Landmark judgment · 2010
B.P. Singhal (Governors' Removal case)
The Court held that although Governors hold office at the President's pleasure, they cannot be removed arbitrarily or merely because their views differ from those of the Union government, and that removals are open to limited judicial review.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 7 May 2010
- Bench
- 5-judge Constitution Bench
- Citation
- (2010) 6 SCC 331
- Doctrine
- Limits on the pleasure doctrine
01The constitutional issue
In July 2004, soon after a change of government at the Centre, the Governors of Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat, Haryana and Goa were removed. B.P. Singhal, a member of Parliament, filed a public interest petition asking whether the pleasure doctrine in Article 156(1) is subject to any limits.
02The decision
R.V. Raveendran J, for a unanimous Court, held that in a constitutional democracy the pleasure doctrine is not unfettered. The President, acting on ministerial advice, may remove a Governor at any time without notice or stated reasons, but not arbitrarily, capriciously or unreasonably. A Governor is not an agent of the Union government and cannot be removed merely for being out of step with its policies or ideology, or because it has lost political confidence in him; there must be a compelling reason.
Removal is open to judicial review on limited grounds. A petitioner must first show a prima facie case of arbitrariness, after which the Union must disclose its reasons. The Court laid down these principles without examining the individual removals of 2004.
03Significance
The judgment rejected the idea that the Governor is a political appointee who must change with the Union government, and aligned the law with the Sarkaria Commission's recommendations. In practice its effect has been modest: changes of government at the Centre have continued to be followed by resignations and transfers of Governors, and the burden on a challenger is hard to discharge.
04What happened afterwards
The Punchhi Commission (2010) proposed that a Governor be removable only by a resolution of the State Legislature. The Court's later decisions on Governors' conduct — Nabam Rebia (2016), the Punjab case (2023) and State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu (2025) — have built on the premise that the Governor is a constitutional office, not a Union functionary.
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: 2010; Article 156(1); pleasure doctrine; limited review. In Mains, use it with the Sarkaria and Punchhi recommendations on the Governor's tenure and independence.
Explore further
Concept
Polity & Governance
Article
Judgment
Institution
Political briefing
Political Issue Dossier
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 7 May 2010. Supreme Court of India
- 02Report of the Commission on Centre–State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988
- 03B.P. Singhal v. Union of India, (2010) 6 SCC 331: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India