Section F · Federalism
Asymmetric Federalism
Special constitutional arrangements for particular States and regions: Article 370 and its end, Article 371, the Fifth and Sixth Schedules, and the Union territories with legislatures.
Overview
In a symmetric federation every unit has the same powers; in an asymmetric one, some units have special status. India is asymmetric by design. Particular States and regions have constitutional protections for customary law, land, local development or employment; tribal areas have their own systems of self-government; and Union territories range from those governed directly by the President to Delhi and Puducherry with elected legislatures.
Asymmetry has been India's main tool for accommodating regional and ethnic diversity within a strong Union, and the source of some of its sharpest constitutional controversies, above all the end of Jammu and Kashmir's special status in 2019.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Article 370
- Temporary provisions for Jammu and Kashmir, declared inoperative in August 2019.
- Articles 371–371J
- Special provisions for Maharashtra, Gujarat, Nagaland, Assam, Manipur, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, Sikkim, Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh, Goa and Karnataka.
- Articles 244 and 244A; Fifth and Sixth Schedules
- Administration of Scheduled Areas and tribal areas; an autonomous State within Assam.
- Articles 239, 239A, 239AA, 240
- Administration of Union territories; legislatures for Puducherry and Delhi; presidential regulations for certain territories.
The idea of asymmetry
Charles Tarlton's 1965 essay distinguished symmetrical federations, whose units share the same relationship to the centre, from asymmetrical ones. Alfred Stepan later contrasted "coming together" federations, formed by sovereign units bargaining as equals (the United States), with "holding together" federations, created to keep a diverse state united by devolving power, often unequally (India, Spain, Belgium). In holding-together federations asymmetry is a concession to the distinctiveness of particular regions rather than a privilege. India combines de jure asymmetry in the text with de facto asymmetry in size, wealth and political weight.
Jammu and Kashmir: Article 370 and after
After the Instrument of Accession of October 1947, Article 370 limited Parliament's power over Jammu and Kashmir to defence, foreign affairs and communications, with other provisions applied only with the State government's concurrence. The Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 1954 extended much of the Constitution and inserted Article 35A on permanent residents; the State had its own constitution from 1957.
On 5 and 6 August 2019 presidential orders applied the whole Constitution to the State and declared Article 370 inoperative, and the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019 created two Union territories from 31 October 2019: Jammu and Kashmir, with a legislature, and Ladakh, without one. In In re Article 370 (11 December 2023) a Constitution Bench upheld the abrogation, holding that Article 370 was a temporary provision and that the State had no internal sovereignty, directed that statehood be restored at the earliest and that elections be held by 30 September 2024. Elections were held in 2024; statehood had not been restored at the time of writing, and Ladakh has seen sustained demands for statehood and Sixth Schedule protection.
Article 371 and the special provisions
- Article 371: development boards for Vidarbha, Marathwada and the rest of Maharashtra, and for Saurashtra, Kutch and the rest of Gujarat.
- 371A (Nagaland, 13th Amendment, 1962): no Act of Parliament on Naga religious or social practices, customary law and procedure, or ownership and transfer of land applies unless the Assembly so resolves; the Governor has special responsibility for law and order.
- 371B (Assam) and 371C (Manipur): committees of members from tribal and hill areas.
- 371D and 371E: equitable opportunities in public employment and education in Andhra Pradesh (and, since 2014, Telangana); a central university.
- 371F (Sikkim, 36th Amendment): protection of existing laws and of the rights of different sections of the population.
- 371G (Mizoram): protections like Nagaland's; 371H (Arunachal Pradesh): the Governor's special responsibility for law and order.
- 371-I (Goa): an Assembly of not less than thirty members; 371J (Karnataka, 98th Amendment, 2012): a development board and reservation in education and employment for the Hyderabad–Karnataka region.
Scheduled Areas and tribal areas
The Fifth Schedule applies to Scheduled Areas in States other than the four north-eastern States covered by the Sixth. The Governor may direct that a law shall not apply or shall apply with modifications, may make regulations restricting the transfer of land by tribal people and regulating money-lending, and must consult a Tribes Advisory Council. The Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 gave gram sabhas in these areas control over minor forest produce, land alienation and local plans. In Samatha v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1997) the Supreme Court held that tribal land in Scheduled Areas could not be leased to private mining companies.
The Sixth Schedule applies to tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram, which have autonomous district councils with legislative, executive and judicial powers over land, forests, customary law and local administration. It originated in the recommendations of the Bordoloi Sub-Committee of the Constituent Assembly and has been extended, as with the Bodoland Territorial Council in 2003.
Union territories with legislatures
Most Union territories are administered by the President through an Administrator (Article 239). Puducherry has a legislature under Article 239A, and Delhi under Article 239AA, inserted by the 69th Amendment (1991), which excludes public order, police and land from the Assembly's competence. In 2018 a Constitution Bench held that the Lieutenant Governor is bound by the aid and advice of the Delhi Council of Ministers except on excluded matters, describing the relationship as collaborative federalism. In Government of NCT of Delhi v. Union of India (2023) it held that the elected government controls services other than those linked to the excluded subjects. Parliament responded with the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Act, 2023, creating an authority chaired by the Chief Minister but giving the Lieutenant Governor the final word on services.
Debates
Does asymmetry strengthen or threaten national unity?
The accommodation view holds that asymmetry ended or contained insurgencies: the Nagaland settlement of 1960–63 and the Mizo Accord of 1986, which led to statehood and Article 371G, are its clearest successes, and protections for land and customary law have kept tribal societies within the constitutional order. The integration view holds that special status creates unequal citizenship, entrenches local elites, encourages further demands and, in Jammu and Kashmir, sustained a separate political identity. Comparative experience in Canada, Spain and the United Kingdom suggests that asymmetry stabilises when it is negotiated and destabilises when it is withdrawn unilaterally.
Was the 2019 reorganisation of Jammu and Kashmir an act of integration or a breach of federal trust?
The integration case: Article 370 was temporary, the Supreme Court upheld its abrogation, and the change extended to the region laws and rights available elsewhere, from reservations to protections against discrimination. The federal-trust case: the change was made while the State was under President's Rule, with Parliament and the Governor standing in for the State's own institutions; a State was reduced to Union territories for the first time; and restoration of statehood remains pending. Both sides agree that the episode tested the limits of Article 3 and Article 356 in ways the framers did not anticipate.
Commissions and committees
Bordoloi Sub-Committee of the Constituent Assembly1947
Sub-committee on the North-East Frontier tribal areas chaired by Gopinath Bordoloi; its recommendations formed the basis of the Sixth Schedule.
Scheduled Areas and Scheduled Tribes Commission (U.N. Dhebar)1961
Reviewed the administration of Scheduled Areas and the welfare of Scheduled Tribes under Article 339.
Bhuria Committee1995
Recommended extending panchayats to Scheduled Areas with strong gram sabhas, leading to PESA, 1996.
Prelims points
- Article 370 was declared inoperative by presidential orders of 5 and 6 August 2019; the Supreme Court upheld this on 11 December 2023.
- The Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019 created two Union territories from 31 October 2019.
- Articles 371A (Nagaland) and 371G (Mizoram) protect customary law and land ownership from Acts of Parliament unless the Assembly agrees.
- Article 371J (98th Amendment, 2012): Hyderabad–Karnataka region.
- Article 371D: equitable opportunities in public employment and education in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana.
- Sixth Schedule: tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram.
- Fifth Schedule: Scheduled Areas and Tribes Advisory Councils in other States.
- Article 239AA (69th Amendment, 1991): Delhi's legislature; public order, police and land excluded.
- Samatha (1997): tribal land in Scheduled Areas cannot be leased to private mining companies.
In the UPSC papers
Asked by UPSC
3 questions · 2025–2026
2026 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks
How far has the Indian federal framework been successful in accommodating regional and cultural diversities ? Highlight the role of asymmetric federalism and suggest measures to make dispute resolution mechanisms more effective.
2025 · GS-II · Q4 · 10 marks
Discuss the nature of Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly after the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization Act, 2019. Briefly describe the powers and functions of the Assembly of the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir.
2025 · PSIR I · Q5(d) · 10 marks
Delineate the key factors that have shaped the evolving political landscape in Jammu and Kashmir post 2019.
Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Asymmetric Federalism in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Asymmetric federalism in India is a means of accommodating diversity rather than a concession to separatism. Discuss.
How to approach it
Define asymmetry, survey Article 371, the Fifth and Sixth Schedules and the Union territories, use the north-eastern settlements as evidence, and address the integration critique.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Compare the Fifth and Sixth Schedules as models of tribal self-government.
How to approach it
Contrast the Governor-centred Fifth Schedule with the council-based Sixth, add PESA and Samatha, and assess effectiveness.
- Q3UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Examine the constitutional questions settled and left open by the Supreme Court's judgment on Article 370 (2023).
How to approach it
Settled: temporary nature, absence of internal sovereignty, validity of the presidential orders. Left open: conversion of a State into a Union territory under Article 3, and the scope of Parliament's role during President's Rule.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
Ideology
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 370 · Temporary provisions with respect to the State of Jammu and Kashmir
- Article 371 · Special provision with respect to the States of Maharashtra and Gujarat
- Article 371A · Special provision with respect to the State of Nagaland
- Article 371B · Special provision with respect to the State of Assam
- Article 371C · Special provision with respect to the State of Manipur
- Article 371D · Special provisions with respect to the State of Andhra Pradesh or the State of Telangana
- Article 371E · Establishment of Central University in Andhra Pradesh
- Article 371F · Special provisions with respect to the State of Sikkim
- Article 371G · Special provision with respect to the State of Mizoram
- Article 371H · Special provision with respect to the State of Arunachal Pradesh
Institution
Political system
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02Judgments of the Supreme Court of India (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
- 03Alfred Stepan, "Federalism and Democracy: Beyond the U.S. Model", Journal of Democracy 10(4) (1999)
- 04Charles D. Tarlton, "Symmetry and Asymmetry as Elements of Federalism: A Theoretical Speculation", Journal of Politics 27(4) (1965)
- 05Louise Tillin, Indian Federalism (2019). Oxford University Press