Knowledge Lab · PSIR Thinker Comparison Lab
Compare thinkers, question by question
Choose two or three thinkers and read their positions side by side. Agreement is rarely the interesting part: look for the assumption that makes them disagree.
Loading the Atlas…
Curated comparisons
Written comparisons on the dimensions where the real disagreement lies, with the fault line identified and advice on using it in an answer.
- Feminism and postcolonialismTwo critical approaches that ask whose experience mainstream theory treats as universal: feminism foregrounds gender, postcolonialism empire and race, and postcolonial feminism questions both.
- Gandhi and AmbedkarThe defining argument of modern Indian political thought: whether caste could be reformed by moral conversion within Hinduism or had to be annihilated by attacking its religious foundations and giving its victims political power of their own.
- Gandhi and M. N. RoyA religious moralist and a rationalist humanist who attacked each other's politics yet converged on a distrust of centralised power, party politics and the pursuit of office, and on the belief that moral transformation must precede political change.
- Hobbes, Locke and RousseauThree social contract theorists who used the same device, a state of nature and an agreement to leave it, to reach absolute sovereignty, limited constitutional government and popular self-legislation.
- Liberalism and MarxismThe two great modern ideologies of emancipation compared: one seeks freedom through rights, markets and limited government, the other through the abolition of class and the collective control of production.
- Marx and GramsciThe founder of historical materialism and his most original twentieth-century reinterpreter, compared on the state, ideology, revolution and the place of culture in the reproduction of capitalism.
- Plato and AristotleTeacher and student on the same questions, justice, the best regime, property and the claims of the many, answered from opposite starting points: knowledge of the ideal, and the study of what cities actually are.
- Rawls and the CommunitariansThe debate of the 1980s in which Sandel, MacIntyre, Walzer and Taylor challenged Rawls's liberalism for its picture of the self, its claim to neutrality and its universalism, and Rawls's reply in Political Liberalism.
- Rawls and NozickTwo Harvard colleagues who began from the same commitment to the separateness of persons and reached opposite conclusions: justice as fairness and the redistributive state, against entitlement and the minimal state.
- Realism and liberalismThe central debate of international relations: whether anarchy condemns states to competition for power, or whether institutions, interdependence and domestic politics allow durable cooperation.