Skip to content

The Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Act, 1985

52nd Amendment (1985)Anti-defection law

The amendment that added the Tenth Schedule, disqualifying legislators who defect from the party on whose ticket they were elected.

01Context

Floor-crossing destabilised State governments throughout the late 1960s and 1970s; the phrase "Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram" entered political vocabulary after a Haryana legislator changed parties several times within days in 1967. A Committee on Defections chaired by Y.B. Chavan reported in 1969, and anti-defection Bills were introduced in 1973 and 1978 but lapsed. After its landslide victory in December 1984, Rajiv Gandhi's government made legislation against defection an early priority, and the amendment passed with near-unanimous support in January 1985.

02What it changed

  • Tenth Schedule added, providing for disqualification of members of Parliament and State legislatures who voluntarily give up membership of their party or defy its whip on a vote without permission, unless the party condones the act within fifteen days.
  • Independent members disqualified if they join a party after election; nominated members if they join one more than six months after taking their seats.
  • Exceptions for a "split" by one-third of a legislature party (later deleted in 2003) and for a merger supported by two-thirds of it.
  • Disputes decided by the Speaker or Chairman, with a clause barring the courts' jurisdiction.
  • Articles 101, 102, 190 and 191 amended to make the Tenth Schedule a ground of disqualification.

03Political and constitutional significance

The amendment transformed the relationship between representatives and parties. It largely stopped individual defections for office, but it also gave party leaderships control over their legislators' votes on every question, which critics argue has weakened deliberation and the accountability of ministers to the House. Its exceptions were soon exploited: "splits" engineered through bulk defections led the Ninety-first Amendment to remove the one-third exception, and resignations and prolonged delays by Speakers in deciding petitions remain ways around the law.

04Judicial interpretation

In Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu (1992) the Supreme Court upheld the Tenth Schedule, holding that it does not violate freedom of speech or the basic structure, but struck down paragraph 7, which barred judicial review, for want of ratification by the States; the presiding officer acts as a tribunal whose decisions are subject to limited review. Subhash Desai (2023) emphasised that the political party, not the legislature party, appoints the whip.

Why it matters for UPSC

The anti-defection law is one of the most frequently examined topics in Indian polity. Candidates should know the grounds and exceptions, the role of the presiding officer, the holding in Kihoto Hollohan, the Ninety-first Amendment's changes, and reform proposals such as entrusting decisions to the Election Commission or limiting the whip to confidence and money votes.

Sources