Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 2007

I.R. Coelho

A unanimous nine-judge bench held that laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 are open to challenge if they damage the basic structure, including the essence of the rights in Articles 14, 19 and 21.

I.R. Coelho (Dead) by LRs v. State of Tamil Nadu
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
11 January 2007
Bench
9-judge Constitution Bench
Citation
(2007) 2 SCC 1
Doctrine
Basic structure review of Ninth Schedule laws (rights test; essence of rights test)

01The constitutional issue

Article 31B, added by the First Amendment, protected Acts placed in the Ninth Schedule from challenge for violating Fundamental Rights. Meant for land reform, the Schedule had grown to well over two hundred laws, including Tamil Nadu's 69 per cent reservation statute.

The Gudalur Janmam Estates (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1969, partly struck down by the Supreme Court in 1972, was then placed in the Schedule by the 34th Amendment. A five-judge bench referred the larger question to nine judges in 1999: does a law inserted in the Ninth Schedule after Kesavananda enjoy blanket immunity?

02The decision

Sabharwal CJ, for a unanimous bench, held that it does not. Article 31B is itself valid, as Waman Rao had held, but it cannot place laws beyond basic-structure review. Every law inserted after 24 April 1973 is tested by its effect on Fundamental Rights. If it abrogates or abridges them in a way that damages the basic structure, the insertion fails.

The Court described Articles 14, 19 and 21, and the principles underlying them, as part of the basic structure, and applied a "rights test" and an "essence of rights" test: the question is not the form of the amendment but the impact of the protected law. Laws already upheld by the Court would not be reopened, but a law struck down and then inserted into the Schedule could be examined afresh. The individual Acts were returned to a three-judge bench.

03Significance

The Ninth Schedule had become a device for immunising controversial laws from rights review; Coelho closed it. The decision carried the basic structure doctrine from the text of amendments to the effect of the laws they protect.

Its critics say the test is uncertain — what is the "essence" of a right? — and that it blurs the line, drawn in Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain, between amendments and ordinary laws. Its defenders answer that the alternative would let Parliament achieve indirectly, by listing a law, what Kesavananda forbids it to do directly.

04What happened afterwards

A three-judge bench applied the test in Glanrock Estate (2010) and upheld the inclusion of the Janmam Act, finding no damage to the basic structure. The decision has made the Ninth Schedule a far less attractive shield, and later controversies over State reservation laws placed in it are argued on the footing that Coelho established.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: nine judges, 11 January 2007; 24 April 1973 cut-off; Articles 14, 19 and 21. In Mains, use it with Waman Rao to explain how the basic structure doctrine reaches the Ninth Schedule.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

1 question · 2025

  1. 2025 · PSIR I · Q5(c) · 10 marks

    Land reforms programmes led to some constitutional amendments. Comment.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to I.R. Coelho in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 11 January 2007. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Sudhir Krishnaswamy, Democracy and Constitutionalism in India: A Study of the Basic Structure Doctrine (Oxford University Press, 2009)
  3. 03I.R. Coelho (Dead) by LRs v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2007) 2 SCC 1: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India