Skip to content

Section A · Constitutional Foundations

Sources of the Constitution

What the framers took from the 1935 Act and from other constitutions, how they changed what they took, and why "borrowed constitution" misdescribes the result.

Overview

The Constitution draws on the Government of India Act, 1935, on the constitutions of several democracies and on the national movement's own constitutional documents. Listing the borrowings is the easy part. The harder part is explaining adaptation: almost every imported feature was altered to suit Indian conditions or to avoid a defect seen abroad, and the most distinctive combinations, such as a federation with a strong Union or enforceable rights beside non-enforceable directives, have no single foreign model.

Constitutional and legal provisions

Article 21
"Procedure established by law", from the Japanese Constitution, in preference to due process.
Article 37
Irish-model directive principles, unenforceable but "fundamental in the governance of the country".
Seventh Schedule
Three legislative lists adapted from the 1935 Act.

The Government of India Act, 1935

The largest single source was the 1935 Act: the federal scheme and its lists, the office of Governor, the structure of the judiciary, the public service commissions, the emergency provisions and much administrative detail. Answering the charge of copying on 4 November 1948, Ambedkar replied that no one holds patent rights in the fundamental ideas of a constitution and that there was nothing to be ashamed of in borrowing; what mattered was correcting faults and fitting the scheme to Indian needs.

Features drawn from other constitutions

Standard accounts attribute the following:

  • United Kingdom: parliamentary and cabinet government, rule of law, legislative procedure, single citizenship, writs, privileges, bicameralism.
  • United States: fundamental rights, judicial review, impeachment of the President, removal of judges, the Vice-President.
  • Ireland: directive principles, nomination to the Rajya Sabha, the method of electing the President.
  • Canada: a federation with a strong centre, residuary powers with the Union, Centre-appointed Governors, advisory jurisdiction.
  • Australia: the Concurrent List, freedom of trade and commerce, joint sittings.
  • Weimar Germany: suspension of fundamental rights during emergency.
  • Soviet Union: fundamental duties (1976) and social, economic and political justice.
  • France: the republic; liberty, equality and fraternity.
  • South Africa: the amendment procedure; election of Rajya Sabha members.
  • Japan: procedure established by law.

Adaptation, not transplantation

Three examples show the pattern. The Westminster model was taken without parliamentary sovereignty: a written constitution, judicial review and a federal division of power bind the Indian Parliament as they never bound the British one. American-style rights were taken with their limits written into the text (Article 19(2)–(6)) rather than left, as in the First Amendment, to judicial invention.

The third example shows that adaptation continues after adoption. B.N. Rau, after consulting American jurists including Justice Felix Frankfurter, advised against a due process clause, and the Assembly chose "procedure established by law". In A.K. Gopalan (1950) the Court read the phrase narrowly; in Maneka Gandhi (1978) it required procedure to be fair, just and reasonable, reintroducing much of what the framers had left out.

Indian sources

The national movement supplied its own texts: the Commonwealth of India Bill (1925), the Nehru Report (1928), the Karachi Resolution (1931) and the Sapru Committee's proposals (1945). Ambedkar's memorandum States and Minorities (1947) shaped the debate on safeguards, and Gandhian ideas entered Part IV through Articles 40, 43, 46, 47 and 48. Calling the document "borrowed" ignores this domestic lineage.

Debates

Is the Constitution a "borrowed" document?

Critics in the Assembly called the draft un-Indian, an imitation of Western models; one member lamented that the country had wanted the music of the veena or sitar and got an English band. The defence is that borrowing was selective and adapted, much came from the national movement, and the combination was new. The fairer question is whether the borrowed institutions were made to work.

Do institutions travel without the conventions that sustain them?

The Westminster model assumes conventions of restraint: a neutral Speaker, a Governor who never acts politically, an executive that accepts opposition rights. Where these conventions were weak, Indian practice has produced recurring disputes over Governors and Speakers. Against this, several transplants have taken firm root, judicial review above all, and the Court has turned some conventions into law (as in S.R. Bommai, which made the floor test a constitutional requirement).

Prelims points

  • United Kingdom: parliamentary system, rule of law, single citizenship, writs, legislative procedure.
  • United States: fundamental rights, judicial review, impeachment of the President, Vice-President.
  • Ireland: directive principles, nomination to the Rajya Sabha, method of presidential election.
  • Canada: strong centre, residuary powers with the Union, advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
  • Australia: Concurrent List, joint sitting, freedom of trade and commerce.
  • Weimar Germany: suspension of fundamental rights during emergency; Japan: procedure established by law.
  • Soviet Union: fundamental duties; South Africa: amendment procedure and election of Rajya Sabha members.
  • Government of India Act, 1935: federal scheme, Governor, public service commissions, emergency provisions.

Practice questions

  1. Q1UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    The framers borrowed widely but adapted carefully. Illustrate with three examples.

    How to approach it

    Choose examples where the change is clear (Westminster without parliamentary sovereignty; rights with textual limits; directives "fundamental in governance") and say what was taken and what was changed.

  2. Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words

    Why did the framers prefer "procedure established by law" to "due process of law", and how has the Supreme Court changed the effect of that choice?

    How to approach it

    Explain the framers' fear of courts blocking social legislation, Rau's consultations, Gopalan's narrow reading and Maneka Gandhi's fair, just and reasonable procedure.

  3. Q3UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words

    Westminster institutions transplanted without Westminster conventions have produced recurrent constitutional friction in India. Discuss with reference to the Governor and the Speaker.

    How to approach it

    Identify the conventions each office assumes, give examples of disputes (government formation, assent, disqualification petitions) and assess judicial codification as a substitute.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
  2. 02Constituent Assembly Debates (Official Report), 1946–1950. Lok Sabha Secretariat
  3. 03Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation (1966). Oxford University Press
  4. 04D.D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India. LexisNexis