Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 1993

Second Judges case

Overruling the First Judges case, the Court read 'consultation' in Articles 124 and 217 to give the Chief Justice of India, acting with senior colleagues, primacy in appointing judges — the origin of the collegium.

Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
6 October 1993
Bench
9-judge Constitution Bench
Citation
(1993) 4 SCC 441
Doctrine
Primacy of the judiciary in appointments; collegium system

01The constitutional issue

Articles 124(2) and 217(1) require the President to appoint judges "after consultation" with the Chief Justice of India and others. In S.P. Gupta (1981) seven judges had held that consultation did not mean concurrence, leaving the final word with the executive.

Petitions about vacancies and delays, and a 1991 referral in Subhash Sharma v. Union of India, brought the question to nine judges: who has primacy in appointing and transferring judges of the higher judiciary?

02The decision

By seven to two the Court overruled S.P. Gupta. J.S. Verma J, for himself and four colleagues, held that the independence of the judiciary is part of the basic structure and that "consultation" must be read to secure it.

In appointments, the opinion of the Chief Justice of India has primacy, but it is an institutional opinion, formed after consulting the two senior-most judges of the Supreme Court. The executive may ask for reconsideration; if the recommendation is reiterated, the appointment must be made. Transfers of High Court judges under Article 222 require the Chief Justice's opinion and are justiciable only on the ground that he was not consulted. The senior-most judge should ordinarily be appointed Chief Justice.

Pandian and Kuldip Singh JJ concurred separately. Ahmadi and Punchhi JJ dissented, holding that the text gave the executive the final say.

03Significance

The judgment moved the appointing power to judges, an arrangement with no close parallel among major constitutional democracies. Its rationale lay in recent memory: the supersession of judges in 1973 and 1977 and the mass transfers of High Court judges during the Emergency.

Critics argue that the Court rewrote a text that says "consultation" and created a self-selecting body that is opaque and answerable to no one; Verma J himself later voiced disquiet at how the system had been worked. Defenders reply that executive primacy had been abused within living memory, and that the realistic alternative was not neutral selection but patronage.

04What happened afterwards

The Third Judges case (1998) widened the collegium to the Chief Justice and four senior-most judges. The 99th Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014 sought to replace the system; the Court struck both down in the NJAC case, restoring the collegium.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: nine judges, 7:2, 6 October 1993; collegium of the Chief Justice and two senior-most judges. In Mains, use it for questions on judicial independence and appointments, weighing independence against accountability.

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

1 question · 2025

  1. 2025 · GS-II · Q13 · 15 marks

    Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Second Judges case in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 6 October 1993. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Abhinav Chandrachud, The Informal Constitution: Unwritten Criteria in Selecting Judges for the Supreme Court of India (Oxford University Press, 2014)
  3. 03Arghya Sengupta, Independence and Accountability of the Indian Higher Judiciary (Cambridge University Press, 2019)
  4. 04Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India, (1993) 4 SCC 441: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India