Section F · Federalism
Cooperative and Competitive Federalism
The models of federal relations, how Indian federalism has moved through phases of dominance, assertion and bargaining, the institutions of intergovernmental cooperation, and the case for and against competition among States.
Overview
The Constitution sets out a division of powers; the working of federalism depends on how governments use it. Political scientists distinguish dual federalism, in which each level keeps to its own sphere, from cooperative federalism, in which levels share tasks and bargain over them, and from competitive federalism, in which States compete with one another for investment and performance, or with the Union for power and resources.
Indian federalism has been all of these at different times. Its character has depended less on constitutional text than on the party system: whether one party ruled at both levels, whether regional parties held the balance in the Union, and how much fiscal room States had.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Article 263
- The President may establish an Inter-State Council to inquire into and advise on disputes and subjects of common interest.
- Article 279A
- The GST Council, a joint body of the Union and the States.
- Articles 258 and 258A
- Mutual entrustment of functions between the Union and the States.
Models of federal relations
American scholars contrasted "layer cake" dual federalism with the "marble cake" of shared functions described by Morton Grodzins. Granville Austin called the Indian design cooperative federalism: interdependence was built in from the start through concurrent powers, shared taxes, all-India services and joint planning. W.H. Morris-Jones described the practice as bargaining federalism, in which outcomes emerge from negotiation between governments rather than from legal boundaries.
Competitive federalism has two senses. Horizontally, States compete for investment, talent and reputation, as in rankings of the ease of doing business or of progress on the Sustainable Development Goals. Vertically, the Union and the States compete for authority and resources. A third term, confrontational federalism, describes periods when that vertical competition turns into open conflict in courts and the streets.
Phases of Indian federalism
From 1950 to 1967 the "Congress system", in Rajni Kothari's phrase, governed at both levels; conflicts were resolved within the party, and the Planning Commission and the National Development Council (1952) gave the Union a strong hand in State development. After 1967 non-Congress governments in several States contested Union dominance. The Rajamannar Committee (1969–71), the Anandpur Sahib Resolution (1973) and the West Bengal government's memorandum (1977) set out demands for autonomy, and the frequent use of Article 356 sharpened conflict.
From 1989 to 2014 coalition governments depended on regional parties, which carried State interests into the Union cabinet; liberalisation after 1991 gave States more room to compete for investment; and S.R. Bommai (1994) curbed Article 356. Since 2014 single-party majorities have restored Union dominance under the official banner of "cooperative, competitive federalism", while disputes with opposition-ruled States over Governors, agencies and funds have multiplied. The return of coalition government after 2024 has reopened the bargaining space.
Institutions of cooperation
NITI Aayog, which replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015 by a Cabinet resolution, has a Governing Council of the Prime Minister and all Chief Ministers and Lieutenant Governors, but no power to allocate funds. The GST Council is the most active intergovernmental body, meeting regularly and deciding by weighted voting. The Inter-State Council, constituted in 1990 on the Sarkaria Commission's recommendation, has met only rarely; its last meeting was in 2016. The five zonal councils, created by the States Reorganisation Act, 1956 and chaired by the Union Home Minister, and the North Eastern Council (1971) provide regional forums.
The contrast is instructive. The GST Council works because it controls something both levels need, and its voting rule forces bargaining; the Inter-State Council has no such stake, so its use depends on the Union's willingness to convene it.
Competition among States
Competition has become an explicit instrument of policy. The Union ranks States on business reforms, health, school education, water management and the Sustainable Development Goals; Finance Commission formulas reward tax effort and demographic performance; and States hold investment summits and offer incentives to attract industry.
The theory, associated with Charles Tiebout's model of mobile citizens choosing among jurisdictions, holds that competition rewards good governance and spreads innovation. Its critics warn of a race to the bottom, in which States weaken labour and environmental protection and offer subsidies that transfer public money to firms, and of widening gaps between States that can compete and those that cannot. Fiscal equalisation through the Finance Commission is the main counterweight.
Contemporary flashpoints
Several disputes define the present period. Governors' delays in assenting to Bills led to the Tamil Nadu and Punjab cases and the 2025 presidential reference. The GST compensation shortfall of 2020 and the end of compensation in 2022 strained the fiscal bargain. States have withdrawn general consent for CBI investigations and contested the role of central agencies. Disputes over disaster relief and over conditions attached to education funds have reached the Supreme Court. Proposals for simultaneous elections and the delimitation of constituencies after the next census raise structural questions about the place of States in national politics. Each is litigated or negotiated separately, which itself shows the weakness of standing forums for consultation.
Debates
Has GST strengthened cooperative federalism or eroded State fiscal autonomy?
The case for strengthening: the GST Council is a genuine institution of pooled sovereignty, States hold two-thirds of the voting weight, decisions have overwhelmingly been taken by consensus, and a national market has replaced a tangle of State taxes and check posts.
The case for erosion: States gave up their main tax lever and can no longer set rates to suit their needs; the Union holds a veto through its one-third vote; compensation has ended; and disputes, such as those over borrowing in 2020, were settled largely on the Union's terms. The Supreme Court's view in Mohit Minerals that recommendations are not binding preserved formal sovereignty, but in practice no State has legislated against the Council.
Is competitive federalism compatible with equity?
Supporters argue that competition spreads good practice and holds State governments to account through comparison, and that rankings have prompted administrative reforms. Sceptics argue that richer, better-governed States attract most investment, that rankings reward measurable outputs over harder-to-measure welfare, and that competition without strong equalising transfers entrenches regional inequality. Most scholars treat competition as useful only within a framework of cooperation and redistribution.
Commissions and committees
Sarkaria Commission1988
Recommended a permanent Inter-State Council under Article 263, constituted in 1990, and consultation with States on matters of common interest.
Punchhi Commission2010
Recommended that the Inter-State Council meet regularly, at least three times a year, with an agenda settled in consultation with the States.
Sub-Group of Chief Ministers on Rationalisation of Centrally Sponsored Schemes2015
Recommended fewer schemes, divided into core and optional categories, with revised Union–State funding ratios.
Prelims points
- NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015 by a Cabinet resolution.
- NITI Aayog's Governing Council includes the Prime Minister and all Chief Ministers.
- The Inter-State Council (Article 263) was constituted in 1990; its last meeting was in 2016.
- Five zonal councils were created under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956; the Union Home Minister chairs them.
- The North Eastern Council was created by the North Eastern Council Act, 1971.
- "Marble cake" federalism: Morton Grodzins; "bargaining federalism": W.H. Morris-Jones.
- The National Development Council was set up in 1952.
In the UPSC papers
Asked by UPSC
2 questions · 2024–2025
2025 · PSIR I · Q6(c) · 15 marks
The recent developments in Indian Politics has not eroded the true spirit of federalism in India. Critically examine this statement with the help of appropriate examples.
2024 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks
What changes has the Union Government recently introduced in the domain of Centre-State relations ? Suggest measures to be adopted to build the trust between the Centre and the States and for strengthening federalism.
Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Cooperative and Competitive Federalism in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Indian federalism has moved between cooperation, competition and confrontation. Analyse with reference to institutions and the party system.
How to approach it
Periodise (Congress system, post-1967, coalition era, post-2014, post-2024), link each phase to party politics, and assess which institutions moderated conflict.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Assess the GST Council as an institution of cooperative federalism.
How to approach it
Explain composition and voting, record of consensus, the compensation dispute and Mohit Minerals; weigh pooled sovereignty against lost autonomy.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Does competition among States improve governance? Discuss.
How to approach it
Present Tiebout-style arguments and Indian ranking practice against race-to-the-bottom and inequality concerns.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
Concept
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
- Centre–State Legislative Relations
- Centre–State Administrative Relations
- Centre–State Financial Relations
- Inter-State Relations
- The Governor
- Electoral Reforms
- Asymmetric Federalism
- The Chief Minister and the State Executive
- Education Governance
- Government Policies and Interventions: Design and Implementation
Article
- Article 263 · Provisions with respect to an inter-State Council
- Article 279A · Goods and Services Tax Council
- Article 258 · Power of the Union to confer powers, etc., on States in certain cases
- Article 258A · Power of the States to entrust functions to the Union
- Article 356 · Provisions in case of failure of constitutional machinery in States
Amendment
Judgment
- S.R. Bommai v. Union of India
- State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu
- In re: Assent, Withholding or Reservation of Bills by the Governor and the President of India (Special Reference No. 1 of 2025)
- In Re: Article 370 of the Constitution
- Mineral Area Development Authority v. Steel Authority of India
- State of Rajasthan v. Union of India
- State of West Bengal v. Union of India
Institution
Political system
Political briefing
Political Issue Dossier
Five-minute module
Dictionary
Sources
- 01Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988. Government of India
- 02Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Punchhi Commission), 2010. Government of India
- 03Granville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution: The Indian Experience (1999). Oxford University Press
- 04Louise Tillin, Indian Federalism (2019). Oxford University Press
- 05Rajni Kothari, "The Congress 'System' in India", Asian Survey 4(12) (1964)