Current developmentIndian Polity · Governance · PSIR
A commission for the tribunals: Parliament answers the Supreme Court
In August 2026 Parliament repealed the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021, whose central provisions the Supreme Court had struck down in November 2025, and created a National Tribunals Commission to select and oversee the members of the tribunals it lists. The new law accepts the Court's standards on tenure and selection, but leaves appointment and removal with the executive that appears before these bodies as a litigant.
Verification
- Facts last verified
- Sources
- 12 · 6 primary or official
- Kind
- Current development
- Event · Published
- 11 August 2026 · 20 November 2026
01Executive summary Facts
The Tribunals Reforms Bill, 2026 was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 10 August 2026, passed there the same day and passed by the Rajya Sabha on 11 August. It repeals the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 and establishes a National Tribunals Commission, chaired by a former Supreme Court judge or High Court Chief Justice, to run selections, review the performance of tribunals and oversee inquiries into complaints against their members. Its Statement of Objects and Reasons presents it as compliance with Madras Bar Association v Union of India, in which the Supreme Court on 19 November 2025 struck down the 2021 Act's minimum age of fifty, four-year terms and two-name panels, and gave the Union four months to set up such a commission. Rules under the new Act were notified on 30 September 2026. The law ends a long contest over tenure and selection procedure on the Court's terms, while the central government keeps the power to appoint the Commission's members, to appoint tribunal members on its recommendation and to remove them after inquiry.
02Background Facts
Tribunals entered the Constitution with the 42nd Amendment of 1976, which inserted Article 323A for administrative tribunals and Article 323B for tribunals on other matters. They were meant to bring specialist knowledge and speed to classes of disputes, from service matters to taxation, and to relieve the High Courts. The price of that design was a question that has never gone away: when a tribunal decides disputes between citizens and the State, who appoints its members, for how long, and who can remove them?
The Supreme Court has answered that question in stages. In L. Chandra Kumar (1997) a seven-judge Bench held that tribunals supplement rather than replace the High Courts, whose power of judicial review cannot be excluded. In Union of India v R. Gandhi (2010), on the company law tribunals, it insisted that a tribunal exercising judicial power must have the independence and judicial character of the court it displaces. In the following decade the Madras Bar Association brought a series of challenges to the terms on which tribunal members served.
The immediate dispute began with the Finance Act, 2017, which merged several tribunals and allowed the Union to fix appointments and service conditions by rules. The Court struck those rules down in Rojer Mathew (2019) and, in 2020, directed five-year terms, eligibility for advocates of ten years' standing and the creation of a National Tribunals Commission. The government responded with an ordinance on 4 April 2021 that imposed a minimum age of fifty, four-year terms, panels of two names for each post and allowances equal to those of civil servants; the Court struck those provisions down in July 2021, and Parliament re-enacted them weeks later in the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021.
On 19 November 2025, in Madras Bar Association v Union of India (2025 INSC 1330), Chief Justice B.R. Gavai, with Justice K. Vinod Chandran concurring, struck down those provisions of the 2021 Act as an impermissible legislative override of binding directions that undermined judicial independence and the separation of powers. The Court rejected the Attorney General's request to refer the matter to a larger Bench, recorded its disapproval of the Union's repeated refusal to accept settled directions, and quoted B.R. Ambedkar's warning of 4 November 1948 that the Constitution could be perverted by changing the form of administration without changing its form. It held that its earlier directions would govern appointments until Parliament enacted a law that faithfully gave effect to them, and gave the Union four months to establish a National Tribunals Commission. That period ended in March 2026; the Bill came in August.
03Political actors Facts
- Union government and the Ministry of Law and Justice
- Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal signed the Bill's Statement of Objects and Reasons on 6 August 2026, which presents it as legislation 'in consonance with the directions of the Supreme Court'; the Department of Legal Affairs notified the rules on 30 September 2026.
- Supreme Court Bench of Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justice K. Vinod Chandran
- Struck down the core of the 2021 Act on 19 November 2025 and directed a National Tribunals Commission; Justice Vinod Chandran called the Act 'old wine in a new bottle'.
- Madras Bar Association
- The petitioner in the line of cases, from 2010 to 2025, whose challenges have defined the constitutional standards for tribunals' composition, tenure and selection.
- Parliament
- Passed the Bill in two days without referring it to a committee, in a session in which, according to PRS, the Lok Sabha functioned for 15 per cent of its scheduled time and the Rajya Sabha for 33 per cent; the Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice had reported on the tribunal system on 7 August.
- National Tribunals Commission
- The new statutory body that selects tribunal members, reviews tribunals' performance, oversees inquiries into complaints and maintains a national data grid; its establishment takes effect from a date the Union notifies.
- Litigants and tribunal members
- Taxpayers, companies, government servants, soldiers and environmental petitioners whose cases wait on vacancies, and members whose tenure and independence the law defines.
04Timeline Facts
1976
The 42nd Amendment inserts Articles 323A and 323B, enabling tribunals for administrative and other matters.
18 March 1997
In L. Chandra Kumar a seven-judge Bench holds that tribunal decisions remain subject to judicial review by the High Courts.
2017
The Finance Act, 2017 merges several tribunals and lets the Union fix appointments and service conditions by rules.
2020
The Supreme Court directs five-year terms, eligibility for advocates of ten years' standing and a National Tribunals Commission.
4 April 2021
The Tribunals Reforms (Rationalisation and Conditions of Service) Ordinance is promulgated.
July 2021
The Court strikes down the ordinance's provisions on minimum age, tenure, two-name panels and allowances.
August 2021
Parliament enacts the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021, re-enacting those provisions in a standalone statute.
19 November 2025
In Madras Bar Association v Union of India the Court strikes down the 2021 Act's provisions and gives the Union four months to establish a National Tribunals Commission.
7 August 2026
The Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice reports on the functioning of the tribunal system.
10 August 2026
The Tribunals Reforms Bill, 2026 is introduced in the Lok Sabha and passed the same day.
11 August 2026
The Rajya Sabha passes the Bill.
30 September 2026
Rules on the Commission and on the qualifications and service of tribunal members are notified (G.S.R. 856(E)).
05Main developments
What happened Facts
On 10 August 2026 the Tribunals Reforms Bill, 2026 (Bill No. 153 of 2026), sponsored by the Ministry of Law and Justice, was introduced in the Lok Sabha and passed the same day; the Rajya Sabha passed it on 11 August, two days before the Monsoon Session ended. The Bill repeals the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 and governs appointments to the bodies listed in its First Schedule, sixteen entries that include the Central Administrative Tribunal, the State Administrative Tribunals, the Securities Appellate Tribunal, the Armed Forces Tribunal, the National Green Tribunal, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal and the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal. Its provisions override the parent statutes of those tribunals where they conflict.
The centrepiece is a National Tribunals Commission, headquartered in New Delhi, with a chairperson who has been a Judge of the Supreme Court or Chief Justice of a High Court, two judicial members who have been High Court judges or Chief Justices, and two technical members with at least twenty-five years' experience in fields such as public administration, finance, law or technology. The central government appoints all five, consulting the Chief Justice of India before appointing the chairperson and the judicial members, for five-year terms or until the age of seventy. The Commission conducts the selection process for the tribunals, reviews their performance and reports annually to the government, oversees inquiries into complaints against their members, and maintains a National Tribunals Data Grid.
Selections are made by search-cum-selection committees that the Commission constitutes. For a tribunal's chairperson the committee is chaired by the Commission's chairperson, who has a casting vote, and includes a technical member of the Commission, a retired High Court Chief Justice nominated by the chairperson and a Secretary to the Government of India nominated by the Union, replaced by the State's Chief Secretary for a State Administrative Tribunal; two empanelled experts and the Commission's secretary sit without a vote. The committee recommends one name for each vacancy and one more for a waiting list, and the government must make the appointment within three months. Chairpersons of tribunals serve five years or until seventy, members five years or until sixty-seven, and may be reappointed after a review of their performance.
Removal remains with the central government. It may remove a chairperson or member on grounds that include insolvency, conviction for an offence involving moral turpitude, incapacity, a prejudicial interest, abuse of position, being 'found incompetent or inefficient' and taking up paid work. For the last four grounds the Ministry administering the tribunal conducts a preliminary inquiry and refers the matter to the Commission, whose chairperson holds the inquiry; no removal on those grounds is allowed without that reference and inquiry. A transitional clause provides that, notwithstanding 'anything contained in any judgment, order or decree of any Court', selection committees already constituted under the 2021 Act may complete their selections, and appointments made on their recommendations are deemed to have been made under the new Act.
On 30 September 2026 the Department of Legal Affairs notified rules under the Act (G.S.R. 856(E)). As summarised by PRS Legislative Research, they set qualifications for the members of fifteen tribunals, allow advocates with at least ten years of relevant practice to be appointed as judicial members, require serving judges and officers appointed to tribunals to resign or retire from their parent service, bar the Commission's members from arbitration or paid work in office and from practising before any tribunal afterwards, and require the process of filling a vacancy to begin six months before it arises.
What changed Facts
- A National Tribunals Commission in law. A five-member body with a judicial chairperson and majority now runs selections, reviews performance and oversees inquiries into complaints for the listed tribunals.
- The Court's tenure standards adopted. Terms are five years, with retirement at seventy for chairpersons and sixty-seven for members, replacing the four-year terms the Court struck down; no minimum age of fifty appears in the Act.
- One name, not two. Selection committees recommend one name and one reserve for each vacancy, and the government must appoint within three months.
- Removal by the executive, after inquiry. The central government removes members, but for misconduct, incompetence or inefficiency only after a ministry's preliminary inquiry and an inquiry by the Commission.
- Past selections saved. A transitional clause protects selections made under the 2021 Act 'notwithstanding' any judgment of a court.
- Rules in place. Rules notified on 30 September 2026 set qualifications for fifteen tribunals and require selection to begin six months before a vacancy arises.
Why it matters Analysis
The Act closes a cycle that ran from the Finance Act, 2017 to the judgment of November 2025, in which the executive and Parliament repeatedly re-enacted provisions the Court had struck down and the Court struck them down again. Unlike the 2021 ordinance and Act, the 2026 law adopts the Court's standards on the points that had been litigated: five-year terms, a single recommendation with a reserve, a time limit for appointment and a commission led by former judges. On those questions the separation of powers has been resolved on the Court's terms.
It does not resolve the deeper question of control. The government appoints the Commission's members, consulting the Chief Justice only for the chairperson and the judicial members; a Secretary to the Government of India sits with a vote on every selection committee; the Ministry that administers a tribunal, and often appears before it as a party, conducts the preliminary inquiry into complaints against its members; and 'incompetence or inefficiency' is a ground of removal. The Commission's secretariat is headed by an officer of the rank of Secretary appointed by the Union, and its regulations are made in consultation with the Union. The Court's own test for the Commission, in November 2025, was independence from executive control, professional expertise, transparent processes and oversight mechanisms. Whether a body designed this way meets the first of those conditions is the question the next challenge will raise.
The manner of enactment matters as well. A reform of the institutions that hear tax, company, environmental, service and consumer disputes was introduced and passed by the Lok Sabha on the same day and by the Rajya Sabha the next, without committee scrutiny, in a session in which the Lok Sabha sat for a fraction of its scheduled time. Parliament had a Standing Committee report on the tribunal system before it, presented three days before the Bill, but did not use it to examine the Bill itself.
06India’s interests Analysis
India's tribunals decide disputes with large economic and social stakes: tax appeals, insolvency and company matters, environmental cases, consumer claims, and the service grievances of government employees and soldiers. Their credibility affects investment, revenue, environmental protection and the morale of public servants. Vacancies and repeated litigation over their constitution have cost all of these, and the Court observed in 2025 that relitigating settled questions consumed judicial time in a system already burdened with pendency.
The national interest therefore lies in a settlement that is both independent and workable. An Act that ends the cycle of invalidation but leaves the executive's role contestable risks a further round of litigation; an Act whose Commission is visibly independent and fills vacancies on time would strengthen the rule of law and the business climate together.
07Institutional analysis
Institutional implications Analysis
The Commission is a statutory body, not a constitutional one. Its independence therefore rests on the Act, the rules and practice, and can be altered by ordinary legislation. The contrast with constitutional bodies is instructive: the members of the Union Public Service Commission, for example, can be removed only in the manner Article 317 prescribes, including an inquiry by the Supreme Court for misbehaviour. The Act protects the Commission's members in a similar way, requiring an inquiry by a committee headed by a Supreme Court judge nominated by the Chief Justice before removal for a prejudicial interest or abuse of position, but that protection is the legislature's to change.
The Act redistributes roles among institutions. The Commission selects and inquires; the central government appoints and removes; the administering Ministries initiate complaints; the Department of Legal Affairs makes the rules; and the High Courts and the Supreme Court retain judicial review of tribunals' decisions under the principle of L. Chandra Kumar. For the State Administrative Tribunals the State's Chief Secretary takes the place of the Union's nominee, so the design has a federal dimension: selection for State tribunals is run by a central commission with a State executive voice.
The Commission's practical test will be vacancies. The Standing Committee's report of August 2026 drew attention to vacancies in the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal and the National Green Tribunal and to the growing workload of the company law tribunals. A rule that the process of filling a vacancy begin six months before it arises, and a three-month limit for appointment, address that problem directly, if they are observed.
Constitutional provisions Facts
Article 323A allows Parliament to provide by law for administrative tribunals for disputes concerning recruitment and conditions of service in the public services, and Article 323B allows the appropriate legislature to establish tribunals for other matters, such as taxation, industrial disputes and land reforms; both were inserted by the 42nd Amendment, which also added entry 11A to the Concurrent List on the administration of justice and the constitution of courts other than the Supreme Court and the High Courts.
In L. Chandra Kumar the Court held that the power of judicial review vested in the High Courts under Article 226 and in the Supreme Court is part of the basic structure, so tribunals' decisions remain subject to it. Under Article 141 the law declared by the Supreme Court binds all courts, and the 2025 judgment treated its earlier directions on tribunals as law so declared, which Parliament may cure by changing the basis of a judgment but may not simply override. Article 50, a Directive Principle, asks the State to separate the judiciary from the executive in its public services, and arbitrary conditions of service can be tested against Article 14.
08Theoretical perspectives Analysis
The case for independent tribunals begins with Montesquieu's argument in The Spirit of the Laws (1748) that there is no liberty if the power of judging is not separated from the legislative and executive powers, and with Alexander Hamilton's defence in Federalist No. 78 of secure tenure as the condition of judicial independence for a branch that has 'neither force nor will, but merely judgment'. Tribunals test those principles because they sit between administration and adjudication: specialist bodies created by statute that nonetheless decide disputes to which the State is a party. Security of tenure, the issue the Court pressed for a decade, is Hamilton's answer applied to them.
The saga can also be read through the idea of dialogue between courts and legislatures, associated with Peter Hogg and Allison Bushell's account of Canadian practice (1997), in which judicial decisions leave room for legislative reply. From 2017 to 2025 the exchange in India looked less like dialogue than repetition, as the Court noted in 2025, with the same provisions re-enacted after each judgment. The 2026 Act breaks that pattern by accepting the Court's standards on tenure and selection, while keeping appointment and removal with the executive. Whether that is dialogue or the opening of a new round depends on how the Court reads it.
The Court's choice of B.R. Ambedkar's warning, that the Constitution can be perverted by changing the form of administration without changing its form, frames the dispute as one about constitutionalism rather than administrative convenience. A tribunal system staffed on short tenures and executive goodwill would leave the text of Article 323A intact while changing what it means. The legitimacy of adjudication by tribunals depends on their being seen to be independent of the party they most often judge, which is why questions of appointment and removal are questions of justice and not merely of governance.
How the different sides read it
The Union government
Parliament has legislated in line with the Court's directions: a judicially led commission, five-year terms, single recommendations and a deadline for appointments. Designing tribunals is a legislative function under Articles 323A and 323B and the legislative lists, and the executive's role in appointment and removal mirrors its role elsewhere in the Constitution. A uniform framework is also the quickest way to fill vacancies that delay thousands of cases.
The Bar and advocates of judicial independence
Tribunals decide disputes in which the government is the most frequent litigant. A law under which the government appoints the selectors and the selected, sits on every selection committee, initiates complaints and removes members for 'inefficiency' leaves the executive in control of its own judges. The transitional clause, overriding judgments once more, and the passage of the Bill in two days without scrutiny repeat the pattern the Court criticised in 2025.
Litigants and the administrative-efficiency view
For taxpayers, companies, soldiers and government servants the decisive question is whether benches sit. A standing commission that starts the selection process six months before a vacancy and a three-month appointment deadline could matter more to access to justice than the composition of selection committees, provided both are honoured.
Comparative perspective
The United Kingdom unified most of its tribunals under the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007, following Sir Andrew Leggatt's review of 2001, placed them under a Senior President of Tribunals drawn from the judiciary, and left the selection of tribunal judges to the independent Judicial Appointments Commission. India's Commission moves towards that model in selection, but stops short of it in appointment and removal.
09Critical evaluation Analysis
The Act settles the questions that were litigated most: tenure, the number of names recommended, the time allowed for appointment and the existence of a commission led by former judges. It also ends, for now, the pattern of re-enacting provisions the Court had struck down, and the rules give the Commission a timetable for filling vacancies.
It does not settle who controls the tribunals. Appointment of the Commission, appointment and removal of tribunal members, the preliminary inquiry into complaints and the Commission's secretariat all remain with the executive, and the transitional clause again operates 'notwithstanding' any judgment. Nor do the sources consulted for this briefing show when the Commission itself will be constituted; the Act leaves that to a notification.
The strongest objection is that a government which is the principal litigant before tribunals still chooses and removes their members, so that the Act cures the defects the Court named without curing the defect the Court described. The strongest reply is that the Court itself placed the duty of establishing the Commission on the executive, that the Commission is led and dominated by former judges, and that removal for misconduct or inefficiency requires the Commission's inquiry. The Court's own test, whether Parliament has 'faithfully' given effect to its principles, will decide between them if the Act is challenged.
10What could happen next Analysis
Analysis, not fact · scenarios and signposts, not predictions
The Act's meaning will be fixed by three things it leaves open: when the Commission is constituted, how it is used, and whether the Court accepts its design.
- If the Union notifies the Commission promptly and appoints its chairperson and judicial members after consulting the Chief Justice, then the selection timetable in the rules can begin to work and vacancies should fall; if notification is delayed, tribunals will continue to fill posts through the transitional route the Act preserves.
- If the Act is challenged, as the history of this dispute makes plausible, then the Court will have to decide whether a commission appointed by the executive, a government nominee on every selection committee and executive removal for 'inefficiency' faithfully give effect to its principles; a ruling against those features would reopen the cycle the Act was meant to close.
- If the Ministries' power to initiate complaints is used against members who rule against them, then the removal procedure will become the test of independence that tenure once was.
- If the Commission publishes its annual performance reviews and vacancy data, then Parliament and the public will for the first time have a common record on which to judge tribunals.
Indicators to watch: the notification establishing the Commission and its first appointments; vacancy and pendency figures in the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, the National Green Tribunal and the company law tribunals; any petition challenging the 2026 Act; the first inquiries into complaints against members; and the Commission's first annual report.
11Concepts and thinkers
- ConceptConstitutionalismLimited government under a higher law: the idea that power is legitimate only when it is constituted, divided and…
- ConceptGovernanceHow collective decisions are actually made and carried out, by governments, markets, networks and citizens together…
- ConceptJusticeThe principles that settle what people are owed: in the distribution of goods and burdens, in the answer to wrongs and…
- ConceptLegitimacyThe quality that turns power into authority: the belief, or the justified claim, that those who rule have the right to…
- ThinkerB. R. AmbedkarThe jurist, economist and leader of the Dalit movement who analysed caste as graded inequality sanctioned by religion…
12UPSC GS-II connection Syllabus
13PSIR Paper I connection Syllabus
14IB Global Politics connection Syllabus
15Potential examination questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
The Tribunals Reforms Act, 2026 settles the dispute over tenure but not the dispute over control. Critically examine.
How to approach it
Trace the cycle from the Finance Act, 2017 to the 2025 judgment; show what the 2026 Act concedes (five-year terms, single recommendations, a judicially led commission, a time limit); identify where executive control remains (appointment, a government nominee on selection committees, ministry-initiated complaints, removal for inefficiency); conclude on whether this meets the Court's test of independence from executive control.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
What is the National Tribunals Commission? How does its design respond to the Supreme Court's judgments on the independence of tribunals?
How to approach it
Describe composition, appointment and functions; link each to the Court's directions on tenure, selection and an independent commission; note one feature that remains contested.
- Q3PSIR style15 marks
Examine the relationship between Parliament and the Supreme Court in India with reference to the reform of tribunals since 2017.
How to approach it
Use the sequence of rules, ordinance, Act and judgments; assess whether it shows dialogue or confrontation; draw on L. Chandra Kumar and Article 141; reach a judgement on what the 2026 Act shows about the separation of powers.
- Q4Prelims style
Under the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2026, (a) who may be appointed chairperson of the National Tribunals Commission, and (b) what is the term of a member of a tribunal listed in the Act?
How to approach it
(a) A person who has been a Judge of the Supreme Court or Chief Justice of a High Court, appointed by the central government after consulting the Chief Justice of India. (b) Five years or until the age of sixty-seven, whichever is earlier; for a chairperson, five years or until seventy.
- Q5Discussion
Can a body that decides disputes between citizens and the state be independent if the state appoints its members?
How to approach it
Distinguish appointment from tenure and removal as sources of independence; use India's tribunals and one other system, such as the United Kingdom's tribunals after 2007; consider how transparency and judicial participation in selection affect legitimacy.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
16Sources
Primary and official documents first. Every factual claim was checked against these on 20 November 2026.
Primary and official sources
- 01PrimaryThe Tribunals Reforms Bill, 2026 (Bill No. 153 of 2026), as introduced in Lok Sabha, with Statement of Objects and Reasons (opens in a new tab). Lok Sabha (via PRS Legislative Research), 10 August 2026 · consulted 20 November 2026
- 02JudgmentMadras Bar Association v Union of India, W.P.(C) No. 1018 of 2021, judgment dated 19 November 2025 (2025 INSC 1330) (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India, 19 November 2025 · consulted 20 November 2026
- 03PrimaryNational Tribunals Commission and Qualification, Selection, and Conditions of Service of Chairperson and Members of Tribunals Rules, 2026 (G.S.R. 856(E)) (opens in a new tab). Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice (Gazette of India), 30 September 2026
- 04PrimaryThe Constitution of India (as on 1 May 2024) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice, May 2024
- 05OfficialStanding Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice, Report No. 166: Review of Functioning of Tribunal System in the Country (opens in a new tab). Rajya Sabha Secretariat, 7 August 2026
- 06OfficialLaw Commission of India, 272nd Report: Assessment of Statutory Frameworks of Tribunals in India (2017). Law Commission of India, 2017
Supporting sources
- 01ScholarshipPeter W. Hogg and Allison A. Bushell, 'The Charter Dialogue Between Courts and Legislatures', Osgoode Hall Law Journal 35(1), 1997
- 02BookAlexander Hamilton, The Federalist No. 78, 1788
- 03OtherThe Tribunals Reforms Bill, 2026: bill track (introduction and passage) (opens in a new tab). PRS Legislative Research, August 2026 · consulted 20 November 2026
- 04OtherMonthly Policy Review, August 2026 (Monsoon Session; Tribunals Reforms Bill; Standing Committee report on tribunals) (opens in a new tab). PRS Legislative Research, August 2026 · consulted 20 November 2026
- 05OtherMonthly Policy Review, October 2026 (rules on the National Tribunals Commission and tribunal members) (opens in a new tab). PRS Legislative Research, October 2026 · consulted 20 November 2026
- 06OtherMonthly Policy Review, November 2025 (Supreme Court strikes down provisions of the Tribunal Reforms Act, 2021) (opens in a new tab). PRS Legislative Research, November 2025 · consulted 20 November 2026
More from the Global Political Briefing
- International RelationsThe Quad in Manila: the leaders' summit returns, with a narrower agenda
- International RelationsManaged thaw: Xi Jinping in New Delhi and the limits of India–China normalisation
- Strategic AffairsWater, terror and the law: the Indus Waters Treaty after the Hague award of August 2026