Skip to content

Contemporary political theory

Amartya Sen

The economist and philosopher who redefined development as the expansion of human capabilities, explained famines through the collapse of entitlements, and argued that justice is a matter of comparing real lives through public reasoning rather than designing perfect institutions.

Thinker dossier

born 1933

Key works
Collective Choice and Social Welfare · 1970On Economic Inequality · 1973'Rational Fools: A Critique of the Behavioural Foundations of Economic Theory' · 1977
Key concepts
Capability · Functionings · Entitlement approach · Development as freedom · Niti and nyaya
In UPSC papers
1 question, 2026

Start here:An introduction

1 min read

Amartya Sen, an economist and philosopher born in Santiniketan in 1933, built his career on asking what it means for a life to go well and how a society can tell whether it is becoming more just. Economists usually measured progress by income, and philosophers by utility or by fair shares of resources. Sen argued that both miss what matters: what people are actually able to do and to be, such as being nourished, literate and healthy, and able to take part in the life of their community.

From that starting point he explained why famines can happen when food is available, why democracies with a free press do not suffer them, why so many women were missing from the world's population, and why justice is better pursued by comparing real lives than by designing perfect institutions. He received the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1998. For a student of India, his work joins political theory directly to hunger, health, education and gender.

How to read this profile

The introduction is the first reading. The seventeen parts below are the full study of Amartya Sen, in five movements, about 15 minutes in all. Parts marked Advanced analysis (5, 11 and 12) weigh and contest the arguments: read them once the rest is secure.

Parts 1–4

Movement I: Foundations

The thinker in time: the setting, the influences, the works and the principal arguments.

01Historical context

Sen's work answers questions posed by poverty, famine and inequality in the twentieth century. Welfare economics measured well-being by income or utility; development policy measured progress by growth in national income; and political philosophy, after Rawls, debated the principles of a perfectly just society. Each, Sen argued, looked in the wrong place: at resources or mental states rather than at what people are actually able to do and be, or at ideal institutions rather than at the injustices people actually suffer.

His Indian experience was formative. As a nine-year-old in Santiniketan he saw the Bengal famine of 1943, in which millions died while food continued to be traded, and as a boy he witnessed communal violence before partition. Those experiences shaped his later work on famine, identity and democracy.

Life and intellectual formation

Born in 1933 in Santiniketan, where Rabindranath Tagore gave him his name, Sen studied at Presidency College, Calcutta, and Trinity College, Cambridge, where he took his doctorate. He taught at Jadavpur University, the Delhi School of Economics, the London School of Economics, Oxford and Harvard, and was Master of Trinity College, Cambridge, from 1998 to 2004.

His early work in social choice theory, Collective Choice and Social Welfare (1970), extended Kenneth Arrow's impossibility theorem. He then turned to inequality, poverty and famine, and to the philosophical foundations of welfare and justice. He received the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1998 for his contributions to welfare economics, and the Bharat Ratna in 1999. With Mahbub ul Haq he helped design the Human Development Index, first published by the UNDP in 1990. Much of his work on India was written with Jean Drèze.

02Intellectual influences

Sen's thought grew out of an argument with welfare economics. Kenneth Arrow's impossibility theorem set the problem of social choice that occupied his early work, and his critique of welfarism, the utilitarian tradition from Bentham to Pigou that judges states of affairs only by the utilities they produce, runs through everything he wrote later. At Trinity he was taught by Joan Robinson, his doctoral supervisor, and learnt from Maurice Dobb and Piero Sraffa, who kept classical political economy and Marx's questions about production and distribution alive in Cambridge.

His positive sources are older. From Aristotle he took the idea that wealth is only useful for the sake of something else and that a good life is a matter of human functioning. From Adam Smith he took two ideas: that what counts as a necessity depends on what a society requires for a person to appear in public without shame (Smith's linen shirt), and the impartial spectator who judges from outside one's own group. He draws on Condorcet, Mary Wollstonecraft and John Stuart Mill for reasoned public discussion and the subjection of women, and on Marx for the idea of human beings mastering the circumstances of their lives. John Rawls, a friend and colleague at Harvard, was his principal interlocutor: the capability approach began as a response to Rawls's primary goods.

Indian sources matter too. Sen grew up in Rabindranath Tagore's school at Santiniketan, whose open, reasoning cosmopolitanism he has often praised. He draws on Ashoka's edicts and Akbar's policy of toleration, on Buddhist councils and on the heterodox, sceptical strands of Indian philosophy for his claim that public reasoning is not a Western invention. The Bengal famine of 1943, which killed people of one class while sparing his own, set the question of his work on entitlements.

03Major works

  1. 1970Collective Choice and Social WelfareSocial choice theory; the same year's article on 'The Impossibility of a Paretian Liberal' showed a conflict between minimal liberty and the Pareto principle.
  2. 1973On Economic InequalityThe measurement of inequality and its welfare foundations; expanded in 1997 with James Foster.
  3. 1977'Rational Fools: A Critique of the Behavioural Foundations of Economic Theory'Philosophy and Public Affairs. People act from sympathy and commitment as well as self-interest.
  4. 1979 lecture; published 1980Equality of What?Tanner Lecture arguing that utility, total utility and primary goods are all inadequate measures of equality, and proposing basic capabilities.
  5. 1981Poverty and Famines: An Essay on Entitlement and DeprivationThe entitlement approach, with case studies including Bengal in 1943.
  6. 1985Commodities and CapabilitiesA formal statement of functionings and capabilities as the space for assessing well-being.
  7. 1989Hunger and Public Action (with Jean Drèze)Famine prevention and chronic hunger; 'growth-mediated' against 'support-led' security.
  8. 1999Development as FreedomDevelopment as the expansion of substantive freedoms.
  9. 1999'Democracy as a Universal Value'Journal of Democracy. Democracy's intrinsic, instrumental and constructive importance.
  10. 2005The Argumentative IndianIndia's traditions of heterodoxy and public reasoning.
  11. 2006Identity and Violence: The Illusion of DestinyAgainst 'solitarist' identities and the clash of civilisations.
  12. 2009The Idea of JusticeJustice as comparative assessment of realisations through public reasoning.
  13. 2013An Uncertain Glory: India and Its Contradictions (with Jean Drèze)India's growth and its neglect of health, education and social provision.
  14. 2021Home in the World: A MemoirHis early life in Dhaka, Santiniketan, Calcutta and Cambridge.

04Principal arguments

Equality of what?

Every serious theory of justice, Sen argued, demands equality of something, so the question is: equality of what? Utilitarianism counts satisfaction, which adapts to deprivation: people who have learned to expect little may report contentment. Rawls's primary goods count resources, but people differ in their ability to convert resources into a good life. A disabled person, a pregnant woman or someone living in a harsh climate needs more resources to achieve the same functionings. The right focus is capability: what people are actually able to do and be.

Functionings and capabilities

Functionings are beings and doings: being nourished, healthy and literate, taking part in the life of the community, appearing in public without shame. Capability is the set of functionings a person can actually choose among, their real freedom to lead the kind of life they have reason to value. The distinction between achieved functioning and capability matters: a person who fasts and a person who starves have the same nutrition but not the same freedom. Sen deliberately refused to specify a fixed list of capabilities, holding that their selection and weighting should be settled by public reasoning in each society.

Development as freedom

Development as Freedom defines development as the expansion of substantive freedoms. Freedom is both the end of development and its principal means. Five instrumental freedoms reinforce one another: political freedoms, economic facilities, social opportunities such as education and health care, transparency guarantees and protective security. Income growth is valuable as a means, but a society can grow while its people remain illiterate, ill and unfree. Sen notes with approval Aristotle's observation that wealth is merely useful for the sake of something else.

Famines and entitlements

Poverty and Famines argued that famines are caused not only by a decline in food availability but by the collapse of people's entitlements: their ability to command food through what they own, produce or can exchange. In Bengal in 1943 food output was not exceptionally low; wartime inflation and speculation destroyed the purchasing power of rural labourers while those in Calcutta were protected. Famines can therefore occur without any violation of property rights. Sen's later argument is that no substantial famine has occurred in a functioning democracy with a relatively free press, because elections and criticism give governments strong incentives to prevent one. India after independence and China's famine of 1958–61 are his contrast.

Missing women

In 1990 Sen estimated that more than 100 million women were 'missing' from the world's population because of discrimination in nutrition and health care and, later, sex-selective abortion. He analysed households as sites of cooperative conflict, in which women's bargaining power depends on outside earnings, literacy and property.

The idea of justice

The Idea of Justice distinguishes two traditions. Transcendental institutionalism, from Hobbes through Rousseau and Kant to Rawls, seeks to identify the perfectly just institutions. Realisation-focused comparison, in Adam Smith, Condorcet, Mary Wollstonecraft, Marx and Mill, asks how to reduce manifest injustice. Sen sides with the second: one does not need to know what a perfect painting would be to judge that one painting is better than another. He draws on the Sanskrit distinction between niti, organisational propriety and rules, and nyaya, realised justice, invoking matsyanyaya, justice in the world of fish, as what must be prevented. His three children quarrelling over a flute, one who can play it, one who is poorest and one who made it, show that plural impartial reasons can support rival claims. Against Rawls's closed impartiality among members of one society, he defends Adam Smith's open impartiality of the 'impartial spectator', which admits voices from outside. Justice is advanced through public reasoning, and democracy is government by discussion.

On human nature

Sen's person is a reasoning agent with plural motives and plural identities. 'Rational Fools' (1977) attacked the economist's assumption that people act only from self-interest: they also act from sympathy, and from commitment, which can lead them to choose against their own welfare. People are agents who pursue goals beyond their own well-being, not only patients whose welfare is to be maximised. Their preferences adapt to circumstances, so the deprived may learn to want little, which is why he distrusts utility as a measure. And their identities are many (nationality, religion, language, class, profession, gender, politics) and ordered by reason, not fixed by birth into a single community.

Parts 5–10

Movement II: Theory

What the thinker added to political theory, the concepts they defined, and their positions on the state, power, liberty, equality, justice and democracy.

05Major theoretical contributions

Advanced analysis

Sen changed the question at the heart of egalitarian theory. 'Equality of What?' (1979) argued that utility and Rawls's primary goods are the wrong objects of equality, because people differ in their ability to convert resources into valuable functionings. His answer, capability, became the basis of the capability approach and, through the UNDP's Human Development Reports from 1990, of a different way of measuring development.

He added an entitlement analysis of famine that moved attention from the supply of food to people's command over it, showing that famines can occur without any fall in output and without any violation of property rights. His observation that functioning democracies with a free press do not suffer substantial famines gave democracy an instrumental defence grounded in evidence.

In The Idea of Justice (2009) he distinguished transcendental institutionalism from realisation-focused comparison and argued that justice can be advanced by removing manifest injustices without agreement on what a perfectly just society would be. His open impartiality, modelled on Adam Smith's impartial spectator, widened the circle of those whose views count. Finally, his criticism of solitarist identities and his recovery of India's traditions of public reasoning gave democratic theory a genealogy that does not run only through the West.

06Conceptual definitions

Capability

A person's real freedom to achieve valuable functionings: what they are actually able to do and be.

Functionings

Valuable beings and doings, such as being nourished, literate and able to take part in community life.

Entitlement approach

Explaining hunger and famine by the collapse of people's command over food rather than by food supply alone.

Development as freedom

Development understood as the expansion of substantive freedoms, which are both its end and its means.

Niti and nyaya

Institutional rules and propriety contrasted with the justice actually realised in people's lives.

Transcendental institutionalism

The approach to justice that seeks perfectly just institutions, which Sen contrasts with comparative assessment.

Open impartiality

Impartial judgement that considers the views of those outside one's own society, following Adam Smith's impartial spectator.

Plural identities

The rejection of 'solitarist' classification of people by a single identity such as religion or civilisation.

07Theory of the State

The state has a central role in providing education, health care and social security, and in protecting against famine, while markets are valuable for exchange and growth. In Hunger and Public Action Drèze and Sen distinguish growth-mediated security, where rising incomes are used to fund public provision, from support-led security, where public provision comes first, as in Sri Lanka, Costa Rica and Kerala. Sen rejects both market fundamentalism and command planning, and insists that a state is judged by the lives it makes possible rather than by its institutions alone. An unaccountable state can itself cause famine, as China's did in 1958–61.

08Theory of Power

Sen has no general theory of power, but power is present throughout as command: over food, over resources, over voice. Famines result from the collapse of some groups' command over food through what they own and can exchange, not simply from shortage. Within households, his model of cooperative conflict shows that women's weaker bargaining position, shaped by outside earnings, literacy, property and perceptions of who contributes what, produces unequal outcomes even where cooperation benefits all. Democracy and a free press matter because they redistribute the power to be heard.

09Liberty and equality

Liberty

Freedom is substantive opportunity, not only non-interference. Sen distinguishes the opportunity aspect of freedom (what a person can actually achieve) from the process aspect (whether they are free from interference in choosing), and well-being freedom from agency freedom, the freedom to pursue goals beyond one's own welfare. His 1970 'Paretian liberal' paradox showed that even a minimal liberty can conflict with the Pareto principle, so liberty cannot be read off preferences.

Equality

The relevant equality is of capabilities. Equal incomes can coexist with deep inequality of real freedom because people differ in their ability to convert resources into functionings: through personal differences such as disability, age or illness, environmental differences, social climate, relative deprivation within a society, and the distribution of resources within the family. Equality of capability therefore justifies unequal resources, as for a person with a disability, and is sensitive to gender and caste in a way that income measures are not.

Rights

Human rights are ethical claims about the importance of certain freedoms. In 'Elements of a Theory of Human Rights' (2004) Sen argues that they need not wait for legislation: they generate perfect obligations on some and Kantian imperfect obligations on everyone in a position to help, and they can be advanced through public discussion, monitoring and agitation as well as through law. Economic and social rights, such as freedom from hunger, are therefore real rights even where they cannot yet be fully enforced.

10Justice and democracy

Justice

Justice is a matter of comparing realised lives and removing remediable injustice, guided by plural impartial reasons and public reasoning, not of designing a perfect basic structure. Sen accepts that reasoning may yield only a partial ranking of alternatives: we may be unable to decide between some states of affairs and still be certain that ending famine or slavery is required. Impartiality must be open, testing a society's judgements against the views of outsiders, so that local prejudice cannot pass for justice.

Democracy

Democracy is government by discussion and public reasoning, with roots in many cultures, including India's. 'Democracy as a Universal Value' (1999) gives it three kinds of importance: intrinsic, since political participation is part of a good life; instrumental, since it gives rulers incentives to respond to need, as the absence of famines in functioning democracies shows; and constructive, since discussion shapes what citizens come to value. He admits its limits: democracies respond to dramatic disasters more readily than to quiet, chronic deprivation such as undernutrition.

Parts 11–12

Movement III: Critique

How the arguments have been attacked, and how scholars read them differently.

11Criticisms

Advanced analysis

  1. 01

    John Rawls

    Rawls replied that primary goods are specified with citizens' capacities in view, and that the capability approach, by asking what lives are worth living, depends on a comprehensive doctrine of the good that a political liberalism cannot adopt.

  2. 02

    Martha Nussbaum

    Nussbaum, who developed the capability approach with Sen, argues that without a list of central capabilities, which she provides in Women and Human Development (2000), the approach cannot guide policy or constitutional guarantees.

  3. 03

    Thomas Pogge

    'Can the Capability Approach Be Justified?' (2002) argued that capabilities cannot be compared or weighed without a contested theory of the good, and that resource-based approaches handle disability and diversity better than Sen allows.

  4. 04

    Jagdish Bhagwati and Arvind Panagariya

    Why Growth Matters (2013) argued against Drèze and Sen that growth-promoting reform is the main engine of poverty reduction and of the revenue that social spending needs, a public debate that ran through 2013.

  5. 05

    Frances Stewart and Séverine Deneulin

    They argued that the capability approach is too individualist, neglecting group capabilities, social structures and power relations that shape what individuals can do.

12Scholarly debates

Advanced analysis

How scholars have read Amartya Sen differently. An answer that names the reading it follows is stronger than one that treats the text as settled.

  1. A framework, not a theory

    Sen deliberately refused to give a list of capabilities or a rule for weighting them. Ingrid Robeyns ('The Capability Approach: A Theoretical Survey', 2005, and Wellbeing, Freedom and Social Justice, 2017) reads this as a strength: the capability approach is an open framework for evaluating lives, which different theories of justice can complete in different ways. Martha Nussbaum reads the same incompleteness as a weakness to be repaired: in Women and Human Development (2000) and Creating Capabilities (2011) she turns the approach into a partial theory of justice, with ten central capabilities that a constitution should guarantee up to a threshold. Sen's own position is that the selection should be made by public reasoning in each society, not by a philosopher.

  2. The anti-ideal reading and its critics

    The Idea of Justice is often read as a rejection of ideal theory: we can rank alternatives and remove manifest injustices without knowing what a perfectly just society would be. A. John Simmons ('Ideal and Nonideal Theory', 2010) replied that judging how close two societies are to justice requires knowing where justice lies, as judging which of two hills is nearer the summit requires knowing the summit; Laura Valentini (2011) argued that Sen's comparative approach rests on implicit principles of its own. Sen's defenders answer that pairwise comparisons can be made with an incomplete ordering, and that agreement on removing particular injustices (famine, slavery, the subjection of women) has historically come before agreement on any ideal.

  3. Ethical or ontological individualism

    Frances Stewart and Séverine Deneulin (2002) read the capability approach as individualist, neglecting groups, structures and power. Sen replied that individuals are socially made and that the approach evaluates individual lives without assuming they are formed in isolation. Robeyns's distinction clarifies the dispute: the approach is ethically individualist, since each person's life is the unit of moral concern, but not ontologically individualist, since it does not claim society is nothing but individuals. Feminist readers have used exactly this to show how household and caste structures shape individual capabilities.

Parts 13–15

Movement IV: Legacy

Why the thinker matters now, whom they connect with, and the arguments applied in India and beyond.

13Contemporary relevance

Sen changed how the world measures progress. The Human Development Index, the multidimensional poverty measures adopted by the UNDP from 2010, the report of the Stiglitz–Sen–Fitoussi Commission on measuring economic performance and social progress (2009) and the Sustainable Development Goals all reflect his argument that income is not the measure of a good life. In political philosophy he is the leading alternative to Rawls, and his insistence that democracy and public reasoning are not Western inventions has shaped debates on global democracy.

14Connections with other thinkers

Each connection recorded in this profile, by relation: who shaped Amartya Sen, whom Amartya Sen shaped, and who argued with or against them.

Influenced by

  • Aristotle384 BCE

    Sen draws on Aristotle's idea that wealth is only a means and that the good life is a matter of human functioning.

  • Karl Marx1818

    Sen cites Marx on human beings mastering the circumstances of their lives and on alienation from what they could be.

  • John Stuart Mill1806

    Sen's democracy as government by discussion and his realisation-focused tradition include Mill.

In dialogue with

  • The Buddhist Tradition450 BCE

    Sen invokes Buddhist councils and Ashoka's edicts on toleration as Indian traditions of public reasoning.

  • Kautilya320 BCE

    In The Idea of Justice Sen contrasts Kautilya's reliance on institutions with Ashoka's on ethical behaviour.

In contrast with

  • Isaiah Berlin1909

    Sen's capability freedom is a positive conception that Berlin would have called the conditions of liberty.

Critic of

  • John Rawls1921

    Sen's critique of primary goods and transcendental institutionalism is the most influential response to Rawls from within liberal egalitarianism.

  • Robert Nozick1938

    Sen's famine analysis shows that respect for libertarian entitlements can coexist with mass starvation.

Also recorded on other profiles

Connections that other profiles in the Atlas make to Amartya Sen, read from Amartya Sen’s side. Their notes are on those profiles.

In contrast with
Michael Sandel

15Indian and international applications

In India

Sen and Drèze's work underlies the case for India's rights-based welfare laws of 2005–2013, from the rural employment guarantee to the right to education and the National Food Security Act, and for the Supreme Court's orders in the right to food litigation of the early 2000s. An Uncertain Glory (2013) argued that India's growth had not been matched by comparable progress in health and education, setting Kerala's record against the national one. His work on missing women frames debate on the child sex ratio, and his argument that democracy and a free press prevented famines after independence is a standard point in Indian political economy. The Sen–Bhagwati debate of 2013 remains the reference point for the argument between growth and redistribution in the PSIR unit on planning and development.

In the world

The UNDP's annual Human Development Report, first published in 1990, is the most visible institutional expression of the capability approach; the Sustainable Development Goals adopted in 2015 share its multidimensional idea of development.

Parts 16–17

Movement V: Examination

Where the thinker sits in the syllabus, and what UPSC has asked.

16Exact syllabus mapping

  1. PSIR Optional

    Paper I · Part A · Political Theory and Politics

    Justice

    Justice: Conceptions of justice with special reference to Rawl's theory of justice and its communitarian critiques.

    Official wording · 1 official question on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  2. PSIR Optional

    Paper I · Part A · Political Theory and Politics

    Equality

    Equality: Social, political and economic; relationship between equality and freedom; Affirmative action.

    Official wording · 4 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  3. PSIR Optional

    Paper I · Part A · Political Theory and Politics

    Rights

    Rights: Meaning and theories; different kinds of rights; Concept of Human Rights.

    Official wording · 2 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  4. PSIR Optional

    Paper I · Part A · Political Theory and Politics

    Democracy

    Democracy: Classical and contemporary theories; different models of democracy—representative, participatory and deliberative.

    Official wording · 3 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  5. PSIR Optional

    Paper I · Part B · Indian Government and Politics

    Planning and Economic Development

    Planning and Economic development: Nehruvian and Gandhian perspectives; role of planning and public sector; Green Revolution, land reforms and agrarian relations; liberalization and economic reforms.

    Official wording · 5 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  6. UPSC GS-II

    Social Justice

    Health, education and human resources

    Issues relating to development and management of Social Sector/Services relating to Health, Education, Human Resources.

    Official wording · 5 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  7. UPSC GS-II

    Social Justice

    Poverty and hunger

    Issues relating to poverty and hunger.

    Official wording · 3 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  8. IB Global Politics

    Thematic study: Rights and justice

    Rights and justice: contested meanings

    Rights; justice, including political and social justice; liberty; equality.

    Paraphrase of the prescribed topic (this platform)

    In the course outlineWhere it is taught
  9. IB Global Politics

    Thematic study: Development and sustainability

    Development and sustainability: contested meanings

    Development; sustainability; poverty; inequality.

    Paraphrase of the prescribed topic (this platform)

    In the course outlineWhere it is taught
  10. IB Global Politics

    Thematic study: Development and sustainability

    Development and sustainability: nature, practice and study

    Dimensions and assessment of development and sustainability; pathways towards them; economic, environmental, political, social and institutional factors; links between development and sustainability.

    Paraphrase of the prescribed topic (this platform)

    In the course outlineWhere it is taught

The syllabus lines this profile of Amartya Sen serves. Progress is kept on this device and gathered on your dashboard.

Beyond the optional: General Studies

GS Paper II: poverty and hunger, welfare schemes and the social sector. GS Paper III and Essay: inclusive growth and human development. GS Paper IV: justice, fairness and the 'impartial spectator'.

17Related PYQs (official wording)

Official wording · verbatim

1 question · 2026

  1. 2026PSIR IQ4(b)15 marks

    What is capability approach? Elaborate the distinctive features of the capability theory of equality.

    The official paper (opens in a new tab)

Transcribed from the official UPSC papers and linked to Amartya Sen in the PYQ dataset (nine official papers, 228 questions: GS Paper II, PSIR Paper I, PSIR Paper II, 2024–2026).PYQ Intelligence →

Using Sen in an answer

Sen serves several Paper I units: Equality, Justice, where he is the leading alternative to Rawls, and Democracy, through his idea of public reasoning. UPSC asked candidates to explain the capability approach and the distinctive features of the capability theory of equality in 2026 (PSIR Paper I). He also strengthens answers on planning in Part B, on poverty and welfare in GS Paper II, and on development in IB Global Politics.

Lead with the question Sen posed in Equality of What?, and show why he rejects both utility, which adapts to deprivation, and primary goods, which ignore differences in people's ability to convert resources into functionings. The contrast between fasting and starving makes the distinction between functioning and capability precise. For justice, contrast him with Rawls on transcendental institutionalism against comparative assessment, and with Nozick through the famine analysis, which shows that respect for libertarian entitlements can coexist with mass starvation. Turn summary into judgement by weighing Nussbaum's objection that without a list of central capabilities the approach cannot guide policy, and Pogge's that comparison needs a contested theory of the good, against Sen's reply that selection and weighting belong to public reasoning.

Avoid reducing Sen to the Human Development Index or casting him as an opponent of growth: he values income as a means, not as the measure of a good life. Do not attribute the list of central capabilities to him, since it is Nussbaum's, and do not confuse his entitlement approach to famine with Nozick's entitlement theory of justice.

Practice questions (original)

  1. Q1PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    Compare Sen's capability approach with Rawls's theory of primary goods.

    How to approach it

    Equality of what; conversion factors; functionings and capabilities; Rawls's reply; Nussbaum's list; which is the better metric of justice.

  2. Q2PSIR style20 marks· 250 words

    "Development is the expansion of freedom." Critically examine Sen's argument.

    How to approach it

    Constitutive and instrumental roles of freedom; five instrumental freedoms; critique of GNP; HDI and multidimensional poverty; Bhagwati and Panagariya, and the individualism objection; Indian evidence.

  3. Q3PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    Explain Sen's distinction between niti and nyaya and its significance for theories of justice.

    How to approach it

    Transcendental institutionalism versus realisation-focused comparison; matsyanyaya; the flute example; open impartiality; whether comparison can proceed without an ideal.

  4. Q4PSIR style10 marks· 150 words

    Why, according to Sen, do famines not occur in functioning democracies?

    How to approach it

    Entitlement failure; incentives of elections and a free press; India and China; qualifications (chronic hunger persists in democracies).

  5. Q5PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    Assess the significance of the debate between Sen and Bhagwati for India's development strategy.

    How to approach it

    Growth-first versus social investment; Kerala and Gujarat models as they were debated; complementarity; implications for welfare policy.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Sources and further reading

  1. 01Amartya Sen, Collective Choice and Social Welfare (1970)
  2. 02Amartya Sen, 'Equality of What?', Tanner Lectures on Human Values (1980)
  3. 03Amartya Sen, Poverty and Famines (1981)
  4. 04Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom (1999)
  5. 05Amartya Sen, The Idea of Justice (2009)
  6. 06Jean Drèze and Amartya Sen, Hunger and Public Action (1989) and An Uncertain Glory (2013)
  7. 07Martha C. Nussbaum, Women and Human Development: The Capabilities Approach (2000)
  8. 08Thomas Pogge, 'Can the Capability Approach Be Justified?', Philosophical Topics (2002)
  9. 09Jagdish Bhagwati and Arvind Panagariya, Why Growth Matters (2013)
  10. 10UNDP, Human Development Report (from 1990) (opens in a new tab). United Nations Development Programme
  11. 11Amartya Sen, 'Rational Fools', Philosophy and Public Affairs (1977)
  12. 12Amartya Sen, 'Elements of a Theory of Human Rights', Philosophy and Public Affairs (2004)
  13. 13Ingrid Robeyns, Wellbeing, Freedom and Social Justice: The Capability Approach Re-Examined (2017)
  14. 14A. John Simmons, 'Ideal and Nonideal Theory', Philosophy and Public Affairs (2010)