Skip to content

The Constitution (Ninety-seventh Amendment) Act, 2011

97th Amendment (2011)

The amendment that sought to give co-operative societies a constitutional framework, adding Part IXB, article 43B and a right to form co-operatives.

01Context

Co-operatives, central to rural credit, dairying, sugar and housing, had become notorious for political capture: State governments superseded elected boards, postponed elections and used societies as patronage networks. The amendment, passed in 2011 and in force from February 2012, aimed to secure their democratic and autonomous functioning across the country.

02What it changed

  • Article 19(1)(c) amended to include the right to form co-operative societies among the freedoms of association.
  • Article 43B inserted, directing the State to promote voluntary formation, autonomous functioning, democratic control and professional management of co-operatives.
  • Part IXB inserted (articles 243ZH to 243ZT): boards of not more than twenty-one directors with seats for Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes and women; five-year terms; elections before expiry of term; limits on supersession; audit, general body meetings, members' right to information, returns, and offences.
  • Article 243ZR applies the Part to multi-State co-operative societies, with Parliament in place of the State legislature.

03Political and constitutional significance

Part IXB tried to do for co-operatives what Parts IX and IXA did for local government. But co-operative societies are a subject of the State List (entry 32), and an amendment that limits the States' power over a State List subject requires ratification by half the State legislatures under the proviso to article 368(2). The amendment was not ratified, and that procedural defect proved fatal to most of Part IXB. The episode is a lesson in the federal limits of the amending power, and it preceded the creation of a Union Ministry of Co-operation in 2021, whose role in a State subject has been debated.

04Judicial interpretation

In Union of India v. Rajendra N. Shah (2021) the Supreme Court, by a majority, held Part IXB unconstitutional so far as it relates to co-operative societies within the States, because it substantially affected entry 32 of the State List without ratification by the States. The Part was saved for multi-State co-operative societies and those in Union territories. The changes to articles 19 and 43B were unaffected.

Why it matters for UPSC

Candidates should use the amendment to explain the ratification requirement in article 368(2) and its federal purpose, and to discuss the governance of co-operatives. The Rajendra N. Shah judgment is a frequent reference in questions on co-operative federalism.

Sources