Skip to content

Political Issue Dossier · India

Governors and State legislation

Article 200 lets a Governor assent to a State Bill, return it or reserve it for the President, but sets no time limit. In 2025 the Supreme Court first imposed deadlines and deemed ten Tamil Nadu Bills to be law, then, answering a presidential reference, withdrew the deadlines while forbidding Governors to sit on Bills indefinitely. The dispute is about who governs a State: its elected legislature or a Union appointee.

At a glance

Region
India
Country most involved
India
Facts checked to
Mapped
6 actors, 4 stakeholders, 13 dated events
Sources
13 · 11 primary or official
Syllabus lines
UPSC 7 · PSIR 4 · IB 2
How it is examined

The central question

What a reader should be able to answer by the end of the dossier.

How far can an appointed Governor delay or block legislation passed by an elected State legislature, and who should decide when the delay becomes unconstitutional: the courts, Parliament through amendment, or convention?

Contents 19 sections
  1. 01Locator map
  2. 02Background
  3. 03Geography
  4. 04Historical development
  5. 05Actor map
  6. 06Stakeholder map
  7. 07Institutional framework
  8. 08Legal framework
  9. 09Timeline
  10. 10Competing narratives
  11. 11Theories applied
  12. 12Political consequences
  13. 13India’s position
  14. 14Possible solutions
  15. 15Critical evaluation
  16. 16Examination applications
  17. 17Practice questions
  18. 18Sources
  19. 19Connected knowledge

How to read the labels

Facts
Sourced statements of fact.
Attributed
Positions and proposals, in the terms of those who hold them.
Analysis
The platform’s reading of the evidence.
Examination
How the issue maps to the syllabi.

01Locator mapFacts

INDIACHINAMYANMAR1234567Supreme Court of IndiaRashtrapati BhavanChennaiThiruvananthapuramChandigarhHyderabadItanagar
IndiaPlaces named in the dossier
  1. 1. Supreme Court of India, New Delhi

    Delivered the Tamil Nadu judgment on 8 April 2025 and the advisory opinion on 20 November 2025.

  2. 2. Rashtrapati Bhavan, New Delhi

    The President referred fourteen questions to the Supreme Court under Article 143 on 13 May 2025.

  3. 3. Chennai

    The Tamil Nadu Assembly re-passed ten Bills in a special session on 18 November 2023.

  4. 4. Thiruvananthapuram

    Kerala, with Tamil Nadu, opposed the reference as an appeal in disguise.

  5. 5. Chandigarh

    Capital of Punjab, whose dispute with its Governor produced the November 2023 ruling that withholding must be followed by return to the legislature.

  6. 6. Hyderabad

    In a Telangana case the Court stressed that 'as soon as possible' in Article 200 has constitutional content.

  7. 7. Itanagar

    Arunachal Pradesh, the setting of Nabam Rebia (2016) on the limits of the Governor's discretion.

Boundaries are from Natural Earth’s India point-of-view data and are approximate at this scale; the map is a teaching aid and does not purport to be an authoritative depiction of international boundaries. Markers that would overlap are drawn apart, with a line to the true position.

02BackgroundFacts

The Governor is the constitutional head of a State and also the Union's appointee. Under Article 155 the President appoints the Governor, and under Article 156 the Governor holds office during the President's pleasure, which in practice means the Union government's. Under Article 163 the Governor acts on the advice of the State Council of Ministers except where the Constitution requires the exercise of discretion.

Article 200 gives the Governor three options when a Bill passed by the State legislature is presented: assent, withhold assent, or reserve the Bill for the President. The first proviso allows a Bill other than a Money Bill to be returned for reconsideration 'as soon as possible', and a Bill passed again must not have assent withheld. The second proviso requires reservation of Bills that would endanger the High Court's position. Nothing in the article says how long the Governor may take.

For decades that silence mattered little. It became a central grievance when Governors in States governed by parties opposed to the Union government left Bills pending for long periods, many of them on universities and the appointment of vice-chancellors. In Tamil Nadu, twelve Bills passed between January 2020 and April 2023 were not acted on until the State went to the Supreme Court in October 2023. The Court's response came in two stages in 2025: a two-judge Bench imposed deadlines and deemed ten Bills to be law, and a five-judge Bench, answering a presidential reference, withdrew the deadlines while holding that indefinite inaction remains open to a limited remedy.

03GeographyFacts

The geography of the dispute follows the map of divided government. Conflict over assent arises where a State is governed by a party in opposition at the Centre while its Governor is appointed by the Union government. Since 2023 disputes have reached the Supreme Court from Punjab, Telangana, Kerala and, above all, Tamil Nadu. In the 2025 reference Tamil Nadu and Kerala led the opposition, joined in submissions by West Bengal, Karnataka, Himachal Pradesh, Punjab and Telangana, while several States governed by the Union's ruling coalition were heard alongside the Union.

The subjects in dispute have a pattern too. Many of the Tamil Nadu Bills concerned State universities, especially the power to appoint vice-chancellors, where the Governor, as chancellor by State law, and the elected government both claim authority. The Governor reserved the re-passed Bills on the ground that they conflicted with Entry 66 of the Union List, on standards in higher education, even while noting that they fell within State competence.

The office itself spans the country's federal map. Each of the 28 States has a Governor, while the Union Territories are run by Lieutenant Governors or Administrators under different provisions. The Governor's role in a State is therefore uniform in law but uneven in practice: in States politically aligned with the Union the office is rarely contentious, while in opposition-ruled States it has become the most visible point of friction in Centre–State relations, alongside fiscal transfers and the deployment of central agencies.

04Historical developmentFacts

The office was inherited from colonial law and reshaped in debate. The Government of India Act, 1935 gave provincial Governors wide discretion. In the Constituent Assembly, B.R. Ambedkar said on 30 July 1949, when the words 'in his discretion' were dropped from the draft of what became Article 200, that 'in a responsible government there can be no room for the Governor acting on discretion'; on 1 June 1949, on the draft of what became Article 163, he had argued that some discretion was compatible with responsible government. Both statements were cited in 2025.

The courts settled the general rule first. In Shamsher Singh v State of Punjab (1974) seven judges held that the President and Governors act on ministerial advice save in exceptional situations. B.P. Singhal (2010) held that a Governor is neither an employee of the Union nor the agent of the party in power, and cannot be removed arbitrarily. Nabam Rebia (2016) set aside an Arunachal Pradesh Governor's unadvised advancing of an Assembly session.

Reform commissions addressed assent specifically. The Sarkaria Commission, appointed in 1983, proposed timelines as 'salutary conventions': discretionary reservation within one month and a presidential decision within four. The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002) proposed four months for the Governor and three for the President, and the Punchhi Commission, constituted in 2007, endorsed those recommendations. A Ministry of Home Affairs office memorandum of 4 February 2016 set a maximum of three months for the Union to process reserved Bills.

The modern conflict reached the Court in 2023. In State of Punjab v Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab (2024) 1 SCC 384, decided in November 2023, the Court held that a Governor who withholds assent must return the Bill to the legislature. Tamil Nadu followed, and with it the decisions of 2025.

05Actor mapFactsAttributed

Who acts on the issue, grouped by kind around it. Each actor’s role is a matter of record; a stated position is the actor’s own.

Governments2

  • Union government

    Stated positionNo judicial timelines; no deemed assent

    Controls the appointment and tenure of Governors in practice and advises the President on reserved Bills. In the reference, represented by the Solicitor General, it argued that the Constitution's silence on time limits is deliberate and cannot be filled by the courts.

  • State governments that opposed the reference, led by Tamil Nadu and Kerala

    Stated positionAssent must follow ministerial advice within a reasonable, enforceable time

    Brought the litigation, defended the April 2025 judgment and argued that the reference was an appeal in disguise against a binding decision.

Institutions3

  • Governors of opposition-ruled States, notably R.N. Ravi in Tamil Nadu

    Stated positionAssent is a matter of the Governor's constitutional judgement, not a ministerial formality

    Took charge in Tamil Nadu in November 2021 and acted on twelve pending Bills only after the State petitioned the Supreme Court: on 13 November 2023 he withheld assent to ten without a message for reconsideration and reserved two, then reserved the ten re-passed Bills for the President on 28 November 2023.

  • President of India

    Decides on reserved Bills under Article 201 on the Union government's advice and, on 13 May 2025, referred fourteen questions to the Supreme Court under Article 143(1).

  • State legislatures

    Pass the Bills, reconsider those returned with a message, and, under the 2025 opinion, take part in what the Court called a dialogic process with the Governor.

Court1

  • Supreme Court of India

    A two-judge Bench (J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan) set timelines and deemed ten Bills assented on 8 April 2025; a five-judge Bench led by Chief Justice B.R. Gavai withdrew the timelines and rejected deemed assent on 20 November 2025, while allowing a limited mandamus against prolonged inaction.

06Stakeholder mapAnalysis

Who has a stake in the outcome, and what it is, placed by how much influence each has over the result. The placing is the dossier’s assessment.

Influence

High

  • The Union government

    Keeps a check on State legislation through Governors and through the President's decision on reserved Bills. Influence is high because it effectively selects and can replace Governors, and because the November 2025 opinion left the choice among Article 200's options to the Governor's discretion.

Influence

Medium

  • Opposition-ruled State governments

    Need their legislative programmes enacted on a predictable timetable. Influence is medium: they won the April 2025 judgment, but after the November opinion they must litigate delay Bill by Bill and show that it is prolonged, unexplained and indefinite.

Influence

Low

  • Universities, students and staff

    Many contested Bills concern university governance and the appointment of vice-chancellors, so delay leaves institutions without settled leadership. Influence is low: they bear the costs of deadlock without a formal role in resolving it.

  • Citizens of the States concerned

    Laws passed by their elected representatives may not take effect for years. Influence is low between elections, though the political cost of visible obstruction can shape a Governor's and a government's conduct.

07Institutional frameworkFacts

Four institutions share responsibility for a State Bill, and the dispute is about the boundaries between them.

The State legislature and Council of Ministers initiate and pass the Bill and, under Article 163, advise the Governor. The Governor decides under Article 200; under the November 2025 opinion, the choice among assent, reservation and return is the Governor's discretion, and withholding without return is not allowed. The President, advised by the Union government, decides on reserved Bills under Article 201, which allows a Bill other than a Money Bill to be returned with a message and gives the legislature six months to reconsider it. The Supreme Court polices the boundaries, through writ jurisdiction and, as in 2025, through advisory opinions under Article 143.

The office of Governor carries a structural tension. B.P. Singhal described a dual role: constitutional head of the State bound by ministerial advice, and a link between the Union and the State. When the State and Union governments are politically aligned, the two roles coincide; when they are opposed, a Governor whose tenure depends on the Union faces divided loyalties.

Mechanisms for resolving that tension outside court are weak. The Inter-State Council under Article 263 can discuss Centre–State friction but has no role in assent. The Ministry of Home Affairs' 2016 guidelines bind the Union's own processing of reserved Bills, not Governors. No convention requires a Governor to state reasons for reserving a Bill. The 2025 opinion therefore leaves the courts as the default arbiter of delay, but with a narrower remedy than the April judgment provided.

09TimelineFacts

  1. In the Constituent Assembly, Ambedkar moves the amendment dropping 'in his discretion' from the draft of what became Article 200.

  2. In Shamsher Singh v State of Punjab a seven-judge Bench holds that the President and Governors act on ministerial advice save in exceptional situations.

  3. The Sarkaria Commission reports, proposing timelines for reservation and presidential decisions as salutary conventions.

  4. B.P. Singhal holds that Governors, though holding office at pleasure, cannot be removed arbitrarily.

  5. A Home Ministry memorandum sets a three-month maximum for the Union to process State Bills.

  6. Nabam Rebia sets aside an Arunachal Pradesh Governor's unadvised advancing of an Assembly session.

  7. In the Punjab case the Court holds that a Governor who withholds assent must return the Bill to the legislature.

  8. Tamil Nadu's Governor withholds assent to ten Bills without a message and reserves two.

  9. The Tamil Nadu Assembly re-passes the ten Bills in a special session.

  10. The Governor reserves the re-passed Bills for the President.

  11. A two-judge Bench sets timelines and declares the ten Bills deemed assented as of 18 November 2023.

  12. The President refers fourteen questions on Articles 200 and 201 to the Supreme Court.

  13. A five-judge Bench advises no judicial timelines and no deemed assent, but a limited mandamus against prolonged inaction.

10Competing narrativesAttributed

Each narrative in its holders’ own terms, and attributed to them. A strong answer weighs them against each other rather than adopting one.

01

Text and the separation of powers

Held bythe Union government

The framers knew how to write time limits, as Article 201's six months for reconsideration shows, and chose not to impose one on the Governor. A court that supplies a deadline, and then deems assent when it expires, amends the Constitution by judgment. The Governor's scrutiny of a Bill is a constitutional safeguard against hasty or invalid legislation, not obstruction.

02

Elected government and federalism

Held byTamil Nadu, Kerala and other States that opposed the reference

Elected legislatures answerable to voters are being frustrated by appointed Governors answerable to the Union. A right without a timetable is a right the other side controls; the April judgment made Article 200 enforceable, and the November opinion leaves States to litigate delay one Bill at a time. They also argued that the reference was an appeal in disguise against a judgment the Union never sought to review.

03

Reform by amendment

Held bythe Sarkaria, NCRWC and Punchhi commissions

The answer to delay is a constitutional rule, not judicial improvisation. Successive commissions proposed time limits, and the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution even suggested removing the Governor's power to withhold assent and confining reservation to the cases the Constitution requires, so that a State Bill could not be killed by being kept in cold storage.

04

Judicial method

Held byconstitutional scholars and the Bar

A third group, without necessarily preferring either outcome, questions the route. A reference was used to revisit, within seven months, the reasoning of a judgment delivered in a live dispute. The Court answered that an advisory opinion may clarify the law without disturbing the relief already granted, but how far an opinion can displace a binding judgment's reasoning remains debated.

11Theories appliedAnalysis

Each theory is applied to the case, not merely defined.

01Law and convention

A.V. Dicey distinguished the law of the constitution from its conventions, rules that are followed but not enforced by courts. The Supreme Court of Canada's Patriation Reference (1981), quoted in the Tamil Nadu judgment, described a royal power to refuse assent as 'a conflict between a legal rule which creates a complete discretion and a conventional rule which completely neutralizes it'. India's 2025 decisions turn on the same distinction: the April judgment treated the convention of acting on advice as close to binding law, while the November opinion read the text as conferring discretion and left restraint to convention and a narrow remedy.

02Principal–agent theory

The Governor is an agent with two principals: the State Council of Ministers, whose advice the Constitution makes the norm, and the Union government, which in practice controls appointment and tenure. Principal–agent theory predicts that an agent drifts towards the principal that controls rewards and removal whenever the principals' interests diverge. The theory explains why assent disputes cluster in opposition-ruled States and why B.P. Singhal's protection against arbitrary removal matters: it weakens the Union's hold over the agent.

03Rules and standards

Legal theorists such as Louis Kaplow contrast rules, which fix outcomes in advance and are cheap to apply but rigid, with standards, which require judgement case by case. The April judgment gave States a rule: fixed timelines. The November opinion substituted a standard: prolonged, unexplained and indefinite inaction. Standards are flexible, but their uncertainty favours the party that controls the pace, here the Governor, until accumulated decisions give 'reasonable time' a working meaning.

04Dialogic constitutionalism

Theories of constitutional dialogue, associated with Peter Hogg and Allison Bushell's work on Canada (1997), see institutions refining law through exchange rather than final command. The November opinion explicitly called Article 200 a dialogic process: a Governor returns a Bill with comments, the legislature reconsiders, and the Governor may then assent or reserve. Dialogue presupposes good faith and reasonable speed, so the theory also identifies the failure the opinion leaves least protected: a Governor who neither speaks nor decides.

12Political consequencesAnalysis

The two decisions of 2025 have consequences of different kinds.

For the Tamil Nadu Bills. The opinion did not disturb the relief granted in April 2025, so the ten Bills declared assented as of 18 November 2023 remain law, even though the reasoning that produced that relief has been disapproved.

For Governors. The silent pocket veto is closed: withholding assent must be accompanied by return to the legislature, and a Governor cannot keep a Bill indefinitely without risking a mandamus. But the choice among options is now authoritatively discretionary, and a re-passed Bill may be reserved, so the Union's influence over contentious State legislation through reservation is confirmed.

For States. The remedy for delay is now case-by-case litigation against a standard rather than a rule. States must build records showing that inaction is prolonged, unexplained and indefinite, and courts will define 'reasonable time' gradually.

For the Supreme Court. The episode shows the advisory jurisdiction being used to revisit a recent judgment's reasoning, which may encourage future governments to seek references rather than review when they disagree with a Bench.

For federal politics. The office of Governor remains a point of friction, and the opinion removes the judicial timetable that would have depoliticised the question. Whether conventions of prompt decision now develop, or disputes multiply, depends more on political practice than on law.

13India’s positionAttributedAnalysis

India's official position, in the sense of the Union government's stated view, was argued before the Court in the reference: the Constitution deliberately sets no time limit on Governors or the President, courts cannot supply one, and there is no deemed assent. The November 2025 opinion largely accepted that position while adding the limited mandamus against prolonged inaction and confirming that a Governor who withholds assent must return the Bill.

Opposition-ruled States hold the opposite view: that assent should follow ministerial advice within an enforceable time, and that the reference should not have been used to revisit a judgment the Union did not seek to review.

Where the national interest lies is a matter of analysis. India's federal compact depends on States believing that elected governments can govern within their constitutional sphere. Prolonged pendency of Bills damages that belief, invites confrontation in the Supreme Court and turns the Governor into a partisan actor, which serves no party in the long run, since control of the Union and of the States changes hands. The durable solution lies in conventions and, if they fail, a constitutional amendment: prompt communication of objections, reasoned returns, sparing use of reservation and timely presidential decisions, perhaps on the timelines successive commissions proposed.

14Possible solutionsAttributedAnalysis

Each option is attributed to whoever proposed it; the assessment of its merits and weaknesses is analysis.

Possible solutions: each option, who proposed it, and an assessment of its merits and weaknesses
01Amend Articles 200 and 201 to set time limitsNational Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002), endorsed by the Punchhi Commission (2010)

Write time limits into the Constitution, for example four months for the Governor and three for the President. It answers the November opinion's objection that only the Constitution can impose deadlines, but needs a special majority, and a deadline without a consequence for missing it would still require a remedy.

02Remove withholding and narrow reservationNational Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002)

Delete the Governor's power to withhold assent, as the Commission recommended, and, in its alternative proposal, confine reservation to the second proviso and the cases the Constitution expressly requires. It would strengthen the federal principle decisively, but the Union would lose a check it regards as necessary against unconstitutional State laws.

03Codify conventions of prompt decisionSarkaria Commission (timelines as 'salutary conventions'); the Home Ministry's 2016 memorandum as a model for executive guidelines

Adopt published guidelines for Governors, with reasons for reservation and target times, alongside the Union's existing three-month guideline for reserved Bills. It needs no amendment and builds on practice, but conventions bind only those willing to be bound.

04Develop the limited mandamus case by caseSupreme Court, advisory opinion of 20 November 2025

Leave the Constitution unchanged and let courts give content to 'prolonged, unexplained and indefinite' inaction through individual cases. It respects the text and the separation of powers, but gives States uncertain and slow relief.

05Reform appointment and tenureSarkaria Commission and later commentators on Centre–State relations

Choose Governors from outside active politics, consult the Chief Minister on appointments and protect tenure, reducing the incentive to act for the Union against the State. It addresses the cause rather than the symptom, but depends on the Union restraining its own appointing power.

15Critical evaluationAnalysis

The two decisions of 2025 are best read as competing answers to a real gap. The April judgment was right that a power to decide carries a duty to decide, and that a Governor who sits on Bills for years defeats a legislature by inaction. Its weakness was method: it read discretion out of Article 200, a reading the November Bench held to rest on a partial reading of Shamsher Singh, imposed timelines the text does not contain, and used Article 142 to substitute the Court for the Governor.

The November opinion is more faithful to the text and to the separation of powers. It closes the most abusive practice, withholding without return, recognises a remedy for indefinite inaction, and treats Article 200 as dialogue rather than command. Its weakness is effect: by confirming the Governor's discretion and allowing reservation of re-passed Bills, it leaves the Union, through its appointees, with substantial leverage over State legislation, and it replaces a clear rule with an uncertain standard that favours delay.

The deeper problem is not judicial. The Constitution entrusted assent to an official expected to behave as a constitutional head, and that expectation rested on conventions that weakened as divided government became normal after 1967. Courts can police the extremes, but they cannot restore a convention. Either the political actors rebuild it, with reasons, restraint and timeliness, or Parliament writes it into the text, as successive commissions recommended. Until one of those happens, assent will remain a federal battleground.

The strongest objection to the States' position is that the text does confer choices and that some State Bills raise genuine questions of competence. The strongest objection to the Union's position is that discretion without time or reasons is indistinguishable from a veto the Constituent Assembly meant to remove.

16Examination applicationsExamination

UPSC CSE

7 syllabus lines

General Studies and Prelims

GS Paper II. The dossier serves the syllabus lines on the functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States and issues of the federal structure, the separation of powers between organs and dispute-redressal mechanisms, the structure and functioning of the executive and judiciary, and appointments to constitutional posts. UPSC set a GS Paper II question on the Governor's assent power in 2026; see previous year questions.

Essay. Essays on federalism, constitutional morality or the separation of powers can use the case to show how conventions fail under divided government.

Prelims. Know the three options under Article 200 and both provisos; the six-month reconsideration period in Article 201; Article 163(2); Article 361; that the November 2025 opinion was given under Article 143; and which Bench decided what.

Answer craft. Strong answers distinguish the April 2025 judgment from the November 2025 opinion precisely, cite Shamsher Singh, B.P. Singhal and Nabam Rebia for the general rule, use the commissions' recommendations for reform, and avoid stating that the November opinion overruled the relief granted to Tamil Nadu.

UPSC CSE · Optional

4 syllabus lines

Political Science and International Relations

Paper I, Part B. The case sits in federalism, on the changing nature of Centre–State relations, and in the principal organs, whose syllabus asks about the envisaged role and actual working of the State executive. It also bears on the salient features, since the parliamentary system rests on the head of state acting on advice.

Paper I, Part A. In the concept of power, the dispute shows two forms of legitimacy colliding: the democratic, legal-rational legitimacy of an elected legislature and the legal-rational legitimacy of an appointed office, a contrast Max Weber's typology helps to name.

Thinkers to deploy. B.R. Ambedkar's two statements of 1949 frame the interpretive dispute. K.C. Wheare's description of India as quasi-federal locates the Governor as a centralising institution. Granville Austin's account of the Constitution as a 'seamless web' of unity, democracy and social revolution helps explain why the framers kept a Union link in every State.

Comparative angle (Paper II, Part A). In the United Kingdom royal assent has not been refused since the reign of Queen Anne, and in Canada the Patriation Reference held that convention neutralises the legal power to refuse assent; India's Governors retain a power that comparable systems have reduced to form.

IB Diploma Programme

2 syllabus lines

Global Politics

What the guide prescribes. The IB Global Politics guide does not name India's Governors. The issue connects to prescribed content in the core concepts of legitimacy, through sources of government legitimacy and challenges to them within a state, and sovereignty, through the internal distribution of authority, and to power as relational and structural.

Teaching suggestions. The case is a compact illustration of how legitimacy can be contested inside a state between an elected body and an appointed one, and of how courts arbitrate such contests. It pairs well with comparative material on heads of state in parliamentary systems. Students could also use it to practise distinguishing legal from conventional rules, a skill that transfers to questions about international norms that bind by practice rather than enforcement.

17Original practice questionsOriginal

  1. Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words

    'A power to decide carries a duty to decide.' In the light of the Supreme Court's decisions of 2025, examine whether Article 200 adequately protects the legislative authority of the States.

    How to approach it

    Contrast the April 2025 timelines and deemed assent with the November 2025 standard of prolonged, unexplained and indefinite inaction; assess the remedy; propose reform through amendment or convention.

  2. Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    Distinguish between withholding assent, returning a Bill and reserving a Bill under Article 200. What did the Supreme Court's advisory opinion of November 2025 hold about each?

    How to approach it

    Define each option and the provisos precisely; state that withholding requires return, that a re-passed Bill may be reserved, and that the choice is discretionary; note non-justiciability before a law comes into force.

  3. Q3PSIR style15 marks

    Is the office of Governor in India a constitutional head or an agent of the Union? Evaluate with reference to recent judicial decisions and the recommendations of reform commissions.

    How to approach it

    Use B.P. Singhal's dual role, principal–agent reasoning, the 2025 decisions and the Sarkaria and Punchhi recommendations; argue a position on reform.

  4. Q4PSIR style15 marks

    Conventions, not courts, sustain parliamentary government. Discuss with reference to the controversy over assent to State Bills in India.

    How to approach it

    Use Dicey's distinction and the Patriation Reference; show how divided government weakened the convention of acting on advice; evaluate the limits of judicial remedies.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

18Sources

The dossier’s facts were last checked on . Primary and official documents are listed apart from the material that interprets them.

Primary and official sources

11

Constitutional and statutory texts, Bills, judgments and official reports.

  1. 01JudgmentIn re: Assent, Withholding or Reservation of Bills by the Governor and the President of India, Special Reference No. 1 of 2025, opinion dated 20 November 2025 (2025 INSC 1333) (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India, 20 November 2025 · consulted 20 November 2026
  2. 02JudgmentState of Tamil Nadu v Governor of Tamil Nadu, W.P.(C) No. 1239 of 2023, judgment dated 8 April 2025 (2025 INSC 481) (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India, 8 April 2025 · consulted 20 November 2026
  3. 03PrimaryThe Constitution of India (as on 1 May 2026): Articles 142, 143, 155, 156, 163, 200, 201 and 361 (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, 1 May 2026 · consulted 20 November 2026
  4. 04JudgmentState of Punjab v Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab, (2024) 1 SCC 384. Supreme Court of India, November 2023
  5. 05JudgmentShamsher Singh v State of Punjab, (1974) 2 SCC 831. Supreme Court of India, 1974
  6. 06JudgmentB.P. Singhal v Union of India, (2010) 6 SCC 331. Supreme Court of India, 7 May 2010
  7. 07PrimaryConstituent Assembly Debates, Volume IX, 30 July 1949 (draft Article 175). Lok Sabha Secretariat, 30 July 1949
  8. 08JudgmentReference re: Resolution to Amend the Constitution (Patriation Reference), [1981] 1 SCR 753. Supreme Court of Canada, 1981
  9. 09OfficialReport of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission). Government of India, 1988
  10. 10OfficialReport of the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution. Government of India, 2002
  11. 11OfficialReport of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Punchhi Commission). Government of India, 2010

Supporting sources

2

Scholarship, books, press reports and other secondary material.

  1. 01ScholarshipLouis Kaplow, 'Rules versus Standards: An Economic Analysis', Duke Law Journal 42(3). Duke University School of Law, 1992
  2. 02ScholarshipPeter W. Hogg and Allison A. Bushell, 'The Charter Dialogue Between Courts and Legislatures', Osgoode Hall Law Journal 35(1). Osgoode Hall Law School, 1997

19Connected knowledge

Facts checked to