Skip to content

Case study · Pacific (Vanuatu) and global · 2019–2026

From a Pacific classroom to the World Court: the ICJ climate advisory opinion

How law students in Vanuatu turned small states' weakness in climate negotiations into strength in a court, what the ICJ said in July 2025, and why an opinion that binds no one still changes the terms of climate politics.

The case

In 2019 a group of law students at the University of the South Pacific's campus in Vanuatu launched a campaign, Pacific Islands Students Fighting Climate Change, for an advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice on states' climate obligations. They persuaded the government of Vanuatu, which built a coalition of co-sponsors and took the request to the UN General Assembly, where every state has one vote. On 29 March 2023 the Assembly adopted the request by consensus, asking the Court what obligations states have to protect the climate system and what legal consequences follow when they cause significant harm.

The proceedings drew participation on a scale the Court had not seen, with oral hearings in December 2024. On 23 July 2025 the Court gave a unanimous opinion. It found that states have binding obligations to protect the climate system from greenhouse gas emissions under the climate treaties, customary international law, human rights law and other bodies of law; that the customary obligations bind states whether or not they are parties to particular climate treaties; and that breaching them is an internationally wrongful act that can engage state responsibility, including reparation. It treated limiting warming to 1.5°C as the primary temperature goal, indicated that fossil-fuel production, licensing and subsidies may amount to wrongful acts, and described a clean, healthy and sustainable environment as a precondition for the enjoyment of other human rights.

The opinion capped a run of decisions: an advisory opinion of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in 2024, the European Court of Human Rights' judgment for older Swiss women in KlimaSeniorinnen the same year, and an advisory opinion of the Inter-American Court in 2025. On 20 May 2026 the General Assembly adopted a Vanuatu-led resolution welcoming the ICJ opinion by 141 votes to 8, with 28 abstentions; the United States voted against.

Actors and stakeholders

  • Pacific Islands Students Fighting Climate ChangeYouth civil society movement

    Role

    Originated the campaign and kept it public, acting as norm entrepreneurs.

    Power and its sources

    The moral authority of the most affected; no formal power, so they borrowed a state's standing.

  • Government of VanuatuSmall island developing state

    Role

    Sponsored the request, built the coalition and led the 2026 follow-up resolution.

    Power and its sources

    One vote in the General Assembly, equal to any other, plus diplomatic and legal skill.

  • UN General AssemblyPlenary organ of the UN

    Role

    Requested the opinion in 2023 and welcomed it in 2026.

    Power and its sources

    A majoritarian forum where small states count; its resolutions do not bind.

  • International Court of JusticePrincipal judicial organ of the UN

    Role

    Gave the advisory opinion.

    Power and its sources

    Authoritative statement of law, but advisory opinions are not binding and carry no enforcement.

  • Major emitting statesStates

    Role

    Several argued that the climate treaties, with their nationally determined commitments, set the full extent of their obligations; the United States opposed the 2026 resolution.

    Power and its sources

    Economic and diplomatic weight, and the ability to disregard an advisory opinion at little immediate cost.

  • Regional courts and tribunalsInternational and regional judicial bodies

    Role

    ITLOS, the European Court of Human Rights and the Inter-American Court reached converging conclusions.

    Power and its sources

    The European Court's judgments bind its member states; the others add authority to the emerging law.

Through the key concepts

power

This is structural power in Susan Strange's sense: not winning a negotiation but shaping the rules under which future negotiations and litigation take place. States with little economic weight moved the question from a forum where economic power decides to one where argument decides.

legitimacy

The opinion's authority rests on unanimity, on unusually broad participation and on the General Assembly's endorsement. Its legitimacy as law will be measured by uptake in national and regional courts; critics object that courts are making policy that belongs to negotiators.

sovereignty

Customary obligations bind states that never accepted the relevant treaties, qualifying the consent-based view of sovereignty. States keep discretion over how to meet the obligations, which is where the next political fights will happen.

interdependence

The atmosphere is a shared resource in which harm is cumulative and crosses borders. The opinion turns that ecological interdependence into legal interdependence, with responsibility owed to states and peoples who emitted least.

Perspectives

Vulnerable states and climate movements

The opinion converts appeals for generosity into legal claims; on Thomas Pogge's logic, climate finance becomes compensation rather than charity.

Major emitters

The Paris Agreement's nationally determined approach is the framework states agreed; an advisory opinion cannot rewrite it, and courts should not substitute for negotiation.

Large developing economies

Obligations must respect common but differentiated responsibilities and historical emissions; developing countries' right to development cannot be traded away.

Realist sceptics

Advisory opinions order nothing; emissions did not fall after July 2025; power, not law, will set the pace of decarbonisation.

Evaluation

As enforcement, the opinion achieved nothing on its own. As norm-building, it is among the most consequential episodes in recent international law, and it shows the norm life cycle running at speed: entrepreneurs (students), a platform (Vanuatu and the General Assembly), a cascade through courts on three continents, and endorsement by a large majority of states.

Its real test is uptake: whether domestic courts, negotiators and finance ministries begin to treat climate obligations as legal duties. The case is also a lesson in power for the course: actors with the least conventional power chose the arena in which conventional power counts least. See development and sustainability and rights and justice.

Questions to take further

  • Can a non-binding opinion change state behaviour, and how would we know?
  • Why did small states succeed in the General Assembly where they had struggled in climate negotiations?
  • Does the opinion make climate finance a matter of compensation rather than aid?
  • Who speaks for future generations in international law?

Sources

  1. 01International Court of Justice, Obligations of States in respect of Climate Change, advisory opinion of 23 July 2025 (opens in a new tab). ICJ, 23 July 2025
  2. 02UN General Assembly resolution 77/276 requesting the advisory opinion, 29 March 2023. United Nations, 29 March 2023
  3. 03UN General Assembly resolution welcoming the advisory opinion (draft A/80/L.65), adopted 20 May 2026. United Nations, 20 May 2026
  4. 04Arjun Agrawal, Global Politics Handbooks 08 and 09