The Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978
44th Amendment (1978)
The amendment that rebuilt the safeguards against abuse of emergency powers, ended the fundamental right to property and reversed most of the Forty-second Amendment's executive-friendly changes.
01Context
After the Forty-third Amendment, the Janata government sought to make a repetition of 1975–77 constitutionally impossible. The Forty-fourth Amendment Bill as passed by the Lok Sabha went further than the final Act: the Congress majority in the Rajya Sabha rejected some clauses, including a proposal to require a referendum for amending certain basic features, so that the Act represents a negotiated settlement between the parties.
02What it changed
- Emergency: "armed rebellion" replaced "internal disturbance" in article 352; a Proclamation needs the Cabinet's written decision, approval within one month by a special majority of each House and renewal every six months, and the Lok Sabha may revoke it by simple majority.
- Rights in emergencies: article 358 limited to war and external aggression; articles 20 and 21 can no longer be suspended under article 359.
- Property: article 19(1)(f) and article 31 removed; article 300A inserted, making property a constitutional right; article 30(1A) protects minority institutions on acquisition.
- Executive: the President may return ministerial advice once for reconsideration (article 74(1)); the finality clauses of the Thirty-eighth Amendment removed; conditions placed on extending President's Rule beyond one year.
- Institutions: terms of the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies restored to five years; article 329A and article 257A omitted; Supreme Court jurisdiction over presidential election disputes restored; article 361A gave constitutional protection to reporting of legislative proceedings.
03Political and constitutional significance
The amendment is the Constitution's institutional memory of the Emergency. Its emergency safeguards have held since 1978: no national Emergency has been proclaimed since then. Its treatment of property was equally consequential, ending three decades of conflict between land reform and judicial review by removing property from Part III while leaving a guarantee that deprivation must be by law.
Critics of the property change argue that it left individuals, especially the poor whose land is acquired for development, with weaker protection than the rich it was meant to restrain. Courts have responded by reading procedural guarantees into article 300A. The amendment's change to article 22, on preventive detention, has never been brought into force.
04Judicial interpretation
In A.K. Roy v. Union of India (1982) the Supreme Court declined to compel the government to bring into force section 3 of the amendment, which would have amended article 22. Later decisions have treated article 300A as requiring a valid law and, in recent judgments, a fair procedure for acquisition.
Why it matters for UPSC
The Forty-fourth Amendment is one of the most frequently examined. Candidates must know its emergency safeguards article by article, the status of the right to property before and after 1978, and the provisions of the Forty-second Amendment it reversed or retained, and should be able to use it as an example of constitutional learning after a crisis.
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended), with the amending Acts (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India
- 02The Constitution of India (as on 1 May 2026), Legislative Department: the footnotes recording the Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978 (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice