Skip to content

Section C · Union Government

The Legislative Process

How Bills become law: ordinary, money and financial Bills, the stages of passage, joint sittings, the budget, and the disputes over the Speaker's money-Bill certificate.

Overview

The Constitution prescribes different procedures for different kinds of Bills, and the classification of a Bill decides how much power the Rajya Sabha has over it. Ordinary Bills need the agreement of both Houses, with a joint sitting to resolve deadlock. Money Bills can be passed by the Lok Sabha alone, with the Rajya Sabha limited to recommendations. Constitutional amendments follow Article 368.

Because the label "money Bill" removes the Rajya Sabha's veto, the Speaker's power to certify a Bill as one has become a constitutional flashpoint. The quality of law-making, measured by debate, committee scrutiny and consultation, is the other great issue of the topic.

Constitutional and legal provisions

Article 107
A Bill other than a money or financial Bill may originate in either House; rules on lapse.
Article 108
Joint sitting where the Houses disagree or one House does not act for six months.
Articles 109–110
Special procedure for money Bills; the definition of a money Bill; the Speaker's decision is final.
Article 111
Assent to Bills; return for reconsideration except for money Bills.
Articles 112–116
Annual financial statement, demands for grants, appropriation, supplementary and excess grants, votes on account.
Article 117
Special provisions for financial Bills.

Kinds of Bills

Bills are ordinary (any matter other than finance), money Bills (Article 110), financial Bills of the first kind (Article 117(1): they contain money-Bill matters but also other provisions, so they must start in the Lok Sabha on the President's recommendation but are otherwise ordinary Bills), financial Bills of the second kind (Article 117(3): they involve expenditure from the Consolidated Fund and may start in either House, but cannot be passed without the President's recommendation), and constitutional amendment Bills (Article 368). Bills are also either government Bills or private members' Bills; only fourteen private members' Bills have become law, the last in 1970.

Passage of an ordinary Bill

An ordinary Bill is introduced with the leave of the House and published (first reading). At the second reading the House debates its principles and may refer it to a select committee of the House, a joint committee of both Houses or, in practice most often, the relevant departmentally related standing committee, or circulate it for public opinion; it then considers the Bill clause by clause. The third reading is a debate on whether to pass the Bill as a whole.

The second House may pass it, amend it (returning it to the first), reject it, or not act on it. Disagreement, rejection or six months' inaction allows the President to summon a joint sitting. When the Lok Sabha is dissolved, a Bill pending in it, or passed by it and pending in the Rajya Sabha, lapses; a Bill pending in the Rajya Sabha that the Lok Sabha has not passed does not.

Money Bills and the Speaker's certificate

A Bill is a money Bill if it contains "only" provisions on taxation, government borrowing, the Consolidated and Contingency Funds, appropriation from the Consolidated Fund, charged expenditure, the receipt or audit of public money, or matters incidental to these (Article 110(1)). It can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha on the President's recommendation. The Rajya Sabha must return it within fourteen days and may only recommend changes, which the Lok Sabha may ignore. The President may not return it.

The Speaker's certificate is "final" (Article 110(3)), and in Mohd. Saeed Siddiqui (2014) the Court declined to review it. The certification of the Aadhaar Act, 2016 as a money Bill brought the issue to a head. In the Aadhaar judgment (2018) the majority upheld the certification because the Act's core concerned expenditure from the Consolidated Fund; Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, dissenting, called it a fraud on the Constitution. In Rojer Mathew v. South Indian Bank (2019) a Constitution Bench doubted the earlier approach and referred the scope of review to a larger bench, where it remains pending.

Joint sittings

A joint sitting under Article 108 is presided over by the Speaker and decides by a majority of members of both Houses present and voting, so the Lok Sabha's larger membership usually prevails. It is not available for money Bills or constitutional amendments. Only three have been held: on the Dowry Prohibition Bill (1961), the Banking Service Commission (Repeal) Bill (1978) and the Prevention of Terrorism Bill (2002). Their rarity reflects the costs to a government of forcing a Bill through against the upper House and the alternative of the money-Bill route.

The budget

The annual financial statement (Article 112) distinguishes expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund, which is discussed but not voted (such as the salaries of the President, judges and the CAG, and debt charges), from voted expenditure, presented as demands for grants (Article 113). After general discussion, departmentally related standing committees examine the demands; the Lok Sabha then votes on them, where members may move cut motions (a policy cut reducing a demand to one rupee, an economy cut, or a token cut of a hundred rupees). Demands not discussed by the deadline are put to the vote together by the guillotine.

The Appropriation Bill authorises withdrawal from the Consolidated Fund (Article 114) and the Finance Bill gives effect to tax proposals, which must be enacted within 75 days under the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act, 1931. Votes on account (Article 116) cover spending until the budget is passed. Since 2017 the budget has been presented on 1 February and the railway budget merged with the general budget.

The quality of law-making

The government's Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy of 2014 asks ministries to publish draft Bills for at least thirty days, but it is not binding and is unevenly followed. Major laws have passed with little debate or committee scrutiny: the three farm laws of 2020 were passed in the Rajya Sabha by voice vote amid demands for a division and repealed in 2021 after sustained protest. Private members' Bills, which allow backbenchers to raise new issues, rarely progress; the Rajya Sabha's passage of the Rights of Transgender Persons Bill in 2015 was the first by that House in decades, and the Lok Sabha did not take it up.

Debates

Should the Speaker's money-Bill certificate be open to judicial review?

For review: the certificate decides whether the Rajya Sabha, a federal chamber, has a say at all, so an unreviewable label lets a government with a Lok Sabha majority bypass bicameralism. The word "only" in Article 110(1) is a limit that someone must enforce.

Against review: Article 110(3) makes the decision final, Article 122 protects parliamentary procedure from courts, and judicial second-guessing of the Speaker would draw courts into the internal working of Parliament. A middle position, the one Rojer Mathew leans towards, allows review only for clear constitutional violation rather than ordinary errors of classification.

Should pre-legislative consultation and committee referral be mandatory?

Mandatory consultation and referral would improve drafting, surface objections early and lend laws legitimacy, as pre-legislative scrutiny does in the United Kingdom. Governments reply that urgent Bills cannot wait, that they hold an electoral mandate, and that committees can be used to stall. A rule that exempts certified urgent Bills but otherwise requires referral is the usual compromise proposal.

Prelims points

  • A money Bill can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha, on the President's recommendation; the Rajya Sabha must return it within 14 days.
  • The Speaker's decision on whether a Bill is a money Bill is final (Article 110(3)).
  • The President cannot return a money Bill for reconsideration.
  • Joint sittings (Article 108) are presided over by the Speaker and are not available for money Bills or constitutional amendments.
  • Joint sittings held: Dowry Prohibition Bill (1961), Banking Service Commission (Repeal) Bill (1978), Prevention of Terrorism Bill (2002).
  • A Bill pending in the Rajya Sabha and not passed by the Lok Sabha does not lapse on dissolution.
  • A financial Bill under Article 117(3) may be introduced in either House.
  • Charged expenditure is not submitted to the vote of Parliament (Article 113).
  • Cut motions: policy cut (one rupee), economy cut, token cut (one hundred rupees).
  • The Finance Bill must be enacted within 75 days (Provisional Collection of Taxes Act, 1931).
  • Only fourteen private members' Bills have become law; the last in 1970.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

1 question · 2025

  1. 2025 · PSIR I · Q6(a) · 20 marks

    Parliamentary committees are indispensable to the legislative process. It provides for the opportunity for cross-pollination between the two chambers of the Parliament. Discuss.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to The Legislative Process in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Practice questions

  1. Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words

    The certification of Bills as money Bills has become a constitutional flashpoint. Examine.

    How to approach it

    Explain Article 110 and the significance of "only", the Aadhaar Act and the majority and dissent, Rojer Mathew's reference, and the federal stakes for the Rajya Sabha; take a reasoned position.

  2. Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    Describe the stages through which an ordinary Bill becomes law and identify where scrutiny could be strengthened.

    How to approach it

    Cover the three readings, committee options, the second House and joint sittings; propose reforms such as mandatory referral and consultation.

  3. Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    Why have joint sittings been so rare in India?

    How to approach it

    Explain Article 108, the three instances, the Lok Sabha's numerical advantage and the political cost of forcing Bills, and the alternative of the money-Bill route.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
  2. 02Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha (opens in a new tab). Lok Sabha Secretariat
  3. 03Subhash C. Kashyap, Our Parliament. National Book Trust
  4. 04PRS Legislative Research, Vital Stats and legislative briefs (opens in a new tab). PRS Legislative Research
  5. 05Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India