Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 1994

S.R. Bommai

The Court subjected President's Rule under Article 356 to judicial review, made the floor of the House the test of a government's majority, and held secularism and federalism to be basic features of the Constitution.

S.R. Bommai v. Union of India
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
11 March 1994
Bench
9-judge Constitution Bench
Citation
[1994] 2 SCR 644; (1994) 3 SCC 1
Doctrine
Limited judicial review of President's Rule; floor test; secularism as a basic feature

01The constitutional issue

In April 1989 the Karnataka government of S.R. Bommai was dismissed under Article 356 on the Governor's report that defections had cost it its majority, although Bommai had asked to prove his strength in the Assembly. Proclamations in Nagaland (1988) and Meghalaya (1991) raised similar questions. After the demolition of the Babri Masjid in December 1992, the BJP governments of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh were dismissed as well.

The Court had to decide whether the President's satisfaction under Article 356 is justiciable, on what grounds, and with what remedy.

02The decision

Nine judges wrote six opinions; the propositions that commanded a majority have been settled by later benches.

The President's satisfaction is open to judicial review on narrow grounds: whether there was relevant material, and whether the proclamation was mala fide or rested on wholly irrelevant or extraneous grounds — not whether the material was sufficient. Article 74(2) bars inquiry into the advice tendered, not into the material behind it. The 44th Amendment had already removed the 38th Amendment's clause making the satisfaction final.

Until both Houses approve the proclamation, the Assembly may only be kept in suspended animation; if the proclamation fails, the dismissed ministry may be restored. Whether a government has lost its majority must be tested on the floor of the House, not in the Governor's chamber.

Secularism was held to be a basic feature, and a State government acting against it may be removed; on that ground the dismissals of the three BJP governments were upheld. The Karnataka proclamation was held invalid, but fresh elections had long since been held and no relief was possible.

03Significance

Bommai ended the routine use of Article 356 against opposition-ruled States — a provision B.R. Ambedkar had hoped would remain a dead letter. Together with coalition politics, it shifted Indian federalism towards the States.

Some critics argue that upholding the 1992 dismissals on the open-ended ground of secularism was itself a political judgment. Others note that review comes too late: the Karnataka ruling arrived five years after the dismissal. The defence is that the floor test is a clear, democratic rule that has disciplined Governors since.

04What happened afterwards

Rameshwar Prasad (2006) invalidated the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly, and Nabam Rebia (2016) restored the Arunachal Pradesh government. In Uttarakhand (2016) a Court-supervised floor test followed the High Court's quashing of President's Rule. Prompt floor tests ordered in Karnataka (2018) and Maharashtra (2019) applied Bommai's principle, and Subhash Desai (2023) examined when a Governor may call one.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: nine judges, 11 March 1994; floor test; suspended animation until parliamentary approval; secularism and federalism as basic features. In Mains, pair it with the Governor's role and the Sarkaria and Punchhi Commissions' recommendations on Article 356.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

2 questions · 2024–2026

  1. 2026 · PSIR I · Q5(b) · 10 marks

    The Constitution of India was secular even before the word was included in the Preamble. Comment.

  2. 2024 · GS-II · Q15 · 15 marks

    Discuss India as a secular state and compare with the secular principles of the US constitution.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to S.R. Bommai in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Explore further

Political system

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 11 March 1994. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988
  3. 03Granville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution: The Indian Experience (Oxford University Press, 1999)
  4. 04S.R. Bommai v. Union of India, [1994] 2 SCR 644: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India