Skip to content

Five-minute module · Thinker

Ambedkar on constitutional morality

Why Ambedkar thought a democratic constitution could fail without a single article being changed, and what his idea of constitutional morality asks of those who hold power.

5 minutes5 steps3 questions to check yourself
Begin with step 1
  1. Step 1 of 5

    A borrowed phrase

    B.R. Ambedkar introduced the phrase to the Constituent Assembly on 4 November 1948, when he moved the Draft Constitution. He took it from the Victorian historian George Grote, whose History of Greece used it to explain what had made Athenian democracy workable: a paramount reverence for the forms of the constitution, combined with free speech and open criticism of those in authority, and a confidence among citizens that their political opponents would hold those forms as sacred as they did. For Grote this was a disposition, not a rule. Ambedkar's question was whether such a disposition existed in India, and what a constitution should do if it did not.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    Not a natural sentiment

    His answer was blunt: "Constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated." Indians, he said, had yet to learn it, and democracy in India was only a top-dressing on a soil that was essentially undemocratic. The claim was sociological before it was legal. A society organised by caste, which Ambedkar analysed as a system of graded inequality, does not spontaneously produce rulers and citizens who accept limits on their power over others. Constitutional morality could therefore not be presupposed, as it largely is in Britain, where unwritten conventions restrain governments. It had to be built, and the Constitution itself would have to carry part of the load.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    Why the Constitution is so detailed

    This is Ambedkar's defence of the Constitution's length. Critics in the Assembly objected that administrative details, from the public services to the conduct of elections, belonged in ordinary law. Ambedkar replied that the form of administration must be appropriate to the form of the constitution, and that it is perfectly possible to pervert a constitution without changing its form, merely by changing the form of the administration. Where constitutional morality is strong, such details can safely be left to legislatures; where it is weak, leaving them out invites a majority to hollow out the Constitution from within. Detail, on this view, stands in for a habit that India had not yet acquired.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    Three warnings of 25 November 1949

    Ambedkar's last speech to the Assembly, on 25 November 1949, turned the idea into three warnings. First, once constitutional methods are available, civil disobedience, non-cooperation and satyagraha are "the grammar of anarchy" and should be abandoned. Second, "in politics, bhakti or hero-worship is a sure road to degradation and to eventual dictatorship": following Mill, he urged citizens not to lay their liberties at the feet of even a great man. Third, political democracy cannot last without social democracy; from 26 January 1950 India would enter "a life of contradictions", with equality in politics and inequality in social and economic life. Each warning names a way in which constitutional forms survive while their spirit dies.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    The idea in the courts

    The phrase does not appear in the constitutional text, but the Supreme Court has made it a standard. Used in Ambedkar's sense, it restrains power: in Manoj Narula (2014) the Court said that constitutional morality should guide the Prime Minister's choice of ministers. Used in a newer, transformative sense, it measures laws and social practices against constitutional values: in Navtej Singh Johar (2018) constitutional rather than popular morality was the test, and in Sabarimala (2018) the majority invoked it against the exclusion of women. Critics argue that the transformative sense lets judges substitute their own morality for a legislature's or a faith's; Justice Indu Malhotra's Sabarimala dissent held that courts should not test religious practice for rationality.

The idea to keep

For Ambedkar, constitutional morality was a cultivated habit of restraint among those who hold power: respect for the Constitution's forms even when they cut against one's own interest. Judging that habit weak in India, he wrote into the text the administrative detail that older democracies leave to convention.

Check yourself

Answer each question in your own words first, then open it to compare.

  1. Q1Why did Ambedkar defend putting administrative detail into the Constitution?

    Answer

    Because constitutional morality had to be cultivated and could not be presumed. Without it, a government could pervert the Constitution without amending it, simply by changing the form of administration; detail in the text narrows that route.

  2. Q2Where did the phrase come from, and what did it mean there?

    Answer

    From George Grote's History of Greece: a paramount reverence for the forms of the constitution, combined with free criticism of those in authority and a confidence that opponents would respect those forms too.

  3. Q3How does the Supreme Court's transformative use of the phrase differ from Ambedkar's?

    Answer

    Ambedkar used it to describe restraint by those who exercise power. The Court has also used it to test laws and social practices against constitutional values, as in Navtej Singh Johar (2018), which critics say gives judges too much latitude.

These questions are original to this platform; they are not previous year questions.

Read next

Sources

  1. 01Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. VII: B.R. Ambedkar moving the Draft Constitution. Lok Sabha Secretariat, 4 November 1948
  2. 02Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. XI: B.R. Ambedkar's closing speech. Lok Sabha Secretariat, 25 November 1949
  3. 03George Grote, A History of Greece
  4. 04Pratap Bhanu Mehta, "What is constitutional morality?", Seminar 615 (opens in a new tab). Seminar, November 2010
  5. 05Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018) 10 SCC 1; Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (2019) 11 SCC 1 (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India

All five-minute modulesMy Study Desk