Landmark judgment · 1970
R.C. Cooper (Bank Nationalisation case)
By ten to one, the Court struck down the 1969 bank nationalisation law for failing to provide compensation on relevant principles and for hostile discrimination, and rejected the view that each Fundamental Right operates in its own compartment.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 10 February 1970
- Bench
- 11-judge Constitution Bench
- Citation
- (1970) 1 SCC 248
- Doctrine
- Effect test; rejection of the compartmentalisation of Fundamental Rights
01The constitutional issue
On 19 July 1969 the President promulgated an ordinance nationalising fourteen major commercial banks, followed by the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1969. R.C. Cooper, a shareholder and director, challenged the law under Article 14, Article 19(1)(f) and (g) and Article 31(2).
02The decision
Shah J, for the majority, held the Act invalid. The compensation it provided was not determined on principles relevant to the value of what was taken — goodwill and other assets were left out — so the guarantee in Article 31(2) was violated. The Act also discriminated: the named banks were barred from carrying on banking business at all, while other banks were not, which was hostile discrimination under Article 14.
More broadly, the Court rejected the approach of A.K. Gopalan. The validity of a law is judged by its direct and inevitable effect on Fundamental Rights, not by its object or form, and Articles 19 and 31 are not mutually exclusive. A.N. Ray J dissented.
03Significance
The judgment pitted the property guarantee against the government's flagship economic measure and helped turn the 1971 election into a contest between the Court's reading of the Constitution and Parliament's. Its critics saw a Court defending concentrated wealth; its defenders saw an insistence that even popular policies follow constitutional rules. Doctrinally, its rejection of compartmentalisation was the more lasting achievement, completed by Maneka Gandhi.
04What happened afterwards
Parliament re-enacted nationalisation in 1970 with specified compensation. The 25th Amendment (1971) replaced "compensation" with "amount" in Article 31(2) and inserted Article 31C; Kesavananda upheld the change. The 44th Amendment (1978) removed the right to property from Part III and made it a constitutional right under Article 300A.
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: 1970; eleven judges; 10:1; Ray J's dissent; the 25th Amendment. In Mains, use it in the history of the right to property and of the integrated reading of Fundamental Rights.
Explore further
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 14 · Equality before law
- Article 19 · Protection of certain rights regarding freedom of speech, etc.
- Article 31 · Compulsory acquisition of property
- Article 31C · Saving of laws giving effect to certain directive principles
- Article 300A · Persons not to be deprived of property save by authority of law
- Article 123 · Power of President to promulgate Ordinances during recess of Parliament
Amendment
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 10 February 1970. Supreme Court of India
- 02Granville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution: The Indian Experience (Oxford University Press, 1999)
- 03Rustom Cavasjee Cooper v. Union of India, (1970) 1 SCC 248: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India