Skip to content

The Constitution (One Hundred and Fifth Amendment) Act, 2021

105th Amendment (2021)

The amendment that restored the power of the States to prepare their own lists of socially and educationally backward classes.

01Context

In the Maratha reservation judgment of May 2021 the Supreme Court held, by majority, that the One Hundred and Second Amendment had given the President the exclusive power to identify socially and educationally backward classes, which would have invalidated the lists maintained by States for their own reservations. The government, which had always maintained that this was not its intention, moved quickly; the amendment passed both Houses without dissent in August 2021.

02What it changed

  • Article 342A amended so that the President's notification identifies socially and educationally backward classes for the purposes of the Central Government (the Central List).
  • Article 342A(3) inserted: every State and Union territory may, by law, prepare and maintain its own list of socially and educationally backward classes for its own purposes, which may differ from the Central List.
  • Articles 338B and 366(26C) amended consequentially.

03Political and constitutional significance

The amendment restored the dual-list system that had existed since 1993: a Central List for central government posts and institutions, and State lists for State purposes. It confirmed that identifying backward classes is a shared federal function. It did not address the fifty per cent ceiling, which was the main reason the Maratha quota had been struck down, so the restoration of State power left the substantive question of how much reservation States can provide unresolved.

Why it matters for UPSC

The amendment is a clear example of Parliament correcting a judicial reading of an earlier amendment, and of the interplay between reservation and federalism. Candidates should be able to explain the sequence from the One Hundred and Second Amendment through the Maratha case to this amendment, and why the fifty per cent ceiling remains a live issue.

Sources