Skip to content

The Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014

99th Amendment (2014)NJAC Amendment

The amendment that replaced the collegium system with a National Judicial Appointments Commission, struck down by the Supreme Court in 2015.

01Context

Since the Second Judges case (1993) and the Third Judges opinion (1998), appointments and transfers of Judges of the higher judiciary had been made on the recommendation of a collegium of senior Judges, a system without parallel in comparative constitutional practice and criticised for opacity. The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002) had recommended a commission. In 2014 Parliament passed the Ninety-ninth Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act almost unanimously, and more than half the States ratified it. It came into force on 13 April 2015.

02What it changed

  • Articles 124A to 124C inserted: a National Judicial Appointments Commission of the Chief Justice of India, the two next senior Judges, the Union Law Minister and two eminent persons chosen by a committee of the Prime Minister, the Chief Justice and the Leader of the Opposition.
  • The Commission to recommend appointments of the Chief Justice of India, Supreme Court Judges, High Court Chief Justices and Judges, and transfers of High Court Judges.
  • Articles 124, 127, 128, 217, 222, 224, 224A and 231 amended to replace consultation with the Chief Justice by recommendation of the Commission.

03Political and constitutional significance

The amendment was the most serious attempt to reverse the collegium system. Its defenders argued that appointments by Judges alone lacked accountability and transparency, and that every other major democracy gives the elected branches a role. The Supreme Court held that the independence of the judiciary, part of the basic structure, requires the judiciary's primacy in appointments, and that the Commission's design, in which any two members could veto a candidate, gave the executive and non-judicial members the power to block judicial choices.

04Judicial interpretation

In Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, the NJAC case (16 October 2015), a five-judge bench by four to one struck down the amendment and the NJAC Act, and the collegium system revived. Justice J. Chelameswar dissented, holding that the amendment did not destroy judicial independence.

Why it matters for UPSC

The NJAC case is central to questions on judicial independence, judicial accountability and separation of powers. Candidates should be able to compare the collegium with the NJAC and with appointment systems abroad, explain the reasoning of the majority and of Justice Chelameswar's dissent, and assess reforms such as a revised memorandum of procedure.

Sources