Skip to content

Five-minute module · Thinker

Rawls's original position

How John Rawls turned the question of what makes a society just into a choice made behind a veil of ignorance, and why the device has been attacked from several directions.

5 minutes5 steps3 questions to check yourself
Begin with step 1
  1. Step 1 of 5

    The question Rawls asked

    John Rawls's A Theory of Justice (1971) asks what principles should govern the basic structure of society: the major institutions that distribute rights and duties, income and opportunity. The dominant answer, utilitarianism, judged institutions by the total or average welfare they produce. Rawls objected that utilitarianism "does not take seriously the distinction between persons": it lets the losses of some be outweighed by the gains of others. He wanted principles that each person could accept as fair, whatever their place in society. The original position is his device for finding them: a social contract that is hypothetical, and whose terms are principles of justice rather than a government.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    Behind the veil of ignorance

    Imagine representatives choosing principles for a society in which they will live, but deprived of the knowledge that would bias them. Behind the veil of ignorance they do not know their class or social status, their natural talents, their conception of the good or the particular circumstances of their society. They do know general facts about economics, psychology and politics, and they know they will want more rather than less of the primary goods: rights and liberties, opportunities, income and wealth, and the social bases of self-respect. Since no one can tailor principles to their own advantage, whatever they agree is fair because the conditions of agreement are fair. Hence Rawls's name for the theory: justice as fairness.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    Choosing under uncertainty

    Rawls argued that rational parties in this position would use a cautious rule of choice, maximin: choose the arrangement whose worst outcome is best, since the stakes are a whole life and there is no basis for estimating probabilities. They would reject utilitarianism, which might sacrifice them if they turned out to belong to a disadvantaged minority. They would choose two principles. First, each person is to have an equal right to the basic liberties, such as freedom of conscience, expression and political participation. Second, social and economic inequalities must be attached to positions open to all under fair equality of opportunity, and must be to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged: the difference principle. The first principle takes priority over the second.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    Lines of attack

    Critics have pressed at every assumption. The economist John Harsanyi argued that rational choosers behind a veil would maximise average utility rather than follow maximin. Robert Nozick objected that justice concerns how holdings came about, not what pattern they form, so the difference principle licenses continual interference with legitimately acquired property. Michael Sandel argued that the parties are unencumbered selves, stripped of the attachments that constitute real persons, so the device presupposes the liberal individualism it claims to justify. Susan Moller Okin argued that Rawls assumed rather than examined the justice of the family, and Amartya Sen asked why primary goods, rather than what people are actually able to do and be, should be the measure.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    What survives the criticism

    Rawls answered partly by narrowing his claim. In Political Liberalism (1993) he presented justice as fairness not as a comprehensive moral truth but as a political conception for a society divided by reasonable religious and philosophical doctrines, one that citizens could endorse from within their different views through an overlapping consensus. The original position became explicitly a device of representation: a way of modelling, in a single thought experiment, constraints we already accept as fair, such as that no one should frame rules to suit their own case. Many who reject the two principles still use that test of impartiality, which is why the device continues to be taught.

The idea to keep

The original position models fairness as ignorance of one's own advantage. Parties who did not know their place in society would, Rawls argued, secure equal basic liberties first and then permit only those inequalities that benefit the least advantaged, under fair equality of opportunity.

Check yourself

Answer each question in your own words first, then open it to compare.

  1. Q1Why do the parties in the original position not know their talents or social position?

    Answer

    So that they cannot tailor principles to their own advantage. What they agree to is fair because the conditions of the agreement are fair.

  2. Q2What is the difference principle?

    Answer

    The part of Rawls's second principle that permits social and economic inequalities only when they work to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged.

  3. Q3State Sandel's objection in one sentence.

    Answer

    The original position assumes an unencumbered self who chooses principles before having any attachments, but real persons are partly constituted by their communities, so the device builds in the liberal individualism it is meant to justify.

These questions are original to this platform; they are not previous year questions.

Read next

Sources

  1. 01John Rawls, A Theory of Justice (1971; revised edition 1999). Harvard University Press
  2. 02John Rawls, Political Liberalism (1993). Columbia University Press
  3. 03Michael J. Sandel, Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (1982). Cambridge University Press
  4. 04John C. Harsanyi, "Can the Maximin Principle Serve as a Basis for Morality? A Critique of John Rawls's Theory", American Political Science Review 69 (1975)
  5. 05Susan Moller Okin, Justice, Gender, and the Family (1989). Basic Books

All five-minute modulesMy Study Desk