Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 1998

Third Judges case

Answering a presidential reference, nine judges unanimously enlarged the collegium: the Chief Justice of India must consult the four senior-most judges before recommending appointments to the Supreme Court, or the recommendation does not bind the Government.

In re Special Reference No. 1 of 1998
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
28 October 1998
Bench
9-judge bench (advisory opinion under Article 143)
Citation
(1998) 7 SCC 739
Doctrine
Collegium system

01The constitutional issue

In 1998 the Union Government and Chief Justice M.M. Punchhi disagreed over recommendations for the Supreme Court; the Government objected that colleagues had not been consulted and that seniority had been passed over.

President K.R. Narayanan referred nine questions to the Court under Article 143 on the meaning of "consultation" in Article 124, Article 217 and Article 222 as interpreted in the Second Judges case.

02The decision

The Court, in an opinion by S.P. Bharucha J, said it was clarifying, not reconsidering, the 1993 judgment. Consultation with the Chief Justice means consultation with a plurality of judges.

For appointments to the Supreme Court, the Chief Justice must consult the four senior-most puisne judges and should obtain the views of the senior-most judge from the candidate's High Court; the views are to be in writing. For High Court appointments the collegium is the Chief Justice and the two senior-most judges. Transfers of High Court judges require consultation with the four senior-most judges and the Chief Justices of the two High Courts concerned.

A recommendation made without this consultation does not bind the Government. If the majority of the collegium is against a candidate, he should not be appointed. Merit is the predominant consideration, and outstanding merit may justify departing from seniority. Judicial review is confined to whether the required consultation took place.

03Significance

The opinion institutionalised the collegium as it still works and turned the Chief Justice's primacy into a collective judgment. It answered one criticism of the 1993 system — that it concentrated power in a single judge — while deepening another: selection remained closed, with no published criteria or reasons, and depended on negotiation within the Court rather than public accountability.

04What happened afterwards

A Memorandum of Procedure adopted in 1999 operationalised the opinion. The NJAC judgment (2015) restored this system after striking down the 99th Amendment, and a revised Memorandum of Procedure has been under discussion between the Government and the judiciary since.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: advisory opinion of nine judges; a collegium of five for the Supreme Court and three for High Court appointments. Mains: the collegium, the Memorandum of Procedure and the commission alternative in judicial appointments.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

2 questions · 2025

  1. 2025 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks

    Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.

  2. 2025 · PSIR I · Q6(b) · 15 marks

    Examine the constitutional provisions and nature of advisory jurisdiction of Supreme Court of India. Evaluate your answer with relevant examples.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Third Judges case in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 28 October 1998 (advisory opinion). Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Abhinav Chandrachud, The Informal Constitution: Unwritten Criteria in Selecting Judges for the Supreme Court of India (Oxford University Press, 2014)