Skip to content

The Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003

91st Amendment (2003)

The amendment that capped the size of Councils of Ministers, removed the anti-defection law's "split" exception and barred defectors from office.

01Context

Large Councils of Ministers had become a means of holding coalitions and defectors together, particularly in the States, and the Tenth Schedule's exception for a "split" by one-third of a legislature party was being used to legitimise mass defections. The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (2002) recommended reforms, and the Vajpayee government enacted this amendment in 2003.

02What it changed

  • Articles 75(1A) and 164(1A): the total number of ministers, including the Prime Minister or Chief Minister, may not exceed fifteen per cent of the total members of the Lok Sabha or Assembly; a State's Council must have at least twelve.
  • Articles 75(1B) and 164(1B): a member disqualified for defection may not be appointed a minister until the end of his term or his re-election.
  • Article 361B inserted: a disqualified defector may not hold any remunerative political post for the same period.
  • Paragraph 3 of the Tenth Schedule, which protected a "split" by one-third of a legislature party, omitted.

03Political and constitutional significance

The amendment closed two loopholes in the politics of defection: rewarding defectors with office, and dressing up defections as splits. The merger exception, requiring two-thirds of the legislature party, remains and has itself been used to effect what are in substance defections. The ministerial cap curbed jumbo cabinets, though parliamentary secretaries and similar posts have sometimes been used to circumvent it, a practice several courts have struck down.

Why it matters for UPSC

Candidates should know the fifteen per cent rule and the minimum of twelve for States, the deletion of the split clause, and the ways in which the anti-defection regime continues to be evaded, and should be able to propose reforms.

Sources