Skip to content

Paper I · Part A · Unit 5

Rights

What a right is, where rights come from, and how the claim that every human being holds them came to organise modern politics.

Official syllabus

Rights: Meaning and theories; different kinds of rights; Concept of Human Rights.

What the unit asks

The unit has three parts and each requires a different skill. Meaning is analytical: what it is to have a right, and how a right differs from a liberty, a power or an interest. Theories are justificatory: natural, legal, historical, idealist, utilitarian and Marxist answers to the question of where rights come from. Kinds and human rights are both classificatory and political: civil against social, individual against group, universal against culturally situated.

The examiner rewards candidates who connect the theory to a living constitutional practice. The Indian Supreme Court's expansion of Article 21 is one of the most instructive examples anywhere of how a thin, negative right can be read into a thick, positive one.

01Meaning: the anatomy of a right

A right is a justified claim that imposes duties on others. Wesley Hohfeld's analysis, developed in essays of 1913 and 1917, distinguished four elements: claims (correlative to duties), liberties or privileges (the absence of a duty), powers (the ability to change legal relations) and immunities (protection from another's power). Most rights in ordinary speech are bundles of these.

Two theories explain what rights protect. The will or choice theory (associated with H. L. A. Hart) holds that a right gives its holder control over another's duty. The interest theory (Joseph Raz) holds that a right exists when an aspect of a person's well-being is sufficient to ground a duty in others. The interest theory more easily explains the rights of children and of those who cannot choose. Ronald Dworkin's description of rights as trumps over collective goals captures their priority in liberal argument. See Rights.

02Theories of rights

Natural rights theory holds that rights belong to persons by nature or reason, prior to the state; Locke's rights to life, liberty and property animate the American Declaration of Independence (1776) and the French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789). Legal positivists reply that rights exist only when law creates them; Bentham dismissed natural rights as 'nonsense upon stilts'. Historical theory (Burke) treats rights as an inheritance, the rights of Englishmen rather than of man.

The idealist theory of T. H. Green held that rights are powers recognised by society as necessary for the common good; Harold Laski described them as the conditions without which no one can be their best self. Utilitarians such as Mill justified rights by their long-run contribution to welfare. Marxists criticise them: in On the Jewish Question (1843) Marx argued that the rights of man are the rights of egoistic man, separated from the community.

03Kinds of rights

Rights are classified along several axes. Moral and legal rights differ in their source. Negative rights require forbearance (freedom of speech); positive rights require provision (education, health). T. H. Marshall's Citizenship and Social Class (1950) narrated the English sequence of civil rights in the eighteenth century, political rights in the nineteenth and social rights in the twentieth; see Citizenship. Karel Vasak's scheme of three generations (civil and political, economic and social, and solidarity rights such as development and a healthy environment) is widely used in international law.

The sharpest current divide is between individual and group rights. Will Kymlicka's Multicultural Citizenship (1995) defended self-government, polyethnic and special representation rights within liberalism. India has long practised group-differentiated rights: minority educational rights (Articles 29 and 30), Fifth and Sixth Schedule protections, and reservations.

04Rights in the Indian Constitution

The Constitution divides rights into justiciable Fundamental Rights (Part III), enforceable through Article 32, which Ambedkar called the heart and soul of the Constitution, and non-justiciable Directive Principles (Part IV), fundamental in governance under Article 37; see Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles of State Policy. The 44th Amendment removed property from the list of Fundamental Rights and made it a constitutional right under Article 300A; the 42nd Amendment added Fundamental Duties (Article 51A).

The Supreme Court converted Article 21 from a guarantee against arbitrary detention into a charter of positive rights. Maneka Gandhi required procedure to be fair, just and reasonable; Olga Tellis linked life to livelihood; Unni Krishnan found a right to education, later codified as Article 21A by the 86th Amendment; Puttaswamy recognised privacy. The line between Parts III and IV has blurred.

05The concept of human rights

Human rights are rights held by every person simply as human: universal, inalienable and, in the language of the Vienna Declaration of 1993, indivisible, interdependent and interrelated. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the UN General Assembly on 10 December 1948, was followed by two covenants in 1966 (on civil and political rights and on economic, social and cultural rights) which entered into force in 1976. Hansa Mehta, an Indian delegate to the drafting commission, is credited with pressing for gender-inclusive language in Article 1.

Hannah Arendt exposed the paradox at the concept's core: in The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951) she observed that stateless people, who had only their humanity, found it protected nothing, and that the fundamental right is the 'right to have rights' — membership of a political community. India gives the concept domestic form through the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 and the NHRC.

06Critiques of human rights

Cultural relativists argue that human rights universalise a Western, individualist morality; the 'Asian values' argument and the Bangkok Declaration of 1993 claimed priority for community, order and development. Feminists showed that a public–private distinction left violence in the home outside human rights law until activists insisted that women's rights are human rights. Marxists see civil rights protecting property while socio-economic rights remain aspirational. Postcolonial critics such as Makau Mutua describe a narrative of savages, victims and saviours that casts the West as rescuer.

Defenders reply that relativism is often invoked by rulers rather than the ruled, that the Universal Declaration was drafted by a diverse commission, and that rights have been claimed from below by anti-colonial, Dalit and women's movements. Sen treats human rights as ethical claims whose universality depends on surviving open public reasoning across cultures. See Contemporary Global Concerns.

Debates

Are socio-economic rights genuine rights?

Maurice Cranston argued that only civil and political rights are real, because they require mere forbearance and can always be honoured; a right to holidays with pay, or to health care in a poor country, cannot. Henry Shue's Basic Rights (1980) replied that every right requires positive action (courts, police, elections cost money) and that subsistence is as basic as security. The Indian Court's reading of Article 21 sides with Shue while leaving the extent of provision to the legislature.

Universal or culturally specific?

Universalists argue that the core of human rights (freedom from torture, slavery, arbitrary killing) commands assent across traditions, and that relativism shields abusers. Relativists answer that the priority and interpretation of rights vary with history and culture. A defensible middle view, associated with Jack Donnelly, accepts universal rights at the level of concept while allowing variation in their interpretation and implementation.

Answer strategy

Separate the three tasks of the syllabus and do each properly: analysis (Hohfeld, choice and interest), justification (the classical theories), classification (Marshall, generations, group rights). Then show that the categories matter: the Indian Court's reading of Article 21 is the best evidence that the boundary between negative and positive rights is a political choice.

On human rights, avoid a list of UN instruments. Present the universalist claim, the strongest critique (relativist, feminist or postcolonial) and a reasoned reply, and use Arendt or Sen to lift the argument. Common errors: treating Laski or Green as natural-rights theorists; confusing the UDHR (a declaration) with the binding covenants; omitting group rights, which the Indian Constitution has always recognised.

Readings

  • Jack Donnelly, Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice
  • Michael Freeman, Human Rights: An Interdisciplinary Approach
  • Jeremy Waldron (ed.), Theories of Rights
  • Upendra Baxi, The Future of Human Rights
  • Andrew Heywood, Political Theory: An Introduction
  • O. P. Gauba, An Introduction to Political Theory

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

2 questions · 2024–2026

  1. 2026 · PSIR I · Q2(a) · 20 marks

    “Rights of the man are separate and independent of the State.” Critically analyze the perspective of Laski.

  2. 2024 · PSIR I · Q3(a) · 20 marks

    The debate on human rights is caught between the limitations of both universalism and cultural relativism. Comment.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Rights in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Practice questions

  1. Q1PSIR style10 marks· 150 words

    Distinguish between the will theory and the interest theory of rights.

    How to approach it

    Hart and Raz; the test cases of children and animals; why the interest theory fits positive rights better.

  2. Q2PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    'Rights are the product of society, not of nature.' Critically examine with reference to the major theories of rights.

    How to approach it

    Natural rights against legal, historical and idealist theories; Laski and Green; the persistence of natural-rights language in human rights law.

  3. Q3PSIR style20 marks· 250 words

    Examine the universalist and cultural relativist positions on human rights. Is a reconciliation possible?

    How to approach it

    UDHR and Vienna; Asian values and Bangkok; feminist and postcolonial critiques; Donnelly's relative universality or Sen's public reasoning.

  4. Q4PSIR style10 marks· 150 words

    Discuss Hannah Arendt's idea of the 'right to have rights' and its relevance to stateless people today.

    How to approach it

    Origins of Totalitarianism; membership as the precondition of rights; refugees and stateless communities as contemporary evidence.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Organisation

IB Global Politics

Sources

  1. 01UPSC, Civil Services Examination Notice: Scheme and Syllabus (Political Science and International Relations) (opens in a new tab). Union Public Service Commission
  2. 02Universal Declaration of Human Rights (United Nations) (opens in a new tab), 10 December 1948
  3. 03Constitution of India (Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice) (opens in a new tab)
  4. 04Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993
  5. 05Hannah Arendt, The Origins of Totalitarianism, 1951
  6. 06T. H. Marshall, Citizenship and Social Class, 1950