Skip to content

Knowledge Lab · GS-II comparison of constitutional schemes · PSIR Paper II

Comparative Politics Lab

Set India's constitutional scheme beside other political systems: how executives are formed, how legislatures are chosen, how power is divided between centre and regions, and how constitutions change.

12 political systems, each from its own verified entry

01Typology

Where each system sits

Each system placed by the form of its executive and by how power is divided between the centre and the regions, as its entry records them. Select a country to find its row in the table that follows.

  1. Parliamentary7 systems

    Unitary
    Unitary with devolution
  2. Semi-presidential2 systems

    Unitary
    Federal
  3. Presidential1 system

  4. Directorial1 system

  5. One-party state1 system

    Unitary

02Overview

The systems at a glance

Form of government, constitution, legislature and territorial organisation, one row per country.

The political systems at a glance
IndiaConstitutional democracy; parliamentary republicParliamentaryCodified, partly rigidBicameralQuasi-federal
United KingdomConstitutional monarchy; parliamentary democracyParliamentaryUncodified, flexibleBicameralUnitary with devolution
United StatesConstitutional federal republic; presidential democracyPresidentialCodified, rigidBicameralFederal
FranceConstitutional republic; semi-presidential democracySemi-presidentialCodified, rigidBicameralUnitary
GermanyFederal parliamentary republic; constitutional democracyParliamentaryCodified, rigidBicameralFederal
JapanConstitutional monarchy; parliamentary democracyParliamentaryCodified, rigidBicameralUnitary
SwitzerlandFederal republic; consensus democracy with direct democracyDirectorialCodified, rigidBicameralFederal
CanadaConstitutional monarchy; federal parliamentary democracyParliamentaryCodified, rigidBicameralFederal
AustraliaConstitutional monarchy; federal parliamentary democracyParliamentaryCodified, rigidBicameralFederal
South AfricaConstitutional democracy; parliamentary republic with an executive presidentParliamentaryCodified, rigidBicameralQuasi-federal
ChinaParty-state; Leninist one-party authoritarian systemOne-party stateCodified, rigidUnicameralUnitary
RussiaElectoral authoritarian; personalised super-presidential systemSemi-presidentialCodified, rigidBicameralFederal

03Comparison

Compare by dimension

One feature at a time across every system, with like grouped with like, so that differences can be explained rather than merely listed.

Constitutional arrangements

The date and rigidity of each constitution, then how each is amended, grouped from flexible to rigid.

A question to compare withWhat does each system require to change its constitution, and who can block a change?

When each constitution dates from

  1. United States1787 (in force 1789) · rigid

  2. Canada1867 and 1982 · rigid

  3. Australia1901 · rigid

  4. Japan1947 · rigid

  5. Germany1949 · rigid

  6. India1950 · partly rigid

  7. France1958 · rigid

  8. China1982 · rigid

  9. Russia1993 · rigid

  10. South Africa1996 (in force 1997) · rigid

  11. Switzerland1999 (in force 2000) · rigid

  12. United KingdomUncodified · flexible

    No single codified document, so no date of adoption

The year of each written constitution as its entry gives it, and the time from then to today.Partly rigidRigidA second date given in the entry

How rigid each is

  1. Flexible1

    • United Kingdom
  2. Partly rigid1

    • India
  3. Rigid10

    • United States
    • France
    • Germany
    • Japan
    • Switzerland
    • Canada
    • Australia
    • South Africa
    • China
    • Russia

11 of 12 have a codified constitution; one does not.

Flexible constitutions1 system

  • United Kingdom

    Uncodified · Parliamentary

    The constitution

    There is no single constitutional document. The constitution lives in statutes such as the Bill of Rights 1689, the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, the Human Rights Act 1998, the devolution Acts of 1998 and the Constitutional Reform Act 2005; in the common law; and in conventions described by Walter Bagehot and A.V. Dicey. Any of it can be changed by an ordinary Act, though the courts treat some 'constitutional statutes' as immune from implied repeal (Thoburn, 2002).

    How it is amended

    No special procedure: constitutional change is made by ordinary legislation, sometimes after advisory referendums (1975, 2011, 2014, 2016), and conventions change by practice. Flexibility depends on political restraint.

Partly rigid constitutions1 system

  • India

    Codified, 1950 · Parliamentary

    The constitution

    Adopted on 26 November 1949 and in force from 26 January 1950, it is among the longest written constitutions, taking much of its administrative framework from the Government of India Act, 1935. Different provisions are amended by different majorities, and since Kesavananda Bharati (1973) Parliament may not destroy its basic structure.

    How it is amended

    Article 368: most provisions need a majority of each House's total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting; provisions on the federal structure also need ratification by half the states; some matters, such as forming new states, change by ordinary law. More than a hundred amendments have been made since 1950.

Rigid constitutions10 systems

  • United States

    Codified, 1787 (in force 1789) · Presidential

    The constitution

    Seven articles and 27 amendments, the first ten (the Bill of Rights) ratified in 1791. Short, general and very hard to amend, it has changed mainly through judicial interpretation, which fuels the dispute between originalist and 'living constitution' readings.

    How it is amended

    Article V: proposal by two-thirds of both Houses (or by a convention called at the request of two-thirds of the states, never used) and ratification by three-quarters of the states. Only 27 amendments have succeeded.

  • France

    Codified, 1958 · Semi-presidential

    The constitution

    Drafted for Charles de Gaulle and approved by referendum on 28 September 1958, it 'rationalised' parliamentary government after the instability of the Fourth Republic: it limits the domain of law (Article 34), lets the government pass a bill without a vote unless a censure motion succeeds (Article 49.3) and gives the President emergency powers (Article 16). Its preamble incorporates the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen.

    How it is amended

    Article 89: both chambers adopt the same text, followed by a referendum or, for government bills, approval by three-fifths of Parliament meeting as a Congress; the republican form cannot be amended. In March 2024 Congress added the guaranteed freedom to have an abortion.

  • Germany

    Codified, 1949 · Parliamentary

    The constitution

    The Basic Law of 23 May 1949 was meant to be provisional until reunification and became the constitution of united Germany in 1990. It opens with the inviolability of human dignity (Article 1), places democracy, federalism and the rule of law beyond amendment (Article 79(3)) and lets the Constitutional Court ban parties that seek to abolish the democratic order (Article 21).

    How it is amended

    Two-thirds of Bundestag members and two-thirds of Bundesrat votes (Article 79(2)). The eternity clause protects human dignity, the principles of Article 20 and the participation of the Länder in legislation. Within those limits the Basic Law is amended often.

  • Japan

    Codified, 1947 · Parliamentary

    The constitution

    Promulgated on 3 November 1946 and in force from 3 May 1947 as a formal revision of the Meiji Constitution, it was drafted largely by occupation officials and adopted by the Imperial Diet. It vests sovereignty in the people and renounces war (Article 9). It has never been amended; change has come by reinterpretation, notably the 2014 Cabinet decision permitting limited collective self-defence.

    How it is amended

    Article 96: initiation by two-thirds of all members of each House, then a majority in a national referendum. In February 2026 the Liberal Democratic Party alone won over two-thirds of lower-house seats, the first single party to do so since the war, but it lacks a majority in the upper house.

  • Switzerland

    Codified, 1999 (in force 2000) · Directorial

    The constitution

    The federal state was founded in 1848; its constitution was totally revised in 1874 and again in 1999, the latest version approved by people and cantons and in force from 1 January 2000. Because citizens can amend it by initiative, it is changed often and records the outcomes of direct democracy.

    How it is amended

    Every amendment needs a mandatory referendum won by a double majority of voters and cantons. A popular initiative with 100,000 signatures collected in 18 months can propose one; 50,000 signatures in 100 days, or eight cantons, can force a referendum on a federal law.

  • Canada

    Codified, 1867 and 1982 · Parliamentary

    The constitution

    The Constitution Act, 1867 (formerly the British North America Act) created the federation; the Constitution Act, 1982 brought the constitution home from Britain and added the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and an amending formula. Quebec never assented to the 1982 settlement, and attempts to win its consent (Meech Lake, 1987–90; Charlottetown, 1992) failed. The conventions of responsible government remain unwritten.

    How it is amended

    The general formula requires Parliament and two-thirds of the provinces (seven) with at least half the population; unanimity is needed for the monarchy, the amending formula and the composition of the Supreme Court; some matters can be changed by Parliament or a province alone.

  • Australia

    Codified, 1901 · Parliamentary

    The constitution

    Drafted at conventions in the 1890s, approved by referendums in the colonies and enacted by the British Parliament as the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1900, it came into force on 1 January 1901. It has no bill of rights, but the High Court implied a freedom of political communication from the system of representative government in 1992.

    How it is amended

    Section 128: a bill passed by both Houses (or by one House twice), then a referendum requiring a national majority and majorities in at least four of the six states. Only 8 of 45 proposals have succeeded; the 2023 proposal for an Indigenous Voice to Parliament was rejected nationally and in every state.

  • South Africa

    Codified, 1996 (in force 1997) · Parliamentary

    The constitution

    An interim constitution of 1993 bound the elected Constitutional Assembly to 34 agreed principles, and the Constitutional Court certified the final text against them, refusing certification once before approving it in December 1996. In force from 4 February 1997, its Bill of Rights includes justiciable rights to housing, health care, food, water, social security and education, and binds private actors as well as the state.

    How it is amended

    Section 74 tiers entrenchment: the founding values in section 1 need 75 per cent of the Assembly and six provinces in the Council; the Bill of Rights two-thirds and six provinces; other provisions two-thirds, with provincial approval where provinces are affected.

  • China

    Codified, 1982 · One-party state

    The constitution

    The fourth constitution of the People's Republic, after those of 1954, 1975 and 1978, amended in 1988, 1993, 1999, 2004 and 2018. The 2018 amendment wrote the Party's leadership into the body of Article 1, removed the two-term limit on the President and Vice-President and created supervisory commissions. The constitution organises and legitimates power rather than limiting it, so its formal rigidity means little where one party controls every supermajority.

    How it is amended

    Article 64: proposal by the Standing Committee or one-fifth of deputies, adoption by two-thirds of all deputies. In practice the Party's Central Committee proposes amendments and the Congress approves them by near-unanimous votes.

  • Russia

    Codified, 1993 · Semi-presidential

    The constitution

    Adopted by referendum on 12 December 1993, two months after President Yeltsin's forcible dissolution of the Supreme Soviet. A 2008 amendment lengthened presidential and Duma terms; the 2020 package, approved in a nationwide vote, reset the incumbent's term count, gave the constitution priority over international rulings and barred the alienation of territory. Russia has also written annexed Ukrainian regions into its list of federal subjects, annexations the UN General Assembly has refused to recognise.

    How it is amended

    Chapters 1, 2 and 9 (foundations, rights and revision) can be changed only through a Constitutional Assembly; the other chapters need three-quarters of the Federation Council, two-thirds of the Duma and approval by the legislatures of two-thirds of the federal subjects (Article 136).

04Side by side

Compare up to four countries

Choose the countries and the features to set beside each other.

Countries
Features

Up to 4 at a time. Columns keep the order in which you select them.

Form of government

India
Parliamentary. Constitutional democracy; parliamentary republic
United Kingdom
Parliamentary. Constitutional monarchy; parliamentary democracy
United States
Presidential. Constitutional federal republic; presidential democracy

Constitution

India
1950; codified, partly rigid. Adopted on 26 November 1949 and in force from 26 January 1950, it is among the longest written constitutions, taking much of its administrative framework from the Government of India Act, 1935. Different provisions are amended by different majorities, and since Kesavananda Bharati (1973) Parliament may not destroy its basic structure.
United Kingdom
Uncodified; uncodified, flexible. There is no single constitutional document. The constitution lives in statutes such as the Bill of Rights 1689, the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, the Human Rights Act 1998, the devolution Acts of 1998 and the Constitutional Reform Act 2005; in the common law; and in conventions described by Walter Bagehot and A.V. Dicey. Any of it can be changed by an ordinary Act, though the courts treat some 'constitutional statutes' as immune from implied repeal (Thoburn, 2002).
United States
1787 (in force 1789); codified, rigid. Seven articles and 27 amendments, the first ten (the Bill of Rights) ratified in 1791. Short, general and very hard to amend, it has changed mainly through judicial interpretation, which fuels the dispute between originalist and 'living constitution' readings.

Head of state

India
The President, elected for five years by the elected members of both Houses of Parliament and of the state and Union territory assemblies, by proportional representation through the single transferable vote. The President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers, made binding by the 42nd and 44th Amendments subject to one request for reconsideration, and may be impeached for violation of the Constitution.
United Kingdom
The monarch, by hereditary succession. Legal powers such as assent to bills and the appointment of the Prime Minister are exercised on ministerial advice or by convention; Bagehot called the Crown the 'dignified' part of the constitution, distinct from the 'efficient' Cabinet.
United States
The President, head of state and of government, elected for four years through the Electoral College (538 electors; 270 needed) and limited to two terms by the 22nd Amendment (1951). The President is not responsible to Congress and can be removed only by impeachment in the House and conviction by two-thirds of the Senate.

Head of government

India
The Prime Minister, appointed as the leader who commands a majority in the Lok Sabha. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha (Article 75(3)) and capped at 15 per cent of its strength.
United Kingdom
The Prime Minister, the leader able to command the confidence of the House of Commons, appointed by the monarch, with a Cabinet collectively responsible to the Commons. The Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022 restored dissolution on the Prime Minister's request; a Parliament ends automatically five years after it first meets.
United States
The President, who appoints department secretaries with Senate consent; they may not sit in Congress. The President may veto bills, subject to override by two-thirds of each House. Richard Neustadt's Presidential Power (1960) described the office's real power as the power to persuade.

Legislature

India
Bicameral. Lok Sabha (House of the People): 543 members elected from single-member constituencies by first past the post, with seats reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, and for women once the 106th Amendment takes effect. (Five years unless dissolved earlier) Rajya Sabha (Council of States): Up to 250 members (245 at present): those elected by state and Union territory legislatures by the single transferable vote, with seats allocated broadly by population, and 12 nominated by the President. (Six years; one-third retire every two years; not subject to dissolution)
United Kingdom
Bicameral. House of Commons: 650 members elected from single-member constituencies by first past the post. (Up to five years) House of Lords: Appointed life peers and 26 Church of England bishops; the House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Act 2026 ended the remaining hereditary seats at the close of the 2024–26 session. The Lords can delay most bills for about a year and money bills for a month (Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949). (Life membership (bishops while in office))
United States
Bicameral. House of Representatives: 435 voting members apportioned among states by population after each census, elected mostly in single-member districts by plurality. (Two years) Senate: 100 members, two per state, directly elected since the 17th Amendment (1913); it confirms appointments and approves treaties by two-thirds. (Six years; one-third elected every two years)

Electoral system

India
First past the post for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies, run by an independent Election Commission; indirect elections by the single transferable vote for the Rajya Sabha, the President and legislative councils. Plurality voting often produces seat shares far from vote shares.
United Kingdom
First past the post for the Commons, which can turn a minority of votes into a large majority, as in 2024, when Labour won a landslide on about a third of the vote. The devolved legislatures use proportional systems: the additional member system in Scotland, closed-list PR for the Welsh Senedd from 2026 and the single transferable vote in Northern Ireland.
United States
Plurality voting in single-member districts, with candidates chosen in party primaries. Electoral votes go winner-take-all in 48 states and the District of Columbia. States draw district boundaries, and Rucho v Common Cause (2019) held partisan gerrymandering beyond the reach of federal courts.

Territorial organisation

India
Quasi-federal. A 'Union of States' (Article 1) of 28 states and 8 Union territories. Three lists divide legislative power, with residuary and emergency powers favouring the Union, and Parliament may reorganise states under Article 3. The Sixth Schedule, the Article 371 provisions and constitutionally mandated panchayats and municipalities add asymmetric and local layers.
United Kingdom
Unitary with devolution. Power was devolved to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland in 1998, asymmetrically and without an English legislature. Westminster remains legally sovereign; under the Sewel convention it does not normally legislate on devolved matters without consent, but Miller (2017) held the convention unenforceable in court.
United States
Federal. Fifty states with their own constitutions keep powers not delegated to the Union (Tenth Amendment). National power grew through the commerce and spending powers, but states run elections, most criminal law and much social policy, and equal representation in the Senate protects small states.

Judiciary and review

India
An integrated hierarchy under the Supreme Court, whose law binds all courts. Review extends to constitutional amendments, rights can be enforced directly in the Supreme Court (Article 32) and High Courts (Article 226), and public interest litigation has widened access. Judges are chosen by a collegium of senior judges, a system the Court created in 1993 and restored when the NJAC judgment (2015) struck down a commission-based alternative.
United Kingdom
The Supreme Court, sitting since 2009 under the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, cannot strike down Acts of Parliament. It reviews executive action, as in Miller/Cherry (2019), which held a prorogation unlawful, and may declare an Act incompatible with Convention rights under the Human Rights Act, leaving the remedy to Parliament.
United States
Federal and state court systems run in parallel. The Supreme Court's nine justices are nominated by the President, confirmed by the Senate and serve during good behaviour. Judicial review, asserted in Marbury v Madison (1803), lets courts strike down federal and state laws, as in Brown v Board of Education (1954); appointments have become central to party conflict.

Amendment

India
Article 368: most provisions need a majority of each House's total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting; provisions on the federal structure also need ratification by half the states; some matters, such as forming new states, change by ordinary law. More than a hundred amendments have been made since 1950.
United Kingdom
No special procedure: constitutional change is made by ordinary legislation, sometimes after advisory referendums (1975, 2011, 2014, 2016), and conventions change by practice. Flexibility depends on political restraint.
United States
Article V: proposal by two-thirds of both Houses (or by a convention called at the request of two-thirds of the states, never used) and ratification by three-quarters of the states. Only 27 amendments have succeeded.

Party system

India
Multiparty. Congress dominance (1952–67) gave way to coalition government built on regional parties (1989–2014) and then to BJP dominance; in 2024 the BJP won 240 of 543 seats and governs with allies.
United Kingdom
A two-party system of Conservatives and Labour, weakened by the Liberal Democrats, nationalist parties, Reform UK and the Greens; plurality voting sustains the two large parties in seats more than in votes.
United States
A durable two-party system of Democrats and Republicans, sustained by plurality voting, ballot-access rules and primaries; once loose coalitions, the parties have become sharply polarised in Congress.

Compared with India

India
The conventional list of borrowings (parliamentary government from Britain, rights and judicial review from the United States, directive principles from Ireland, a strong-centre federation from Canada, the Concurrent List from Australia) is better read as adaptation than as copying. Ambedkar defended borrowing in the Constituent Assembly while insisting that each choice suited Indian conditions: a parliamentary executive because daily accountability mattered more than fixed-term stability, a Union its units could not break, and rights qualified by the needs of social reform. For GS-II comparison the useful question is always what India did differently with a borrowed idea, and why.
United Kingdom
India took from Britain parliamentary government, collective responsibility, the Speaker, legislative procedure and the prerogative writs, and departed from it where it mattered: a written constitution, a republican head of state, federalism, enforceable rights and judicial review of legislation, so that Parliament is supreme only within the Constitution. Conventions Britain leaves to restraint, India often codified (binding advice to the President) or handed to courts (the floor test after S.R. Bommai). India's anti-defection law has no British counterpart, and its Speaker, unlike Westminster's, remains a party politician. Westminster practices do not transplant automatically.
United States
India drew on American practice for fundamental rights, judicial review, an independent judiciary, the removal process for judges and a Vice-President who chairs the upper house, but rejected the presidential executive: Ambedkar told the Constituent Assembly that parliamentary government offered daily accountability where presidential government offered only periodic assessment. India also declined a due process clause after B.N. Rau's consultations in the United States, though Maneka Gandhi (1978) later read fairness into Article 21. Federalism differs too. Texas v White (1869) described 'an indestructible Union, composed of indestructible States'; India's Union is indestructible, but Parliament may redraw its states.

Comparison is a method, not a list of differences. A good comparative answer chooses a dimension (how the executive is held to account, say), explains why systems differ on it, and then judges what the difference does in practice.