Skip to content

Thematic study · First assessment 2026

Rights and justice

Every claim of right is a claim about power. What rights, justice, liberty and equality mean; who asserts, enforces and evades them; how a moral claim becomes law; and why the debates do not close.

Prescribed content

  • Rights
  • Justice, including political and social
  • Liberty
  • Equality
  • The state and national governments
  • IGOs, including ICJ, UNHCR, UNHRC, ICC
  • Regional human rights tribunals
  • Civil society organizations, including advocacy
  • Marginalized, vulnerable or most affected groups and individuals
  • Private companies and unions
  • Codification, protection and monitoring
  • International and regional rights frameworks, including the UN system and the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights
  • Development of world norms in rights and justice, including R2P
  • Responses to violations of rights and perceived injustices
  • Diverse standards and understandings of rights
  • Politicization of rights and justice
  • Claims on individual and collective rights

Overview

Every government claims to defend rights and deliver justice. The disagreement in this theme is rarely about whether justice matters; it is about what the words mean, who defines them and who is expected to pay. To declare something a right is to lift it out of ordinary bargaining and majority vote, which is why so many political battles are fought over definitions.

The guide divides the theme into four prescribed topics: contested meanings; the stakeholders and actors who assert and resist claims; the nature, practice and study of rights, from codification to responses to violations; and the debates. The sections follow that order and draw on Handbooks 07, 08 and 09. One argument runs through all four: codification is a promise and enforcement is a fact. The capacities needed to make a right real are spread across actors with no obligation to cooperate.

Inquiry questions

  • Can a right exist if no actor is willing to enforce it?
  • Why do states ratify human rights treaties they do not intend to honour?
  • Is justice possible without equality, and equality of what?
  • Has universal jurisdiction made international criminal justice more or less selective?
  • Who should speak for those who cannot vote, lobby or litigate?

01Contested meanings: rights, justice, liberty and equality

These are essentially contested concepts, in W. B. Gallie's phrase: more evidence cannot settle disputes about them, because the parties disagree about what would count as the right answer. An essay that opens by declaring that justice means fairness has already taken a side.

Rights. A right is an entitlement that others are obliged to respect, so every right implies a duty-bearer and a cost. Natural rights are said to precede the state, legal rights are granted by it, moral rights are claims about what people ought to have, and human rights codify moral claims as universal law. Rights are inalienable in principle and violated in fact. The divide between negative rights (freedom from interference) and positive rights (provision) is shakier than it looks: even a fair trial needs courts and salaries. Group rights, such as self-determination or land, unsettle liberal theory because peoples hold them and they can constrain their own members.

Justice. 'To each their due' settles nothing until 'due' is defined by desert, need, entitlement, equality or utility. John Rawls (A Theory of Justice, 1971) argued that people choosing behind a veil of ignorance would accept inequalities only if they benefit the least advantaged; Robert Nozick (Anarchy, State, and Utopia, 1974) replied that a distribution is just if holdings were justly acquired and transferred (Rawls and Nozick compared). The guide names egalitarian, cosmopolitan and ecological justice: how far justice reaches within a society, beyond the border, and beyond the human and the present. Peter Singer grounds duties to the distant poor in our capacity to help; Thomas Pogge grounds them in our participation in an order that harms them, which turns aid from charity into compensation.

Liberty. Isaiah Berlin distinguished negative liberty, the area in which one is left alone, from positive liberty, self-mastery and the capacity to act, and warned that the second can license coercion in the name of a person's 'true' self. Critics reply that negative liberty alone leaves people free to starve. Amartya Sen's capability approach keeps the substance of positive liberty without its menace.

Equality. Legal, political, opportunity and outcome equality make different demands. Equity treats people differently to reach fair outcomes and can therefore be attacked as discrimination in equality's name. India's Constitution holds both: Article 14 guarantees equality before the law, Article 16 permits reservation of posts for backward classes, and the Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney read such provisions as a means of achieving equality rather than an exception to it.

02Stakeholders and actors

The actor most often accused of violating rights is also the one expected to enforce them. The state signs treaties, staffs courts and polices borders, and is the principal defendant. Other actors exist to pressure, shame, litigate around or replace a state that will not act against itself.

  • International courts. The International Court of Justice settles disputes between states and gives advisory opinions; the International Criminal Court tries individuals. The ICC has jurisdiction but no police. Mongolia did not arrest President Putin during his visit in September 2024 despite a warrant; the Philippines surrendered former President Duterte in March 2025 once his alliance with the government had collapsed, and his charges were confirmed in April 2026. The Court supplies the warrant; politics supplies the arrest. The ICJ route is shown by The Gambia v Myanmar.
  • UN bodies. The Human Rights Council reviews every member state through the Universal Periodic Review, but it is composed of states that elect one another. UNHCR supervises non-refoulement yet relies on voluntary funding from states whose border policies it must criticise.
  • Regional tribunals. The European and Inter-American courts of human rights and the African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights let individuals sue their own states. In 2024 the European Court found in KlimaSeniorinnen v Switzerland that inadequate climate policy breached the Convention. Individual access to the African Court depends on a state's declaration, and several states have withdrawn theirs since 2016.
  • Civil society. Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the Child Rights International Network hold no territory; their power is credible evidence. Keck and Sikkink's boomerang model (Activists Beyond Borders, 1998) explains how groups blocked at home reach transnational networks that press their state from outside.
  • The most affected. Refugees, migrants, children and minorities hold the strongest moral claims and the weakest resources; Hannah Arendt wrote in The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951) that the stateless lose 'the right to have rights'. Yet they act: the ICJ's 2025 climate opinion began with law students in the Pacific.
  • Companies and unions. Supply chains separate the brand that sets price and deadline from the factory that fails. The UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (2011) are voluntary; the binding brand–union safety accord signed after the Rana Plaza collapse in Bangladesh in 2013 proved more effective because breach carried a cost.

A right becomes real when its violation becomes expensive for someone with the power to stop it.

03Nature, practice and study: codification, protection and monitoring

A right climbs a ladder: moral claim, shared norm, declaration, treaty, national law that citizens can invoke, and finally custom or peremptory norm (jus cogens) binding even states that never consented. Each rung a right fails to reach was a political choice.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights was adopted by the UN General Assembly on 10 December 1948 with no votes against and eight abstentions. It was a declaration, not a treaty, because that was the price of agreement, although many of its core prohibitions have since become customary law. Turning it into binding law took until 1966 and produced two covenants: civil and political rights with immediate obligations, and economic, social and cultural rights realised progressively within available resources. This is the guide's point that different conceptions of justice produce different codifications and hierarchies of rights. Torture admits no excuse; a housing shortage always admits one.

Hierarchy appears in law. Some rights cannot be suspended even in emergencies; others can be if an emergency threatens the life of the nation. Reservations let states ratify while excluding provisions: the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (1979) is among the most widely ratified treaties and among the most heavily reserved, often on family and inheritance law.

The UN system pairs charter-based bodies, political and universal, with expert treaty committees whose views bind no one. Regional systems rest on the European Convention (1950), the American Convention (1969) and the African Charter (1981), which recognises peoples' rights and individual duties. The European system works best, largely because the execution of judgments is politically supervised.

The guide notes that actors may lack the means or the will to protect rights. The failures need opposite remedies, capacity-building for one and pressure for the other, and unwilling states prefer to plead incapacity. Monitoring through state reports, peer review, special rapporteurs, commissions of inquiry, NGO documentation and satellite imagery supplies the evidence for every response, which is why repressive governments attack it first.

04World norms, R2P and responses to violations

Norms are built by identifiable actors against resistance. One sign that a norm has been internalised is that violators deny the facts instead of defending the practice. The responsibility to protect, developed by an international commission in 2001 and endorsed at the 2005 World Summit, recasts sovereignty as responsibility: each state must protect its population from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity; others should help; and where a state manifestly fails, the international community should act collectively through the Security Council, with force as a last resort. It created no new legal authority to use force. Libya in 2011 was its high point and its undoing: an operation authorised to protect civilians ended in regime change, and Russia and China later blocked action on Syria, including an ICC referral in 2014. R2P succeeded as a norm and has largely failed as an enforcement mechanism tied to the veto.

Responses run from documentation and shaming through sanctions and prosecution to authorised force, and the choice tracks the violator's exposure more than the gravity of the violation. The guide names the internationalisation of rights through universal jurisdiction and international humanitarian law: when every international route was closed, German courts convicted Syrian officials (universal jurisdiction and Syria). After mass violence, societies weigh retributive against restorative justice, and how a conflict ended usually decides which they get, as Colombia's peace process shows. The named violations, from child soldiers, trafficking, forced labour and forced relocation to abuses of prisoners of war, curbs on speech, counter-terrorism excesses and gender discrimination, are all prohibited at a high level of law. They persist because victims are weak and enforcement is national while many of the crimes are not.

05Debates: politicisation, individual and collective claims, diverse standards

Politicisation. Rights language is a weapon as well as a shield. States invoke human rights against rivals and fall silent about allies; humanitarian arguments have covered other motives; sanctions framed as defending rights often hurt populations more than rulers. Governments also dismiss legitimate criticism as foreign interference. A strong answer treats selectivity as evidence about power rather than proof that the norms are empty, since hypocrisy concedes the standard it breaches.

Individual and collective claims. Liberal rights are held by persons; claims to land, language and self-determination are held by peoples. The Inter-American Court in Saramaka People v Suriname (2007) and the African Court in the Ogiek case against Kenya (2017) recognised collective rights to ancestral land. Freedom of association makes labour rights collective in another sense. The hard cases arise when a group right is exercised against the group's own members, as in disputes over religious personal law and gender equality.

Diverse standards. The universality debate is often reduced to 'the West versus the rest'. It contains two separate critiques. The philosophical one, made inside Western thought by communitarians such as Michael Sandel, objects that universal rights presuppose an 'unencumbered self' detached from community. The political one objects that universal standards were codified while much of the world was colonised and are enforced selectively against the weak. The first is answered by reworking the theory of the person, the second only by changing who writes and enforces the rules. Sen's reply bears on both: values such as tolerance and liberty have roots in many traditions, and it is usually governments, not populations, that call liberty foreign. The guide's contested examples, including Sharia-based family law, honour killings, hate crime laws and rights relating to sexual orientation and identity, are best analysed as disputes about who decides, not as clashes of civilisations.

How human rights are enforced

Layered architectureOriginal

Five tiers of the human rights system, from the norms of the International Bill of Human Rights through monitoring and adjudication to domestic institutions and civil society, showing why a right becomes real only when its violation becomes costly.

  1. 01 · 3 entries

    Norms

    • Universal Declaration of Human Rights

      Adopted by the General Assembly on 10 December 1948, with 48 votes in favour, none against and eight abstentions. It is a declaration, not a treaty, because that was the price of agreement, but many of its core prohibitions, such as that on torture, are now widely regarded as customary international law.

    • ICCPR and ICESCR

      The two covenants, adopted in 1966 and in force from 1976, turned the Declaration into binding treaty law. Civil and political rights carry immediate obligations; economic, social and cultural rights are to be realised progressively within available resources, a difference that reflects competing conceptions of justice.

      More detail

      With the Declaration they form the International Bill of Human Rights. Some rights in the civil and political covenant, such as freedom from torture, cannot be suspended even in an emergency; others can be when an emergency threatens the life of the nation.

    • Core thematic conventions

      Later treaties protect particular groups or prohibit particular practices: the conventions on racial discrimination (1965), discrimination against women (1979), torture (1984), the rights of the child (1989) and persons with disabilities (2006). Reservations let states ratify while excluding provisions, so wide ratification can coexist with weak commitment.

      More detail

      The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women is among the most widely ratified treaties and among the most heavily reserved, often on family and inheritance law.

  2. 02 · 3 entries

    Monitoring

    • Treaty bodies

      Committees of independent experts, such as the Human Rights Committee under the civil and political covenant, examine states' periodic reports and, where states accept it, individual complaints. Their concluding observations and views are authoritative but not binding judgments, so their effect depends on publicity and domestic uptake.

    • Universal Periodic Review

      Since 2008 the Human Rights Council, created in 2006 to replace a Commission whose credibility politicisation had damaged, has reviewed the record of every UN member in turn. Because states review one another the process is universal and hard to avoid, but states decide which recommendations to accept.

      More detail

      In April 2022 the General Assembly suspended Russia's membership of the Council, one of the few sanctions the system has applied to a member of the Council itself.

    • Special procedures

      Mandate-holders appointed by the Human Rights Council, special rapporteurs, independent experts and working groups, investigate themes such as torture or freedom of expression, or the situation in particular countries. They report and send communications to governments, though country visits require the state's invitation.

      More detail

      Commissions of inquiry and fact-finding missions, such as the UN mission on Myanmar that reported in 2018, add documentation that later supports litigation, as in The Gambia v Myanmar.

  3. 03 · 3 entries

    Adjudication

    • Regional human rights courts

      Regional courts hear claims that states have broken their human rights treaties: in Europe directly from individuals, in the Americas through the Inter-American Commission, and in Africa directly only where a state has accepted it. The European system works best, largely because the execution of judgments is politically supervised.

      More detail

      In KlimaSeniorinnen v Switzerland (2024) the European Court found that inadequate climate policy breached the Convention. Several African states have withdrawn their declarations allowing individuals direct access to the African Court since 2016.

    • International Court of Justice: its limits

      In contentious cases the ICJ hears only disputes between states, and only where they have consented, often through a treaty clause such as Article IX of the Genocide Convention. Victims cannot bring cases, and the Court has no police: compliance depends on states and, ultimately, on a Security Council where the veto applies.

      More detail

      The Gambia v Myanmar showed a workaround: because Genocide Convention obligations are owed to all parties, a state with no direct injury could sue. The climate advisory opinion of July 2025 shows the Court's other route, advice requested by the General Assembly.

    • International Criminal Court

      The Rome Statute (1998, in force 2002) created a permanent court to try individuals, not states, for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression. It acts only when national courts are unwilling or unable, and it has jurisdiction but no police, so arrests depend on states' political will.

      More detail

      Mongolia did not arrest President Putin during his visit in September 2024 despite a warrant; the Philippines surrendered former President Duterte in March 2025. Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger notified their withdrawal from the Statute in June 2026.

  4. 04 · 3 entries

    Domestic enforcement

    • Constitutional and supreme courts

      Most rights are enforced, if at all, in national courts applying constitutions and incorporated treaties. Courts can turn international norms into domestic law: in Vishaka (1997) India's Supreme Court drew on the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women to frame binding guidelines against workplace sexual harassment.

      More detail

      Article 32 of India's Constitution makes the right to move the Supreme Court for the enforcement of fundamental rights itself a fundamental right.

    • National human rights institutions

      Commissions that investigate complaints, monitor places of detention and advise governments, judged internationally against the Paris Principles endorsed by the General Assembly in 1993. India's National Human Rights Commission, a statutory body created that year, can inquire and recommend but cannot compel, so its influence depends on governments acting on its findings.

    • Universal jurisdiction

      Some states let their courts try the gravest international crimes wherever they were committed. When every international route on Syria was blocked, German courts convicted Syrian officials, including a former intelligence colonel sentenced to life imprisonment in Koblenz in January 2022, on evidence gathered by survivors and NGOs.

  5. 05 · 3 entries

    Civil society

    • Human rights NGOs

      Organisations such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch hold no territory; their power is credible evidence. They document violations, submit shadow reports to treaty bodies and the Universal Periodic Review, and name and shame governments, which is why repressive states attack monitoring first.

    • Transnational advocacy: the boomerang

      Margaret Keck and Kathryn Sikkink's boomerang model (1998) explains how groups blocked at home reach transnational networks, which press their state from outside through other governments and international bodies. It explains successes, and also why the strategy fails against states indifferent to outside pressure.

    • Strategic litigation by those affected

      The most affected increasingly use courts themselves. Pacific law students began the campaign that led to the International Court of Justice's 2025 climate opinion, and an association of older Swiss women won KlimaSeniorinnen at the European Court in 2024. Litigation turns moral claims into legal obligations with costs attached.

Sources7
  1. 01Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) (opens in a new tab). United Nations
  2. 02International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)
  3. 03Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (1998)
  4. 04UN General Assembly resolution 48/134, Principles relating to the Status of National Institutions (Paris Principles) (1993), and resolution 60/251 establishing the Human Rights Council (2006)
  5. 05European Court of Human Rights, Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v Switzerland (Grand Chamber, 9 April 2024)
  6. 06Margaret E. Keck and Kathryn Sikkink, Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics (Cornell University Press, 1998)
  7. 07International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026). International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024

Original teaching visual: an analytical summary, not IB material.

Reviewed 20 November 2026

Key ideas

  • Every right implies a duty-bearer and a cost; the political question is who bears the duty and whether they can be made to.
  • Rights, justice, liberty and equality are essentially contested: the definition is the argument.
  • The state is both principal protector and principal violator; other actors exist to work around that contradiction.
  • The two covenants of 1966 show different conceptions of justice producing different hierarchies of rights.
  • Means and will are different failures with opposite remedies.
  • R2P has succeeded as a norm and largely failed as an enforcement mechanism tied to the veto.
  • Universalism faces two distinct critiques, philosophical and political, which need different replies.

Common misconceptions

  • The misconception

    Human rights are inalienable, so they cannot be taken away.

    The correction

    'Inalienable' is a moral claim. Rights are inalienable in principle and violated in fact; the international regime exists to narrow that gap.

  • The misconception

    The UN protects human rights.

    The correction

    UN human rights bodies codify, monitor and report. The only UN organ that can compel a state is the Security Council, which is not a human rights body and is governed by the veto.

  • The misconception

    The ICJ and the ICC are the same kind of court.

    The correction

    The ICJ hears disputes between states and gives advisory opinions; the ICC tries individuals. The wrong court means the wrong defendant and the wrong remedy.

  • The misconception

    The UDHR is a binding treaty.

    The correction

    It is a General Assembly declaration. Many of its core prohibitions have since become customary international law, which is a more precise claim.

  • The misconception

    Rights and justice mean the same thing.

    The correction

    Rights protect individuals against the collective; justice asks what the collective owes everyone. They collide over wealth taxes, amnesties and affirmative action.

How it is assessed

Paper 2, section A sets one question on each thematic study, typically with an AO3 command term: evaluate the effectiveness of courts or NGOs, discuss whether rights are universal, examine the tension between liberty and equality. Precision is part of the argument: name the specific treaty, court or body, and do not offer the UDHR where a binding instrument is needed. Section B may ask you to carry a concept such as legitimacy or structural violence across this theme and another. Rights-related sources can also appear in Paper 1, whose core topics include legitimacy and sovereignty. In the engagement project, ask whose rights are claimed in your issue and who bears the cost of honouring them. HL students will find the equality, identity and borders topic areas grow directly from this theme. See Paper 2.

Case studies

Practice questions

  1. Q1IB Paper 2 style15 marks

    Evaluate the effectiveness of regional human rights tribunals in protecting the rights of individuals.

    How to approach it

    Compare at least two systems. Use the supervision of judgments, individual access and state withdrawal as criteria, develop one case from each system, and judge what explains the difference in effectiveness.

  2. Q2IB Paper 2 style15 marks

    'Rights that are not enforced are only aspirations.' Discuss this claim.

    How to approach it

    Separate legal force from political effect. Weigh the enforcement gap (ICC arrests, treaty-body findings) against evidence that codification changes behaviour over time, such as customary law, domestic litigation or denial replacing justification.

  3. Q3IB Paper 2 style15 marks

    To what extent has the responsibility to protect changed the relationship between sovereignty and human rights?

    How to approach it

    Distinguish the three pillars, use Libya and at least one later case, and judge R2P separately as a norm and as an enforcement mechanism.

  4. Q4IB Paper 2 style15 marks

    Examine the claim that the legitimacy of international institutions depends more on their outcomes than on their procedures. Refer to at least two thematic studies.

    How to approach it

    An integrating question: trace legitimacy through a rights institution (a court or the UNHRC) and a development or peace institution, contrasting output legitimacy with procedural fairness and selectivity.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not IB examination questions.

Across the handbooks

Where this unit meets the nine original handbooks: the handbooks written for it, the others that take it up, and what each shares with it.

  1. 01Framing Global Politics
  2. 02Power
  3. 03Sovereignty
  4. 04Legitimacy
  5. 05Interdependence
  6. 06Theoretical Perspectives
  7. 07Rights & Justice
  8. 08Stakeholders & Actors
  9. 09Nature, Practice & Study
  • Written for this unit
  • Takes up this unit
  • Shares its cases, concepts or thinkers

The handbooks are original to this platform. These links follow each handbook’s syllabus coverage and cross-references.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01International Baccalaureate, Diploma Programme Global politics guide (first assessment 2026), published February 2024, updated July 2024. International Baccalaureate Organization, 2024
  2. 02Arjun Agrawal, Global Politics Handbooks 07–09: Rights & Justice; Stakeholders & Actors; Nature, Practice & Study
  3. 03Universal Declaration of Human Rights, UN General Assembly resolution 217 A (III), 10 December 1948. United Nations
  4. 042005 World Summit Outcome, UN General Assembly resolution 60/1, paragraphs 138–139. United Nations
  5. 05Margaret E. Keck and Kathryn Sikkink, Activists Beyond Borders (1998)
  6. 06Isaiah Berlin, 'Two Concepts of Liberty' (1958), in Four Essays on Liberty (1969)
  7. 07International Criminal Court, case information for The Prosecutor v. Rodrigo Roa Duterte (opens in a new tab). ICC, 2026