Section J · Elections and Political Processes
The Anti-Defection Law
The Tenth Schedule was written to stop legislators changing sides for office. Four decades on, the questions are who decides disqualification, how fast, and whether power has passed from legislators to party leaderships.
Overview
The wave of floor-crossing after the 1967 elections, which gave Indian politics the phrase 'Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram', brought down several state governments and made defection a constitutional problem. After failed bills in the 1970s, the 52nd Amendment (1985) added the Tenth Schedule, making a legislator who leaves his or her party, or defies its whip, liable to disqualification. The 91st Amendment (2003) removed the exception for 'splits' and barred defectors from ministerial office until re-elected.
The law assumes that in a parliamentary system voters choose parties as much as candidates. Its critics accept the problem but doubt the cure: the Schedule makes the presiding officer, usually a party politician, the judge of defection, and it binds legislators on every vote, not only on the survival of the government.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Articles 102(2) and 191(2)
- A member disqualified under the Tenth Schedule is disqualified from membership of Parliament or a state legislature.
- Tenth Schedule, paragraph 2
- Disqualification for voluntarily giving up party membership, or for voting or abstaining contrary to the party's direction without permission unless condoned within 15 days; for independents who join a party; and for nominated members who join one more than six months after taking their seat.
- Tenth Schedule, paragraphs 4–7
- No disqualification where two-thirds of a legislature party agree to a merger (4) or for presiding officers who leave their party (5). The Speaker or Chairman decides (6); the bar on courts (7) was held invalid in Kihoto Hollohan (1992).
- Articles 75(1A)–(1B), 164(1A)–(1B) and 361B
- Inserted in 2003: ministries capped at 15 per cent of the lower House (at least 12 in a state), and disqualified defectors barred from ministerial and remunerative political posts until re-elected.
What counts as defection
'Voluntarily giving up membership' need not be a resignation: in Ravi S. Naik v Union of India (1994) the Court held it may be inferred from conduct, such as campaigning for a rival. An expelled member remains bound to the party for the Schedule's purposes (G. Viswanathan v Speaker, Tamil Nadu, 1996). The whip applies to any vote in the House. Votes cast outside the House fall outside the Schedule: Rajya Sabha elections use an open ballot for party members, but cross-voting there attracts party discipline, not disqualification (Kuldip Nayar v Union of India, 2006).
Splits, mergers and resignations
Before 2003 a 'split' by one-third of a legislature party was protected, which encouraged defection in groups. The 91st Amendment removed it, leaving the merger exception, under which two-thirds of the legislature party may merge with another party. Whether the original party must itself merge, or the legislators' decision suffices, has been litigated without a final answer. Mass resignation has become the other route: in 2019 the Karnataka Speaker disqualified seventeen MLAs who had resigned to bring down the government, and the Supreme Court upheld the disqualification but set aside his order barring them from contesting until the end of the assembly's term.
The presiding officer as tribunal
Kihoto Hollohan treated the presiding officer as a tribunal whose decisions are reviewable on limited grounds, such as mala fides, perversity and breach of natural justice, but only after a decision. Delay became the weapon. In Keisham Meghachandra Singh v Speaker, Manipur (2020) the Court said petitions should ordinarily be decided within three months and asked Parliament to consider an independent tribunal. Subhash Desai v Principal Secretary (2023) held that the whip is appointed by the political party, not the legislature party, and referred the Nabam Rebia question, whether a Speaker facing a removal notice may decide petitions, to a larger bench. In Padi Kaushik Reddy v State of Telangana (July 2025) it set the Telangana Speaker a three-month deadline and urged Parliament to revisit the mechanism, later warning of contempt.
Stability and its costs
The law has reduced opportunistic individual defection. Its costs fall on deliberation. Because the whip binds on every vote, a legislator cannot vote against a bill on grounds of conscience or constituency interest without risking the seat, which weakens Parliament as a check on the executive and turns debate into a formality. Party leaderships gain, and since few Indian parties practise internal democracy, power moves to small groups at the top. The demand that drives defection has not gone: it has moved to engineered resignations, mergers and the use of governors and floor tests.
Comparative perspective
Britain has no anti-defection law: members may cross the floor and keep their seats, relying on the electoral cost of disloyalty, as Churchill did twice. South Africa, under a list system in which seats belong more plainly to parties, allowed floor-crossing in fixed windows from 2002 but abolished it by constitutional amendment in 2009, after the windows had mainly benefited the governing party. India's law stands between these poles, and its hardest problem, the impartiality of the adjudicator, is one neither model solves.
Debates
Should the whip bind legislators only on motions that decide a government's survival?
The Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990) proposed limiting disqualification to voluntary defection and to defiance of the whip on motions of confidence and no-confidence. Supporters say this would protect the stability the law was meant to secure while restoring legislators' independent judgement on ordinary legislation. Opponents reply that party government depends on passing its programme, that a narrow whip invites bargaining for votes on major bills, and that voters elect candidates on party manifestos.
Who should decide disqualification petitions?
Keeping the decision with the presiding officer respects the autonomy of the House and the reasoning of the Kihoto majority. The alternatives each carry a cost. A decision by the President or Governor on the Election Commission's advice, as Goswami proposed, could draw the Commission into partisan conflict; an independent tribunal raises questions about appointment; courts would multiply litigation. The judgments since 2020 show the Court managing delay case by case while asking Parliament to choose.
Commissions and committees
Committee on Defections (Y.B. Chavan)1967–69
Studied the post-1967 defections and proposed curbs, including on defectors holding ministerial office; legislation did not follow for over a decade.
Dinesh Goswami Committee on Electoral Reforms1990
Proposed confining disqualification to voluntary defection and defiance of the whip on confidence and no-confidence motions, decided by the President or Governor on the Election Commission's advice.
Law Commission 170th Report and National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution1999 and 2002
Recommended deleting the split exception, which the 91st Amendment did, and barring defectors from office until a fresh mandate.
Prelims points
- The Tenth Schedule was added by the 52nd Amendment Act, 1985.
- The 91st Amendment (2003) deleted the one-third 'split' exception and capped the Council of Ministers at 15 per cent of the lower House.
- The merger exception requires the agreement of two-thirds of the legislature party.
- An independent member is disqualified on joining a party; a nominated member may join one within six months of taking the seat.
- The Speaker or Chairman decides; paragraph 7's bar on judicial review was held invalid in Kihoto Hollohan (1992) for want of state ratification.
- Defiance of a whip may be condoned by the party within 15 days.
- Cross-voting in Rajya Sabha elections does not attract the Tenth Schedule.
- Article 361B bars a disqualified defector from remunerative political posts.
- Keisham Meghachandra Singh (2020): petitions should ordinarily be decided within three months.
In the UPSC papers
Asked by UPSC
1 question · 2026
2026 · GS-II · Q3 · 10 marks
Examine whether the constitutional office of the Lok Sabha Speaker has become vulnerable to partisan politics under the current anti-defection regime. What institutional changes are required to ensure the neutrality of the Lok Sabha Speaker in managing a polarised House ?
Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to The Anti-Defection Law in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
The anti-defection law has curbed individual defections but not the fall of governments through engineered resignations and mergers. Critically examine.
How to approach it
Trace 1967 to the 52nd and 91st Amendments; explain the grounds and the merger exception; use the 2019 Karnataka resignations and Subhash Desai; assess what the law has achieved; propose reforms on the adjudicator and the scope of the whip.
- Q2UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Examine the role of the presiding officer under the Tenth Schedule in the light of recent judgments. Is an independent adjudicator the answer?
How to approach it
Set out Kihoto Hollohan; show the problem of delay through Keisham Meghachandra and Padi Kaushik Reddy; weigh the Speaker, the Election Commission and a tribunal as adjudicators, with the costs of each.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
'The whip should bind a legislator on the survival of a government, not on every vote.' Discuss.
How to approach it
Explain paragraph 2(1)(b); give the deliberative case for a narrow whip and the party-government case against it; refer to Goswami and British practice.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
Concept
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
Amendment
Judgment
Political system
Timeline
Dictionary
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02Kihoto Hollohan v Zachillhu (1992); Keisham Meghachandra Singh v Speaker, Manipur Legislative Assembly (2020); Subhash Desai v Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra (2023); Padi Kaushik Reddy v State of Telangana (2025) (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India
- 03Report of the Committee on Electoral Reforms (Dinesh Goswami Committee). Ministry of Law and Justice, 1990
- 04Law Commission of India, 170th Report: Reform of the Electoral Laws (opens in a new tab). Law Commission of India, 1999
- 05Report of the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution. Ministry of Law and Justice, 2002