Section C · Union Government
Parliamentary Accountability of the Executive
The devices through which Parliament questions, censures and controls the government, the role of the opposition, and why these instruments have weakened in practice.
Overview
In a parliamentary system the executive answers to the legislature every day, not only at elections. The Indian Parliament has a full set of instruments for this: questions, motions, debates on the budget, committees, and in the last resort the vote of no confidence. Guillermo O'Donnell's distinction is useful here: elections provide vertical accountability, from citizens to rulers, while Parliament, courts and auditors provide horizontal accountability, from one institution to another.
The instruments survive, but their force depends on time, information and the willingness of a majority to tolerate scrutiny. Fewer sittings, disruption, guillotined budgets and the weakening of question hour have reduced what Parliament actually extracts from the government.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Article 75(3)
- The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha.
- Articles 113–116
- Parliament's control over expenditure through demands for grants and appropriation.
- Article 118
- Each House makes rules for its procedure, the source of questions and motions.
- Article 151
- CAG reports on Union accounts are laid before Parliament.
Questions and Zero Hour
The first hour of a sitting is normally Question Hour. Starred questions receive oral answers and allow supplementary questions; unstarred questions receive written answers; short-notice questions, on matters of urgent public importance, can be asked with less than ten days' notice if the Speaker and the minister agree. Question Hour is the most direct test of ministerial command of a department, which is why its suspension during the Monsoon Session of 2020 was so widely criticised.
Zero Hour, which follows, is an Indian innovation dating from 1962 that does not appear in the rules: members raise urgent matters without notice. Half-an-hour discussions allow follow-up on answers that a member considers inadequate.
Motions and debates
An adjournment motion, admissible only in the Lok Sabha and needing the support of fifty members, sets aside normal business to discuss a definite matter of urgent public importance and carries an implied censure. A calling attention motion, another Indian innovation in use since 1954, draws a minister's attention to an urgent matter and requires a statement. Short duration discussions (Rule 193 in the Lok Sabha) allow debate without a vote; a motion under Rule 184 ends in a vote, which is why oppositions often demand it and governments resist it.
The ultimate instruments are the no-confidence motion (Rule 198, needing fifty members, with no reasons required) and the censure motion, which must state reasons and may target a minister or the whole Council. Defeat on the motion of thanks for the President's address, or on a money Bill, also signals loss of confidence. In the Rajya Sabha, notices under Rule 267 to suspend business for a discussion are the opposition's most frequent and most frequently refused device.
Financial accountability
Parliament's control of money is formally strong: no tax without law (Article 265), no expenditure without appropriation, and audit by the CAG examined by the Public Accounts Committee. In practice, the time available to debate demands for grants is short, and most demands are passed by the guillotine without discussion; in some recent years the entire budget has been guillotined amid disruption. Departmentally related standing committees examine demands before the vote, but their reports arrive after positions are fixed. The real scrutiny of spending is retrospective, through audit.
The opposition and its Leader
The Leader of the Opposition has statutory standing under the Salary and Allowances of Leaders of Opposition in Parliament Act, 1977, but recognition in the Lok Sabha has followed a convention, traced to Speaker Mavalankar, that the party must hold a tenth of the seats. No party met it in 2014 or 2019, so the Lok Sabha had no recognised Leader of the Opposition for ten years until June 2024.
The office matters beyond the House: the Leader of the Opposition, or the leader of the largest opposition party, sits on the selection committees for the Central Vigilance Commissioner, the Chief Information Commissioner, the Lokpal, the Director of the CBI, the NHRC and the Election Commission. The absence of a recognised leader therefore weakened accountability institutions well outside Parliament.
Erosion in practice
Several trends have weakened parliamentary accountability. Sittings have declined; significant Bills pass with little debate; ordinances and the money-Bill route avoid the Rajya Sabha; and disruption, used by oppositions of every party, consumes time that could be used for questions. Suspension of members has grown: Rule 374A, adopted by the Lok Sabha in 2001, allows automatic suspension for grave disorder, and in December 2023 a record 146 members of both Houses were suspended in a single session.
The anti-defection law adds a structural constraint: a member who votes against the party whip risks disqualification, so the government's own backbenchers, the most important check in Westminster systems, rarely act independently in India.
Debates
Is disruption a legitimate tool of the opposition?
Leaders of both major national parties have, when in opposition, defended disruption as the only means of forcing a debate the government refuses, and point to occasions when it produced inquiries or resignations. Critics answer that disruption wastes Question Hour, the opposition's best instrument; lets governments pass Bills without debate amid the noise; and erodes public respect for Parliament. A better bargain, they argue, would give the opposition guaranteed time in exchange for orderly proceedings.
Would a fixed calendar and opposition days strengthen accountability?
The United Kingdom allots twenty opposition days a session on which the opposition chooses the subject of debate, and many legislatures fix their sitting calendars in advance. Supporters argue that India would gain predictable scrutiny and less incentive to disrupt. Sceptics doubt that procedural reforms can change incentives created by majoritarian party politics, and note that the executive's control of the calendar is itself a source of its dominance.
Prelims points
- Starred questions get oral answers with supplementaries; unstarred questions get written answers.
- Short-notice questions may be asked with less than ten days' notice.
- Zero Hour is an informal Indian innovation dating from 1962.
- The calling attention motion is an Indian innovation in use since 1954.
- An adjournment motion can be moved only in the Lok Sabha, with the support of 50 members.
- No-confidence motion: Rule 198, 50 members, no reasons needed; a censure motion must state reasons.
- Rule 193: discussion without a vote; Rule 184: motion ending in a vote (Lok Sabha).
- Recognition as Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha follows a 10 per cent convention; statutory status under the 1977 Act.
- Rule 374A (Lok Sabha, 2001) provides for automatic suspension for grave disorder.
In the UPSC papers
Asked by UPSC
4 questions · 2024–2026
2026 · PSIR I · Q7(b) · 15 marks
Highlight any five constitutional provisions that restrain the powers of the executive, and evaluate their effectiveness in current times.
2026 · PSIR I · Q8(b) · 15 marks
Critically comment on the shifts in the functioning of the Indian Parliament in the last two decades.
2024 · GS-II · Q3 · 10 marks
“The growth of cabinet system has practically resulted in the marginalisation of the parliamentary supremacy.” Elucidate.
2024 · GS-II · Q4 · 10 marks
“The duty of the Comptroller and Auditor General is not merely to ensure the legality of expenditure but also its propriety.” Comment.
Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Parliamentary Accountability of the Executive in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
The instruments of parliamentary accountability exist on paper but are weakening in practice. Examine.
How to approach it
Survey questions, motions, financial control and committees; then evidence of erosion (sittings, guillotine, disruption, suspensions, the anti-defection law); end with reforms.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Discuss the role of the Leader of the Opposition in India's accountability institutions.
How to approach it
Explain recognition, the 10 per cent convention, the 2014–24 gap and the selection committees on which the Leader sits.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Is disruption of Parliament ever a legitimate opposition strategy? Discuss.
How to approach it
Weigh the argument from refused debate against the costs to Question Hour and legislative scrutiny; propose institutional alternatives.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
Institution
Political system
Sources
- 01Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha (opens in a new tab). Lok Sabha Secretariat
- 02Subhash C. Kashyap, Our Parliament. National Book Trust
- 03PRS Legislative Research, Vital Stats and legislative briefs (opens in a new tab). PRS Legislative Research
- 04Guillermo O'Donnell, "Horizontal Accountability in New Democracies", Journal of Democracy 9(3) (1998)
- 05Devesh Kapur and Pratap Bhanu Mehta, "The Indian Parliament as an Institution of Accountability" (2006). UNRISD