Strategic and contemporary issues
Climate Diplomacy
India's climate diplomacy from Rio to Antalya: the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities, the Glasgow pledges, a third nationally determined contribution for 2035, and the politics of finance and carbon borders.
Overview
India is the world's third-largest emitter of greenhouse gases in absolute terms and one of the lowest per person among major economies. Its climate diplomacy has always been built on that contrast. Since the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (1992), India has defended the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities: all states share the duty to act, but those that industrialised first bear greater responsibility and must provide finance and technology.
The diplomacy has moved from defensive to constructive without abandoning that principle. India accepted economy-wide targets under the Paris Agreement (2015), announced a net-zero goal for 2070 at Glasgow (2021), and has built coalitions of its own. Its constant demand is that ambition be matched by finance.
01Principles: equity and differentiation
Under the Kyoto Protocol (1997) only industrialised countries had binding targets. India, with China, Brazil and South Africa in the BASIC group formed in 2009, resisted efforts to impose similar obligations on developing countries, and it belongs to the Like-Minded Developing Countries in the negotiations. The Paris Agreement replaced the binary with nationally determined contributions that every party sets for itself, reviewed in five-year cycles. India accepted this because it preserved differentiation in practice: each state decides its contribution according to its circumstances.
02Pledges: from Paris to NDC 3.0
India's first contribution (2015) promised to cut the emissions intensity of GDP by 33–35 per cent from 2005 levels by 2030 and to reach 40 per cent non-fossil electricity capacity. At Glasgow on 1 November 2021 Narendra Modi announced five commitments, the Panchamrit, including 500 gigawatts of non-fossil capacity by 2030 and net zero by 2070. The updated contribution of August 2022 raised the intensity target to 45 per cent and the non-fossil capacity target to 50 per cent by 2030, and added LiFE, a movement for sustainable lifestyles. India reached half of its installed capacity from non-fossil sources in 2025, five years early. In March 2026 the Union Cabinet approved a third contribution for 2031–35: a 47 per cent cut in emissions intensity from 2005 levels and 60 per cent non-fossil capacity by 2035, with an additional carbon sink of 3.5–4 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent.
03Finance: the unkept bargain
In 2009 developed countries promised USD 100 billion a year in climate finance by 2020; by the OECD's reckoning the target was met only in 2022. At Baku in November 2024 the parties adopted a new goal of at least USD 300 billion a year by 2035. India's delegate rejected it as far too small and objected to the manner of its adoption, a protest many developing countries supported. A fund for loss and damage was operationalised at Dubai in 2023. For India, finance is not charity but the condition on which developing countries agreed to self-determined ambition.
04Carbon borders and unilateral measures
The European Union's carbon border adjustment mechanism, whose definitive phase began on 1 January 2026, charges importers for the carbon embedded in goods such as steel and aluminium, of which India is a significant exporter to Europe. India argues that such measures are unilateral, discriminatory and inconsistent with differentiated responsibility, and has raised them in the WTO and in its trade negotiations with the EU. The second withdrawal of the United States from the Paris Agreement, effective in January 2026, weakened the North's credibility further.
05India's coalitions and initiatives
India has tried to lead through institutions of its own: the International Solar Alliance (2015), the Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure (2019), the Leadership Group for Industry Transition with Sweden (2019), the Green Grids Initiative (2021) and the Global Biofuels Alliance (2023) (see energy diplomacy). Mission LiFE, launched with the UN Secretary-General in October 2022, carries India's argument that consumption patterns in rich societies matter as much as production. At Dubai in December 2023 Modi offered to host COP33 in 2028.
06Climate diplomacy in 2026
COP31 opened at Antalya on 9 November 2026 under a Turkish presidency, with Australia presiding over the negotiations, in a year when the energy shock from the war in West Asia pushed governments towards energy security. The International Court of Justice's advisory opinion of 23 July 2025, which held that states have obligations under international law to protect the climate system, has added a legal dimension to arguments about responsibility that India has made for three decades.
07Reading it through IR theory
Realism treats climate negotiations as a struggle over who bears the costs of adjustment. States weigh relative gains, and India's defence of differentiation and its rejection of the Baku finance goal can be read as protecting development space against richer competitors. E. H. Carr's warning that appeals to a universal harmony of interests often serve the dominant helps explain India's suspicion of unilateral measures such as the EU's carbon border mechanism. Realism cannot easily explain, however, why India accepted economy-wide targets at Paris and built institutions of its own. Liberal institutionalism can. The UN climate regime lowers the costs of cooperation and, through nationally determined contributions reviewed in five-year cycles, lets every party act on its own terms while being seen to act; India accepted Paris because the design preserved differentiation in practice. The regime's weakness is enforcement, since the finance bargain on which developing countries' ambition rests has been delayed or judged inadequate. Constructivism focuses on norms. Common but differentiated responsibilities is a norm of justice that India has defended for three decades, the advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice has given arguments about responsibility a legal dimension, and Mission LiFE seeks to reframe the problem around consumption in rich societies; constructivists would add that the categories of 1992 are themselves contested as economies change. Postcolonial critics go further, reading carbon borders and unkept finance as a transfer of costs from North to South, though they say less about India's own rising emissions.
08India's options and the way forward
India's choices turn on how to reconcile development, credibility and leverage. One option is to hold firmly to differentiation, refusing new obligations until finance is delivered; this protects policy space and solidarity with developing countries, but risks casting India as an obstacle as its absolute emissions grow. A second is to lead by example, building on a non-fossil transition that has already run ahead of its targets and using that record to press for finance; this strengthens India's moral position but commits domestic resources without guaranteed reciprocity. A third concerns carbon borders: India can contest the EU mechanism in the WTO and in trade negotiations, or develop a domestic carbon market credible enough to reduce its exposure; the two are compatible, but the second involves domestic costs. Coalitions provide a fourth lever, through BASIC, the Like-Minded Developing Countries and India's own initiatives such as the solar alliance and the disaster-resilience coalition, though the 1992 distinction between developed and developing countries on which some of these rest is increasingly contested. On balance, India's most defensible course combines firm insistence on finance and differentiation with visible delivery at home, so that its claim to equity rests on performance as well as principle.
Key points
- Common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities is the anchor principle.
- Panchamrit at Glasgow (1 November 2021): 500 GW non-fossil capacity by 2030 and net zero by 2070.
- Updated NDC (August 2022): 45 per cent intensity reduction and 50 per cent non-fossil capacity by 2030.
- NDC for 2031–35 (approved March 2026): 47 per cent intensity reduction and 60 per cent non-fossil capacity by 2035.
- India rejected the Baku finance goal of USD 300 billion a year by 2035 as inadequate.
- India opposes the EU's carbon border mechanism as unilateral and discriminatory.
Debates
Is differentiated responsibility still fair when India is the third-largest emitter?
Yes: responsibility depends on cumulative and per-person emissions, on which India's record is modest, and on capability; hundreds of millions of Indians still need energy for basic development.
Less so: the atmosphere responds to total emissions; India's absolute emissions are rising fast, and the distinction between developed and developing countries drawn in 1992 no longer fits economies such as China, the Gulf states or, increasingly, India.
Should trade measures such as the carbon border mechanism be used to enforce climate goals?
Yes: without border adjustments, strict domestic carbon pricing drives industry to countries with weaker rules; the measures protect ambition and encourage others to price carbon.
No: they shift the cost of rich countries' policies onto developing exporters, ignore differentiated responsibility and finance commitments, and act as protectionism under a climate label.
Should developing countries make their climate ambition conditional on finance?
Yes: the Paris bargain combined self-determined contributions with support from those who industrialised first; the promise of USD 100 billion a year was met, by the OECD's reckoning, only in 2022, and India judged the Baku goal far too small, so conditionality is the main leverage developing countries hold.
No: the atmosphere responds to total emissions whatever the state of finance, and the International Court of Justice has held that states have obligations under international law to protect the climate system; India's own transition has run ahead of its targets, which suggests that much ambition serves national interests in any case.
A balanced answer separates the two. Finance should govern the pace of the most costly measures, while actions that serve development and energy security proceed regardless.
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
India's climate diplomacy has moved from defence to leadership without abandoning the principle of differentiation. Examine.
How to approach it
Kyoto and BASIC; Paris NDCs; Panchamrit and NDC 3.0; ISA, CDRI, LiFE; constant demand for finance.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Critically examine India's objections to the new collective quantified goal on climate finance agreed at Baku.
How to approach it
Size, sources and timeline; the USD 100 billion record; developing-country solidarity.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Discuss the implications of the EU's carbon border adjustment mechanism for India.
How to approach it
Sectors affected, WTO and CBDR arguments, domestic carbon market, the India–EU trade agreement.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
Concept
Thinker
Ideology
IB Global Politics
IB case study
Political briefing
Political Issue Dossier
Sources
- 01United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (opens in a new tab). UNFCCC
- 02Cabinet approves India's Nationally Determined Contribution (2031–2035) to be communicated to the UNFCCC (opens in a new tab). Prime Minister's Office, March 2026
- 03India's Updated First Nationally Determined Contribution under the Paris Agreement. Government of India, August 2022
- 04Obligations of States in respect of Climate Change, Advisory Opinion. International Court of Justice, 23 July 2025
- 05COP to be hosted by Türkiye with Australia leading negotiations (opens in a new tab). Minister for Foreign Affairs, Australia
- 06Navroz K. Dubash (ed.), India in a Warming World: Integrating Climate Change and Development (2019)