Section F · Federalism
Centre–State Administrative Relations
Union directions to States, delegation of functions, the all-India services, Articles 355 and 356, and the contemporary disputes over central agencies.
Overview
Executive power follows legislative power: the Union's executive power extends to Union subjects and the States' to State subjects. But the Constitution adds instruments that allow the Union to direct, supervise and in the last resort displace State executives. The States must exercise their power so as to comply with Union laws, the Union may give directions, the all-India services link the two levels of administration, and Article 356 allows the President to take over a State's government.
The history of these powers is largely the history of Article 356, which Ambedkar hoped would remain a dead letter and which was invoked more than a hundred times before the Supreme Court constrained it in 1994.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Articles 256–257
- States must ensure compliance with Union laws and not impede Union executive power; the Union may give directions, including on communications of national or military importance and the protection of railways.
- Articles 258 and 258A
- The Union may entrust functions to States, and States to the Union, with consent.
- Articles 261 and 263
- Full faith and credit to public acts and judicial proceedings; the Inter-State Council.
- Article 312
- Creation of all-India services by Parliament after a Rajya Sabha resolution by two-thirds of members present and voting.
- Articles 355, 356, 365
- The Union's duty to protect States and ensure constitutional government; President's Rule; failure to comply with Union directions.
Directions and cooperation
Articles 256 and 257 oblige the States to comply with Union laws and allow the Union to give directions to that end, and on specific matters such as communications of national or military importance and the protection of railways. If a State fails to comply, Article 365 allows the President to treat it as a situation in which the State's government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution. Formal directions are rarely used; the Union's influence works mainly through funding, the all-India services and the Governor. Articles 258 and 258A allow either level to entrust functions to the other by consent, a flexible device used for elections, the census and many centrally sponsored schemes.
The all-India services
The Indian Administrative Service and the Indian Police Service, created under the All India Services Act, 1951, and the Indian Forest Service (1966) are recruited by the Union but serve in State cadres, under State control for day-to-day purposes, with appointment and dismissal reserved to the Union. Vallabhbhai Patel defended them in the Constituent Assembly as the guarantee of a united administration, the successor to the "steel frame" of the colonial civil service.
They are a hinge of the federal system and therefore a site of friction. In 2022 the Union proposed amending the IAS cadre rules so that officers could be sent on central deputation without the State's agreement; several States objected that the change would make officers answerable to the Union over their elected governments.
Article 356 and President's Rule
On a report from the Governor or otherwise, the President may proclaim that a State's government cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution, assume its executive functions and transfer its legislative powers to Parliament. Each House must approve the proclamation within two months; it lasts six months at a time, up to three years, and beyond one year only if a national emergency is in force and the Election Commission certifies that elections cannot be held (the 44th Amendment).
The first prominent use was the dismissal of the Communist government of Kerala in 1959. The Janata government dismissed nine Congress State governments in 1977, and the Congress returned the favour with nine more in 1980; the Supreme Court declined to interfere in State of Rajasthan v. Union of India (1977). Proclamations were also used against governments that retained a majority on the floor.
The Bommai settlement
S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), decided by nine judges, transformed the law. A proclamation is subject to judicial review; the material behind it must be relevant; the question of majority must be tested on the floor of the House, not in the Governor's residence; the Assembly may be suspended but not dissolved until both Houses approve the proclamation; and if the proclamation is invalid, the Court may restore the dismissed government. The Court also held secularism to be a basic feature and upheld the dismissal of three State governments after the demolition of the Babri Masjid in 1992 on that ground.
Rameshwar Prasad (2006) held the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly in 2005 unconstitutional and criticised the Governor's report. In 2016 courts reversed President's Rule in Uttarakhand and, in Nabam Rebia, restored the dismissed government of Arunachal Pradesh. Since Bommai the use of Article 356 has fallen sharply.
Central forces and investigating agencies
Police and public order are State subjects, but the Union may deploy its armed forces and central armed police in aid of the civil power (Union List Entry 2A, added in 1976), and Article 355 imposes on it a duty to protect States against internal disturbance. The Central Bureau of Investigation, constituted under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946, needs a State's consent to investigate within it (section 6). Several States have withdrawn their general consent, and in State of West Bengal v. Union of India (2024) the Supreme Court held the State's suit under Article 131 over CBI investigations to be maintainable. Investigations by agencies that do not need consent, such as the Enforcement Directorate under the money-laundering law, have become a fresh source of federal conflict.
Debates
Should Article 356 be retained?
Abolition was urged by the Rajamannar Committee and by many State parties, on the ground that the provision had been used mainly to dismiss opposition governments. Retention with safeguards was recommended by the Sarkaria Commission and the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution, which saw a genuine need for a remedy when constitutional government does break down, as in insurgencies or complete political deadlock.
Bommai effectively chose retention with judicial safeguards, and the fall in its use since 1994 supports that choice. The Punchhi Commission proposed "localised emergency" provisions so that the Union could act in a limited area without suspending a whole State's government.
Should central investigating agencies need State consent?
The consent requirement protects the State's control over policing and prevents the Union from using investigations against opposition governments. Against it, corruption and organised crime cross State lines, State police may be unwilling to investigate State politicians, and a consent veto lets governments shield their own. A neutral mechanism for authorising investigations, or a statutorily independent CBI, would address both concerns better than the present all-or-nothing consent.
Commissions and committees
Administrative Reforms Commission (first)1969
Its report on Centre–State relations recommended setting up an Inter-State Council under Article 263 and appointing Governors with long experience in public life and a non-partisan outlook.
Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu)1971
Recommended deleting Articles 356, 357 and 365 and constituting an Inter-State Council.
Sarkaria Commission1988
Chaired by Justice R.S. Sarkaria; 247 recommendations. Article 356 to be used only as a last resort, after a warning to the State and exploration of alternatives; majority to be tested on the floor; a permanent Inter-State Council.
Punchhi Commission2010
Chaired by Justice M.M. Punchhi. Proposed localised emergency provisions under Articles 355 and 356 and a fixed tenure for Governors with removal only through a resolution of the State legislature.
Prelims points
- Article 256: States must comply with Union laws; Article 365 links non-compliance with Union directions to Article 356.
- Articles 258 and 258A allow mutual delegation of functions with consent.
- All-India services (Article 312): IAS and IPS under the All India Services Act, 1951; Indian Forest Service from 1966.
- President's Rule: approval by both Houses within two months; six months at a time; maximum three years.
- Beyond one year, President's Rule needs a national emergency and an Election Commission certificate (44th Amendment).
- The first prominent use of Article 356 was against the Kerala government in 1959.
- S.R. Bommai (1994): judicial review, floor test, no dissolution before parliamentary approval, restoration possible.
- The CBI needs State consent under section 6 of the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946.
- Sarkaria Commission: set up 1983, reported 1988; Punchhi Commission: set up 2007, reported 2010.
In the UPSC papers
Asked by UPSC
1 question · 2024
2024 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks
What changes has the Union Government recently introduced in the domain of Centre-State relations ? Suggest measures to be adopted to build the trust between the Centre and the States and for strengthening federalism.
Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Centre–State Administrative Relations in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Article 356 was meant to be a dead letter but became a political weapon. Examine its use since 1950 and the safeguards developed by the Supreme Court.
How to approach it
Trace the record (1959, 1977, 1980, 1992), the Rajasthan case, Bommai's principles, Rameshwar Prasad and 2016; evaluate the post-Bommai decline and the localised emergency proposal.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Discuss the role of the all-India services in Indian federalism.
How to approach it
Explain recruitment and control, Patel's rationale, their integrating role, and the 2022 deputation dispute.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Should State consent be required for investigations by central agencies? Discuss.
How to approach it
Weigh federal control of policing against cross-border crime and political misuse; mention the 2024 West Bengal suit and possible institutional reforms.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
Concept
Thinker
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 256 · Obligation of States and the Union
- Article 257 · Control of the Union over States in certain cases
- Article 258 · Power of the Union to confer powers, etc., on States in certain cases
- Article 258A · Power of the States to entrust functions to the Union
- Article 261 · Public acts, records and judicial proceedings
- Article 263 · Provisions with respect to an inter-State Council
- Article 312 · All-India services
- Article 355 · Duty of the Union to protect States against external aggression and internal disturbance
- Article 356 · Provisions in case of failure of constitutional machinery in States
- Article 357 · Exercise of legislative powers under Proclamation issued under article 356
Amendment
Judgment
Institution
Five-minute module
Dictionary
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
- 03Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988. Government of India
- 04Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Punchhi Commission), 2010. Government of India
- 05Report of the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution, 2002. Ministry of Law and Justice
- 06Granville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution: The Indian Experience (1999). Oxford University Press