Skip to content

Section F · Federalism

Centre–State Legislative Relations

Articles 245–255 and the Seventh Schedule: the three Lists, the Union's residuary and overriding powers, the occasions on which Parliament may legislate in the State field, and the doctrines that police the boundary.

Overview

The Constitution divides legislative power between Parliament and the State legislatures by subject, in three Lists of the Seventh Schedule. The division is weighted towards the Union: the Union List is the longest and most important, the residuary power belongs to Parliament, Union law prevails in the Concurrent field, and Parliament may in several circumstances legislate on State subjects.

Yet the State List is a real and exclusive field. Policing, public order, land, agriculture, public health and local government are State subjects, and the courts protect that field through doctrines of interpretation. Contemporary disputes, from farm laws to mining taxes, turn on where a law falls between the Lists.

Constitutional and legal provisions

Article 245
Parliament legislates for the whole or any part of India and its laws are not invalid for extra-territorial operation; State legislatures legislate for their State.
Article 246 and Seventh Schedule
Exclusive Union List, exclusive State List and Concurrent List, with Union primacy where they overlap.
Article 246A
Parliament and State legislatures may both legislate on goods and services tax; inter-State supply is reserved to Parliament (101st Amendment).
Article 248
Residuary power of legislation, including taxation, belongs to Parliament.
Articles 249, 250, 252, 253
Parliament may legislate on State subjects in the national interest, during an emergency, at the request of two or more States, and to implement international agreements.
Article 254
Union law prevails over repugnant State law on Concurrent subjects, unless the State law has received the President's assent.

Territorial extent

Parliament may legislate for all or any part of India, and its laws may operate outside India (Article 245(2)); State laws are confined to the State but may affect persons and things outside it if there is a sufficient territorial nexus. Some areas are subject to special regimes: the Governor may direct that Acts do not apply, or apply with modifications, to Scheduled Areas under the Fifth Schedule; autonomous district councils make laws for tribal areas under the Sixth Schedule; and the President makes regulations for certain Union territories under Article 240.

The three Lists

The Union List covers subjects needing national uniformity: defence, foreign affairs, atomic energy, railways, currency, banking, inter-State trade, and the main taxes on income and corporations. The State List covers public order and police, public health, agriculture, land, water (subject to Union regulation of inter-State rivers), local government and several taxes. The Concurrent List covers criminal law and procedure, marriage and succession, contracts, bankruptcy, labour, economic and social planning and, since 1976, education, forests, protection of wild animals and birds, weights and measures, and the administration of justice, all transferred from the State List by the 42nd Amendment.

As adopted, the Lists had 97, 66 and 47 entries. Residuary power lies with Parliament (Article 248 and Entry 97 of the Union List), as in Canada, whereas in the United States and Australia it lies with the states.

When Parliament may legislate in the State field

Article 249: if the Rajya Sabha resolves by two-thirds of members present and voting that it is necessary in the national interest, Parliament may legislate on a State List matter for up to a year at a time. Article 250: during a national emergency Parliament may legislate on any State subject; such laws lapse six months after the emergency ends. Article 252: if two or more State legislatures request it, Parliament may legislate for those States, and other States may adopt the law; only Parliament can then amend it. The Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972 and the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 were enacted this way. Article 253: Parliament may legislate on any subject to implement treaties and international decisions, the basis of much environmental law. Under President's Rule, Parliament legislates for the State (Article 357).

Repugnancy and the doctrines of interpretation

On a Concurrent subject a Union law prevails over an inconsistent State law (Article 254(1)). Under Article 254(2), a State law reserved for and assented to by the President prevails within that State, though Parliament may later override it; States have used this route to adapt Union labour and land laws. M. Karunanidhi v. Union of India (1979) set out the tests for repugnancy: direct conflict, impossibility of obeying both, or Parliament's intention to occupy the whole field.

Courts classify laws by their pith and substance, tolerate incidental encroachment, and reject colourable attempts to legislate indirectly on another List's subject (see constitutional doctrines). Recent decisions have protected the State field: in Mineral Area Development Authority (2024) a nine-judge bench held 8:1 that royalty on minerals is not a tax and that States' power to tax mineral rights is not displaced by the Union's mining legislation, overruling the 1989 India Cement decision.

Contemporary disputes

The three farm laws of 2020 were enacted under the Concurrent entry on trade and commerce in foodstuffs, although agriculture and agricultural markets are State subjects; several States objected that the Union had legislated in their field without consultation, and the laws were repealed in 2021. The criminal law codes of 2023, enacted under the Concurrent List, drew objections from some States to the absence of consultation and to Hindi names.

The goods and services tax created a new kind of concurrency. In Union of India v. Mohit Minerals (2022) the Court held that Article 246A gives Parliament and the States simultaneous power and that the GST Council's recommendations are persuasive rather than binding, describing Indian federalism as a dialogue rather than a hierarchy.

Debates

Is the Concurrent List an instrument of cooperation or of centralisation?

The cooperative reading sees the Concurrent List as shared space where national minimum standards coexist with State variation, and Article 254(2) as a means for States to adapt Union laws. The centralising reading notes that Union law prevails, that the List has grown only in the Union's favour (the 1976 transfers were never reversed), and that Parliament has legislated on Concurrent subjects without consulting States, as in 2020. Both Sarkaria and Punchhi recommended consultation through the Inter-State Council before Parliament legislates on Concurrent subjects; it has not become a practice.

Should residuary powers be moved to the States or the Concurrent List?

The Rajamannar Committee (1971) and the Anandpur Sahib Resolution (1973) asked for residuary powers to go to the States, as in classical federations. The Sarkaria Commission recommended keeping residuary taxation with Parliament and moving other residuary subjects to the Concurrent List. Against any change, new subjects such as cyberspace and outer space often need national regulation, and shifting the residuary power would invite constant litigation over classification.

Commissions and committees

  • Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu)1971

    Appointed by the Tamil Nadu government; recommended transferring residuary powers to the States and reducing the Union's overriding powers.

  • Sarkaria Commission1988

    Recommended that residuary taxation remain with Parliament and other residuary subjects move to the Concurrent List, and that the Union consult States through the Inter-State Council before legislating on Concurrent subjects.

  • Punchhi Commission2010

    Urged restraint by the Union in occupying the Concurrent field and prior consultation with States on Concurrent legislation.

Prelims points

  • The Seventh Schedule originally had 97 Union, 66 State and 47 Concurrent entries.
  • The 42nd Amendment moved five subjects to the Concurrent List: education; forests; protection of wild animals and birds; weights and measures; administration of justice (except the Supreme Court and High Courts).
  • Residuary power belongs to Parliament (Article 248; Entry 97 of the Union List).
  • Article 249: Rajya Sabha resolution by two-thirds of members present and voting; valid for one year at a time.
  • Article 252: a law made at the request of States can be amended or repealed only by Parliament.
  • Article 253: Parliament may legislate on any subject to implement international agreements.
  • Article 254(2): a State law on a Concurrent subject prevails in that State if it has the President's assent.
  • Article 246A (101st Amendment, 2016) gives simultaneous power over GST.
  • Mineral Area Development Authority (2024): royalty is not a tax; States may tax mineral rights.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

1 question · 2024

  1. 2024 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks

    What changes has the Union Government recently introduced in the domain of Centre-State relations ? Suggest measures to be adopted to build the trust between the Centre and the States and for strengthening federalism.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Centre–State Legislative Relations in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Practice questions

  1. Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words

    The distribution of legislative powers in India is weighted towards the Union but not closed to the States. Examine.

    How to approach it

    Show the Union's advantages (Union List, residuary power, Articles 249–253, Article 254), then the protected State field and judicial doctrines, using Mineral Area Development Authority and Mohit Minerals.

  2. Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    Discuss the doctrine of repugnancy under Article 254 with examples.

    How to approach it

    Explain clauses (1) and (2), the tests in Karunanidhi and the occupied-field idea, with an example of a State using presidential assent.

  3. Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    Should the Union consult States before legislating on Concurrent List subjects? Discuss with reference to recent controversies.

    How to approach it

    Use the farm laws and the criminal law codes, the Sarkaria and Punchhi recommendations, and the role of the Inter-State Council.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

PSIR Optional

Political Issue Dossier

Sources

  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
  2. 02Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
  3. 03Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988. Government of India
  4. 04Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Punchhi Commission), 2010. Government of India
  5. 05M.P. Jain, Indian Constitutional Law. LexisNexis
  6. 06Louise Tillin, Indian Federalism (2019). Oxford University Press