Skip to content

The Constitution (Thirty-eighth Amendment) Act, 1975

38th Amendment (1975)

An Emergency-era amendment that placed the President's satisfaction in proclaiming emergencies and promulgating ordinances beyond the reach of the courts.

01Context

The national Emergency on the ground of "internal disturbance" was proclaimed on 25 June 1975, after the Allahabad High Court had set aside the Prime Minister's election. With opposition leaders in detention, Parliament passed the Thirty-eighth Amendment within weeks to remove possible judicial challenges to the Emergency and to the ordinances being issued under it.

02What it changed

  • The satisfaction of the President or the Governor in promulgating ordinances (articles 123, 213 and 239B) declared final and not open to question in any court.
  • The President's satisfaction in proclaiming an Emergency under article 352, President's Rule under article 356 and a financial emergency under article 360 likewise declared final and non-justiciable.
  • Article 352 amended to allow different Proclamations on different grounds, whether or not one was already in force.
  • Article 359(1A) inserted, so that laws made during an Emergency could not be challenged for inconsistency with the rights whose enforcement had been suspended.

03Political and constitutional significance

The amendment was the first of the Emergency's constitutional changes and expressed its central idea: that the executive's judgment of necessity should be unreviewable. It stands with the Thirty-ninth and Forty-second Amendments as evidence that a written constitution can be turned against its own safeguards by a sufficient majority. Every finality clause it inserted was removed by the Forty-fourth Amendment, and the Supreme Court later held in S.R. Bommai that the proclamation of President's Rule is open to judicial review in any event.

Why it matters for UPSC

Examiners use the Thirty-eighth Amendment in questions on the Emergency, judicial review of executive satisfaction and the Forty-fourth Amendment's safeguards. A strong answer contrasts the 1975 finality clauses with the post-1978 position and with the review standards developed in Bommai.

Sources