Section L · Social Justice
Government Policies and Interventions: Design and Implementation
Why well-intentioned schemes succeed or fail: a framework for analysing design and implementation in India's federal system, applied to well-documented interventions in sanitation, cooking fuel, farm incomes, agricultural markets and the girl child.
Overview
The GS-II syllabus asks about 'government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation'. Questions rarely reward a list of schemes. They reward an analysis of why a scheme produced the results it did, and a candidate who can carry a framework from one sector to another.
This entry offers such a framework and applies it to interventions whose design and results are documented by official audits, parliamentary committees and independent research. Budget figures change every year and are left out; the governance lessons are more durable. The schemes are examples, not a catalogue: the same questions apply to any intervention a paper may name.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Article 282
- The Union or a state may make grants for any public purpose, the basis of centrally sponsored schemes in subjects on the State List.
- Articles 275 and 280
- Statutory grants-in-aid to states and the Finance Commission, the formula-based channel of transfers that contrasts with discretionary scheme grants.
- Rationalised framework for centrally sponsored schemes (2016)
- Following a sub-group of Chief Ministers (2015): 'core of the core', core and optional schemes, with the Union–state funding ratio generally 60:40 and 90:10 for north-eastern and Himalayan states.
- Seventh Schedule
- Agriculture, public health and local government are State subjects; Concurrent List entry 33 (trade and commerce in foodstuffs) was the basis of the 2020 farm laws.
A framework for analysing a scheme
Seven questions organise most answers.
- Problem definition: what failure is the scheme meant to correct, and is the diagnosis right?
- Instrument: cash, goods, services, insurance, regulation, infrastructure or persuasion?
- Targeting: universal or targeted, and with what exclusion and inclusion errors?
- Federal design: who pays, who decides and how much room states have to adapt.
- Delivery capacity: staff, records, technology and the discretion of front-line workers.
- Feedback: monitoring of outcomes rather than outputs, social audit and grievance redress.
- Legitimacy: consultation with those affected and trust in the state's intentions.
Centrally sponsored schemes and federal design
Centrally sponsored schemes let the Union pursue national priorities in State subjects, but proliferation brought uniform templates, delayed releases and conditions that states found intrusive. The B.K. Chaturvedi Committee (2011) recommended consolidation, and the 2015 sub-group of Chief Ministers produced the present classification and sharing ratios. When the Fourteenth Finance Commission raised states' share of divisible taxes to 42 per cent, the Union reduced its share of several schemes, illustrating the trade-off between untied and tied money. Branding requirements and the linking of funds to policy adoption remain sources of friction.
Swachh Bharat and Ujjwala: access versus use
Swachh Bharat Mission (Gramin), launched on 2 October 2014, built household toilets at great speed and villages were declared open-defecation free by 2019. Diane Coffey and Dean Spears's Where India Goes (2017) showed why construction does not guarantee use: caste-based notions of purity make emptying pits stigmatised, so many people kept defecating in the open. The Ujjwala Yojana (2016) gave LPG connections to poor women, but refill rates stayed low, as the CAG's audit of 2019 found, largely because cylinders cost more than freely gathered fuel; later targeted subsidies addressed price. Both show that delivering an asset is not the same as changing a behaviour.
PM-KISAN and the farm laws: targeting and legitimacy
PM-KISAN (2019) transfers ₹6,000 a year to landholding farm families in three instalments, a simple design that reaches many quickly. Because eligibility rests on land records, it excludes tenants and landless labourers, who are often poorer; Odisha's KALIA scheme (2018) showed that a design including sharecroppers and the landless was possible. The three farm laws of 2020 illustrate failure of a different kind. They were passed without committee scrutiny, the Rajya Sabha voted by voice amid protests, farmers' unions saw them as a threat to procurement, and after a year of protest Parliament repealed them in 2021. Whatever their economic merits, their process cost them legitimacy.
Beti Bachao Beti Padhao: campaign or programme
Launched in January 2015 at Panipat to address the falling child sex ratio and girls' education, the scheme combined advocacy with district-level action. A Lok Sabha committee on the empowerment of women reported in 2021 that most of its funds in the early years had gone on media publicity rather than on interventions in health and education. Awareness campaigns can shift norms, but where the causes of a problem lie in property, marriage and labour markets, publicity cannot substitute for programmes that change incentives.
Designing for implementation
Matt Andrews, Lant Pritchett and Michael Woolcock's Building State Capability (2017) warn against 'isomorphic mimicry', adopting the forms of successful programmes without their functions, and recommend 'problem-driven iterative adaptation': define the problem locally, try solutions, learn and adjust. Indian practice offers examples of both. The Aspirational Districts Programme (2018) combined monitoring, ranking and convergence in 112 lagging districts; schemes designed in Delhi for the whole country often fail where conditions differ. The common lesson is to measure outcomes, involve implementers early and let states adapt.
Debates
Universal or targeted: which design reaches the poor better?
Targeting saves money but every test, whether a poverty survey, a land record or an authentication, excludes some of the eligible, and the excluded are usually the most vulnerable. Universal schemes cost more but are simpler and harder to capture. The Economic Survey of 2016–17 discussed a universal basic income as an alternative to many targeted schemes. In practice India mixes both, and the choice should depend on the cost of exclusion in each sector.
Does Union design of schemes undermine state autonomy?
Union schemes have spread national minimum standards, from sanitation to rural roads, and carried resources to poorer states. They also impose uniform designs, demand matching funds that strain state budgets and use branding and conditions to claim political credit. The federal answer is not to abolish such schemes but to give states more room to adapt them, more of the money untied and a voice in their design.
Commissions and committees
B.K. Chaturvedi Committee on Restructuring of Centrally Sponsored Schemes2011
Recommended consolidating schemes and giving states greater flexibility.
Sub-Group of Chief Ministers on Rationalisation of Centrally Sponsored Schemes2015
Proposed the core of the core, core and optional classification and the funding patterns adopted in 2016.
Supreme Court-appointed Committee on the Farm Laws2021
Formed when the Court stayed the laws in January 2021; its report was submitted in March 2021, before the laws were repealed.
Prelims points
- Centrally sponsored schemes rest on Article 282; core schemes are generally shared 60:40, and 90:10 for north-eastern and Himalayan states.
- PM-KISAN pays ₹6,000 a year in three instalments to landholding farmer families (from 2019).
- The Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana was launched on 1 May 2016.
- Swachh Bharat Mission (Gramin) was launched on 2 October 2014.
- The Farm Laws Repeal Act, 2021 repealed the three farm laws of 2020.
- Beti Bachao Beti Padhao was launched on 22 January 2015 at Panipat.
- The Aspirational Districts Programme (2018) covers 112 districts.
- The Jal Jeevan Mission for household tap connections was announced on 15 August 2019.
- The Economic Survey 2016–17 discussed a universal basic income.
In the UPSC papers
Asked by UPSC
2 questions · 2024–2026
2026 · GS-II · Q17 · 15 marks
Can the constitutional mandate of rights-based welfare be effectively realised in the context of non-integrated governance and minimal public investment ? Examine.
2024 · GS-II · Q11 · 15 marks
What are the aims and objects of recently passed and enforced, The Public Examination (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024 ? Whether University/State Education Board examinations, too, are covered under the Act ?
Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Government Policies and Interventions: Design and Implementation in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Many Indian schemes succeed in creating assets but fail to change outcomes. Examine with reference to any two interventions.
How to approach it
Use Swachh Bharat and Ujjwala or Jal Jeevan; separate outputs from outcomes; explain behavioural, price and maintenance factors; suggest outcome-based monitoring and community involvement.
- Q2UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Evaluate the design of centrally sponsored schemes from the standpoint of cooperative federalism.
How to approach it
Explain Article 282 and the 2016 framework; weigh national standards and redistribution against uniformity, conditions and fiscal strain; propose reforms.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
What lessons for policy design and consultation does the enactment and repeal of the farm laws of 2020 offer?
How to approach it
Summarise the laws and process; separate the economic from the procedural objections; draw lessons on consultation, federal competence and trust.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02Report of the Sub-Group of Chief Ministers on Rationalisation of Centrally Sponsored Schemes. NITI Aayog, 2015
- 03Comptroller and Auditor General of India, Performance Audit of Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana (2019) (opens in a new tab). CAG of India, 2019
- 04Committee on Empowerment of Women (Lok Sabha), report on Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (2021). Lok Sabha Secretariat, 2021
- 05Diane Coffey and Dean Spears, Where India Goes: Abandoned Toilets, Stunted Development and the Costs of Caste (HarperCollins India, 2017)
- 06Matt Andrews, Lant Pritchett and Michael Woolcock, Building State Capability (Oxford University Press, 2017)
- 07Economic Survey 2016–17, chapter on universal basic income. Ministry of Finance, 2017