Core topic · First assessment 2026
Sovereignty in global politics
Sovereignty as a claim to supreme authority: its classical and modern meanings, its sources, its internal and external faces, and the challenges that test it, from globalisation and secession to R2P and indigenous claims.
Prescribed content
- Nature of state sovereignty
- Traditional and modern notions of state sovereignty
- Sources of sovereignty
- Internal and external dimensions of sovereignty
- Challenges to state sovereignty
Overview
Sovereignty is the organising principle of the modern international system. The guide’s initial guidance describes it as a state’s independence, its control over territory and its ability to govern itself, and frames a live dispute: some argue that sovereignty is being eroded by forces states cannot fully control, such as borderless communication and trade, while others argue that states still exercise great power when acting in their national interest.
The prescribed content has two strands. The first is the nature of state sovereignty: traditional and modern notions, its sources, and its internal and external dimensions. The second is challenges to state sovereignty, which the guide asks students to assess according to which notion of sovereignty is in view. Sovereignty is also to be studied through the thematic studies, because it carries different implications for rights, for development and for conflict.
The unit’s argument fits in one sentence. Sovereignty is a claim to supreme authority; power decides whether the claim holds, legitimacy whether it is accepted, and interdependence what it is worth.
Inquiry questions
- Who decides which entities are states?
- Can a state be sovereign and powerless at the same time?
- Does pooling sovereignty express it or surrender it?
- Is intervention the enemy of sovereignty or, in some cases, its enforcement?
- Can sovereignty survive when data, capital and pathogens ignore borders?
01Classical and modern meanings
Jean Bodin, in Six Books of the Commonwealth (1576), defined sovereignty as the absolute and perpetual power of a commonwealth: subject to no higher authority and outlasting any ruler. Thomas Hobbes, in Leviathan (1651), added that it must be undivided, since divided authority cannot keep the peace. Max Weber supplied an empirical test: a state is the community that successfully claims a monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a territory. Where that claim fails, the state is fragile, whatever its legal status.
Two dimensions follow. Internal sovereignty is supreme authority within the state, whose decisions bind every person and institution inside its borders. External sovereignty is the absence of any higher authority in external affairs, together with recognition as an equal by other states. Cutting across both is the distinction between legal sovereignty, the right to make final decisions under law, and political sovereignty, the capacity to have them obeyed. The instructive cases are those in which the two come apart.
Modern notions widen the concept. Popular sovereignty, from Rousseau and the democratic revolutions, locates final authority in the people. Pooled sovereignty describes states exercising authority jointly, as members of the European Union do. Conditional sovereignty treats sovereignty as carrying duties whose breach may forfeit immunity from intervention. Claims to digital or data sovereignty assert control over infrastructure and information that ignore territorial borders.
02From Westphalia to the present
The Peace of Westphalia (1648) is the conventional shorthand for a system of territorial states that recognise no external authority over their internal affairs. Historians such as Andreas Osiander have shown that the treaties did not create that system at a stroke, and strong answers treat 1648 as a symbol of a centuries-long consolidation rather than a founding date.
The system was also exclusive. European states granted one another sovereignty while denying it to the peoples they colonised, which is why postcolonial scholars describe the international order as a hierarchy rather than an anarchy of equals. The UN Charter (1945) affirmed the sovereign equality of members (Article 2(1)), prohibited the threat or use of force against any state’s territorial integrity (Article 2(4)) and barred UN intervention in matters essentially within domestic jurisdiction (Article 2(7)), subject to Security Council enforcement. Decolonisation universalised the form: UN membership rose from 51 founding states to 193. Formal independence did not end structural inequality, and Walter Mignolo‘s decolonial critique argues that the very model of a proper state was a European export.
The modern history of sovereignty is therefore not a story of simple erosion. International legal sovereignty has never been more widely held, while control over flows of capital, data, people and pathogens has become harder to exercise.
03Four sovereignties and organised hypocrisy
Much confusion about sovereignty is equivocation. Stephen Krasner, in Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (1999), distinguished four meanings. International legal sovereignty is mutual recognition as a formal equal, expressed in UN membership and the capacity to make treaties. Westphalian sovereignty is the exclusion of external actors from domestic authority structures. Domestic sovereignty is the effective organisation of authority within the state, close to Weber’s test. Interdependence sovereignty is the ability to control movements across borders.
The framework shows that a state can gain one sovereignty while losing another. Somalia holds international legal sovereignty but has long lacked domestic sovereignty over much of its territory; Somaliland has the reverse profile. Globalisation erodes interdependence sovereignty, yet international legal sovereignty is more secure than ever.
Krasner’s conclusion is deliberately provocative. Sovereignty is organised hypocrisy: states proclaim non-intervention and equality while routinely breaching them, sometimes by force and often by invitation, and the norms survive because they remain useful. The phrase captures how sovereignty can be at once a real institution and a convenient fiction.
04Sources of sovereignty and the politics of recognition
The guide names four areas to consider: possession and use of force; international law and norms; recognition by other states, given for reasons of economics and the balance of power as well as principle; and the consent, or lack of consent, of the governed through political participation. The sources can conflict, and asking which an entity has and which it lacks is a fast way into a contested case. Taiwan has effective government, armed forces and popular participation but formal recognition from only a small and shrinking number of states. Somalia’s federal government has recognition and a UN seat but limited control on the ground. Palestine is recognised by a large majority of UN members, including the United Kingdom, Canada and France from September 2025, yet it lacks control of its territory, and the United States vetoed its admission to full UN membership in April 2024.
Two doctrines frame the debate. The declaratory theory holds that a state exists once it meets the criteria of the 1933 Montevideo Convention (population, territory, government and capacity to enter into relations), recognition merely acknowledging the fact. The constitutive theory holds that recognition creates statehood. Practice sits uneasily between them. Kosovo declared independence in 2008, and the International Court of Justice advised in 2010 that the declaration did not violate international law, yet the number of states recognising it is disputed and some have withdrawn recognition. No new member has joined the UN since South Sudan in 2011: the club of sovereigns decides who may enter.
05Self-determination and territorial integrity
The UN Charter upholds both the self-determination of peoples (Article 1(2)) and the territorial integrity of states (Article 2(4)). When a people within a state seeks to leave, the two principles point in opposite directions, and outside the colonial context international law offers no rule for choosing between them.
Four cases show how the gap is filled. Scotland’s 2014 referendum was held under an agreement with the UK government, which accepted the result in advance; Scotland voted to remain, and in 2022 the UK Supreme Court held that the Scottish Parliament could not legislate for another referendum without Westminster’s consent. Catalonia’s 2017 referendum was held without the consent of the Spanish state, was declared unconstitutional, and the declaration of independence that followed won no recognition. Crimea’s 2014 referendum, held under Russian military control, was followed by annexation and rejected by the UN General Assembly in resolution 68/262, which affirmed Ukraine’s territorial integrity. Kosovo’s declaration followed mass atrocity and NATO intervention and was backed by powerful states, which yielded partial recognition but no UN seat.
The pattern is instructive. Secession succeeds when the parent state consents or powerful states impose it, and fails when neither holds. Law supplies the vocabulary of the argument; consent and power decide the outcome.
06Challenges to state sovereignty
The guide lists two groups of challenges. One comprises increased global interdependence, influence or interference from other states, supranationality and humanitarian intervention. The other comprises indigenous national claims and alternative notions of sovereignty, transnational cultural groups, nationalist movements, violent non-state actors and the influence of transnational companies. Whether each is a challenge depends on which sovereignty is in view.
Globalisation is the central case. WTO rules constrain what a state may tax or subsidise, but states signed the agreements and may leave them, so accepting a binding commitment is itself an exercise of sovereignty. IMF lending conditions leave sovereignty formally intact while narrowing policy autonomy. Some transnational companies command more resources than their host states, yet only states can tax, license and imprison. The COVID-19 pandemic, a borderless threat, produced some of the most sweeping border closures in modern history, including between close allies, which suggests that crisis can reveal sovereignty rather than dissolve it.
Violent non-state actors attack domestic sovereignty directly, as al-Shabaab has in Somalia, and can reach far beyond their territory, as Houthi attacks on Red Sea shipping from late 2023 showed. Military governments in Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger presented the expulsion of French forces and their exit from ECOWAS as a recovery of sovereignty, a claim examined in the Alliance of Sahel States case. Transnational cultural groups such as the Kurds, divided between Türkiye, Iraq, Syria and Iran, test the fit between nation and state. The newest challenge is digital, since data and models cross borders that sovereignty was built to police. States answer by regulating market access, as the EU has with its AI Act, and by controlling data flows, as India’s 2023 data-protection law does by allowing the government to restrict transfers of personal data to specified countries.
07Humanitarian intervention and the Responsibility to Protect
The Responsibility to Protect (R2P) is the most ambitious recent attempt to redefine sovereignty. The International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, set up by Canada, argued in its 2001 report that sovereignty implies a responsibility to protect one’s population, and that when a state is unwilling or unable to prevent large-scale loss of life or ethnic cleansing, the responsibility passes to the international community. The 2005 UN World Summit endorsed a narrower version: each state must protect its population from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity, and collective action, including force, is to be taken through the Security Council case by case.
Libya in 2011 is the case for. Security Council resolution 1973 authorised ‘all necessary measures’ to protect civilians, with Brazil, China, Germany, India and Russia abstaining; the intervention was then widely seen, above all by Russia and China, to have slid into regime change. Syria is the case against: atrocities plainly met the threshold, but repeated draft resolutions were vetoed, and survivors eventually sought accountability in national courts abroad, as the universal jurisdiction case shows. The body that authorises force is the one most likely to be paralysed when a permanent member’s interests are engaged.
Supporters argue that R2P shifted the burden of argument, so that a government accused of atrocities can no longer close the conversation by invoking internal affairs. John Mearsheimer and other realists reply that states do not spend blood and treasure for strangers, and that intervention happens where the target is weak and a great power has interests. Many states of the Global South see sovereign equality as the weak state’s only shield; Brazil’s 2011 proposal of ‘responsibility while protecting’ sought to tie any use of force to stricter accountability. In the language of the norm life cycle, R2P emerged, began to cascade and then stalled.
08Indigenous claims and alternative notions of sovereignty
The guide explicitly includes indigenous national claims and alternative notions of sovereignty, and this is the strand most often skipped. Indigenous claims usually predate the colonial state and were never surrendered; they are often grounded in relationships to land, law and lineage rather than in exclusive control of bounded territory. The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007) affirms a right to self-determination exercised mainly through autonomy and self-government within existing states, which many claimants regard as a partial answer. Arrangements range from Greenland’s self-government within the Danish realm to India’s Sixth Schedule, under which autonomous district councils in parts of the north-east make laws on land, customary practice and local administration. In 2023 Australian voters rejected a proposal to create an Indigenous advisory body in the constitution, showing how contested even modest recognition can be.
Two thinkers named in the guide question the standard model. Mignolo argues that to be heard, a people must frame its claim in the coloniser’s vocabulary of statehood, so the form of the claim is itself a constraint. Qin Yaqing‘s relational theory implies that if authority grows through relationships rather than being exhausted by sharing, sovereignty need not be exclusive to be real, and pooling may enlarge it. Both ask whether exclusive, territorial sovereignty describes the world or reflects one civilisation’s theory that conquest made universal.
Sovereignty from Westphalia to the present
TimelineOriginal
Seventeen moments that show sovereignty changing shape: from the Westphalian symbol and the UN Charter through decolonisation and the responsibility to protect to contested recognitions in 2025, where law supplies the vocabulary and power often decides.
- 1648Peace of Westphalia
- 1933Montevideo Convention
- 1945UN Charter signed
- 1960Declaration on decolonisation
- 1992Maastricht Treaty: pooled sovereignty
- 1999NATO's Kosovo intervention
- 2005World Summit endorses the responsibility to protect
- 2007Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
- 2008Kosovo declares independence
- 2010ICJ advisory opinion on Kosovo
- 2011Resolution 1973 on Libya
- 2011South Sudan joins the UN
- 2014General Assembly on Ukraine's territorial integrity
- 2019ICJ advisory opinion on the Chagos Archipelago
- 2025Russia recognises the Taliban government
- 2025Western states recognise Palestine
- 2025Israel recognises Somaliland
Every entry, in order
Treaties signed at Münster and Osnabrück end the Thirty Years' War. The settlement became shorthand for a system of territorial states recognising no outside authority over their internal affairs, though historians such as Andreas Osiander show that system was consolidated over centuries rather than founded in 1648.
More detailLess detail
Westphalian sovereignty, in Stephen Krasner's terms, is the exclusion of external actors from domestic authority. Treating 1648 as a founding date also hides how long European states denied sovereignty to the peoples they colonised.
American states sign the Convention on the Rights and Duties of States, whose criteria of statehood are a permanent population, a defined territory, a government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. It also declares that a state's political existence is independent of recognition by others.
More detailLess detail
This is the declaratory theory of statehood. The rival constitutive theory holds that recognition creates a state; practice since 1945, from Kosovo to Somaliland, sits uneasily between the two.
Fifty states sign the Charter at San Francisco; it enters into force on 24 October 1945. It affirms the sovereign equality of members (Article 2(1)), prohibits the threat or use of force against any state's territorial integrity (2(4)) and bars UN intervention in domestic matters (2(7)), subject to Security Council enforcement.
More detailLess detail
The Charter also proclaims the self-determination of peoples (Article 1(2)), a principle that pulls against territorial integrity whenever a people within a state seeks to leave.
The General Assembly adopts resolution 1514 (XV), declaring that subjecting peoples to alien domination denies fundamental human rights and that all peoples have the right to self-determination. Decolonisation universalised the sovereign state: UN membership grew from 51 founding members to 193.
More detailLess detail
Postcolonial critics such as Walter Mignolo argue that formal independence spread a European model of the state without ending structural inequality, so decolonisation universalised sovereignty and hierarchy together.
Maastricht Treaty: pooled sovereignty
Twelve European states sign the Treaty on European Union, in force from 1 November 1993, creating economic and monetary union. Members pool authority in supranational institutions whose law has primacy over national law; the United Kingdom's exit in 2020 showed that pooled sovereignty can still be taken back.
More detailLess detail
Whether pooling is a loss or an exercise of sovereignty is the core debate: states chose to join, and the UK left on 31 January 2020 under the withdrawal clause of Article 50 of the Treaty on European Union.
NATO begins air strikes against the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia to stop the repression of Kosovo Albanians, without Security Council authorisation, which Russian and Chinese opposition made unobtainable. Supporters called it humanitarian necessity, critics a breach of Article 2(4). The dilemma led to the idea of a responsibility to protect.
More detailLess detail
The Independent International Commission on Kosovo later called the intervention 'illegal but legitimate', a phrase that captures the gap between law and legitimacy.
World Summit endorses the responsibility to protect
The World Summit Outcome (paragraphs 138–139) commits every state to protect its population from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity, and declares states prepared to act collectively through the Security Council, case by case, where a state manifestly fails. It created no new authority to use force.
More detailLess detail
The International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, set up by Canada, had argued in December 2001 that sovereignty implies responsibility; the Summit endorsed a narrower version. Brazil's 2011 proposal of 'responsibility while protecting' later sought stricter accountability for any use of force.
Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
The General Assembly adopts the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (resolution 61/295), affirming self-determination exercised mainly through autonomy and self-government within existing states. Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States voted against, though all four later endorsed it.
More detailLess detail
Indigenous claims often rest on relationships to land and law that predate the colonial state, which is why they are treated as alternative notions of sovereignty rather than as demands for secession.
Kosovo's leaders declare independence from Serbia, nine years after NATO's intervention and a period of UN administration. The United States and most EU states recognise it; Serbia, Russia, China and five EU members do not. Kosovo has partial recognition and no UN seat, and the number of recognising states is disputed.
ICJ advisory opinion on Kosovo
Answering a General Assembly request made at Serbia's initiative, the International Court of Justice advises that Kosovo's declaration of independence did not violate international law. The Court answered a narrow question: it did not decide whether Kosovo is a state or whether international law confers a right to secede.
More detailLess detail
Law supplied the vocabulary, but outcomes followed consent and power: secession has succeeded where the parent state agreed or powerful states backed it.
The Security Council authorises 'all necessary measures' to protect civilians in Libya, the high point of the responsibility to protect. Brazil, China, Germany, India and Russia abstain. The NATO-led operation that followed was widely seen, above all in Moscow and Beijing, to have slid into regime change.
More detailLess detail
The backlash shaped Syria: Russia and China vetoed repeated draft resolutions, including a 2014 referral to the International Criminal Court, and survivors later sought justice in national courts abroad.
Five days after independence, South Sudan becomes the 193rd member of the United Nations, following a referendum held under the 2005 peace agreement with Khartoum. It remains the latest new member: since then the club of sovereigns has admitted no one, whatever claimants' effective control.
More detailLess detail
Secession with the parent state's consent, as here, has proved the reliable route to membership; Somaliland, Kosovo and Palestine show how far effective control, recognition and membership can come apart.
General Assembly on Ukraine's territorial integrity
After Russia annexes Crimea following a referendum held under Russian military control, the General Assembly adopts resolution 68/262, affirming Ukraine's territorial integrity and declaring that the referendum has no validity. With 100 states in favour, 11 against and 58 abstaining, the vote shows how many states avoid taking sides.
ICJ advisory opinion on the Chagos Archipelago
The International Court of Justice advises that Mauritius's decolonisation was not lawfully completed at independence in 1968, because Britain had detached the Chagos Archipelago, and that the United Kingdom is obliged to end its administration as rapidly as possible. Advisory opinions do not bind, but this one reshaped the dispute.
More detailLess detail
A UK–Mauritius treaty signed on 22 May 2025 would transfer sovereignty while the UK keeps rights over the Diego Garcia base for an initial 99 years. It had not entered into force by October 2026, after the UK paused it for want of US support.
Russia recognises the Taliban government
Russia becomes the first state formally to recognise the Taliban's Islamic Emirate, almost four years after the Taliban took Kabul. The Taliban control the whole country, yet as of November 2026 Russia remained the only state to recognise them, showing that effective control does not compel recognition.
More detailLess detail
Others engage without recognising: China accepted the credentials of a Taliban-appointed ambassador in January 2024, and several neighbours and Gulf states host Taliban-appointed diplomats.
Western states recognise Palestine
The United Kingdom, Canada and Australia recognise the State of Palestine, and France follows the next day at the United Nations. Palestine is now recognised by a large majority of UN members but lacks control of its territory and full membership, which a US veto blocked in April 2024.
More detailLess detail
Recognition is a political signal as much as a legal act: a state recognised by most UN members still cannot join without a Security Council recommendation, where a permanent member's veto decides.
Israel becomes the first UN member state to recognise Somaliland, which declared in 1991 that it had restored the independence it held briefly in 1960. Somalia, the African Union and several states condemn the move. Somaliland has effective government, elections and a currency, but recognition from almost no one.
More detailLess detail
Somalia's federal government claims the territory, and the African Union upholds the principle that borders inherited at independence should be respected. Somaliland's profile, effective control without recognition, is the reverse of Somalia's.
Sources15
- 01Charter of the United Nations (1945) (opens in a new tab). United Nations
- 02Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (Montevideo, 1933)
- 03UN General Assembly resolution 1514 (XV), Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples (1960)
- 04UN General Assembly resolution 60/1, 2005 World Summit Outcome, paragraphs 138–139
- 05UN General Assembly resolution 61/295, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007)
- 06International Court of Justice, Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence in respect of Kosovo, Advisory Opinion of 22 July 2010. International Court of Justice
- 07International Court of Justice, Legal Consequences of the Separation of the Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius in 1965, Advisory Opinion of 25 February 2019. International Court of Justice
- 08UN Security Council resolution 1973 (2011) and UN General Assembly resolution 68/262 (2014)
- 09International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, The Responsibility to Protect (2001)
- 10Stephen D. Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (Princeton University Press, 1999)
- 11Andreas Osiander, 'Sovereignty, International Relations, and the Westphalian Myth', International Organization 55:2 (2001)
- 12Axios, 'UK, Canada and Australia formally recognize Palestinian state' (opens in a new tab), 21 September 2025
- 13The National, 'Israel recognises Somalia's breakaway Somaliland region as independent state' (opens in a new tab), 26 December 2025
- 14The Tribune, 'Russia becomes first country to formally recognise Taliban government in Afghanistan' (opens in a new tab), July 2025
- 15Al Jazeera, 'UK-Mauritius Chagos sovereignty deal stalls amid fears of further delays' (opens in a new tab), 2 October 2026
Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.
Reviewed 20 November 2026
Key ideas
- Sovereignty is a claim to supreme authority that must be recognised to function; it has internal and external dimensions.
- Legal sovereignty is a right and political sovereignty a capacity; the revealing cases are those where they diverge.
- Krasner’s four sovereignties show that a state can gain one form while losing another, and that the norm survives as organised hypocrisy.
- Sovereignty rests on force, law, recognition and consent, and recognition is a political act.
- Self-determination and territorial integrity conflict; secession succeeds when the parent state consents or powerful states impose it.
- R2P reframed sovereignty as responsibility but stalled because the authority to act lies with a Security Council that can be paralysed.
- Indigenous and decolonial perspectives question whether exclusive, territorial sovereignty is universal at all.
Common misconceptions
The misconception
Sovereignty means a state can do whatever it likes.
The correction
Sovereignty has never been absolute in practice. It is a status conferred by mutual recognition, and the states that confer it also write the rules that constrain it. Absolute sovereignty is a theoretical limit, not a description of any real state.
The misconception
State, nation and nation-state mean the same thing.
The correction
A state is a legal and political entity recognised by other states; a nation is a community of identity recognised by its own members; a nation-state is the comparatively rare case in which the two coincide. Many conflicts arise where they do not.
The misconception
The United Nations is a supranational body.
The correction
The UN is intergovernmental. The General Assembly makes recommendations, and only decisions of the Security Council bind members, with each permanent member holding a veto. The EU, whose law takes precedence over national law in its fields of competence, is the clearest supranational example.
The misconception
Recognition is a legal fact that follows automatically from meeting the criteria of statehood.
The correction
Recognition is a political act, granted or withheld for strategic and economic reasons as well as principle. Disputed counts, as with Kosovo, and entities that meet the criteria without recognition, as with Taiwan and Somaliland, show it.
The misconception
Globalisation has simply eroded sovereignty.
The correction
It has eroded control over cross-border flows while international legal sovereignty has spread, and states that pool authority may gain influence they could not exercise alone. The precise answer names which sovereignty is meant.
The misconception
Indigenous and alternative notions of sovereignty are optional extras.
The correction
They are named in the prescribed content and can be examined directly. They also supply the strongest test of whether the Westphalian model is universal.
How it is assessed
Paper 1 sources on sovereignty often concern an intervention, a treaty, a territorial dispute or a recognition decision. Typical tasks include explaining a term such as pooled sovereignty or R2P (question 2), comparing sources with opposed views on non-intervention (question 3) and evaluating a claim such as ‘globalisation has eroded sovereignty’ with your own knowledge (question 4). Always say which sovereignty you mean.
Paper 2 Section A questions bring sovereignty into each theme: universal rights against non-interference, control of resources against lenders’ conditions, territorial integrity against self-determination. Section B integrating questions reward a precise definition and a judgement that distinguishes kinds of sovereignty rather than answering yes or no.
At HL, Paper 3 challenges such as borders, environment and health are hard because problems cross borders while authority does not; naming that tension strengthens both analysis and recommendations. In the engagement project, sovereignty questions appear at local scale in disputes over land rights, planning, policing or indigenous claims: ask who claims final authority, and who recognises it.
Case studies
- Horn of AfricaSomaliland: effective statehood without recognition
- Europe, with global reachThe EU AI Act and the contest to govern artificial intelligence
- Southeast AsiaThe South China Sea arbitration and its aftermath
- South and Central AsiaAfghanistan under the Taliban: control without recognition
- West Africa (Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger)The Alliance of Sahel States: juntas, sovereignty and the exits from ECOWAS and the ICC
- Syria and GermanyUniversal jurisdiction: Syria's torturers in German courts
Practice questions
- Q1IB Paper 1 style4 marks
A source argues that ‘recognition, not effectiveness, makes a state’. Explain this claim with reference to the declaratory and constitutive theories of statehood.
How to approach it
Set out both theories accurately, with the Montevideo criteria for the declaratory view. Explain that the claim endorses the constitutive view and illustrate it with an entity that meets the criteria without wide recognition, such as Taiwan or Somaliland. A final mark can come from noting that practice sits between the two theories.
- Q2IB Paper 1 style6 marks
Compare and contrast two sources’ views of humanitarian intervention, one arguing that sovereignty entails a responsibility to protect and the other that intervention is applied selectively.
How to approach it
Build a running comparison: what each source assumes sovereignty is for, who each thinks should authorise force, and how each reads cases such as Libya and Syria. Note any common ground, for example that both accept atrocity prevention as a goal, and use the terms R2P, right authority and selectivity precisely.
- Q3IB Paper 1 style12 marks
Using the sources and your own knowledge, evaluate the claim that globalisation has eroded state sovereignty.
How to approach it
Use Krasner’s four sovereignties to structure the judgement: interdependence sovereignty eroded, international legal sovereignty strengthened. Weigh the sources’ perspectives, add your own cases (WTO commitments, IMF conditions, COVID-19 border closures, data localisation) and conclude that globalisation changes what sovereignty is used for rather than simply reducing it, if the evidence supports that.
- Q4IB Paper 2 style15 marks
To what extent is state sovereignty conditional on the protection of a state’s population?
How to approach it
Integrate rights and justice with peace and conflict. Present R2P’s claim at full strength and test it against practice: Libya, Syria, vetoes, selectivity and the Global South’s defence of non-intervention. Distinguish the normative claim (sovereignty ought to be conditional) from the empirical one (it is treated as conditional only when great powers agree), and judge.
- Q5IB Paper 2 style15 marks
Examine whether pooling sovereignty in regional organisations increases or reduces a state’s power.
How to approach it
Define pooled sovereignty and distinguish supranational from intergovernmental bodies. Weigh the EU’s collective weight in trade and regulation against loss of autonomy, using Brexit as a test of competing definitions, and compare a looser body such as ASEAN or the AU. Conclude by distinguishing formal autonomy from the capacity to achieve outcomes.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not IB examination questions.
Across the handbooks
Where this unit meets the nine original handbooks: the handbook written for it, the others that take it up, and what each shares with it.
- 01Framing Global Politics
- 02Power
- 03Sovereignty
- 04Legitimacy
- 05Interdependence
- 06Theoretical Perspectives
- 07Rights & Justice
- 08Stakeholders & Actors
- 09Nature, Practice & Study
- Written for this unit
- Takes up this unit
- Shares its cases, concepts or thinkers
Handbook 03Written for this unit
SovereigntyAuthority · Territory · Legitimacy · Responsibility in an Interdependent World
- Cases in common:
- Somaliland: effective statehood without recognition,The South China Sea arbitration and its aftermath
- Thinkers in common:
- Thomas Hobbes,Max Weber,Walter D. Mignolo,Qin Yaqing,John J. Mearsheimer
Leads on to: Legitimacy in global politicsInterdependence in global politicsPeace and conflictPaper 1: working with sources
Handbook 04Takes up this unit
LegitimacyWhy People Obey — and What Happens When They Stop
- Case in common:
- Afghanistan under the Taliban: control without recognition
- Thinkers in common:
- Thomas Hobbes,Jean-Jacques Rousseau,Max Weber
Leads on to: Power in global politicsLegitimacy in global politicsPaper 1: working with sources
Handbook 05Takes up this unit
InterdependenceGlobal Governance, International Law & the Networked World
Leads on to: Legitimacy in global politicsInterdependence in global politicsPaper 1: working with sources
Handbook 09Takes up this unit
Nature, Practice & StudyRights and justice: codification, protection, monitoring, R2P and response
- Concepts in common:
- Human rights,Sovereignty
Leads on to: Rights and justicePaper 2: the essays
Handbook 02Shares material with this unit
PowerDefinitions, Classifications & Contested Meanings
- Cases in common:
- The EU AI Act and the contest to govern artificial intelligence,The South China Sea arbitration and its aftermath
- Thinkers in common:
- Max Weber,Qin Yaqing,John J. Mearsheimer,Walter D. Mignolo
Leads on to: Framing global politicsPower in global politicsTheoretical perspectives in global politicsPaper 1: working with sources
Handbook 01Shares material with this unit
Framing Global PoliticsSystems and Interactions in Global Politics
- Cases in common:
- The South China Sea arbitration and its aftermath,The EU AI Act and the contest to govern artificial intelligence
- Thinker in common:
- Max Weber
Leads on to: Framing global politicsPower in global politicsLegitimacy in global politicsThe engagement projectPaper 1: working with sources
Handbook 08Shares material with this unit
Stakeholders & ActorsRights and justice: states, courts, NGOs, corporations and the most affected
- Concepts in common:
- Legitimacy,Sovereignty
- Thinker in common:
- Max Weber
Leads on to: Legitimacy in global politicsRights and justicePaper 2: the essays
The handbooks are original to this platform. These links follow each handbook’s syllabus coverage and cross-references.
Explore further
Concept
Thinker
Country
Organisation
IB Global Politics
IB case study
- Somaliland: effective statehood without recognition
- The EU AI Act and the contest to govern artificial intelligence
- The South China Sea arbitration and its aftermath
- Afghanistan under the Taliban: control without recognition
- The Alliance of Sahel States: juntas, sovereignty and the exits from ECOWAS and the ICC
- Universal jurisdiction: Syria's torturers in German courts
- Deep-sea mining and the International Seabed Authority
- The Gambia v Myanmar: the Rohingya genocide case at the World Court
- Sri Lanka: default, protest and recovery under an IMF programme
- The WTO Appellate Body impasse
Political briefing
- Bangladesh after the ballot: the BNP's return and India's recalibration
- From The Hague to New York: the General Assembly endorses the world court's climate opinion
- Water, terror and the law: the Indus Waters Treaty after the Hague award of August 2026
- Who taxes the ground beneath? Parliament curbs the States' mineral levies
- No deadlines, no deemed assent: the Supreme Court's opinion on Governors and State Bills
Political Issue Dossier
Resource
Dictionary
Sources
- 01International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024
- 02Arjun Agrawal, Global Politics Handbook 03: Sovereignty (Publisher’s Edition)
- 03Charter of the United Nations (1945) (opens in a new tab)
- 04Stephen D. Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (Princeton University Press, 1999)
- 05International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, The Responsibility to Protect (2001)
- 06UN General Assembly, 2005 World Summit Outcome, resolution 60/1, paragraphs 138–139
- 07UN General Assembly, Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, resolution 61/295 (2007)
- 08Andreas Osiander, ‘Sovereignty, International Relations, and the Westphalian Myth’, International Organization 55:2 (2001)






