Five-minute module · Constitutional concept
Article 356 and cooperative federalism
How an emergency power that its framers hoped would stay unused became a weapon against State governments, and how S.R. Bommai changed the terms of the Union's relationship with the States.
Step 1 of 5
A power meant for breakdown
Article 356 allows the President, on a report from the Governor or otherwise, to assume the functions of a State government when satisfied that "the government of the State cannot be carried on in accordance with the provisions of this Constitution". The State's legislative powers then pass to Parliament, and the proclamation lapses after two months unless both Houses approve it. Article 355 places on the Union the duty to ensure that every State is governed in accordance with the Constitution. When the provision was debated in August 1949, Ambedkar said he expected it to remain a "dead letter", to be used only as a last resort, after a warning to the State and, if need be, fresh elections. The design assumed restraint.
Step 2 of 5
From last resort to political weapon
Practice departed from the design. The power was used repeatedly against State governments that had lost the Union government's favour rather than the confidence of their Assemblies. After winning the Lok Sabha election of 1977, the Janata government dismissed nine Congress-ruled State governments; on returning to power in 1980, the Congress dismissed nine opposition governments in turn. In State of Rajasthan v. Union of India (1977) the Supreme Court declined to intervene. Governors' reports were the usual trigger, and claims that a ministry had lost its majority were settled in Raj Bhavan rather than on the floor of the House. The Governor became the hinge on which the Union's political interest turned into constitutional action.
Step 3 of 5
Bommai: the floor, not Raj Bhavan
In S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (11 March 1994) nine judges rewrote the terms of use. The clause that had made the President's satisfaction final, inserted by the 38th Amendment, had been removed by the 44th in 1978, and the Court held proclamations open to judicial review: it may ask whether there was relevant material and whether the power was used in bad faith. A ministry's majority is to be tested on the floor of the Assembly, not in the Governor's opinion. Until both Houses approve the proclamation the Assembly may be suspended but not dissolved, so that a government wrongly dismissed can be restored. The Court also held secularism and federalism to be basic features.
Step 4 of 5
What changed after 1994
Bommai raised the cost of misuse without removing the power, and later courts enforced it. In Rameshwar Prasad (2006) the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly in 2005 was held unconstitutional; in 2016 the Court restored the displaced government of Arunachal Pradesh in Nabam Rebia and ordered a floor test in Uttarakhand. Commissions pressed the same point: the Sarkaria Commission (1988) urged use only as a last resort, and the Punchhi Commission (2010) suggested localising emergency provisions so that a disturbed area, rather than a whole State, could be placed under special arrangements. The power remains in use, as in Manipur in February 2025, but its use must now be defended before a court and in both Houses.
Step 5 of 5
Why it matters for cooperative federalism
Cooperative federalism describes a Union and States that treat each other as partners in a shared constitutional order, bargaining through institutions such as the Inter-State Council and the GST Council rather than overruling each other. Article 356 is the point at which one partner can suspend the other. Before Bommai, the threat of dismissal made State governments dependent on the Union's goodwill; after it, a State government that keeps its majority on the floor has a constitutional answer to a hostile Union. On this reading, Bommai did not make Indian federalism cooperative, but it made cooperation possible by removing the Union's easiest way of ending a disagreement.
The idea to keep
Article 356 is legitimate only as a last resort. Since S.R. Bommai (1994) the President's satisfaction is open to judicial review, a ministry's majority is tested on the floor of the House, and the Assembly may not be dissolved before Parliament approves the proclamation.
Check yourself
Answer each question in your own words first, then open it to compare.
Q1Why can a court now review a proclamation under Article 356?
Answer
The 44th Amendment (1978) removed the clause, inserted in 1975, that made the President's satisfaction final, and S.R. Bommai (1994) held that a court may examine whether relevant material existed and whether the power was used in bad faith.
Q2Why does it matter that the Assembly is suspended rather than dissolved before Parliament approves the proclamation?
Answer
It preserves the remedy. If Parliament withholds approval or a court strikes the proclamation down, the dismissed government and the Assembly can be restored; a dissolved Assembly could not be.
Q3Where, after Bommai, is a government's majority tested?
Answer
On the floor of the Legislative Assembly, not in the Governor's private assessment.
These questions are original to this platform; they are not previous year questions.
Read next
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended): Articles 355 and 356 (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) 3 SCC 1 (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
- 03Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. IX (debate on the provisions for failure of constitutional machinery in the States). Lok Sabha Secretariat, August 1949
- 04Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission). Government of India, 1988
- 05Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Punchhi Commission). Government of India, 2010