01
Sovereign response to terrorism
Held byGovernment of India
India placed the treaty in abeyance 'in exercise of its rights as a sovereign nation under international law' and holds that, while it is in abeyance, India 'is no longer bound to perform any of its obligations under the Treaty'. A treaty concluded, in its preamble's words, 'in a spirit of goodwill and friendship' cannot oblige India to behave as if that spirit survived sustained cross-border terrorism. The Court of Arbitration was constituted in breach of the treaty's graded mechanism, so its pronouncements are void, and India had in any case sought modification since 2023 to reflect changed circumstances.