Section A · Constitutional Foundations
Historical Background of the Constitution
How a century and a half of colonial statutes, and the national movement's answer to them, built the machinery the Constituent Assembly inherited and defined what it chose to reject.
Overview
The Constitution of 1950 was written by an Indian assembly, but much of its machinery had been assembled by the British Parliament between 1773 and 1935. Each colonial statute answered a problem of control: first over the East India Company, then over a subject population that demanded a share of power. Representation was conceded in measured doses, and always as a grant from Westminster.
The national movement answered with a constitutional tradition of its own, built around rights, responsible government and a constitution made by Indians. The Constitution kept much of the colonial state's administrative skeleton while reversing its source of authority, from the British Parliament to "We, the people of India".
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Article 395
- Repeals the Indian Independence Act, 1947 and the Government of India Act, 1935 (with the Acts amending it), but not the Abolition of Privy Council Jurisdiction Act, 1949.
- Preamble
- Locates the Constitution's authority in the people of India, not in any Act of the British Parliament.
Company rule and the centralising statutes, 1773–1853
The Regulating Act, 1773, Parliament's first attempt to regulate the East India Company, made the Governor of Bengal the Governor-General of Bengal (Warren Hastings), subordinated Bombay and Madras, and led to a Supreme Court at Calcutta in 1774. Pitt's India Act, 1784 set up a Board of Control beside the Court of Directors, separating the Company's political from its commercial functions ("double government").
The Charter Act, 1833 made the Governor-General of Bengal the Governor-General of India (Lord William Bentinck), concentrated legislative power in him and ended the Company's trade. The Charter Act, 1853 separated the council's legislative and executive functions and opened the civil service to competition. The legacy was an executive-led state in which legislation was a function of government rather than a check on it.
Crown rule and the politics of representation, 1858–1909
After 1857 the Government of India Act, 1858 transferred power to the Crown, created a Secretary of State with a fifteen-member Council of India, and restyled the Governor-General as Viceroy. The Indian Councils Act, 1861 brought nominated Indians into the legislative council, restored legislative powers to Bombay and Madras, recognised the portfolio system and allowed the Viceroy to issue ordinances.
The Indian Councils Act, 1892 permitted discussion of the budget and questions, with members chosen on the recommendation of bodies such as municipalities and chambers of commerce. The Indian Councils Act, 1909 (Morley–Minto) enlarged the councils and created a separate electorate for Muslims; Satyendra Prasad Sinha joined the Viceroy's Executive Council. Representation now meant the representation of communities and interests, not of citizens, an idea that shaped every later argument about minorities.
Dyarchy and the Act of 1919
The Montagu declaration of August 1917 promised "the progressive realisation of responsible government". The Government of India Act, 1919 split provincial subjects into transferred subjects, run by the Governor with ministers responsible to the legislative council, and reserved subjects, kept with the Governor and his executive council. This was dyarchy: responsibility for some subjects, none for others.
At the centre it created a bicameral legislature, mostly directly elected on a franchise limited by property, tax and education. Separate electorates were extended to Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians and Europeans, and a public service commission followed in 1926. The statutory review it required produced the all-British Simon Commission of 1927, whose boycott, and the Nehru Report of 1928, marked the point at which Indians began drafting constitutions of their own.
The Government of India Act, 1935
The Government of India Act, 1935 was the most direct ancestor of the Constitution. It proposed an All-India Federation of provinces and princely states, which never came into being because the states did not accede. It divided legislative power into Federal, Provincial and Concurrent Lists, left residuary power with the Governor-General, and replaced dyarchy in the provinces with provincial autonomy; the 1937 elections produced Congress ministries in most provinces. Dyarchy was planned for the centre but never operated.
The Act created the Federal Court (1937) and public service commissions, abolished the Council of India, and extended separate electorates to the depressed classes, women and labour after the Communal Award and Poona Pact of 1932. Its Governor kept discretion and "special responsibilities", and Section 93 let him take over a province whose government could not be carried on, the clearest ancestor of Article 356.
The nationalist constitutional tradition
The Commonwealth of India Bill (1925), associated with Annie Besant, and the Nehru Report (1928) set out Indian schemes with declarations of rights, responsible government and joint electorates. The Karachi Resolution of 1931 joined civil liberties to commitments on labour and the economy, foreshadowing the pairing of Parts III and IV.
The demand that Indians alone should frame their constitution was first put by M.N. Roy in 1934, adopted by the Congress in 1935 and accepted in principle by the British in the August Offer of 1940. Fundamental rights were therefore no foreign implant: arbitrary colonial power, from the Rowlatt Act (1919) onwards, had made them a central nationalist demand.
From the Cabinet Mission to the Independence Act, 1946–47
After the Cripps proposals of 1942 were rejected, the Cabinet Mission of 1946 proposed a limited Union, groupings of provinces and a Constituent Assembly elected by the provincial assemblies. The Mountbatten Plan of 3 June 1947 accepted partition.
The Indian Independence Act, 1947 (royal assent 18 July 1947) created two dominions from 15 August 1947, abolished the Secretary of State, ended British paramountcy over the princely states, made the Governor-General and Governors constitutional heads, and empowered each Constituent Assembly to repeal any Act of the British Parliament, including the Independence Act itself. Article 395 used that power. Repealing the 1935 and 1947 Acts, rather than resting on them, asserted autochthony: a constitution that owes its validity to no foreign legislature.
Debates
Was the Constitution a continuation of the Government of India Act, 1935 or a break from it?
The continuity case is strong on machinery: the three lists, the appointed Governor, the emergency and breakdown powers, the public service commissions, the Federal Court's design and the all-India civil service all passed into the Constitution, and several Assembly members called the draft the old Act reworked.
The case for rupture rests on authority and purpose. The 1935 Act was a grant from Westminster on a propertied franchise; the Constitution claimed the people's authority, enfranchised every adult, made rights enforceable against the legislature, ended separate electorates and created a republic. A balanced answer sees institutional continuity serving new ends, and notes that the inheritance caused most trouble where colonial machinery was used in a colonial spirit, as with Article 356 before 1994.
Did colonial communal representation shape the Constitution's approach to minorities?
One reading holds that separate electorates, from 1909 to 1935, hardened communal identity into a political category and fed the logic of partition, so the Assembly was right to end reserved seats for religious minorities in 1949 and build representation around the individual citizen.
The opposing reading notes that this left religious minorities with no guaranteed share of seats, while Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes kept reserved constituencies, a settlement rooted in the Poona Pact compromise between Gandhi and Ambedkar. Representing minorities in a majoritarian electoral system was not simply a colonial problem, and it did not disappear with separate electorates.
Commissions and committees
Simon Commission1927
Statutory commission under the 1919 Act, with no Indian member. Its report (1930) recommended abolishing dyarchy, extending responsible government in the provinces, a federation including the princely states, and retaining communal electorates.
Nehru Report1928
Committee of the All Parties Conference chaired by Motilal Nehru. Proposed dominion status, a declaration of fundamental rights, joint electorates with reserved seats for minorities, and linguistic provinces.
Sapru Committee1945
Non-party committee chaired by Tej Bahadur Sapru. Its constitutional proposals divided rights into justiciable and non-justiciable categories, the distinction later drawn between Parts III and IV.
Prelims points
- Regulating Act, 1773: Governor-General of Bengal; Supreme Court at Calcutta established in 1774.
- Pitt's India Act, 1784: Board of Control alongside the Court of Directors ("double government").
- Charter Act, 1833: Governor-General of India (Lord William Bentinck); the Company's commercial functions ended.
- Charter Act, 1853: legislative and executive functions separated; open competition for the civil service.
- Indian Councils Act, 1909: separate electorate for Muslims; S.P. Sinha first Indian on the Viceroy's Executive Council.
- Government of India Act, 1919: provincial dyarchy; bicameral central legislature; public service commission (1926).
- Government of India Act, 1935: three lists; provincial autonomy; Federal Court (1937); the Federation never came into being.
- Indian Independence Act, 1947: royal assent 18 July 1947; repealed with the 1935 Act by Article 395.
- A constituent assembly was first demanded by M.N. Roy (1934) and accepted in principle in the August Offer (1940).
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
The Government of India Act, 1935 supplied the machinery of the Constitution but not its political philosophy. Examine.
How to approach it
Name specific borrowings (lists, Governor, Section 93 and Article 356, service commissions, Federal Court) and departures (popular sovereignty, adult franchise, enforceable rights, the end of separate electorates). Conclude on where inherited machinery carried inherited habits.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Trace how the principle of representation changed between the Indian Councils Act, 1861 and the Indian Independence Act, 1947.
How to approach it
Move from nomination (1861) to recommendation (1892), communal electorates (1909 onwards), a restricted direct franchise (1919, 1935) and an indirectly elected Assembly (1946), noting who was excluded at each stage.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Why did the framers repeal the Indian Independence Act, 1947 in Article 395? Discuss the idea of constitutional autochthony.
How to approach it
Explain legal continuity, the Assembly's power under the 1947 Act and the choice to rest the Constitution on the people; contrast dominion constitutions that remained Acts of Westminster.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
Amendment
Political system
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02Constituent Assembly Debates (Official Report), 1946–1950. Lok Sabha Secretariat
- 03Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation (1966). Oxford University Press
- 04B. Shiva Rao (ed.), The Framing of India's Constitution: Select Documents (1966–68). Indian Institute of Public Administration
- 05A.B. Keith, A Constitutional History of India, 1600–1935 (1936)