Five-minute module · Constitutional concept
The basic structure doctrine
Why the Supreme Court held that the power to amend the Constitution is not a power to destroy it, how the limit has been applied, and why it remains contested.
Step 1 of 5
The question the text leaves open
Article 368 lets Parliament amend the Constitution by special majorities, with ratification by half the States for provisions that affect the federal structure. It sets procedural conditions but no substantive limits. In the 1950s and 1960s land-reform laws collided with the fundamental right to property, and Parliament repeatedly amended Part III to save them. The question was whether anything in the Constitution lay beyond amendment. In Shankari Prasad (1951) the Court held that an amendment is not "law" under Article 13, so fundamental rights could be amended. In Golaknath (1967) eleven judges held by 6:5 that it is, so they could not be abridged at all. Parliament replied with the 24th Amendment (1971).
Step 2 of 5
Kesavananda Bharati: amending is not abrogating
In Kesavananda Bharati, decided on 24 April 1973, a bench of thirteen judges overruled Golaknath and upheld the 24th Amendment: Parliament may amend any provision, fundamental rights included. But a majority of seven to six added a limit that appears nowhere in the text. The power to "amend", Justice H.R. Khanna reasoned, presupposes that the Constitution survives the change with its identity intact; it cannot extend to abrogating the Constitution or destroying its basic structure. The limit is implied from the nature of the power itself rather than from any article. That move is the whole doctrine in miniature: the Constitution's identity, not its wording, marks the boundary of the amending power.
Step 3 of 5
What counts as basic
The Court has never given an exhaustive list. Chief Justice Sikri's illustrations in Kesavananda (the supremacy of the Constitution, republican and democratic government, secularism, the separation of powers and federalism) have been extended case by case: free and fair elections in Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975); judicial review and the balance between Parts III and IV in Minerva Mills (1980); secularism and federalism in S.R. Bommai (1994); the independence of the judiciary in the NJAC case (2015). The open list is deliberate. A feature is basic when its removal would turn the Constitution into a different constitution, and that judgement can only be made against a particular amendment.
Step 4 of 5
The doctrine at work
The doctrine bites on constitutional amendments, not on ordinary laws, which are tested against the fundamental rights in the usual way. Its hardest test came after the 42nd Amendment (1976) declared the amending power unlimited and amendments immune from challenge. In Minerva Mills the Court struck down those clauses of Article 368: a limited amending power is itself part of the basic structure, so Parliament cannot amend its way out of the limit. Laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 are open to review for their effect on basic rights (I.R. Coelho, 2007). Many challenges fail: the 103rd Amendment's reservations for economically weaker sections were upheld in Janhit Abhiyan (2022).
Step 5 of 5
Safeguard or usurpation
Critics make a democratic objection. A divided bench gave unelected judges the last word over elected representatives exercising the amending power, on the strength of a limit the framers did not write, and the doctrine's content is decided by the same court that applies it. Defenders make a constitutional reply. A written constitution that any sufficiently large majority could rewrite at will would bind no one, and the amendments of 1975–76, which tried to put a Prime Minister's election beyond the courts and the amending power beyond review, show that the danger was not hypothetical. A middle position accepts the doctrine but asks for restraint: use it to protect the conditions of democratic politics, not to second-guess policy.
The idea to keep
Parliament may amend every provision of the Constitution, but not so as to destroy its identity. Since Kesavananda Bharati (1973) that limit has been read into the word "amend" itself, and its content is settled by the Supreme Court one amendment at a time.
Check yourself
Answer each question in your own words first, then open it to compare.
Q1If Kesavananda Bharati upheld the 24th Amendment, why did the Court need a doctrine at all?
Answer
Upholding the 24th Amendment meant that Parliament could amend any provision, fundamental rights included. Without an implied limit, nothing would stop an amendment from abolishing elections or judicial review; the basic structure doctrine supplies that limit.
Q2Does the basic structure doctrine apply to ordinary laws?
Answer
Not directly. Ordinary laws are tested against the fundamental rights and the other provisions of the Constitution. The doctrine applies to constitutional amendments and, since I.R. Coelho (2007), to laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973.
Q3What did Minerva Mills (1980) add?
Answer
That the limited nature of the amending power is itself a basic feature. The clauses of the 42nd Amendment that declared the power unlimited and amendments immune from review were struck down.
These questions are original to this platform; they are not previous year questions.
Read next
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended): Articles 13 and 368 (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) 4 SCC 225; Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980) 3 SCC 625; I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007) 2 SCC 1 (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
- 03Sudhir Krishnaswamy, Democracy and Constitutionalism in India: A Study of the Basic Structure Doctrine (2009). Oxford University Press
- 04Granville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution: The Indian Experience (1999). Oxford University Press