Section G · Local Government
Local Finance and Devolution
The three Fs of decentralisation (functions, funds and functionaries), State and Union Finance Commissions, own revenues and transfers, and why devolution to local governments remains incomplete.
Overview
Decentralisation is meaningful only if local governments have something to do, the money to do it and the people to do it with: functions, funds and functionaries, the "three Fs". The 73rd and 74th Amendments created the institutions and the fiscal machinery, including State Finance Commissions, but left the actual transfer of all three to the States.
The result is a system in which local bodies raise little of their own revenue, depend on transfers whose timing and conditions they do not control, and lack the staff to plan or deliver services. The most important recent pressure for change has come from the Union Finance Commission, which has tied its grants to conditions on the States.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Articles 243G and 243W
- States may endow panchayats and municipalities with powers and responsibilities, including Eleventh and Twelfth Schedule subjects.
- Articles 243H and 243X
- States may authorise local bodies to levy taxes, assign them State taxes and provide grants.
- Articles 243-I and 243Y
- A State Finance Commission every five years to review local finances and recommend the sharing of State revenues.
- Article 280(3)(bb) and (c)
- The Finance Commission recommends measures to augment a State's Consolidated Fund to supplement the resources of panchayats and municipalities.
Functions, funds and functionaries
The Eleventh and Twelfth Schedules list subjects that States "may" devolve. Effective devolution requires activity mapping, assigning specific tasks within each subject to each tier, followed by the transfer of the corresponding funds and staff. Most States have devolved some functions on paper, fewer have transferred funds, and fewer still have placed staff under the control of local bodies. The Ministry of Panchayati Raj's periodic ranking of States on devolution, and the Second Administrative Reforms Commission's report on local governance (2007), both identify the same gap: responsibilities assigned without the means to discharge them.
Own revenues
Panchayats may levy taxes and fees such as house tax, fees for markets and water, and in some States taxes on professions, entertainment or land; municipalities rely mainly on property tax, with fees and charges for services. In practice own revenue is small. Rates are set or capped by States, assessments are outdated, collection is weak, and elected representatives are reluctant to tax their own voters.
The GST worsened the position of many urban bodies by subsuming octroi and local entry taxes in 2017 without a guaranteed share of the new tax for local governments. Studies by the Reserve Bank of municipal (2022) and panchayat finances (2024) found both heavily dependent on transfers.
State Finance Commissions
Articles 243-I and 243Y require each State to constitute a Finance Commission every five years to recommend the distribution of State taxes and grants between the State and its local bodies, and among local bodies. The record is poor. Many States have constituted their commissions late, some have skipped cycles, reports have been delayed in reaching the legislature, and recommendations have often been ignored, with no action-taken report laid. Because the Union Finance Commission is meant to draw on State commissions' findings, their failure also weakens national fiscal planning for local government. The Fifteenth Finance Commission made the release of local body grants conditional on States constituting their commissions and acting on their reports.
The Union Finance Commission and local bodies
Since the 73rd and 74th Amendments added clauses (bb) and (c) to Article 280(3), the Finance Commission has recommended grants for local bodies, beginning with the Tenth Commission. The Fourteenth Commission (2015–20) directed its grants to gram panchayats only, as basic and performance grants. The Fifteenth Commission (2021–26) extended grants to all tiers, divided rural grants into untied (40 per cent) and tied (60 per cent, for sanitation and drinking water), added health grants channelled through local bodies, and attached entry conditions for urban bodies on audited accounts and property tax floor rates.
These conditions have done more than decades of exhortation to make States publish local accounts and constitute their finance commissions, but they also make local finance depend on conditions set in Delhi rather than on the States' own commitment.
Functionaries and capacity
Most panchayats have little staff of their own; secretaries, engineers and accountants usually belong to State departments and answer to them. Line departments run schools, health centres and irrigation in parallel with panchayats, and user committees, self-help groups and constituency development schemes for legislators create further parallel channels. Planning has been strengthened by the Gram Panchayat Development Plan process and digital tools for accounting, but plans remain constrained by tied funds.
Capacity is often cited as a reason for withholding devolution; advocates of decentralisation reply that capacity grows only when local bodies are given responsibility and resources, so the argument is circular.
Theory and practice
Fiscal federalism theory supports devolution. Wallace Oates's decentralisation theorem holds that public goods whose benefits are local are best provided by the lowest level of government able to provide them; Charles Tiebout argued that mobile residents choosing among localities reveal their preferences; and the principle of subsidiarity, prominent in the European Union, makes the same point normatively. The counter-arguments are capture by local elites, documented in India by Pranab Bardhan and Dilip Mookherjee among others, inequality between rich and poor localities, and weak accountability where voters lack information.
Indian practice shows both. Kerala's People's Plan Campaign (1996) and later reforms in Karnataka devolved substantial funds and built participatory planning; elsewhere devolution stalled. The difference lies in State political commitment, not in the constitutional text.
Debates
Should local bodies receive a constitutionally fixed share of State revenues?
A fixed share, on the model of the divisible pool for States, would give local governments predictable resources and end their dependence on discretionary State grants. States object that it would reduce their own fiscal flexibility, that capacity to spend varies widely, and that the State Finance Commission already provides a mechanism; supporters reply that the mechanism has failed precisely because its recommendations are not binding.
Is weak capacity a reason to withhold devolution or a consequence of withholding it?
Sceptics point to misuse of funds, poor accounts and elite capture as evidence that local bodies are not ready for more resources. Advocates reply that local bodies cannot build capacity without responsibility, staff and stable funding, and that the experience of States that devolved substantially shows capacity following devolution rather than preceding it. Sequenced devolution with audit and social audit is the usual compromise.
Commissions and committees
Second Administrative Reforms Commission, Sixth Report: Local Governance2007
Urged clear assignment of functions to each tier through activity mapping, matched by devolution of funds and functionaries, and stronger State Finance Commissions.
Fifteenth Finance Commission2020
Grants to all tiers of rural local bodies (60 per cent tied, 40 per cent untied), health grants through local bodies, and conditions on audited accounts, property tax floor rates and the constitution of State Finance Commissions.
Prelims points
- Articles 243-I and 243Y: State Finance Commission every five years for panchayats and municipalities.
- Article 280(3)(bb) and (c), added in 1992, require the Union Finance Commission to recommend measures for local bodies.
- Articles 243H and 243X: local taxation powers exist only if State law confers them.
- Eleventh Schedule: 29 subjects; Twelfth Schedule: 18 functions.
- The Tenth Finance Commission was the first to recommend grants for local bodies.
- The Fourteenth Finance Commission gave grants only to gram panchayats.
- Fifteenth Finance Commission: rural grants 60 per cent tied (sanitation, drinking water) and 40 per cent untied.
- Octroi and local entry taxes were subsumed in GST in 2017.
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Without the three Fs, the 73rd and 74th Amendments remain incomplete. Examine.
How to approach it
Define functions, funds and functionaries, show the gap in each with evidence, explain the role of State and Union Finance Commissions, and propose reforms.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Assess the role of State Finance Commissions in local fiscal devolution.
How to approach it
Cover their mandate, their record of delay and non-implementation, and the effect of the Fifteenth Finance Commission's conditions.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
How has the introduction of GST affected the finances of urban local bodies?
How to approach it
Explain the loss of octroi and entry tax, the absence of a local share, dependence on transfers and options such as a share of GST for cities.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 243G · Powers, authority and responsibilities of Panchayats
- Article 243H · Powers to impose taxes by, and Funds of, the Panchayats
- Article 243-I · Constitution of Finance Commission to review financial position
- Article 243W · Powers, authority and responsibilities of Municipalities, etc.
- Article 243X · Power to impose taxes by, and Funds of, the Municipalities
- Article 243Y · Finance Commission
- Article 280 · Finance Commission
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02Second Administrative Reforms Commission, Sixth Report: Local Governance (2007). Department of Administrative Reforms and Public Grievances
- 03Report of the Fifteenth Finance Commission for 2021–26 (2020). Finance Commission of India
- 04Reserve Bank of India, Report on Municipal Finances (2022). Reserve Bank of India
- 05Wallace E. Oates, Fiscal Federalism (1972)