Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 2006

Rameshwar Prasad (Bihar Assembly case)

By three to two, the Court held the 2005 dissolution of the Bihar Assembly unconstitutional, finding that the Governor's report rested on extraneous considerations, but declined to restore the Assembly because fresh elections were under way.

Rameshwar Prasad v. Union of India
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
24 January 2006
Bench
5-judge Constitution Bench
Citation
(2006) 2 SCC 1

01The constitutional issue

The Bihar election of February 2005 produced no majority, and President's Rule was imposed with the newly elected Assembly in suspended animation. In May, as a coalition appeared to be gathering support, Governor Buta Singh reported that legislators were being lured with money and recommended dissolution. The Union Cabinet met at night, and the President, then abroad, approved the dissolution on 23 May 2005 — before the Assembly had ever met.

02The decision

Sabharwal CJ, with B.N. Agrawal and Ashok Bhan JJ, held the proclamation unconstitutional. The Governor had relied on his own unverified suspicion of horse-trading; he could not shut out a claim to form a government on the ground that its majority had been obtained by improper means, which was a matter for the floor of the House. A report based on such extraneous considerations could not support the President's satisfaction under Article 356. The Governor's personal immunity under Article 361 did not bar the Court from examining the validity of his actions.

Because elections had already been called, the Court did not restore the Assembly. K.G. Balakrishnan and Arijit Pasayat JJ dissented, holding that the material before the Governor justified his report. The conclusion had been announced in October 2005, with reasons following in January 2006.

03Significance

The judgment extended S.R. Bommai to a dissolution ordered before an Assembly had met and placed the anti-defection problem where the Constitution puts it — in the legislature and the courts, not the Governor's assessment. Its limitation is the familiar one: a remedy that arrives after the event.

04What happened afterwards

Buta Singh resigned shortly after the reasons were published. The coalition that had been denied the chance to form a government won the later 2005 election. Nabam Rebia (2016) and Subhash Desai (2023) continued the Court's scrutiny of Governors' roles in government formation.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: 2006; 3:2; the Bihar dissolution; Article 361. In Mains, use it on the Governor's discretion and Article 356.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 24 January 2006. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Rameshwar Prasad v. Union of India, (2006) 2 SCC 1: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India