Skip to content

Section F · Federalism

Centre–State Financial Relations

Taxing powers, the sharing of Union taxes, Finance Commissions, grants, the GST Council and borrowing: how money moves between the Union and the States, and why the States want more of it.

Overview

Fiscal federalism in India is built on a deliberate imbalance. The Union has the more buoyant taxes; the States carry most of the responsibility for spending on health, education, police, agriculture and local government. The gap is closed by transfers: a constitutionally mandated share of Union taxes, grants recommended by an independent Finance Commission, and discretionary grants for schemes the Union designs.

Since 2017 the goods and services tax has added a fourth element, a shared tax governed jointly through the GST Council. How fair, predictable and free of conditions these transfers are has become the central question of Indian federalism.

Constitutional and legal provisions

Article 265
No tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law.
Articles 268–269A
Duties levied by the Union but collected by States; taxes assigned to States; apportionment of GST on inter-State supply.
Articles 270–271
Union taxes shared with States through the divisible pool; surcharges retained by the Union.
Articles 275 and 282
Statutory grants-in-aid on Finance Commission recommendation; discretionary grants for any public purpose.
Article 279A
The GST Council (101st Amendment).
Article 280
The Finance Commission, constituted every five years.
Articles 292–293
Borrowing by the Union and the States; States need Union consent to borrow while indebted to it.

Taxing powers and the vertical gap

The Lists separate taxing powers. The Union taxes non-agricultural income and corporations, customs and some excise duties; the States tax land, agricultural income, alcohol for human consumption, vehicles, stamp duty on most instruments and the sale of electricity, and since the mining royalty case (2024) mineral rights. Residuary taxation belongs to the Union. After the GST, both levels share the main tax on goods and services.

The result is a large vertical gap: the Union collects most of the revenue, the States undertake most of the spending. The framers accepted this, partly because a strong Union was needed for planning and redistribution, and built in mandatory sharing to close it.

Sharing Union taxes

Until 2000 the Constitution required only income tax to be shared and allowed Union excise duties to be shared. The 80th Amendment, following the Tenth Finance Commission's alternative scheme, made all Union taxes part of a divisible pool (Article 270), except duties under Articles 268 and 269, GST apportioned under Article 269A, surcharges (Article 271) and cesses levied for specific purposes.

The exclusions have become a grievance. Cesses and surcharges are not shared, and States argue that the Union's increasing reliance on them has reduced the effective share of gross tax revenue transferred to them below the share the Finance Commission recommends.

The Finance Commission

The Finance Commission (Article 280), a chairman and four members appointed by the President every five years, recommends the States' share of the divisible pool (vertical devolution), its distribution among States (horizontal devolution), the principles for grants-in-aid, and measures to supplement the resources of panchayats and municipalities. Its recommendations are laid before Parliament and have almost always been accepted on tax devolution.

The Fourteenth Commission (Y.V. Reddy) raised the States' share from 32 to 42 per cent for 2015–20. The Fifteenth (N.K. Singh) set it at 41 per cent for 2021–26, after the reorganisation of Jammu and Kashmir, and distributed it using income distance (45 per cent), population in 2011 (15), area (15), forest and ecology (10), demographic performance (12.5) and tax effort (2.5). Its move from 1971 to 2011 population figures alarmed southern States, which had reduced fertility earlier; the demographic performance criterion was its answer. The Sixteenth Finance Commission, chaired by Arvind Panagariya, covers 2026–31.

Grants and centrally sponsored schemes

Statutory grants under Article 275, charged on the Consolidated Fund, are recommended by the Finance Commission: revenue deficit grants, sector grants and grants for local bodies, with a specific provision for the welfare of Scheduled Tribes. Discretionary grants under Article 282 let the Union fund any public purpose, and they finance the centrally sponsored schemes through which the Union shapes State spending in health, education, rural development and nutrition, usually with a required State share (commonly 60:40, and 90:10 for north-eastern and Himalayan States).

Until 2015 the Planning Commission also distributed plan assistance, using formulas such as the Gadgil formula of 1969. Its replacement by NITI Aayog ended plan grants and shifted more resources to Finance Commission transfers, but centrally sponsored schemes, with their conditions and branding requirements, remain a point of friction.

GST and the GST Council

The 101st Amendment (2016) created a dual GST, rolled out on 1 July 2017: Central GST and State GST on intra-State supplies, and Integrated GST on inter-State supplies, apportioned between the Union and the destination State. It subsumed Union excise and service tax and State VAT, entry tax and several other levies. The GST Council (Article 279A) consists of the Union Finance Minister as chair, a Union Minister of State and the finance ministers of the States. Decisions need three-quarters of the weighted votes of members present and voting, with the Union's vote counting for one-third and the States' together for two-thirds, so neither side can act alone.

States surrendered most of their indirect taxation in exchange for compensation, guaranteed for five years at an assumed 14 per cent annual growth in revenue. When the pandemic produced a shortfall in 2020, the Union and the States disputed who should borrow to fill it. In Mohit Minerals (2022) the Supreme Court held that the Council's recommendations are persuasive, not binding.

Borrowing

The Union may borrow on the security of the Consolidated Fund within limits Parliament may set (Article 292). States may borrow only within India and, since every State owes money to the Union, need its consent to borrow (Article 293(3)). The Union sets annual borrowing ceilings, linked to a percentage of gross State domestic product, and since 2022 has counted borrowing by State-owned entities against those ceilings. Kerala challenged this in an Article 131 suit; in 2024 the Supreme Court declined interim relief and referred questions on the interpretation of Article 293 to a Constitution Bench.

Debates

Does the vertical fiscal imbalance undermine State autonomy?

One view holds that the imbalance is a sound design: it allows redistribution from richer to poorer States and national standards in core services. The other holds that dependence on transfers, especially conditional scheme funding, gives the Union leverage over State priorities, and that the shrinking share of shareable revenue, the end of GST compensation and borrowing limits have left States with responsibility but little fiscal room. The disagreement is less about the existence of the gap than about the conditions attached to closing it.

Should Finance Commission formulas reward need or performance?

Equity requires transfers to the poorest States, which is why income distance carries the largest weight. Efficiency arguments ask that States that raise their own revenue, control population growth or improve governance should not be penalised. Southern and western States argue that they subsidise others while their populations, and hence their political weight after the next delimitation, decline. Every Commission has balanced the two, and the balance itself is the most contested question in fiscal federalism.

Commissions and committees

  • Tenth Finance Commission1995

    Proposed an alternative scheme sharing a fixed proportion of all Union taxes; enacted by the 80th Amendment (2000).

  • Fourteenth Finance Commission (Y.V. Reddy)2015

    Raised the States' share of the divisible pool from 32 to 42 per cent for 2015–20.

  • Fifteenth Finance Commission (N.K. Singh)2020

    41 per cent share for 2021–26; adopted 2011 population with a demographic performance criterion; conditions on grants to local bodies.

Prelims points

  • Finance Commission: Article 280; chairman and four members; every five years.
  • Fifteenth Finance Commission (N.K. Singh): 41 per cent devolution for 2021–26.
  • Fourteenth Finance Commission (Y.V. Reddy): 42 per cent for 2015–20.
  • The 80th Amendment (2000) placed all Union taxes, with stated exceptions, in the divisible pool.
  • Surcharges (Article 271) and cesses are not shared with States.
  • Article 275 grants are charged on the Consolidated Fund; Article 282 grants are discretionary.
  • GST: 101st Amendment (2016); introduced on 1 July 2017; Articles 246A, 269A and 279A.
  • GST Council: three-fourths weighted majority; the Union's vote counts for one-third and the States' for two-thirds.
  • Article 276 caps profession tax at ₹2,500 a year.
  • Article 293(3): a State indebted to the Union needs its consent to borrow.
  • Sixteenth Finance Commission: chaired by Arvind Panagariya; award period 2026–31.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

3 questions · 2024–2026

  1. 2026 · PSIR I · Q6(c) · 15 marks

    Evaluate the Centre-State relation with reference to Article 293 and analyze its implications for the Indian federal structure.

  2. 2025 · GS-II · Q14 · 15 marks

    Examine the evolving pattern of Centre-State financial relations in the context of planned development in India. How far have the recent reforms impacted the fiscal federalism in India?

  3. 2024 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks

    What changes has the Union Government recently introduced in the domain of Centre-State relations ? Suggest measures to be adopted to build the trust between the Centre and the States and for strengthening federalism.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Centre–State Financial Relations in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Practice questions

  1. Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words

    Vertical fiscal imbalance is a design feature of Indian federalism, not a defect. Discuss.

    How to approach it

    Explain the framers' reasons, the transfer system that closes the gap, and the contemporary pressures (cesses, conditional schemes, GST, borrowing limits); conclude on where reform should focus.

  2. Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    Evaluate the Finance Commission's role in balancing equity and efficiency among States.

    How to approach it

    Use the Fifteenth Commission's criteria, the population controversy and the demographic performance criterion.

  3. Q3UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words

    Has the GST Council created a new form of pooled sovereignty? Discuss with reference to Mohit Minerals (2022).

    How to approach it

    Explain Article 279A, the weighted voting, the compensation bargain and its end, and the Court's holding that recommendations are persuasive; assess what States gained and lost.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
  2. 02Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
  3. 03Report of the Fifteenth Finance Commission for 2021–26 (2020). Finance Commission of India
  4. 04Y.V. Reddy and G.R. Reddy, Indian Fiscal Federalism (2019). Oxford University Press
  5. 05M. Govinda Rao and Nirvikar Singh, Political Economy of Federalism in India (2005). Oxford University Press