Skip to content

International relations theory

Alexander Wendt

Constructivist theorist who argued that "anarchy is what states make of it": the meaning of the international system depends on shared ideas, identities and practices.

Thinker dossier

born 1958

Key works
'The Agent–Structure Problem in International Relations Theory' · 1987'Anarchy is What States Make of It: The Social Construction of Power Politics' · 1992'Collective Identity Formation and the International State' · 1994
Key concepts
Anarchy is what states make of it · Three cultures of anarchy · Mutual constitution · Degrees of internalisation · Master variables of collective identity

Start here:An introduction

1 min read

Alexander Wendt, born in Mainz in 1958 and trained in the United States, became the political scientist most closely associated with constructivism in International Relations. His question is easy to state and hard to answer: why do states treat one another as enemies, rivals or friends? Realists replied that anarchy, the absence of a world government, forces every state to arm, to distrust others and to balance against them. Wendt answered that anarchy has no fixed logic. Weapons, borders and wealth matter, but what they mean depends on the ideas states share about one another, and those ideas are made and remade through interaction.

A student should care because the argument changes what counts as an explanation in world politics. Hostility and cooperation become things to be explained rather than assumed, and the end of the Cold War, the European Union or India's shifting relations with its neighbours become puzzles about identity as well as power.

How to read this profile

The introduction is the first reading. The seventeen parts below are the full study of Alexander Wendt, in five movements, about 11 minutes in all. Parts marked Advanced analysis (5, 11 and 12) weigh and contest the arguments: read them once the rest is secure.

Parts 1–4

Movement I: Foundations

The thinker in time: the setting, the influences, the works and the principal arguments.

01Historical context

Wendt wrote as the Cold War ended in a way that neither neorealism nor neoliberalism had anticipated: a superpower transformed its own identity and the rivalry dissolved. Drawing on social theory, including Anthony Giddens's structuration theory and scientific realism, he offered a way of taking ideas seriously without abandoning the scientific ambitions of mainstream IR.

The discipline he addressed was divided. In the 'neo–neo' debate of the 1980s, neorealists and neoliberal institutionalists disagreed about how much states could cooperate but shared a rationalist starting point: states as given actors with given interests. Critical theorists and post-structuralists, whom Robert Keohane grouped as 'reflectivists' in 1988, rejected that starting point but were accused of offering no research programme. Wendt's work set out to occupy the ground between them, and it made constructivism one of the three main approaches taught in IR by the end of the 1990s.

Life and intellectual formation

Born in Mainz, West Germany, in 1958, Wendt studied at Macalester College and took his doctorate at the University of Minnesota. At Minnesota he worked with Raymond Duvall, with whom he later wrote on institutions and sovereignty. He taught at Yale, Dartmouth and the University of Chicago before moving to Ohio State University. His 1992 article in International Organization made his name; Social Theory of International Politics (1999), a systematic restatement, became one of the most cited books in the discipline. His later work turned to the possibility of a world state and to the bearing of quantum physics on social science.

02Intellectual influences

Wendt assembled his constructivism from social theory more than from earlier IR. From Anthony Giddens's structuration theory (The Constitution of Society, 1984) he took the idea that agents and structures constitute each other, the theme of his 1987 article. From the scientific realism of Roy Bhaskar and others he took the claim that unobservable entities, such as states or the international system, can be real and have causal powers, which let him treat ideas as causes without becoming a pure interpretivist. From George Herbert Mead's symbolic interactionism he took a model of identity formed in interaction: actors learn who they are by taking the role of the other, which becomes his account of how enmity and friendship are learnt. His later work on a world state draws on Hegel's struggle for recognition, read through Axel Honneth.

Within IR he built on the first constructivists, Nicholas Onuf (World of Our Making, 1989), Friedrich Kratochwil and John Ruggie. The theory he reacted against was Kenneth Waltz's Theory of International Politics (1979), which he read as both individualist (structure as the unintended product of self-interested units) and materialist (structure as the distribution of capabilities). He also answered Robert Keohane's 1988 challenge to 'reflective' scholars to produce a research programme able to compete with rationalist institutionalism. His three cultures of anarchy recall the English School's three traditions of Hobbes, Grotius and Kant in Martin Wight's teaching, though Wendt grounds them in a different social theory.

03Major works

  1. 1987'The Agent–Structure Problem in International Relations Theory'International Organization. Uses structuration theory and scientific realism to argue that neither Waltz's structures nor rational-choice agents can be explained alone.
  2. 1992'Anarchy is What States Make of It: The Social Construction of Power Politics'International Organization. Self-help as an institution produced by interaction, not a logical consequence of anarchy.
  3. 1994'Collective Identity Formation and the International State'American Political Science Review. How collective identities among states can form.
  4. 1995'Constructing International Politics'International Security. Reply to Mearsheimer's critique of institutions and critical theory.
  5. 1999Social Theory of International PoliticsThe systematic statement: ideas and structure, states as actors, the three cultures of anarchy and the conditions of structural change.
  6. 2003'Why a World State is Inevitable'European Journal of International Relations. A teleological argument from the struggle for recognition.
  7. 2004'The State as Person in International Theory'Review of International Studies. Defends treating states as real corporate persons.
  8. 2015Quantum Mind and Social ScienceArgues that consciousness and social life are quantum-mechanical phenomena; a departure from his earlier IR work.

04Principal arguments

Wendt's central claim is that the structures of international politics are social as well as material. Material capabilities matter, but their meaning depends on ideas: five hundred British nuclear weapons, he observed in 'Constructing International Politics' (1995), are less threatening to the United States than five North Korean ones, because of the relationship in which they sit. Agents and structures are mutually constituted: states' practices create the structures that in turn shape their identities and interests.

Self-help and power politics are therefore not logical consequences of anarchy but institutions produced by interaction. Social Theory of International Politics describes three cultures of anarchy: a Hobbesian culture in which states see each other as enemies, a Lockean culture of rivals who accept each other's existence, and a Kantian culture of friends who settle disputes without war. Each culture can be internalised to different degrees, through force, self-interest or belief in its legitimacy.

Collective identity can grow when four "master variables" are present: interdependence, common fate, homogeneity and self-restraint. Wendt called his position a via media between rationalism and post-structuralism, accepting a scientific realist view of knowledge.

The argument has a practical edge. If self-help is an institution rather than a law of nature, it is reproduced by practice: states that treat each other as enemies confirm each other's fears, a self-fulfilling prophecy. The same mechanism can work in the other direction, so that sustained cooperation and restraint can change identities over time. Cultures are sticky once internalised, which is why change is slow, but they are not fixed.

On human nature

Wendt does not derive international politics from human nature and rejects the classical realist move from a selfish or power-seeking human nature to conflict among states. He allows a thin material base, which he calls 'rump materialism': human nature, geography, technology and the distribution of capabilities set limits and create possibilities. What they mean for behaviour depends on shared ideas. People and the states they compose need security, recognition and self-esteem, but whether those needs produce enmity or cooperation is decided in interaction, not by nature.

Parts 5–10

Movement II: Theory

What the thinker added to political theory, the concepts they defined, and their positions on the state, power, liberty, equality, justice and democracy.

05Major theoretical contributions

Advanced analysis

Wendt's first contribution was to give International Relations a social ontology. Neorealists and neoliberals disagreed about cooperation but shared a rationalist picture of states with given interests; their critics rejected that picture but offered no research programme. Drawing on Giddens's structuration theory and on scientific realism, Wendt argued that agents and structures constitute each other and that ideas constitute interests as well as causing behaviour, which made identity a subject for the ordinary methods of social science.

His second was to turn anarchy from a constant into a variable. The three cultures of anarchy, Hobbesian, Lockean and Kantian, each held in place by force, self-interest or belief in its legitimacy, gave the discipline a vocabulary for comparing kinds of international system, and his four master variables of collective identity named the conditions under which a system might move from one culture to another.

Third, he defended treating the state as a real corporate agent with interests of its own, and added collective self-esteem to the standard list of national interests. Finally, his argument that a world state is inevitable reopened, from within mainstream theory, the old question of whether international politics has a direction.

06Conceptual definitions

Anarchy is what states make of it

The claim that the absence of world government has no fixed logic; its consequences depend on the identities and practices of states.

Three cultures of anarchy

Hobbesian (enemies), Lockean (rivals) and Kantian (friends): shared understandings that structure relations among states.

Mutual constitution

Agents and structures produce and reproduce each other, so neither can be explained without the other.

Degrees of internalisation

A culture of anarchy can be held in place by force, by self-interest or by acceptance of its legitimacy; the deeper the internalisation, the more stable the culture.

Master variables of collective identity

Interdependence, common fate and homogeneity, which can encourage states to identify with one another, and self-restraint, which allows them to trust that identification.

Corporate and social identity

A state's corporate identity rests on its own body and organisation and gives it basic interests; its social identities, such as rival or friend, are formed in relation to others.

07Theory of the State

Wendt is unusually explicit that states are real actors. In Social Theory of International Politics and 'The State as Person in International Theory' (2004) he argues that the state is a corporate agent with a body (a population and territory organised by a legal order claiming a monopoly of legitimate force) and with intentions, not merely a fiction. Its corporate identity gives it four national interests: physical survival, autonomy, economic well-being and collective self-esteem, the last his addition to a list taken from Alexander George and Robert Keohane. What these interests require, and whether others threaten them, depends on the social identities states acquire. Sovereignty is itself an institution that exists because states recognise one another's claims.

08Theory of Power

Material power is real but underdetermines outcomes. The distribution of capabilities affects behaviour only through the distribution of interests and identities: the same arsenal is a threat or a reassurance depending on who holds it and how the relationship is understood. Wendt reverses the realist order of explanation: ideas largely constitute what power means and what states want, so a balance of power is a social fact as well as a material one. Security dilemmas are therefore made, and can in principle be unmade, which is the basis of his account of security communities.

10Justice and democracy

Democracy

Wendt has no theory of democracy as such, but regime type enters his account through identity. A state's type identity, as a democracy, a monarchy or a communist state, shapes how others perceive it, and homogeneity of type is one of his master variables: states that see one another as alike find a collective identity easier to form. Social Theory of International Politics examines how capitalism and democracy helped produce a Kantian culture among Western states, in which disputes are settled without war and members come to one another's aid. The constructivist implication is that peace among democracies rests on shared identity and its internalisation rather than on regime type alone, so it is real but neither automatic nor permanent.

Parts 11–12

Movement III: Critique

How the arguments have been attacked, and how scholars read them differently.

11Criticisms

Advanced analysis

  1. 01

    John Mearsheimer, Dale Copeland and other realists

    Mearsheimer's 'The False Promise of International Institutions' (1994–95) argued that because states can never be certain of others' intentions, ideas cannot override the security imperatives of anarchy. Copeland's review of Social Theory (2000) sharpened the point: even if a rival is benign today, no state can know what its intentions will be in twenty years, so the uncertainty that drives balancing is built into anarchy rather than produced by a particular culture.

  2. 02

    Critical constructivists and post-structuralists

    Steve Smith, Friedrich Kratochwil and Maja Zehfuss argue that Wendt's state-centrism, his treatment of states as unitary persons with identities formed before interaction, and his scientific realism concede too much to the mainstream, and leave out language, discourse and the power to define identities.

  3. 03

    The theory explains change more readily after the fact than before it. It can redescribe the end of the Cold War as a change of identity, but it says less about when identities shift and why some Hobbesian relationships persist despite deep interdependence.

  4. 04

    Feminist and postcolonial scholars

    Treating the state as a person with a corporate identity abstracts from who speaks for the state and whose identity counts. Feminist and postcolonial writers ask whether a theory that describes the history of anarchy largely through European cases, and treats states as the only persons that matter, can account for empire, race and gender in the making of international order.

12Scholarly debates

Advanced analysis

How scholars have read Alexander Wendt differently. An answer that names the reading it follows is stronger than one that treats the text as settled.

  1. The via media reading

    On this reading, which is Wendt's own, constructivism is a social ontology rather than a rival substantive theory: it says what the international system is made of and leaves room for causal explanation by ordinary social-scientific methods. Emanuel Adler's 'Seizing the Middle Ground' (1997) and Ted Hopf's distinction between conventional and critical constructivism (1998) placed Wendt at the conventional end, able to talk to rationalists. James Fearon and Wendt, in 'Rationalism v. Constructivism: A Skeptical View' (2002), went further, arguing that the two are better treated as tools for different questions than as incompatible world views.

  2. The critical reading: constructivism domesticated

    Critics to Wendt's left argue that the middle ground does not hold. Steve Smith ('Wendt's World', 2000) and Friedrich Kratochwil ('Constructing a New Orthodoxy?', 2000) objected that scientific realism and a positivist idea of explanation sit uneasily with the claim that social reality consists of shared meanings. Maja Zehfuss (Constructivism in International Relations, 2002) argued that Wendt's 'corporate' state, which exists before any interaction, brings back the given actor he set out to explain. On this reading Wendt made constructivism acceptable to the American mainstream at the price of its critical edge.

  3. The teleological reading

    A third reading follows the direction of Wendt's later work. 'Why a World State is Inevitable' (2003) argues that the struggle of individuals and groups for recognition, together with the growing destructiveness of war, drives the system through stages towards a world state. Read back into Social Theory, the three cultures look like a progressive sequence from Hobbes to Kant. Critics such as Vaughn Shannon (2005) replied that a theory built on agency and contingency cannot predict an inevitable end point, and that Wendt's own account allows cultures to persist for centuries or slide backwards.

Parts 13–15

Movement IV: Legacy

Why the thinker matters now, whom they connect with, and the arguments applied in India and beyond.

13Contemporary relevance

Wendt is the standard reference for constructivism, which the IB guide lists among the theories students should review, and for the idea that Sovereignty and Security are social institutions. PSIR answers on approaches to IR increasingly use him to evaluate realism: he does not deny that power politics exists, but asks how it is produced and how it might be changed.

The argument is tested by current events in both directions. Russia's relations with the West moved from partnership in the 1990s to open hostility, and the United States and China are debating whether their relationship is a rivalry between states that accept each other or something closer to enmity. Constructivists read these as shifts in identity and mutual representation; realists read them as the return of material competition. A strong answer uses the case to weigh the two.

14Connections with other thinkers

Each connection recorded in this profile, by relation: who shaped Alexander Wendt, whom Alexander Wendt shaped, and who argued with or against them.

Influenced

  • Qin Yaqing1953

    Qin Yaqing engaged closely with Wendt's work before developing a relational theory rooted in Chinese thought.

In contrast with

  • Robert O. Keohane1941

    He accepted Keohane's interest in institutions but treated interests as constructed rather than given.

Critic of

  • Kenneth N. Waltz1924

    Wendt framed constructivism as a response to Waltz's materialist account of anarchy.

Criticised by

  • John J. Mearsheimer1947

    Mearsheimer's "The False Promise of International Institutions" criticised critical and constructivist theories.

Also recorded on other profiles

Connections that other profiles in the Atlas make to Alexander Wendt, read from Alexander Wendt’s side. Their notes are on those profiles.

Influenced by
Thomas Hobbes

15Indian and international applications

In India

India–China relations moved from the "brotherhood" rhetoric and the Panchsheel agreement of 1954 to war in 1962, an example of how a relationship's culture can change in a few years. India–Pakistan relations are often described as Hobbesian, yet even there practices such as the 1988 agreement not to attack each other's nuclear installations, with lists exchanged every January, show a Lockean element: rivals who accept each other's existence. Constructivists also read non-alignment and strategic autonomy as identity commitments rooted in anti-colonial nationalism, not only as calculations of power.

In the world

The transformation of Franco-German relations after 1945 into a security community is the classic Kantian case; ASEAN's norms of non-interference and consultation show identity-based regional order.

Parts 16–17

Movement V: Examination

Where the thinker sits in the syllabus, and what UPSC has asked.

16Exact syllabus mapping

  1. PSIR Optional

    Paper II · Part A · Comparative Politics and International Relations

    Approaches to the Study of International Relations

    Approaches to the Study of International Relations: Idealist, Realist, Marxist, Functionalist and Systems theory.

    Official wording · 6 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  2. PSIR Optional

    Paper II · Part A · Comparative Politics and International Relations

    Key Concepts in International Relations

    Key concepts in International Relations: National interest, security and power; Balance of power and deterrence; Transnational actors and collective security; World capitalist economy and globalisation.

    Official wording · 10 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  3. IB Global Politics

    Core topics

    Sovereignty in global politics

    The nature of state sovereignty (traditional and modern notions, sources, internal and external dimensions) and challenges to state sovereignty.

    Paraphrase of the prescribed topic (this platform)

    In the course outlineWhere it is taught
  4. IB Global Politics

    Core topics

    Theoretical perspectives in global politics

    Theories, models and analytical frameworks; their use and applicability to political issues; their bias and limitations.

    Paraphrase of the prescribed topic (this platform)

    In the course outlineWhere it is taught

The syllabus lines this profile of Alexander Wendt serves. Progress is kept on this device and gathered on your dashboard.

17Related PYQs (official wording)

No linked question yet

None of the questions in the PYQ dataset is linked to Alexander Wendt, so none is shown here. The practice questions further down are original to this platform, not previous year questions.

Dataset searched: Nine official papers, 228 questions: GS Paper II, PSIR Paper I, PSIR Paper II, 2024–2026.

Browse every question in PYQ Intelligence

Using Wendt in an answer

Wendt is most useful in Paper II answers on approaches to the study of International Relations and on key concepts such as national interest, security and power, where he supplies the standard constructivist critique of realism. Because the syllabus does not list constructivism among the approaches, he works best as an evaluative lens rather than as a stand-alone topic. In IB Global Politics he is the reference point for constructivism and for the claim that sovereignty is a social institution.

Lead with two arguments: anarchy has no fixed logic, because its consequences depend on the identities and practices of states; and the three cultures of anarchy, Hobbesian enemies, Lockean rivals and Kantian friends, can be internalised through force, self-interest or belief in their legitimacy. Pair him with Waltz, whose materialist account of structure he answers, and with Mearsheimer, whose point that states can never be certain of others' intentions is the sharpest realist reply. The evaluative move is to concede that cultures are sticky and change slow, then show with the Franco-German security community, or the turn in relations between India and China, that identities and interests do change. Close with the criticism that the theory explains change better after the event than before.

Avoid three misuses. Wendt does not say that material power is irrelevant, only that it acquires meaning through relationships. Constructivism is not idealism under a new name. And his treatment of the state as a unitary person is itself contested by critical constructivists and by feminist and postcolonial scholars.

Practice questions (original)

  1. Q1PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    "Anarchy is what states make of it." Examine Wendt's argument and its implications for realism.

    How to approach it

    Explain mutual constitution and the three cultures; contrast with Waltz; illustrate with the end of the Cold War or South Asia.

  2. Q2IB Paper 2 style15 marks

    To what extent are national interests shaped by identity rather than by material power?

    How to approach it

    Use constructivist and realist explanations of the same case; consider how identities change and how material power constrains them.

  3. Q3PSIR style10 marks· 150 words

    Distinguish the Hobbesian, Lockean and Kantian cultures of anarchy. Which best describes India's relations with its neighbours?

    How to approach it

    Define each culture by the role states assign one another (enemy, rival, friend) and the degree of internalisation; apply to two contrasting relationships; note the limits of the typology.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Sources and further reading

  1. 01Alexander Wendt, 'Anarchy is What States Make of It', International Organization (1992)
  2. 02Alexander Wendt, Social Theory of International Politics (1999)
  3. 03Alexander Wendt, 'Constructing International Politics', International Security (1995)
  4. 04Ted Hopf, 'The Promise of Constructivism in International Relations Theory', International Security (1998)
  5. 05Maja Zehfuss, Constructivism in International Relations: The Politics of Reality (2002)
  6. 06Stefano Guzzini and Anna Leander (eds), Constructivism and International Relations: Alexander Wendt and His Critics (2006)
  7. 07Alexander Wendt, 'Why a World State is Inevitable', European Journal of International Relations 9:4 (2003) (opens in a new tab). European Journal of International Relations, 2003
  8. 08Vaughn P. Shannon, 'Wendt's Violation of the Constructivist Project: Agency and Why a World State is Not Inevitable', European Journal of International Relations (2005), 2005