacy also depends on the quality of the governance process itself, its efficacy, accountability, transparency, inclusiveness and openness to consultation. Good process rarely builds legitimacy on its own, but opaque or captured procedures can undermine the legitimacy that inputs and outputs provide.

    Basis
    Quality of the procedures between input and output: accountability, transparency, inclusiveness and openness to consultation.
    Example
    Schmidt's critique of opaque euro-area crisis decision-making, which eroded trust in EU governance.
    Strength
    Applies where elections are absent, giving global bodies a standard they can actually meet.
    Vulnerability
    Asymmetric: good process goes unnoticed, while secrecy or capture by insiders delegitimises quickly.

External legitimacy

  1. International recognition

    External acknowledgement by other states and international bodies that an entity is a state, or that a government speaks for it. Recognition unlocks treaties, credit, trade and seats, but it is given for reasons of interest as well as principle and says nothing about acceptance at home.

    Basis
    Acceptance by other states and by bodies such as the UN Credentials Committee or regional organisations.
    Example
    The Taliban control Afghanistan, but by November 2026 only Russia recognised them; Palestine has wide recognition without UN membership.
    Strength
    Brings access to treaties, finance, aid and diplomatic standing that strengthen state capacity.
    Vulnerability
    Political and reversible: it can be withheld, withdrawn or suspended, and cannot manufacture consent at home.
Sources6
  1. 01International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024
  2. 02Max Weber, 'Politics as a Vocation' (1919) and Economy and Society (1922)
  3. 03David Beetham, The Legitimation of Power (Macmillan, 1991)
  4. 04Fritz W. Scharpf, Governing in Europe: Effective and Democratic? (Oxford University Press, 1999)
  5. 05Vivien A. Schmidt, 'Democracy and Legitimacy in the European Union Revisited: Input, Output and "Throughput"', Political Studies 61:1 (2013)
  6. 06David Held, Democracy and the Global Order (Polity, 1995)

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Legitimacy in global politics

Plate 04Layered architectureOriginal

The architecture of global governance

Six tiers of global governance, from the UN's universal organs to private standard-setters, showing where binding authority, weighted voting, consensus, pooled sovereignty and informal steering each sit, and why no tier amounts to world government.

  1. 01 · 4 entries

    The UN system

    • General Assembly

      Every UN member sits with one vote, embodying sovereign equality. The Assembly debates any matter within the Charter, approves the budget and elects members of other organs, but outside budgetary and internal matters its resolutions are recommendations: legitimacy without much power.

      More detail

      Workarounds give it leverage: the 'Uniting for Peace' resolution of 1950 lets it meet when the Security Council is deadlocked, and since a 2022 decision it meets whenever a permanent member casts a veto.

    • Security Council

      Fifteen members, five of them permanent and holding a veto. It has primary responsibility for international peace and security, its decisions bind all members under Article 25, and under Chapter VII it can impose sanctions and authorise force. It is weakest when a permanent member is party to a conflict.

      More detail

      The veto was the price of keeping the great powers inside after the League of Nations had watched them stay out or leave. Reform is blocked because the five would have to agree to dilute their own privilege.

    • Other principal organs

      The Economic and Social Council (54 members) coordinates economic and social work; the International Court of Justice settles disputes between consenting states and gives advisory opinions; the Secretariat administers. The Trusteeship Council has been suspended since 1994, when Palau, the last trust territory, became independent.

    • Specialised agencies, funds and programmes

      Technical bodies with their own constitutions and budgets, such as the WHO, ILO, FAO, UNESCO and ITU, are linked to the UN by agreement; funds and programmes such as UNDP, UNICEF and UNHCR depend on voluntary contributions. They deliver the task-centred cooperation David Mitrany advocated.

      More detail

      The WHO-coordinated eradication of smallpox, certified in 1980, is the classic success. Because much funding is voluntary and earmarked, donors shape priorities, and the agencies are exposed when major contributors cut back.

  2. 02 · 2 entries

    Bretton Woods institutions

    • International Monetary Fund

      Created at Bretton Woods in 1944 to oversee the international monetary system and lend, on conditions, to members in balance-of-payments difficulty. Votes follow quotas, so the United States, with about 16.5 per cent, can block decisions needing 85 per cent, and by convention a European leads it.

      More detail

      Conditionality leaves sovereignty formally intact while narrowing policy choices, as Sri Lanka's programme, approved in March 2023 after its default, shows.

    • World Bank Group

      The second Bretton Woods institution, the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, now sits in a group of five that lends to governments, invests in private firms, insures investors and hosts investor–state arbitration. Voting follows shareholding, and by convention an American has led it.

      More detail

      The International Development Association, added in 1960, gives the poorest countries grants and low-interest credits funded by donor replenishments; affected communities can complain to an independent Inspection Panel created in 1993.

  3. 03 · 2 entries

    World Trade Organization

    • WTO rules and the Ministerial Conference

      Established on 1 January 1995, the WTO administers binding agreements on trade in goods and services and on intellectual property. It decides by consensus, which gives every member, large or small, a blocking power and has made comprehensive rounds such as Doha, launched in 2001, nearly impossible to conclude.

    • Dispute settlement and the Appellate Body

      Panels and a standing Appellate Body made trade rules enforceable until the United States blocked appointments and the Appellate Body lost its quorum on 11 December 2019. Losing parties can now appeal 'into the void'; an interim arbitration arrangement covers only its participants, which do not include the United States or India.

  4. 04 · 3 entries

    Regional organisations

    • European Union

      The deepest regional organisation: members pool sovereignty in a Commission, Parliament, Council and Court whose law has direct effect and primacy over national law. Qualified majority voting can bind outvoted members, while foreign policy, taxation and enlargement still require unanimity.

    • African Union

      Its Constitutive Act (2000) replaced the OAU's strict non-interference with a right to intervene in a member state in grave circumstances, namely war crimes, genocide and crimes against humanity, and it suspends governments that seize power unconstitutionally. Since 2023 it has been a permanent member of the G20.

    • ASEAN

      The Association of South-East Asian Nations works by consultation, consensus and non-interference, the 'ASEAN Way'. Its influence comes less from binding rules than from convening others, through the ASEAN Regional Forum and the East Asia Summit, and consensus has limited its response to crises such as Myanmar's coup of 2021.

  5. 05 · 3 entries

    Minilaterals and G-groupings

    • G7

      The steering group of advanced industrial democracies, born at Rambouillet in 1975 after the monetary and oil shocks. It has no charter, secretariat or budget; its decisions are political commitments, made effective through members' weight in the IMF, the World Bank and the Financial Action Task Force it created in 1989.

    • G20

      Nineteen countries, the European Union and, since the New Delhi summit of 2023, the African Union. Raised to leaders' level in the 2008 financial crisis, it decides by consensus without binding rules, so a leaders' declaration, rather than a chair's summary, has become a measure of a presidency's skill.

    • BRICS and the Quad

      Two minilaterals with different agendas. BRICS, enlarged from 2024, presses for reform of Western-led institutions and created the New Development Bank; the Quad of Australia, India, Japan and the United States cooperates on Indo-Pacific public goods without a treaty or secretariat. India belongs to both.

      More detail

      Minilaterals trade universality for speed: small groups can agree where the UN or the WTO cannot, but they decide without most of the states their decisions affect, which raises the problem of input legitimacy.

  6. 06 · 3 entries

    Transnational and private governance

    • Technical standard-setters

      Bodies most voters never notice write rules others follow. The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision sets capital standards that national regulators adopt; the International Organization for Standardization, a federation of national standards bodies, publishes standards that firms apply worldwide. Authority comes from expertise and market necessity, not treaty.

    • Private and multi-stakeholder governance

      Firms, NGOs and mixed bodies govern where states do not. ICANN, a non-profit, coordinates the internet's domain-name system; the Kimberley Process joins states, industry and civil society to certify rough diamonds as conflict-free; schemes such as the Forest Stewardship Council certify supply chains. Accountability is their weakest point.

    • NGOs, experts and platforms

      Actors without legislative authority also shape governance. NGO coalitions helped write the 1997 landmines convention; the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change shapes what negotiators accept as fact; digital platforms set the rules of online public space while claiming no governing role, which creates an accountability gap.

Sources7
  1. 01Charter of the United Nations (1945) (opens in a new tab). United Nations
  2. 02International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024
  3. 03Articles of Agreement of the International Monetary Fund (1944, as amended)
  4. 04Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization and the Dispute Settlement Understanding (1994)
  5. 05Constitutive Act of the African Union (2000) and the ASEAN Charter (2007)
  6. 06Robert O. Keohane, After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy (Princeton University Press, 1984)
  7. 07David Mitrany, A Working Peace System (Royal Institute of International Affairs, 1943)

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Interdependence in global politics

Plate 05Comparison matrixOriginal

Theoretical perspectives compared

Six lenses on global politics compared across actors, power, sovereignty, conflict, cooperation and key thinkers, so that the assumptions each theory makes, and the evidence each tends to miss, can be read across a single row.

  1. Realism

    International politics is a struggle for security under anarchy: with no authority above states, each must help itself, and one state's defence looks like another's threat. Realism is strongest where survival is at stake and weakest on institutions, norms and peaceful change, such as the end of the Cold War.

    Key actors
    Sovereign states, above all great powers, treated as unitary and rational.
    Power
    Material capability, especially military; relative gains matter because today's partner may be tomorrow's threat.
    Sovereignty
    The organising principle of an anarchic system; states guard their own and breach others' when interests demand.
    Conflict
    Recurrent and structural: the security dilemma means even defensive states arm, so war remains possible.
    Cooperation
    Possible but fragile, limited by fear of cheating and of rivals gaining more; alliances follow interests.
    Key thinkers
    Thucydides, Kautilya, E. H. Carr, Morgenthau, Waltz, Mearsheimer.
  2. Liberalism

    Anarchy makes cooperation difficult, not impossible. Institutions supply information and lengthen the shadow of the future, established democracies rarely if ever fight one another, and trade raises the cost of war. Liberalism works best where interests converge and issues are technical, and least where the stakes are existential.

    Key actors
    States, international institutions, firms, NGOs and individuals; the domestic regime type matters.
    Power
    Plural and positive-sum: economic, institutional and soft power; asymmetric interdependence gives leverage.
    Sovereignty
    Can be pooled or limited by consent through institutions and law without being lost.
    Conflict
    Reducible through democracy, trade and institutions; caused by mistrust and missing information as much as by anarchy.
    Cooperation
    Rational when states seek absolute gains; institutions sustain it through reciprocity and reputation.
    Key thinkers
    Kant, Woodrow Wilson, Mitrany, Keohane, Nye.
  3. Constructivism

    Interests are not given by material facts but made by shared ideas and identities: anarchy is what states make of it. Norms spread through a life cycle of emergence, cascade and internalisation. The approach explains change well, but predicts poorly which contested norms will prevail.

    Key actors
    States and non-state norm entrepreneurs, defined by identities that interaction creates and changes.
    Power
    Ideational as well as material: the power to define meanings, legitimacy and appropriate behaviour.
    Sovereignty
    A social institution that exists because states recognise it; its content, as R2P shows, can change.
    Conflict
    Depends on how actors perceive one another: enmity is constructed, so it can be reconstructed.
    Cooperation
    Grows as identities converge and norms are internalised; European integration and nuclear non-use are examples.
    Key thinkers
    Alexander Wendt, Martha Finnemore, Kathryn Sikkink, Nicholas Onuf.
  4. Marxism and critical theory

    World politics is shaped by a capitalist world economy divided by class and by core and periphery. Critical theory asks, with Robert Cox, for whom and for what purpose an order exists. The lens is sharp on debt, commodity dependence and weighted voting, but risks determinism.

    Key actors
    Classes, capital and transnational corporations; states act largely for dominant economic interests.
    Power
    Structural and economic, sustained by hegemony: rule through consent as well as force.
    Sovereignty
    Formal equality masking economic dependence; core states and capital constrain peripheral states' choices.
    Conflict
    Rooted in exploitation and unequal exchange between classes, and between core and periphery.
    Cooperation
    Often serves dominant interests; counter-hegemonic coalitions can challenge the order.
    Key thinkers
    Marx, Lenin, Gramsci, Wallerstein, Robert Cox.
  5. Feminism

    Feminism begins with a question standard theories cannot answer: where are the women? It shows how security, markets and diplomacy rest on gendered assumptions and unrecorded labour, and asks whom 'security' secures. Critics call it normative; feminists reply that every theory is.

    Key actors
    States and individuals, especially women and others marginalised in conventional accounts of politics.
    Power
    Gendered: power over is distinguished from power to and power with, and gender hierarchies shape all three.
    Sovereignty
    The tough, self-reliant sovereign state reflects masculine ideals; protecting the state can mean neglecting people.
    Conflict
    Violence in war and violence at home lie on one continuum; women bear distinct harms, including sexual violence.
    Cooperation
    Inclusive processes matter: research links women's participation to more durable peace agreements.
    Key thinkers
    J. Ann Tickner, Cynthia Enloe, bell hooks, Carole Pateman.
  6. Postcolonialism

    The present order, its borders, economics and categories of knowledge, was built under empire and still bears its logic. Postcolonial thinkers ask why some violations mobilise coalitions while others draw only statements, and whose concepts count as universal. The charge of selectivity is its sharpest tool.

    Key actors
    Formerly colonised peoples and states, alongside the former colonial powers and the institutions they built.
    Power
    Persists through hierarchies of knowledge, economy and representation long after formal independence.
    Sovereignty
    Granted to European states while denied to colonised peoples; formal independence did not end dependence.
    Conflict
    Many conflicts trace to colonial borders and divide-and-rule; Fanon saw decolonisation as inherently violent.
    Cooperation
    Solidarity of the Global South, from Bandung to non-alignment, to reshape rules written without it.
    Key thinkers
    Frantz Fanon, Edward Said, Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, Walter Mignolo.
Sources8
  1. 01International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024
  2. 02Kenneth N. Waltz, Theory of International Politics (Addison-Wesley, 1979)
  3. 03Robert O. Keohane, After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy (Princeton University Press, 1984)
  4. 04Alexander Wendt, 'Anarchy is What States Make of It: The Social Construction of Power Politics', International Organization 46:2 (1992)
  5. 05Martha Finnemore and Kathryn Sikkink, 'International Norm Dynamics and Political Change', International Organization 52:4 (1998)
  6. 06Robert W. Cox, 'Social Forces, States and World Orders: Beyond International Relations Theory', Millennium 10:2 (1981)
  7. 07J. Ann Tickner, Gender in International Relations (Columbia University Press, 1992)
  8. 08Edward W. Said, Orientalism (Pantheon, 1978)

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Theoretical perspectives in global politics

Plate 06Layered architectureOriginal

How human rights are enforced

Five tiers of the human rights system, from the norms of the International Bill of Human Rights through monitoring and adjudication to domestic institutions and civil society, showing why a right becomes real only when its violation becomes costly.

  1. 01 · 3 entries

    Norms

    • Universal Declaration of Human Rights

      Adopted by the General Assembly on 10 December 1948, with 48 votes in favour, none against and eight abstentions. It is a declaration, not a treaty, because that was the price of agreement, but many of its core prohibitions, such as that on torture, are now widely regarded as customary international law.

    • ICCPR and ICESCR

      The two covenants, adopted in 1966 and in force from 1976, turned the Declaration into binding treaty law. Civil and political rights carry immediate obligations; economic, social and cultural rights are to be realised progressively within available resources, a difference that reflects competing conceptions of justice.

      More detail

      With the Declaration they form the International Bill of Human Rights. Some rights in the civil and political covenant, such as freedom from torture, cannot be suspended even in an emergency; others can be when an emergency threatens the life of the nation.

    • Core thematic conventions

      Later treaties protect particular groups or prohibit particular practices: the conventions on racial discrimination (1965), discrimination against women (1979), torture (1984), the rights of the child (1989) and persons with disabilities (2006). Reservations let states ratify while excluding provisions, so wide ratification can coexist with weak commitment.

      More detail

      The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women is among the most widely ratified treaties and among the most heavily reserved, often on family and inheritance law.

  2. 02 · 3 entries

    Monitoring

    • Treaty bodies

      Committees of independent experts, such as the Human Rights Committee under the civil and political covenant, examine states' periodic reports and, where states accept it, individual complaints. Their concluding observations and views are authoritative but not binding judgments, so their effect depends on publicity and domestic uptake.

    • Universal Periodic Review

      Since 2008 the Human Rights Council, created in 2006 to replace a Commission whose credibility politicisation had damaged, has reviewed the record of every UN member in turn. Because states review one another the process is universal and hard to avoid, but states decide which recommendations to accept.

      More detail

      In April 2022 the General Assembly suspended Russia's membership of the Council, one of the few sanctions the system has applied to a member of the Council itself.

    • Special procedures

      Mandate-holders appointed by the Human Rights Council, special rapporteurs, independent experts and working groups, investigate themes such as torture or freedom of expression, or the situation in particular countries. They report and send communications to governments, though country visits require the state's invitation.

      More detail

      Commissions of inquiry and fact-finding missions, such as the UN mission on Myanmar that reported in 2018, add documentation that later supports litigation, as in The Gambia v Myanmar.

  3. 03 · 3 entries

    Adjudication

    • Regional human rights courts

      Regional courts hear claims that states have broken their human rights treaties: in Europe directly from individuals, in the Americas through the Inter-American Commission, and in Africa directly only where a state has accepted it. The European system works best, largely because the execution of judgments is politically supervised.

      More detail

      In KlimaSeniorinnen v Switzerland (2024) the European Court found that inadequate climate policy breached the Convention. Several African states have withdrawn their declarations allowing individuals direct access to the African Court since 2016.

    • International Court of Justice: its limits

      In contentious cases the ICJ hears only disputes between states, and only where they have consented, often through a treaty clause such as Article IX of the Genocide Convention. Victims cannot bring cases, and the Court has no police: compliance depends on states and, ultimately, on a Security Council where the veto applies.

      More detail

      The Gambia v Myanmar showed a workaround: because Genocide Convention obligations are owed to all parties, a state with no direct injury could sue. The climate advisory opinion of July 2025 shows the Court's other route, advice requested by the General Assembly.

    • International Criminal Court

      The Rome Statute (1998, in force 2002) created a permanent court to try individuals, not states, for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression. It acts only when national courts are unwilling or unable, and it has jurisdiction but no police, so arrests depend on states' political will.

      More detail

      Mongolia did not arrest President Putin during his visit in September 2024 despite a warrant; the Philippines surrendered former President Duterte in March 2025. Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger notified their withdrawal from the Statute in June 2026.

  4. 04 · 3 entries

    Domestic enforcement

    • Constitutional and supreme courts

      Most rights are enforced, if at all, in national courts applying constitutions and incorporated treaties. Courts can turn international norms into domestic law: in Vishaka (1997) India's Supreme Court drew on the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women to frame binding guidelines against workplace sexual harassment.

      More detail

      Article 32 of India's Constitution makes the right to move the Supreme Court for the enforcement of fundamental rights itself a fundamental right.

    • National human rights institutions

      Commissions that investigate complaints, monitor places of detention and advise governments, judged internationally against the Paris Principles endorsed by the General Assembly in 1993. India's National Human Rights Commission, a statutory body created that year, can inquire and recommend but cannot compel, so its influence depends on governments acting on its findings.

    • Universal jurisdiction

      Some states let their courts try the gravest international crimes wherever they were committed. When every international route on Syria was blocked, German courts convicted Syrian officials, including a former intelligence colonel sentenced to life imprisonment in Koblenz in January 2022, on evidence gathered by survivors and NGOs.

  5. 05 · 3 entries

    Civil society

    • Human rights NGOs

      Organisations such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch hold no territory; their power is credible evidence. They document violations, submit shadow reports to treaty bodies and the Universal Periodic Review, and name and shame governments, which is why repressive states attack monitoring first.

    • Transnational advocacy: the boomerang

      Margaret Keck and Kathryn Sikkink's boomerang model (1998) explains how groups blocked at home reach transnational networks, which press their state from outside through other governments and international bodies. It explains successes, and also why the strategy fails against states indifferent to outside pressure.

    • Strategic litigation by those affected

      The most affected increasingly use courts themselves. Pacific law students began the campaign that led to the International Court of Justice's 2025 climate opinion, and an association of older Swiss women won KlimaSeniorinnen at the European Court in 2024. Litigation turns moral claims into legal obligations with costs attached.

Sources7
  1. 01Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) (opens in a new tab). United Nations
  2. 02International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)
  3. 03Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (1998)
  4. 04UN General Assembly resolution 48/134, Principles relating to the Status of National Institutions (Paris Principles) (1993), and resolution 60/251 establishing the Human Rights Council (2006)
  5. 05European Court of Human Rights, Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v Switzerland (Grand Chamber, 9 April 2024)
  6. 06Margaret E. Keck and Kathryn Sikkink, Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics (Cornell University Press, 1998)
  7. 07International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Rights and justice

Plate 07Comparison matrixOriginal

Analysing conflict

Three toolkits for analysing conflict in one matrix: types of conflict by who fights whom, Galtung's direct, structural and cultural violence, and the stages of a conflict cycle, each with a definition, an example and a question to ask.

Types of conflict

  1. Interstate conflict

    Armed conflict between the forces of two or more states, the classic subject of international relations. It is now rarer than conflict within states, but it carries the highest risks of escalation, especially where nuclear powers or alliances are involved.

    Definition
    Organised armed violence between two or more states over territory, government or other incompatible goals.
    Example
    Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine from February 2022.
    Analytical question
    What explains the onset: the distribution of power, domestic politics, leaders' beliefs or misperception?
  2. Intrastate conflict

    Armed conflict between a government and organised groups within its territory. It is the most common form today and is often internationalised, as outside powers arm or fund different sides, which blurs the line between civil and international war and prolongs the fighting.

    Definition
    Armed conflict between a state's government and one or more organised armed groups inside it.
    Example
    Sudan since April 2023: the army against the Rapid Support Forces, with heavy outside involvement.
    Analytical question
    Is the war driven by greed, grievance or horizontal inequality, and who sustains it from outside?
  3. Non-state conflict

    Armed conflict in which no government is a party: organised groups fight one another for territory, resources or followers. Such conflicts flourish where the state is absent or captured, and they show that the state is not always the main source of order, or of violence.

    Definition
    Organised armed violence between groups, none of which is the government of a state.
    Example
    Fighting between rival drug cartels in Mexico; clashes between al-Qaeda and Islamic State affiliates in the Sahel.
    Analytical question
    What do the groups compete for, and why can the state not, or not wish to, intervene?
  4. Frozen conflict

    A conflict in which fighting has stopped without a political settlement, leaving a ceasefire line, a de facto authority and unresolved claims. Frozen conflicts can last for decades and can thaw suddenly, as the conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh did in the wars of 2020 and 2023.

    Definition
    Active fighting has ended, but no settlement resolves the dispute, leaving de facto authorities in place.
    Example
    Transnistria since the ceasefire of 1992; the division of Cyprus since 1974.
    Analytical question
    Who benefits from the status quo, and what would change the parties' calculations?

Galtung's triangle of violence

  1. Direct violence

    Violence with an identifiable perpetrator and victim: killing, maiming, sexual violence, forced displacement. It is the most visible corner of Johan Galtung's triangle and the one a ceasefire addresses, which is why stopping the shooting rarely ends a conflict on its own.

    Definition
    Physical or psychological harm inflicted intentionally by an identifiable actor on identifiable victims.
    Example
    The 1994 genocide of the Tutsi in Rwanda, carried out by soldiers, militias and neighbours.
    Analytical question
    Who commits the violence, against whom, by what means, and what enables or restrains them?
  2. Structural violence

    Harm built into social, economic and political arrangements, with no single perpetrator: people die or are diminished because of unequal access to food, care, land or rights. Galtung (1969) defined positive peace as the absence of structural as well as direct violence.

    Definition
    Avoidable harm caused by unequal structures rather than by any identifiable individual's act.
    Example
    Deaths from treatable disease where medicine exists but is unequally distributed; the racial order of apartheid South Africa.
    Analytical question
    Which arrangements produce avoidable harm, who benefits from them, and why do they persist?
  3. Cultural violence

    The ideas, symbols and narratives that make direct and structural violence seem normal, justified or invisible, from religion and ideology to language and art. Galtung added it to his framework in 1990. It explains why dehumanising propaganda so often precedes mass atrocity.

    Definition
    Aspects of culture used to legitimise direct or structural violence, making it look right or unremarkable.
    Example
    Rwandan radio broadcasts that called the Tutsi 'cockroaches' before and during the 1994 genocide.
    Analytical question
    Which narratives legitimise the harm, who produces them, and how could they be countered?

Stages of conflict

  1. Latent conflict

    Incompatible goals and grievances exist in structures and attitudes but are not yet expressed through organised action. Analysts look for horizontal inequalities, exclusion and blocked channels of redress, because latent conflict is where prevention is cheapest and attention rarest.

    Definition
    Grievances and incompatible goals are present but not yet mobilised into open confrontation.
    Example
    Discrimination against Catholics in Northern Ireland in housing and local voting before the civil rights campaign of the late 1960s.
    Analytical question
    Which grievances could mobilise people, and do institutions offer a peaceful channel for them?
  2. Escalation

    Conflict becomes overt and intensifies as positions harden, demands multiply, violence begins and each side's actions confirm the other's fears. Repression of peaceful protest is a common trigger, and escalation is usually quicker to start than to reverse.

    Definition
    Open confrontation intensifies in scope, means and number of parties, often turning violent.
    Example
    Syria in 2011, where lethal repression of peaceful protests helped turn an uprising into civil war within months.
    Analytical question
    What triggered escalation, and which actions by each side made the other's worst fears seem true?
  3. Crisis

    The peak of tension, when the risk of large-scale violence or war is highest and decisions are compressed into days or hours. Crises test communication between adversaries, the judgement of leaders and the availability of face-saving exits for both sides.

    Definition
    The point of greatest intensity and danger, demanding urgent decisions under uncertainty.
    Example
    The Cuban missile crisis of October 1962, when US–Soviet confrontation brought nuclear war within reach.
    Analytical question
    What exits are available to each party, and how reliable are their channels of communication?
  4. De-escalation

    Violence and tension decline as parties judge continued confrontation too costly, often at what William Zartman called a mutually hurting stalemate. De-escalation is usually stepwise and reversible: disengagement, hotlines and confidence-building measures come before any settlement of the underlying dispute.

    Definition
    Intensity falls through ceasefires, disengagement and confidence-building, without yet resolving the causes.
    Example
    India and China's October 2024 agreement on patrolling arrangements at the last friction points of the 2020 standoff along the Line of Actual Control.
    Analytical question
    Is the decline in violence a ripe moment for negotiation, or merely a pause to regroup?
  5. Settlement

    The fighting is ended by negotiation, mediation, arbitration, imposed terms or victory, addressing at least some of the incompatible goals. A settlement's durability depends as much on whether those it binds accept it, and whether spoilers can be contained, as on its terms.

    Definition
    A formal end to fighting through agreement, arbitration, imposed terms or victory, addressing some underlying issues.
    Example
    The African Union-brokered Pretoria agreement of November 2022, which ended the war in Tigray.
    Analytical question
    Do the terms address the parties' underlying needs, and who was excluded from the table?
  6. Post-conflict

    After a settlement, societies face disarmament, the return of the displaced, institution-building, reconciliation and justice. Negative peace may hold while positive peace fails: Bosnia's Dayton settlement of 1995 has prevented renewed war for three decades while entrenching ethnic division.

    Definition
    Rebuilding security, institutions and relationships after fighting ends, to prevent relapse and address causes.
    Example
    Colombia's Special Jurisdiction for Peace, which issued its first restorative sentences to former FARC leaders in September 2025.
    Analytical question
    Is the peace negative or positive, and does justice take a retributive or a restorative form?
Sources6
  1. 01Johan Galtung, 'Violence, Peace, and Peace Research', Journal of Peace Research 6:3 (1969)
  2. 02Johan Galtung, 'Cultural Violence', Journal of Peace Research 27:3 (1990)
  3. 03Uppsala Conflict Data Program, definitions of state-based and non-state conflict. Department of Peace and Conflict Research, Uppsala University
  4. 04I. William Zartman, Ripe for Resolution: Conflict and Intervention in Africa (Oxford University Press, 1985)
  5. 05Michael S. Lund, Preventing Violent Conflicts: A Strategy for Preventive Diplomacy (United States Institute of Peace Press, 1996)
  6. 06International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Peace and conflict

Plate 08Relationship mapOriginal

Deep-sea mining: a stakeholder map

Who acts and who is affected in the contest over mining the seabed beyond national jurisdiction: states, an international authority, a company, coalitions and scientists, and stakeholders such as ecosystems and future generations that cannot act for themselves.

Who connects to whom

  1. UNCLOS and the common heritage principle

    The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea declares the seabed beyond national jurisdiction, 'the Area', and its mineral resources the common heritage of mankind, to be managed on behalf of mankind as a whole. A 1994 Implementation Agreement reshaped Part XI and contains the two-year rule that Nauru later invoked.

    Connects to 02 International Seabed Authority,06 United States government,10 Ecosystems and future generations

  2. International Seabed Authority

    The intergovernmental body in Kingston, Jamaica, that organises and controls mineral activities in the Area on behalf of all states. It has issued exploration contracts but has not adopted the exploitation regulations, the Mining Code, and must reconcile its mandate to organise mining with its duty to protect the marine environment.

    Connects to 01 UNCLOS and the common heritage principle,03 Nauru and Tonga (sponsoring states),04 Other contractor states,05 The Metals Company,06 United States government,07 Moratorium and pause coalition,08 Scientists and civil society

    More detail

    Its 36-member Council works largely by consensus, and its sessions of March and July 2026 again ended without a code. Its Secretary-General since 2025, Leticia Carvalho, has emphasised environmental protection and criticised unilateral licensing.

  3. Nauru and Tonga (sponsoring states)

    Small Pacific island states that sponsor subsidiaries of The Metals Company. In June 2021 Nauru invoked the two-year rule to press the Council to finish the Mining Code; the deadline passed in July 2023 without one. Sponsorship promises revenue and diplomatic weight, but carries legal responsibilities and political risk.

    Connects to 02 International Seabed Authority,05 The Metals Company

  4. Other contractor states

    China, India, Japan, South Korea and Russia, among others, hold ISA exploration contracts through state agencies or firms. Their interest in eventual access to seabed minerals gives them a stake in an agreed code, while their positions on its timing and on precaution vary.

    Connects to 02 International Seabed Authority

    More detail

    India holds an ISA contract to explore polymetallic nodules in the Central Indian Ocean Basin.

  5. The Metals Company

    A transnational company and the most advanced would-be miner in the Clarion–Clipperton Zone of the Pacific. In 2025 it turned from the ISA route, sponsored by Nauru and Tonga, to licensing under US law, showing a firm's power to choose between regulatory systems.

    Connects to 02 International Seabed Authority,03 Nauru and Tonga (sponsoring states),06 United States government

    More detail

    Its US subsidiary's consolidated application covers some 65,000 square kilometres of the zone. By August 2026 the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration had found it compliant with the application requirements but had issued no permit.

  6. United States government

    Never a party to UNCLOS, the United States ordered an accelerated process in April 2025 to license seabed mining under its Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act of 1980, presenting critical minerals as a national security priority. It thereby opened a rival legal pathway that bypasses the ISA.

    Connects to 01 UNCLOS and the common heritage principle,02 International Seabed Authority,05 The Metals Company

    More detail

    Most ISA members regard unilateral licensing as contrary to international law; the question is whether rules that many states treat as customary law bind a non-party.

  7. Moratorium and pause coalition

    A growing group of states, around forty by 2026 on campaigners' counts and including France, Germany, Chile, Costa Rica, Palau, Fiji and the United Kingdom, calls for a moratorium or precautionary pause until the science is better understood. Within the ISA it has enough weight to block a code it judges inadequate.

    Connects to 02 International Seabed Authority,08 Scientists and civil society,09 Pacific communities

  8. Scientists and civil society

    An epistemic community of marine scientists, with environmental NGOs, documents how little is known about deep-sea ecosystems and campaigns for precaution. It has knowledge and moral authority but no vote, so it works by shaping what states and the ISA accept as evidence.

    Connects to 02 International Seabed Authority,07 Moratorium and pause coalition,10 Ecosystems and future generations

  9. Pacific communities

    Pacific peoples and indigenous voices present the ocean as a shared heritage and a source of identity rather than a resource frontier, and object that decisions have been taken without adequate consultation. Their claim suggests a non-territorial idea of stewardship that sits uneasily with sovereignty.

    Connects to 07 Moratorium and pause coalition,10 Ecosystems and future generations

  10. Ecosystems and future generations

    Stakeholders with interests but no agency: abyssal ecosystems where scientists warn that harm from mining may be irreversible, and future generations who will inherit the consequences. Neither has a seat in the ISA or a voice in US licensing, so others must speak for them.

    Connects to 01 UNCLOS and the common heritage principle,08 Scientists and civil society,09 Pacific communities

    More detail

    This is the case's sharpest lesson for the course's distinction between actors and stakeholders: those most affected are the ones that cannot act.

Sources5
  1. 01United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982), Part XI, and the Agreement relating to the Implementation of Part XI (1994)
  2. 02International Seabed Authority (opens in a new tab)
  3. 03IISD Earth Negotiations Bulletin, summary report of the 31st session of the ISA Council (Part II) (opens in a new tab), July 2026
  4. 04Executive Order 'Unleashing America's Offshore Critical Minerals and Resources'. The White House, 24 April 2025
  5. 05Ocean News & Technology, 'NOAA Determines TMC USA's Consolidated Deep-Seabed Mining Application is in Full Compliance' (opens in a new tab), May 2026

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: Deep-sea mining and the International Seabed Authority

UPSC CSE · Indian Polity

The Constitution

How the Constitution distributes power among the organs and levels of government, how each is held to account, and how the text has changed. Explanations, not the constitutional text.

Plate 09Layered architectureOriginal

The Union Legislature

Parliament under Article 79 as a three-part institution, the President, the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha, with each part's powers and the procedures, from money Bills to joint sittings, that settle disagreements between them.

  1. 01 · 2 entries

    Parliament

    • Parliament (Article 79)

      Article 79 provides that Parliament consists of the President and two Houses, the Council of States and the House of the People. It legislates, controls taxation and spending, holds the executive to account, amends the Constitution under Article 368, elects the Vice-President and takes part in electing the President.

      More detail

      The President is part of Parliament but sits in neither House, which is why a Bill becomes an Act only with the President's assent (Article 111).

    • Sessions, privileges and quorum

      No more than six months may pass between sessions (Article 85). Members have freedom of speech in Parliament and immunity from court proceedings for anything said or any vote given there (Article 105). Quorum is one-tenth of the total number of members of a House (Article 100(3)).

  2. 02 · 3 entries

    President

    • Summons, prorogation and addresses

      The President summons each House, prorogues the Houses and may dissolve the Lok Sabha (Article 85), addresses both Houses at the first session after each general election and at the first session of each year (Article 87), and may send messages to either House (Article 86), acting on ministerial advice.

    • Assent to Bills (Article 111)

      A Bill passed by both Houses goes to the President, who assents or withholds assent. Except for a money Bill, the President may return it for reconsideration, but if the Houses pass it again, with or without amendment, the President may not withhold assent.

      More detail

      For constitutional amendment Bills the 24th Amendment made assent obligatory (Article 368(2)).

    • Ordinances (Article 123)

      Except when both Houses are in session, the President may promulgate an ordinance with the force of an Act if circumstances make immediate action necessary. It must be laid before both Houses and ceases to operate six weeks after Parliament reassembles, or sooner if both Houses pass resolutions disapproving it.

      More detail

      An ordinance making a provision Parliament could not enact is void (Article 123(3)). In Krishna Kumar Singh (2017) a seven-judge bench held that laying an ordinance before the legislature is mandatory and that re-promulgation is permissible only in exceptional circumstances.

  3. 03 · 3 entries

    Rajya Sabha

    • Composition (Article 80)

      The Council of States has twelve members nominated by the President for special knowledge or practical experience in literature, science, art and social service, and not more than 238 representatives of the States and Union territories. State representatives are elected by the elected members of each Legislative Assembly by single transferable vote.

      More detail

      Seats are allotted by the Fourth Schedule, roughly by population rather than equally, and the House has 245 members.

    • A permanent House

      The Rajya Sabha is not subject to dissolution; as nearly as possible one-third of its members retire on the expiry of every second year (Article 83(1)). The Vice-President is its ex officio Chairman (Article 89), and the House chooses a Deputy Chairman from among its members.

    • Special powers of the Rajya Sabha

      By a resolution of two-thirds of members present and voting, the Rajya Sabha can authorise Parliament to legislate on a State List matter in the national interest (Article 249) or to create new all-India services (Article 312). A resolution to remove the Vice-President must begin there (Article 67(b)).

  4. 04 · 3 entries

    Lok Sabha

    • Composition (Article 81)

      The House of the People consists of not more than 530 members directly elected from territorial constituencies in the States and not more than 20 representing the Union territories. It has 543 elected seats, and seats for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes are reserved under Article 330.

      More detail

      Women's reservation under Article 330A, inserted by the 106th Amendment, takes effect only after the delimitation that follows the first census after the amendment's commencement.

    • Term and presiding officers

      The Lok Sabha continues for five years from the date appointed for its first meeting unless dissolved sooner. During a Proclamation of Emergency Parliament may extend its term by law one year at a time, but not beyond six months after the Proclamation ends (Article 83(2)). It chooses its Speaker and Deputy Speaker (Article 93).

    • Money Bills and the confidence of the House

      A money Bill may be introduced only in the Lok Sabha; the Rajya Sabha must return it within fourteen days with recommendations the Lok Sabha may reject (Article 109), and the Speaker's decision that a Bill is a money Bill is final (Article 110(3)). The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the House of the People (Article 75(3)).

      More detail

      Only the Lok Sabha votes on demands for grants (Article 113(2)). Whether courts may review the Speaker's money-Bill certificate was referred to a larger bench in Rojer Mathew (2019).

  5. 05 · 4 entries

    Shared procedures

    • Ordinary Bills (Article 107)

      An ordinary Bill may originate in either House and is passed only when both agree to it in the same form. It does not lapse on prorogation; on dissolution of the Lok Sabha, a Bill pending there, or passed by it and pending in the Rajya Sabha, lapses, subject to Article 108.

      More detail

      A Bill pending in the Rajya Sabha that the Lok Sabha has not passed survives a dissolution (Article 107(4)).

    • Joint sitting (Article 108)

      If one House rejects a Bill, the Houses finally disagree on amendments, or six months pass without the other House passing it, the President may summon a joint sitting. The Speaker presides (Article 118(4)) and a majority of members of both Houses present and voting decides. It is not available for money Bills.

      More detail

      Nor is it available for constitutional amendments, which each House must pass separately under Article 368(2). Only three joint sittings have been held: on the Dowry Prohibition Bill (1961), the Banking Service Commission (Repeal) Bill (1978) and the Prevention of Terrorism Bill (2002).

    • Budget and financial control (Articles 112–117)

      The President causes the annual financial statement to be laid before both Houses (Article 112). Charged expenditure is discussed but not voted; other expenditure is voted by the Lok Sabha as demands for grants (Article 113), and no money leaves the Consolidated Fund except under appropriation made by law (Article 114(3)).

    • Amending the Constitution (Article 368)

      An amendment Bill may be introduced in either House and must pass each House by a majority of its total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting, with no joint sitting. Amendments to the federal provisions listed in the proviso also need ratification by at least half the State legislatures.

Sources3
  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  2. 02Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha. Lok Sabha Secretariat
  3. 03Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Plate 10Relationship mapOriginal

The Union Executive

How the Union executive fits together: a President in whom executive power is formally vested, a Vice-President, a Prime Minister and Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, and the Attorney General, with the articles that link them.

Who connects to whom

  1. President (Articles 52–62)

    Article 52 creates the office and Article 53 vests the Union's executive power in the President, who also holds supreme command of the defence forces. Articles 54–62 govern election, a five-year term, qualifications, oath, impeachment and vacancies. The President must act on the Council of Ministers' advice (Article 74(1)).

    Connects to 02 Electoral college and impeachment,03 Pardoning power (Article 72),04 Vice-President (Articles 63–71),05 Prime Minister,06 Council of Ministers (Articles 74–75),08 Attorney General (Article 76),11 Supreme Court

  2. Electoral college and impeachment

    The President is elected by the elected members of both Houses and of the State Legislative Assemblies, including Delhi and Puducherry, by proportional representation through the single transferable vote (Articles 54–55). Removal is only by impeachment for violation of the Constitution, needing two-thirds of each House's total membership (Article 61).

    Connects to 01 President (Articles 52–62),09 Lok Sabha,10 Rajya Sabha,11 Supreme Court

    More detail

    Votes are weighted by population so that the States as a whole and the Union carry equal weight (Article 55(2)). Disputes about the election are decided by the Supreme Court (Article 71).

  3. Pardoning power (Article 72)

    The President may grant pardons, reprieves, respites or remissions, or suspend, remit or commute sentences, in cases tried by court martial, offences against Union laws and all death sentences. The power is exercised on ministerial advice and is open to judicial review on limited grounds.

    Connects to 01 President (Articles 52–62),06 Council of Ministers (Articles 74–75),11 Supreme Court

    More detail

    Governors hold a parallel power for offences against State laws (Article 161), and Article 72(3) preserves a Governor's power to suspend, remit or commute a death sentence.

  4. Vice-President (Articles 63–71)

    Elected by the members of both Houses of Parliament, nominated as well as elected, by proportional representation through the single transferable vote (Article 66). The Vice-President is ex officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha (Article 64) and acts as President when that office falls vacant, until a successor takes office (Article 65).

    Connects to 01 President (Articles 52–62),09 Lok Sabha,10 Rajya Sabha,11 Supreme Court

    More detail

    Removal is by a Rajya Sabha resolution passed by a majority of all its then members and agreed to by the Lok Sabha, after fourteen days' notice (Article 67(b)); no ground is specified.

  5. Prime Minister

    Appointed by the President (Article 75(1)), by convention the leader able to command a majority in the Lok Sabha. The Prime Minister heads the Council of Ministers (Article 74(1)), advises on the appointment of other ministers and must communicate the Council's decisions to the President (Article 78).

    Connects to 01 President (Articles 52–62),06 Council of Ministers (Articles 74–75),07 Collective responsibility (Article 75(3)),09 Lok Sabha

    More detail

    Most of the office's dominance rests on convention and practice rather than text; the Prime Minister's resignation or death dissolves the Council of Ministers.

  6. Council of Ministers (Articles 74–75)

    A Council headed by the Prime Minister aids and advises the President, who must act on its advice but may require it to reconsider (Article 74(1)); no court may inquire into what advice was given (Article 74(2)). Ministers hold office during the President's pleasure, in practice while the Lok Sabha's confidence lasts.

    Connects to 01 President (Articles 52–62),03 Pardoning power (Article 72),05 Prime Minister,07 Collective responsibility (Article 75(3)),08 Attorney General (Article 76)

    More detail

    Since the 91st Amendment (2003) the Council, including the Prime Minister, may not exceed 15 per cent of the Lok Sabha's total membership (Article 75(1A)), and a member disqualified for defection cannot be appointed a minister until re-elected (Article 75(1B)).

  7. Collective responsibility (Article 75(3))

    The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the House of the People: ministers stand or fall together, and a government that loses the Lok Sabha's confidence, through a no-confidence motion or defeat on a confidence vote, is bound by convention to resign. Ministers also share public responsibility for Cabinet decisions.

    Connects to 05 Prime Minister,06 Council of Ministers (Articles 74–75),09 Lok Sabha

    More detail

    Governments have fallen on confidence votes: V.P. Singh's in 1990 and Atal Bihari Vajpayee's, by a single vote, in 1999.

  8. Attorney General (Article 76)

    Appointed by the President from those qualified to be Supreme Court judges, the Attorney General advises the Government of India on legal matters, has a right of audience in all courts and holds office during the President's pleasure. The Attorney General may speak in either House but not vote (Article 88).

    Connects to 01 President (Articles 52–62),06 Council of Ministers (Articles 74–75),09 Lok Sabha,10 Rajya Sabha,11 Supreme Court

    More detail

    The Attorney General is not a member of the Council of Ministers; political responsibility for legal affairs rests with the Law Minister.

  9. Lok Sabha

    The directly elected House to which the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible. Its confidence sustains the government, its control of money Bills and demands for grants gives it the decisive voice in Union finance, and its members vote in the elections of the President and Vice-President.

    Connects to 02 Electoral college and impeachment,04 Vice-President (Articles 63–71),05 Prime Minister,07 Collective responsibility (Article 75(3)),08 Attorney General (Article 76)

  10. Rajya Sabha

    The Council of States, presided over by the Vice-President as ex officio Chairman. Ministers answer on its floor and may be drawn from it, but the government does not depend on its confidence. Its elected members vote in the presidential election, and a resolution to remove the Vice-President must begin there.

    Connects to 02 Electoral college and impeachment,04 Vice-President (Articles 63–71),08 Attorney General (Article 76)

  11. Supreme Court

    Decides all doubts and disputes about the election of a President or Vice-President, and its decision is final (Article 71). The President may refer questions of law or fact to it for an advisory opinion (Article 143), and it reviews executive action, including pardons, on limited grounds.

    Connects to 01 President (Articles 52–62),02 Electoral college and impeachment,03 Pardoning power (Article 72),04 Vice-President (Articles 63–71),08 Attorney General (Article 76)

    More detail

    In November 2025 a five-judge bench answered a presidential reference on assent to Bills, advising that courts cannot fix timelines for the President or Governors to act.

Sources3
  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  2. 02Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
  3. 03Constituent Assembly Debates (1946–1950). Lok Sabha Secretariat

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Plate 11Layered architectureOriginal

The Indian judiciary

A single integrated judiciary in three tiers, the Supreme Court, the High Courts and the subordinate courts, with the writ jurisdiction and the power of judicial review that run through it, linked to the judgments that shaped each.

  1. 01 · 2 entries

    Supreme Court

    • Establishment and composition (Article 124)

      Article 124 establishes the Supreme Court: the Chief Justice of India and other judges, whose number Parliament fixes by law. Judges serve until the age of sixty-five and can be removed only by order of the President after an address by each House on proved misbehaviour or incapacity (Article 124(4)).

      More detail

      Each House must support the address by a majority of its total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting. No Supreme Court judge has been removed. The printed text of Article 124(2) still carries, in brackets, the words on the National Judicial Appointments Commission that the Court struck down in 2015.

    • Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court

      Original jurisdiction in disputes between the Union and States or between States (Article 131); appeals from High Courts (Articles 132–134) and special leave to appeal from any court or tribunal except military tribunals (Article 136); and advisory opinions on questions the President refers (Article 143).

      More detail

      Its law binds all courts in India (Article 141), and Article 142 lets it make any order necessary for complete justice. The advisory opinion of November 2025 held that Article 142 cannot supply 'deemed assent' to Bills.

  2. 02 · 2 entries

    High Courts

    • High Courts (Article 214)

      There shall be a High Court for each State (Article 214), though Parliament may by law establish a common High Court for two or more States, or for two or more States and a Union territory (Article 231). Judges are appointed by the President after consultation (Article 217) and retire at sixty-two.

    • Superintendence and appeals

      Every High Court has superintendence over all courts and tribunals in its territory, except military tribunals (Article 227), and hears civil and criminal appeals. It must withdraw a case raising a substantial question of constitutional interpretation from a subordinate court (Article 228). Since L. Chandra Kumar (1997) a division bench reviews tribunal decisions.

  3. 03 · 2 entries

    Subordinate courts

    • District judges (Article 233)

      District judges are appointed, posted and promoted by the Governor in consultation with the High Court. A person not already in the service of the Union or the State must have been an advocate or pleader for at least seven years and be recommended by the High Court (Article 233(2)).

    • Judicial service and High Court control

      Other judicial officers are appointed by the Governor under rules made after consulting the State Public Service Commission and the High Court (Article 234). The High Court controls district and subordinate courts, including posting, promotion and leave (Article 235), which makes it the administrative head of the State judiciary.

      More detail

      Article 236 defines 'district judge' and 'judicial service', and Article 237 lets the Governor apply these provisions to classes of magistrates. Most pending cases in India are in the district and subordinate courts.

  4. 04 · 2 entries

    Writ jurisdiction

    • Article 32: the Supreme Court's writs

      The right to move the Supreme Court to enforce fundamental rights is itself a fundamental right (Article 32(1)). The Court may issue directions, orders or writs, including habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto and certiorari, and the right may not be suspended except as the Constitution provides.

      More detail

      Public interest litigation, from Hussainara Khatoon (1979) onwards, relaxed the rules of standing so that others could petition for those unable to reach the Court.

    • Article 226: the High Courts' writs

      High Courts may issue writs to any person or authority, including a government, within their territory, for the enforcement of fundamental rights 'and for any other purpose' (Article 226(1)). The jurisdiction is wider than Article 32's but discretionary, and for most citizens the High Court is the effective constitutional court.

  5. 05 · 5 entries

    Judicial review

    • Kesavananda Bharati (1973)

      By seven judges to six, the Court held that Parliament may amend any part of the Constitution under Article 368 but may not destroy its basic structure. The doctrine made the Court the judge of constitutional amendments as well as of ordinary laws, and the list of basic features was left open.

    • Minerva Mills (1980)

      The Court struck down the 42nd Amendment's clauses that sought to make the amending power unlimited and amendments unreviewable, holding that a limited amending power, and the balance between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles, are themselves part of the basic structure.

    • L. Chandra Kumar (1997)

      A seven-judge bench held that the judicial review powers of the High Courts under Articles 226 and 227 and of the Supreme Court under Article 32 are part of the basic structure, so tribunals may act as courts of first instance but cannot oust the High Courts.

    • Reach of judicial review

      Laws are reviewed for legislative competence and consistency with fundamental rights (Article 13); executive action for illegality, irrationality and procedural impropriety. Review reaches apparently political powers too: President's Rule since S.R. Bommai (1994), Speakers' anti-defection rulings since Kihoto Hollohan (1992), and Ninth Schedule laws since I.R. Coelho (2007).

    • NJAC case (2015)

      By four to one, a five-judge bench struck down the 99th Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014, which Parliament had passed almost unanimously, holding judicial primacy in appointments to be part of the basic structure. The collegium created by the Second and Third Judges cases revived.

Sources2
  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  2. 02Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Plate 12Comparison matrixOriginal

Distribution of legislative powers

How Articles 245–254 and the Seventh Schedule divide law-making between Parliament and the State legislatures: the three Lists, the residuary power, the occasions on which Parliament may legislate in the State field, and the rule for conflicts.

The Seventh Schedule

  1. Union List (List I)

    Subjects needing national uniformity, on which Parliament has exclusive power (Article 246(1)). The List was numbered to 97 entries in 1950 and still has entries numbered up to 97, but amendments have inserted lettered entries and omitted others, so the numbering no longer gives the count.

    Who legislates
    Parliament alone, notwithstanding the other Lists (Article 246(1)).
    Scope
    Entries numbered up to 97: lettered entries 2A, 92A and 92B inserted; entries 33, 92 and 92C omitted.
    Illustration
    Defence, foreign affairs, atomic energy, railways, currency, banking, census, citizenship, and taxes on non-agricultural income.
    Limit or condition
    None from the States; where a Union entry overlaps a State or Concurrent entry, the Union power prevails.
    More detail

    The 42nd Amendment inserted entry 2A, on deploying Union forces in aid of the civil power in a State; the Sixth Amendment (1956) inserted entry 92A on taxes on inter-State sales; and the 101st Amendment omitted entries 92 and 92C when it introduced the goods and services tax.

  2. State List (List II)

    Subjects of regional and local concern, on which each State legislature has exclusive power for its State (Article 246(3)), subject to the Union and Concurrent Lists. Entries are numbered up to 66, but entry 36 (omitted in 1956), entries 11, 19, 20 and 29 (1976) and entries 52 and 55 (2016) have been omitted.

    Who legislates
    The State legislature, exclusively for its own State (Article 246(3)).
    Scope
    Entries numbered up to 66, with seven numbered entries now omitted, so fewer than 66 remain.
    Illustration
    Public order, police, public health, agriculture, land, local government, and excise on alcoholic liquor for human consumption.
    Limit or condition
    Parliament may enter the field under Articles 249, 250, 252 and 253, and during President's Rule (Article 357).
  3. Concurrent List (List III)

    Subjects on which Parliament and the State legislatures may both legislate (Article 246(2)), Union law prevailing in conflict. Entries are numbered up to 47, with lettered entries 11A, 17A, 17B, 20A and 33A added in 1976 by the 42nd Amendment, which moved education, forests, wildlife, weights and measures and the administration of justice from the State List.

    Who legislates
    Parliament and the State legislatures concurrently (Article 246(2)).
    Scope
    Entries numbered up to 47, with lettered entries 11A, 17A, 17B, 20A and 33A added in 1976.
    Illustration
    Criminal law and procedure, marriage and divorce, contracts, bankruptcy, forests, education, economic and social planning.
    Limit or condition
    Union law prevails over repugnant State law, unless the State law was reserved for and received the President's assent (Article 254).

Articles 245–254

  1. Territorial extent (Article 245)

    Parliament may make laws for the whole or any part of India, and a State legislature for the whole or any part of its State. No law made by Parliament is invalid merely because it would operate outside India, which lets Union law reach citizens and conduct abroad.

    Who legislates
    Parliament for all or part of India; each State legislature for its State.
    Scope
    The territorial reach of laws; Parliament's laws may have extra-territorial operation (Article 245(2)).
    Illustration
    Union criminal law can apply to offences committed by Indian citizens outside India.
    Limit or condition
    State laws need a sufficient territorial nexus; Scheduled Areas and tribal areas have special regimes.
  2. Residuary power (Article 248)

    Parliament has exclusive power over any matter not enumerated in the Concurrent or State List, including any tax not mentioned in either (Article 248), reinforced by entry 97 of the Union List. Since 2016 the power has been expressly subject to Article 246A on the goods and services tax.

    Who legislates
    Parliament exclusively.
    Scope
    Matters and taxes not enumerated in the State or Concurrent List (Article 248(1)–(2)).
    Illustration
    As in Canada, residuary power lies with the federation; in the United States and Australia it lies with the states.
    Limit or condition
    Subject to Article 246A since the 101st Amendment (2016).
  3. Goods and services tax (Article 246A)

    Inserted by the 101st Amendment, Article 246A gives Parliament and every State legislature simultaneous power to make laws on goods and services tax, notwithstanding Articles 246 and 254, while reserving GST on inter-State supplies to Parliament. Rates and rules are recommended by the GST Council (Article 279A).

    Who legislates
    Parliament and every State legislature simultaneously; Parliament alone for inter-State supplies.
    Scope
    Goods and services tax imposed by the Union or by a State (Article 246A(1)–(2)).
    Illustration
    Central and State GST on the same supply; integrated GST on inter-State supplies (Article 269A).
    Limit or condition
    In Mohit Minerals (2022) the Court held GST Council recommendations persuasive rather than binding.
  4. National interest (Article 249)

    If the Rajya Sabha declares, by a resolution supported by not less than two-thirds of members present and voting, that it is necessary or expedient in the national interest, Parliament may legislate on a State List matter, or on GST under Article 246A, while the resolution remains in force.

    Who legislates
    Parliament, on the authority of a Rajya Sabha resolution.
    Scope
    Any State List matter, or GST, specified in the resolution (Article 249(1)).
    Illustration
    The Rajya Sabha, the States' own chamber, must authorise any entry into their field.
    Limit or condition
    The resolution lasts up to one year and may be renewed; the law lapses six months after the resolution ends.
  5. Emergency (Article 250)

    While a Proclamation of Emergency is in operation, Parliament may make laws for the whole or any part of India on any State List matter, or on GST under Article 246A. Such laws cease to have effect six months after the Proclamation ends, to the extent Parliament was otherwise incompetent to make them.

    Who legislates
    Parliament, during a national emergency under Article 352.
    Scope
    Any State List matter, or GST, for the whole or any part of India (Article 250(1)).
    Illustration
    The federal division of legislative power yields to a unitary one for the duration of a national emergency.
    Limit or condition
    Laws lapse six months after the Proclamation ceases to operate (Article 250(2)).
  6. Consent of States (Article 252)

    If all the Houses of the legislatures of two or more States pass resolutions asking Parliament to regulate a State matter, Parliament may legislate for those States, and other States may adopt the Act by resolution. Only Parliament can then amend or repeal it, so consent once given is hard to reverse.

    Who legislates
    Parliament, at the request of two or more State legislatures.
    Scope
    A matter otherwise outside Parliament's competence, for the requesting States and any that later adopt the Act.
    Illustration
    The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 was enacted after State resolutions under Article 252.
    Limit or condition
    A State cannot amend or repeal the Act for itself; only Parliament can (Article 252(2)).
  7. International agreements (Article 253)

    Notwithstanding the division of powers, Parliament may make any law for the whole or any part of India to implement a treaty, agreement or convention, or a decision of an international conference or body. Treaty-making can therefore carry the Union into subjects otherwise reserved to the States.

    Who legislates
    Parliament, whichever List the subject falls in.
    Scope
    Any subject, to implement treaties, agreements, conventions or decisions of international bodies.
    Illustration
    The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 recites the decisions of the 1972 Stockholm Conference it was enacted to implement.
    Limit or condition
    Laws remain subject to fundamental rights and other constitutional limits.
  8. Repugnancy (Article 254)

    On a Concurrent subject, a Union law prevails over an inconsistent State law, which is void to the extent of the repugnancy (Article 254(1)). A State law reserved for and assented to by the President prevails in that State (Article 254(2)), though Parliament may later amend or repeal it.

    Who legislates
    Both, with Parliament's law prevailing in a conflict on Concurrent matters.
    Scope
    Inconsistency between Union and State laws, mainly on Concurrent List subjects.
    Illustration
    States have used Article 254(2) assent to adapt Union labour and land laws to local conditions.
    Limit or condition
    A State law with presidential assent prevails only in that State and only until Parliament legislates again.
Sources4
  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended), Part XI and the Seventh Schedule (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  2. 02The Constitution (Seventh Amendment) Act, 1956; The Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976; The Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016. Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  3. 03Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India (reproduction of the official text) (opens in a new tab). Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India
  4. 04Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Plate 13ClassificationOriginal

Constitutional bodies by function

The bodies and offices the Constitution itself creates to run elections, recruit civil servants, divide and audit public money, protect disadvantaged groups and advise governments on law, grouped by function with their articles.

  1. 01 · 2 entries

    Elections

    • Election Commission of India (Article 324)

      Superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, the State legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President is vested in the Commission. The Chief Election Commissioner can be removed only like a Supreme Court judge, and under Article 324(2) appointments follow a 2023 Act providing a selection committee.

      More detail

      The committee comprises the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition (or leader of the largest opposition party) and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. In Anoop Baranwal (2023) the Supreme Court had directed, pending a law, a committee that included the Chief Justice of India.

    • State Election Commissions (Articles 243K, 243ZA)

      Each State has a State Election Commissioner, appointed by the Governor, to conduct elections to panchayats (Article 243K) and municipalities (Article 243ZA). Created by the 73rd and 74th Amendments, the Commissioner can be removed only like a High Court judge, so that local elections do not depend on a State government's convenience.

  2. 02 · 1 entry

    Public services

    • Union Public Service Commission (Article 315)

      Article 315 provides a Public Service Commission for the Union and for each State. The UPSC conducts examinations for the Union's services and is to be consulted on recruitment, promotions and discipline (Article 320). Members serve six years or until sixty-five, and removal for misbehaviour requires a Supreme Court inquiry (Article 317).

      More detail

      Consultation under Article 320(3) has been held directory rather than mandatory, and the Commission's annual report goes to Parliament with reasons for any advice not accepted (Article 323).

  3. 03 · 3 entries

    Public finance and audit

    • Finance Commission (Article 280)

      Constituted by the President every fifth year or earlier, with a Chairman and four other members, it recommends how the net proceeds of shareable Union taxes are divided between the Union and the States and among the States, and the principles governing grants-in-aid. The Sixteenth Commission was constituted for 2026–31.

    • Comptroller and Auditor General (Articles 148–151)

      Appointed by the President by warrant and removable only like a Supreme Court judge (Article 148), the CAG audits the accounts of the Union and the States. Reports on Union accounts go to the President, who has them laid before Parliament (Article 151), where the Public Accounts Committee examines them.

    • GST Council (Article 279A)

      Chaired by the Union Finance Minister, with a Union Minister of State and a minister nominated by each State, the Council recommends GST rates, exemptions and model laws. Decisions need three-quarters of the weighted votes of members present and voting, the Union's vote counting for one-third and the States' together for two-thirds.

  4. 04 · 3 entries

    Protective commissions

    • National Commission for Scheduled Castes (Article 338)

      A Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson and three other members appointed by the President investigate and monitor the safeguards for Scheduled Castes, inquire into complaints and advise on their socio-economic development. Its reports are laid before Parliament with a memorandum on action taken; it recommends but cannot compel.

    • National Commission for Scheduled Tribes (Article 338A)

      The 89th Amendment (2003) divided the joint commission for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, and this Commission was constituted in 2004. It monitors the safeguards for Scheduled Tribes, whose concerns over land, forests, displacement and self-government in Scheduled Areas differ from those of Scheduled Castes.

    • National Commission for Backward Classes (Article 338B)

      First created by statute in 1993 on the Supreme Court's direction in Indra Sawhney, it gained constitutional status through the 102nd Amendment (2018). The 105th Amendment (2021) then restored each State's power to prepare its own list of socially and educationally backward classes.

  5. 05 · 2 entries

    Law officers

    • Attorney General for India (Article 76)

      An office rather than a body: the Union's highest law officer, appointed by the President from those qualified to be Supreme Court judges. The Attorney General advises the Government of India, has a right of audience in all courts, may speak in Parliament without a vote and holds office at the President's pleasure.

    • Advocate General for the State (Article 165)

      The State counterpart of the Attorney General, appointed by the Governor from those qualified to be High Court judges. The Advocate General advises the State government on legal matters, may speak in the State legislature without a vote (Article 177) and holds office during the Governor's pleasure.

Sources3
  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  2. 02Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  3. 03Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Plate 14Relationship mapOriginal

Centre–State relations

The constitutional channels between the Union and the States, legislative, administrative, financial and emergency, and the institutions that work them, from the Governor to the Inter-State Council, with statutory bodies such as the zonal councils marked as statutory.

Who connects to whom

  1. Union government (acting through the President)

    Most Centre–State powers are formally the President's, exercised on the Union Council of Ministers' advice: appointing Governors, proclaiming emergencies, constituting Finance Commissions and establishing the Inter-State Council. Together with the Union's power to give directions to States, these channels are in practice controlled by the Union government.

    Connects to 03 Administrative relations (Articles 256–263),05 Finance Commission (Article 280),07 Emergency provisions (Articles 352, 356, 360),08 Governor (Articles 153–162),09 Inter-State Council (Article 263)

  2. Legislative relations (Articles 245–255)

    Articles 245–255 and the Seventh Schedule divide law-making by subject: an exclusive Union List, an exclusive State List and a Concurrent List, with the residuary power and primacy in conflict lying with Parliament. Parliament may enter the State field in the national interest, in an emergency, by State consent or to implement treaties.

    Connects to 03 Administrative relations (Articles 256–263),04 Financial relations (Articles 264–293),06 GST Council (Article 279A),07 Emergency provisions (Articles 352, 356, 360),08 Governor (Articles 153–162)

  3. Administrative relations (Articles 256–263)

    States must exercise executive power so as to comply with Union laws and not impede the Union's executive power, and the Union may give directions to that end (Articles 256–257). Either level may entrust functions to the other by consent (Articles 258, 258A), and Parliament may provide for adjudicating inter-State river disputes (Article 262).

    Connects to 01 Union government (acting through the President),02 Legislative relations (Articles 245–255),07 Emergency provisions (Articles 352, 356, 360),08 Governor (Articles 153–162),09 Inter-State Council (Article 263),10 Zonal councils (statutory)

    More detail

    If a State fails to comply with Union directions, Article 365 lets the President treat it as a failure of constitutional machinery, the bridge to Article 356.

  4. Financial relations (Articles 264–293)

    Taxing powers follow the Lists, leaving the Union with most revenue and the States with most spending. Union taxes form a divisible pool shared on Finance Commission advice (Article 270), statutory and discretionary grants flow under Articles 275 and 282, and States indebted to the Union need its consent to borrow (Article 293(3)).

    Connects to 02 Legislative relations (Articles 245–255),05 Finance Commission (Article 280),06 GST Council (Article 279A),07 Emergency provisions (Articles 352, 356, 360)

    More detail

    Cesses and surcharges are excluded from the divisible pool, and the Union's growing reliance on them is a standing grievance of the States.

  5. Finance Commission (Article 280)

    A constitutional body appointed by the President every fifth year or earlier to recommend the share of divisible Union taxes that goes to the States, its distribution among them and the principles governing grants-in-aid. It is the main rule-based channel of fiscal transfer between the two levels.

    Connects to 01 Union government (acting through the President),04 Financial relations (Articles 264–293),06 GST Council (Article 279A)

  6. GST Council (Article 279A)

    A constitutional forum of the Union and State finance ministers that recommends goods and services tax rates and rules, deciding by three-quarters of weighted votes with the Union's vote counting for one-third. GST pooled fiscal sovereignty, and the Council has become a standing arena of cooperative and contested federalism.

    Connects to 02 Legislative relations (Articles 245–255),04 Financial relations (Articles 264–293),05 Finance Commission (Article 280)

  7. Emergency provisions (Articles 352, 356, 360)

    Three emergencies centralise power: a national emergency when India's security is threatened by war, external aggression or armed rebellion (Article 352), President's Rule when a State's government cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution (Article 356), and a financial emergency when India's financial stability or credit is threatened (Article 360).

    Connects to 01 Union government (acting through the President),02 Legislative relations (Articles 245–255),03 Administrative relations (Articles 256–263),04 Financial relations (Articles 264–293),08 Governor (Articles 153–162)

    More detail

    President's Rule needs approval by both Houses within two months and lasts six months at a time, up to three years. Since S.R. Bommai (1994) proclamations are open to judicial review and a government's majority is tested on the floor of the House.

  8. Governor (Articles 153–162)

    Appointed by the President and holding office during the President's pleasure, in practice the Union government's (Articles 155–156), the Governor is the State's constitutional head and a link between the levels: exercising the State's executive power on ministerial advice, reporting under Article 356 and reserving Bills for the President (Article 200).

    Connects to 01 Union government (acting through the President),02 Legislative relations (Articles 245–255),03 Administrative relations (Articles 256–263),07 Emergency provisions (Articles 352, 356, 360),10 Zonal councils (statutory)

    More detail

    In November 2025 the Supreme Court, answering a presidential reference, advised that courts cannot fix timelines for Governors to act on Bills but may direct a Governor to act after prolonged, unexplained inaction.

  9. Inter-State Council (Article 263)

    Article 263 lets the President establish a council to inquire into disputes between States, investigate subjects of common interest and recommend better coordination of policy. Set up in 1990 on the Sarkaria Commission's recommendation and chaired by the Prime Minister, it has met only rarely.

    Connects to 01 Union government (acting through the President),03 Administrative relations (Articles 256–263),10 Zonal councils (statutory)

    More detail

    The 1990 Order did not give the Council the Article 263(a) function of advising on disputes between States; a Standing Committee chaired by the Union Home Minister prepares its work.

  10. Zonal councils (statutory)

    Statutory, not constitutional: five councils, Northern, Central, Eastern, Western and Southern, created by the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. Chaired by the Union Home Minister, with the Chief Ministers and two other ministers from each State, they advise on regional matters such as boundaries, transport and linguistic minorities.

    Connects to 03 Administrative relations (Articles 256–263),08 Governor (Articles 153–162),09 Inter-State Council (Article 263)

    More detail

    The North Eastern Council, created by its own Act in 1971, is a separate statutory body for the north-eastern States.

Sources5
  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended), Parts XI, XII and XVIII (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  2. 02States Reorganisation Act, 1956 (Part III: Zonal Councils). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  3. 03Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988
  4. 04Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Punchhi Commission), 2010
  5. 05Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Plate 15Relationship mapOriginal

Chains of constitutional accountability

Who answers to whom: ministers to the Lok Sabha, the executive to Parliament, public spending to the CAG and Public Accounts Committee, and all power to courts and voters, with the statutory right to information marked as statutory.

Who connects to whom

  1. Council of Ministers

    The government in practice: the Prime Minister and ministers who aid and advise the President (Article 74). Every chain of accountability runs to or through it, because it directs the administration whose decisions Parliament questions, the CAG audits, courts review and voters judge.

    Connects to 02 Lok Sabha: collective responsibility (Article 75(3)),03 Parliamentary questions and motions,04 Parliamentary committees,05 Comptroller and Auditor General (Articles 148–151),06 Public Accounts Committee,07 Judicial review,10 Right to information (statutory)

  2. Lok Sabha: collective responsibility (Article 75(3))

    The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the House of the People, so it holds office only while it keeps the Lok Sabha's confidence. Under the House's rules a no-confidence motion needs the support of fifty members to be taken up; defeat on it, or on a major financial measure, signals that confidence is lost.

    Connects to 01 Council of Ministers,03 Parliamentary questions and motions,09 Citizens and elections

  3. Parliamentary questions and motions

    Question Hour tests ministers' command of their departments through starred and unstarred questions, and adjournment, calling-attention and censure motions force debate on urgent failures. These devices rest on the Houses' rules of procedure, made under Article 118, rather than on the constitutional text itself.

    Connects to 01 Council of Ministers,02 Lok Sabha: collective responsibility (Article 75(3)),04 Parliamentary committees

    More detail

    The suspension of Question Hour in the Monsoon Session of 2020 showed how far these devices depend on the restraint of the majority.

  4. Parliamentary committees

    Committees allow sustained, less partisan scrutiny: twenty-four departmentally related standing committees examine demands for grants and Bills, and the financial committees examine spending after the event. Like questions, they are creatures of the rules of procedure, and their influence depends on how often Bills are referred to them.

    Connects to 01 Council of Ministers,03 Parliamentary questions and motions,06 Public Accounts Committee

  5. Comptroller and Auditor General (Articles 148–151)

    An independent auditor who can be removed only like a Supreme Court judge (Article 148). The CAG audits Union and State accounts under a 1971 Act (Article 149) and reports to the President or the Governor, who must have the reports laid before Parliament or the State legislature (Article 151).

    Connects to 01 Council of Ministers,06 Public Accounts Committee

  6. Public Accounts Committee

    A committee of Parliament, constituted under the rules of procedure rather than the Constitution, that examines the government's accounts and the CAG's audit reports, asking whether money was spent as Parliament intended. By convention since 1967 its chair is a member of the Opposition, and ministers cannot be members.

    Connects to 01 Council of Ministers,04 Parliamentary committees,05 Comptroller and Auditor General (Articles 148–151)

    More detail

    Its weakness is timing: it examines spending after the event, often years later, and the government answers through action-taken reports.

  7. Judicial review

    Courts hold public power to the Constitution: laws for competence and fundamental rights, executive action for legality and reasonableness, and amendments for the basic structure. Writs under Articles 32 and 226 let individuals challenge official action, and review itself is part of the basic structure (L. Chandra Kumar, 1997).

    Connects to 01 Council of Ministers,08 Election Commission of India (Article 324),09 Citizens and elections,10 Right to information (statutory)

    More detail

    Review reaches the electoral process too: in February 2024 the Supreme Court struck down the electoral bond scheme for violating voters' right to information.

  8. Election Commission of India (Article 324)

    The Commission superintends, directs and controls elections to Parliament, the State legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President, so it guards the chain through which voters hold governments to account. Its own independence rests on the Chief Election Commissioner's protected tenure and on appointment rules set by statute.

    Connects to 07 Judicial review,09 Citizens and elections

  9. Citizens and elections

    The final chain runs to voters. Elections to the Lok Sabha and the State assemblies are held on the basis of adult suffrage, every citizen aged eighteen or more being entitled to register unless disqualified (Article 326), and save in an emergency the Lok Sabha must face the electorate at least every five years (Article 83(2)).

    Connects to 02 Lok Sabha: collective responsibility (Article 75(3)),07 Judicial review,08 Election Commission of India (Article 324),10 Right to information (statutory)

  10. Right to information (statutory)

    Statutory, not constitutional: the Right to Information Act, 2005 lets citizens demand records from public authorities, with appeals to information commissions that can penalise officers. The Supreme Court had earlier inferred a right to know from Article 19(1)(a), but the enforcement machinery is created by Parliament and can be changed by it.

    Connects to 01 Council of Ministers,07 Judicial review,09 Citizens and elections

    More detail

    A 2019 amendment gave the Union control of information commissioners' terms and pay, and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 rewrote the Act's exemption for personal information.

Sources5
  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  2. 02Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha. Lok Sabha Secretariat
  3. 03Comptroller and Auditor-General's (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act, 1971. Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  4. 04Right to Information Act, 2005 (as amended). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
  5. 05Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Plate 16TimelineOriginal

How the Constitution has evolved

From the Government of India Act, 1935 and the Constituent Assembly to the amendments and judgments that reshaped the Constitution, a timeline of the dialogue between Parliament's amending power and the Supreme Court's basic structure doctrine.

  • Founding
  • Amendment
  • Judgment
  1. · Founding

    Government of India Act, 1935

    The longest statute the British Parliament had then passed proposed an all-India federation, which never came into being, and gave the provinces responsible government. Its division of legislative power into federal, provincial and concurrent lists, its Federal Court and its emergency powers supplied much of the Constitution's structure.

  2. · Founding

    Constituent Assembly first meets

    The Assembly met in the Constitution Hall in New Delhi with Sachchidananda Sinha as provisional chairman; the Muslim League stayed away. Rajendra Prasad was elected permanent President on 11 December, and on 13 December Jawaharlal Nehru moved the Objectives Resolution, whose principles shaped the Preamble.

  3. · Founding

    Constitution adopted

    The Constituent Assembly adopted the Constitution, the date on which the Preamble records that the people of India gave it to themselves. Provisions on citizenship, elections and a few other matters took effect at once (Article 394); the day has been marked as Constitution Day since 2015.

  4. · Founding

    Constitution comes into force

    The Constitution came fully into force and India became a republic, with Rajendra Prasad as President. The Government of India Act, 1935 and the Indian Independence Act, 1947 were repealed, and the Supreme Court took the place of the Federal Court. The date recalled the Purna Swaraj pledge of 1930.

  5. · Amendment

    First Amendment

    The provisional Parliament added public order and other grounds to the permissible restrictions on speech in Article 19(2), enabled special provision for backward classes (Article 15(4)), and inserted Articles 31A and 31B and the Ninth Schedule to shield land reform from judicial challenge.

    More detail

    In Shankari Prasad (October 1951) the Supreme Court upheld the amendment, holding that a constitutional amendment is not 'law' under Article 13(2), so the amending power extends to fundamental rights.

  6. · Amendment

    Seventh Amendment takes effect

    Taking effect with the States Reorganisation Act, the Seventh Amendment gave constitutional form to the reorganisation of States largely on linguistic lines and abolished the four classes of State (Parts A, B, C and D) created in 1950, giving the federation the basic shape it still has.

    More detail

    It also allowed one person to be appointed Governor of two or more States.

  7. · Judgment

    Golaknath

    An eleven-judge bench held by six to five that a constitutional amendment is 'law' under Article 13, so Parliament cannot take away or abridge fundamental rights. Applying prospective overruling, it left earlier amendments intact, and set off a confrontation that the 24th Amendment and Kesavananda Bharati would resolve.

  8. · Amendment

    Twenty-fourth Amendment

    Parliament's reply to Golaknath declared that the amending power under Article 368 is constituent and extends to any provision, including fundamental rights, added Article 13(4) to exclude amendments from the meaning of 'law', and made the President's assent to amendment Bills obligatory.

  9. · Judgment

    Kesavananda Bharati

    By seven to six, a thirteen-judge bench overruled Golaknath and upheld the 24th Amendment, but held that Parliament may not use the amending power to destroy the Constitution's basic structure. The limit has governed every amendment since, and the Court left the list of basic features open.

  10. · Judgment

    Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain

    During the Emergency the Court struck down clause (4) of Article 329A, inserted by the 39th Amendment to place the Prime Minister's election beyond judicial scrutiny, as destructive of the basic structure; Khanna J identified free and fair elections as an essential feature of democracy.

    More detail

    The Court nonetheless upheld Indira Gandhi's election under retrospectively amended election law.

  11. · Amendment

    Forty-second Amendment

    Passed during the Emergency, the 'mini-Constitution' added 'socialist', 'secular' and 'integrity' to the Preamble, inserted fundamental duties and new directive principles, moved five subjects to the Concurrent List, extended legislatures' terms and sought to place amendments beyond judicial review.

  12. · Amendment

    Forty-fourth Amendment

    The Janata government's amendment, negotiated with the Opposition majority in the Rajya Sabha, replaced 'internal disturbance' with 'armed rebellion' as a ground for national emergency, required the Cabinet's written decision, made Articles 20 and 21 non-suspendable, ended the fundamental right to property and restored five-year terms.

  13. · Judgment

    Minerva Mills

    A Constitution Bench struck down the 42nd Amendment's clauses making the amending power unlimited and unreviewable, and the extension of Article 31C to every directive principle, holding that a limited amending power and the balance between Parts III and IV are themselves basic features.

  14. · Amendment

    Fifty-second Amendment: anti-defection law

    The amendment added the Tenth Schedule, disqualifying legislators who give up membership of their party or defy its whip, with the Speaker or Chairman deciding. Kihoto Hollohan (1992) upheld the law but subjected presiding officers' decisions to judicial review; the 91st Amendment (2003) removed the exception for splits.

  15. · Amendment

    Sixty-first Amendment

    Article 326 was amended to lower the voting age for elections to the Lok Sabha and the State Legislative Assemblies from twenty-one to eighteen. Unlike most amendments, which adjust the balance between institutions, it widened the electorate itself.

  16. · Judgment

    Indra Sawhney

    A nine-judge bench upheld twenty-seven per cent reservation for other backward classes in central posts but excluded the creamy layer, held that reservation should not ordinarily exceed fifty per cent and ruled out reservation in promotions. Each holding has since prompted amendments and further litigation.

  17. · Amendment

    73rd and 74th Amendments in force

    The 73rd Amendment came into force, giving panchayats constitutional status in Part IX with a three-tier structure, regular elections, reservations for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and women, and State Finance Commissions. The 74th Amendment, creating Part IXA for municipalities, followed on 1 June 1993.

  18. · Judgment

    S.R. Bommai

    A nine-judge bench subjected President's Rule under Article 356 to judicial review, made the floor of the House the test of a government's majority, and held that an Assembly may not be dissolved before Parliament approves the proclamation. It treated secularism and federalism as basic features.

  19. · Amendment

    Eighty-sixth Amendment

    Article 21A made free and compulsory education for children aged six to fourteen a fundamental right, in such manner as the State may by law determine; Article 45 was recast for early childhood care, and a parental duty was added to the fundamental duties. Article 21A came into force on 1 April 2010.

  20. · Judgment

    I.R. Coelho

    A unanimous nine-judge bench held that laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973, the date of Kesavananda Bharati, are open to challenge if they damage the basic structure, including the rights in Articles 14, 19 and 21. The Schedule ceased to be a complete shield.

  21. · Amendment

    Ninety-seventh Amendment

    The amendment added the right to form co-operative societies to Article 19(1)(c), inserted Article 43B on promoting co-operatives and created Part IXB on their democratic functioning. In Rajendra N. Shah (2021) the Supreme Court, by a majority, held Part IXB invalid for co-operatives within the States, for want of ratification by the States.

    More detail

    Part IXB survives for multi-State co-operative societies and those in Union territories, and the changes to Articles 19 and 43B were unaffected.

  22. · Judgment

    NJAC case

    By four to one, a five-judge bench struck down the 99th Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014, which Parliament had passed almost unanimously and more than half the States had ratified, holding judicial primacy in appointments to be part of the basic structure. The collegium revived.

  23. · Amendment

    One Hundred and First Amendment

    The goods and services tax amendment gave Parliament and the State legislatures simultaneous power to tax goods and services (Article 246A), created the GST Council (Article 279A) and rewrote the Seventh Schedule's tax entries. GST was rolled out on 1 July 2017, pooling fiscal sovereignty between the two levels.

  24. · Amendment

    One Hundred and Third Amendment

    Articles 15(6) and 16(6) enabled reservation of up to ten per cent in education and public employment for economically weaker sections outside the existing reserved categories, the first constitutional basis for reservation on economic criteria alone. The Supreme Court upheld it by three to two in Janhit Abhiyan (2022).

  25. · Amendment

    One Hundred and Fourth Amendment

    Reservation of seats for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies was extended to 25 January 2030, while the nomination of Anglo-Indian members was allowed to lapse in January 2020. The time limit in Article 334 has been extended in this way every decade.

  26. · Amendment

    One Hundred and Fifth Amendment

    After the Maratha reservation judgment of May 2021 read the 102nd Amendment as leaving only the President to identify socially and educationally backward classes, Parliament restored each State's power to prepare and maintain its own list (Article 342A(3)), passing the amendment without dissent.

  27. · Amendment

    One Hundred and Sixth Amendment

    The Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam reserves one-third of seats in the Lok Sabha, the State Assemblies and the Delhi Assembly for women (Articles 330A, 332A and 239AA), for fifteen years, rotating after each delimitation. The reservation takes effect only after a delimitation based on the first census after the amendment's commencement (Article 334A).

    More detail

    The official edition of the Constitution (as on 1 May 2026) records the provisions inserting Articles 330A, 332A and 334A as in force from 16 April 2026. On 17 April 2026 a further amendment Bill, which would have enlarged the Lok Sabha and based delimitation on the 2011 census, fell short of the two-thirds majority required in the Lok Sabha, so the reservation still awaits the census and delimitation.

Sources5

Original explanatory diagram: a plain-language summary, not the constitutional text.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

In context: the Constitution Explorer

Every visual is original to this platform and drawn from its content files; each lists the sources it rests on. The constitutional diagrams summarise provisions in plain language: for the official wording, open the article pages they link to. The IB visuals are independent teaching material, not produced or endorsed by the International Baccalaureate Organization. Back to the Knowledge Lab.