Skip to content

The Constitution (Thirty-ninth Amendment) Act, 1975

39th Amendment (1975)

The amendment that placed the elections of the Prime Minister and the Speaker beyond judicial challenge and voided the pending appeal on Indira Gandhi's election.

01Context

On 12 June 1975 the Allahabad High Court, in an election petition filed by Raj Narain, set aside Indira Gandhi's 1971 election to the Lok Sabha for electoral malpractice and disqualified her for six years. The Supreme Court granted only a conditional stay, and her appeal was pending when the Emergency was proclaimed. Parliament passed the Thirty-ninth Amendment in August 1975, days before the appeal was to be heard.

02What it changed

  • Article 71 substituted so that disputes about the election of a President or Vice-President would be decided by an authority set up by law, not necessarily the Supreme Court.
  • Article 329A inserted: disputes about the election of a person who was Prime Minister or Speaker at the time of the election, or became one later, could be decided only by an authority created by Parliament, and the existing election law would not apply to them.
  • Clause (4) of article 329A declared the High Court's judgment void and the election of the Prime Minister valid, notwithstanding any court order.
  • Election laws, including the amendments of 1974 and 1975 to the election law, placed in the Ninth Schedule.

03Political and constitutional significance

The amendment was the clearest attempt in Indian history to use the amending power to decide a particular dispute in favour of the person holding power. In striking down clause (4), the Supreme Court applied the basic structure doctrine for the first time to invalidate a constitutional amendment, holding that free and fair elections, the rule of law and judicial review are part of that structure. The judgment confirmed that Kesavananda Bharati was not a dead letter, even in the Emergency.

04Judicial interpretation

In Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (7 November 1975) the Supreme Court struck down article 329A(4) as destroying the basic structure, while upholding the Prime Minister's election under the amended election laws. Article 329A was omitted by the Forty-fourth Amendment, which also restored the Supreme Court's jurisdiction under article 71.

Why it matters for UPSC

Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain is a staple of questions on the basic structure doctrine. Candidates should explain which part of the amendment was struck down and why, note that the election was nonetheless upheld under the retrospectively amended election law, and link the episode to the Forty-fourth Amendment's omission of article 329A.

Sources