Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 2015

NJAC case (Fourth Judges case)

By four to one, the Court struck down the 99th Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014, holding judicial primacy in appointments to be part of the basic structure, and revived the collegium.

Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
16 October 2015
Bench
5-judge Constitution Bench
Citation
(2016) 5 SCC 1
Doctrine
Independence of the judiciary as basic structure; judicial primacy in appointments

01The constitutional issue

In 2014 Parliament, with near-unanimous support, passed the 99th Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act. The amendment inserted Articles 124A–124C, creating a six-member commission: the Chief Justice of India, the two next senior judges, the Union Law Minister and two "eminent persons" chosen by the Prime Minister, the Chief Justice and the Leader of the Opposition. Any two members could block a recommendation.

The question was whether this design violated the independence of the judiciary, a basic feature of the Constitution.

02The decision

Khehar, Lokur, Kurian Joseph and Goel JJ, writing separately, held the amendment unconstitutional. Judicial independence is a basic feature, and primacy of the judiciary in appointments is integral to it. The commission gave the three judges no decisive voice and allowed any two members — potentially the Law Minister and one eminent person — to veto a candidate. The Law Minister's presence compromised independence, since the Government is the largest litigant; the loosely defined eminent persons added to the risk.

With the amendment void, the NJAC Act fell, and the collegium system as it stood before the amendment revived. In a separate order in December 2015, the majority acknowledged shortcomings in the collegium and called for a revised Memorandum of Procedure.

Chelameswar J dissented. Judicial primacy, he held, is not part of the basic structure; the collegium's record showed a lack of transparency and accountability; and a mixed commission was a legitimate democratic choice.

03Significance

The judgment confirmed that judicial independence, as the Court understands it, includes control of appointments — an unusual position in comparative terms — and showed the doctrine's reach against an amendment backed by almost all of Parliament and ratified by more than half the States.

The criticisms are institutional and democratic. The Court decided a case about its own powers; the collegium it restored has no textual basis; and appointment by judges without published criteria or reasons is hard to square with accountability. Defenders answer that a body in which the executive could veto judicial nominees would have made judges dependent on the State's largest litigant.

04What happened afterwards

The Memorandum of Procedure has remained a point of friction between the Government and the collegium. From 2017 the collegium began publishing its resolutions online, though the practice has varied. Delays in notifying recommended names, and the Government's practice of clearing some names in a batch while holding back others, have repeatedly come before the Court.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: 99th Amendment, Articles 124A–124C, the commission's composition, 4:1, 16 October 2015. In Mains, compare the collegium with commission models such as the United Kingdom's Judicial Appointments Commission and South Africa's Judicial Service Commission.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

1 question · 2025

  1. 2025 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks

    Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to NJAC case (Fourth Judges case) in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 16 October 2015. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Arghya Sengupta, Independence and Accountability of the Indian Higher Judiciary (Cambridge University Press, 2019)
  3. 03Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, (2016) 5 SCC 1: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India