Curated comparison · thinkers
Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau
Three social contract theorists who used the same device, a state of nature and an agreement to leave it, to reach absolute sovereignty, limited constitutional government and popular self-legislation.
Framing the comparison
The social contract is a method before it is a doctrine. Each theorist imagines human beings without government, asks what they would be like and why they would agree to political authority, and derives from that agreement the extent and limits of obligation. Because the conclusions follow from the premises, the most useful way to compare Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau is to trace how a different picture of human nature and of the state of nature produces a different sovereign.
The three are not a simple progression towards democracy. Rousseau criticises Locke as sharply as Locke answers Hobbes, and each answers a different political crisis: civil war, royal absolutism and the inequality of a commercial society.
Side by side
Human nature
- Hobbes
Self-interested, fearful and roughly equal in vulnerability, driven by a restless desire for power because security can never be assured.
- Locke
Rational and capable of knowing the law of nature, though partial to oneself and liable to judge one's own case unfairly.
- Rousseau
Naturally good, solitary and moved by self-love and pity; corrupted by society, comparison and amour-propre.
State of nature
- Hobbes
A war of every man against every man in which life is solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short; no justice, property or industry.
- Locke
A state of perfect freedom and equality under the law of nature, with inconveniences (no settled law, impartial judge or enforcement) rather than constant war.
- Rousseau
An original condition of peaceful independence, followed by a social stage in which property and inequality produce conflict.
Why contract
Terms of the contract
- Hobbes
Each covenants with each to authorise a sovereign who is not a party and so cannot breach it; rights are surrendered except self-preservation.
- Locke
Individuals consent to form a society that acts by majority and entrusts power to a government on conditions; natural rights are retained.
- Rousseau
Each gives himself and all his rights wholly to the community, creating a sovereign people that wills through the general will.
Sovereignty
- Hobbes
Absolute, undivided and unlimited, held by a monarch or assembly; division of sovereignty causes civil war.
- Locke
Popular sovereignty in reserve; the legislative is supreme within government but holds power on trust.
- Rousseau
Inalienable, indivisible and unrepresentable sovereignty of the assembled people; government is only its agent.
Liberty
- Hobbes
Absence of external impediments; liberty of subjects lies in the silence of the law; fear and liberty are compatible.
- Locke
Freedom under law, not licence; law preserves and enlarges freedom, and arbitrary power destroys it.
- Rousseau
Civil and moral liberty: obedience to a law one prescribes to oneself; dependence on another's will is the core of unfreedom.
Property
- Hobbes
Created by the sovereign; there is no mine and thine before the commonwealth.
- Locke
A natural right acquired by labour, limited by provisos until money allows unequal accumulation by tacit consent.
- Rousseau
The origin of inequality and conflict; legitimate only as regulated by the general will, with no extremes of wealth and poverty.
Resistance
- Hobbes
No right of rebellion, but a retained right to resist those who come to kill you, and obligation ends when protection fails.
- Locke
The people may resist and replace a government that breaks its trust; the people shall be judge.
- Rousseau
The sovereign people may change the government at will; periodic assemblies should ask whether to keep it.
Legacy
- Hobbes
The theory of the modern sovereign state, realism in international relations and the security–liberty trade-off.
- Locke
Liberal constitutionalism, natural rights, limited government and the Declaration of Independence.
- Rousseau
Popular sovereignty, participatory democracy and egalitarian critique; contested link to the Jacobins and to totalitarian democracy.
Equality
- Hobbes
Natural equality of vulnerability and hope: the weakest can kill the strongest, which is why equality produces war and why all must submit equally to the sovereign.
- Locke
Equality of natural freedom and jurisdiction, no one subject to another's will by nature; compatible with large inequalities of property after money.
- Rousseau
Natural inequalities are slight; moral and political inequality is made by society and property, and liberty requires that no one be rich enough to buy another or poor enough to sell himself.
Religion and the state
- Hobbes
The sovereign decides public worship and doctrine, since disputes over religion had caused civil war; private belief is beyond compulsion.
- Locke
Toleration: the magistrate's authority extends only to civil interests, and churches are voluntary societies; atheists and Catholics excluded.
- Rousseau
A civil religion of a few simple dogmas to attach citizens to the laws, with intolerance as the one forbidden dogma.
What they share
The three share the assumptions that define the contract tradition. Political authority is not natural, as it was for Aristotle, nor given by God to kings through Adam, as Filmer claimed; it is made by human beings and must be justified to them. The justification begins from individuals, imagined before or apart from government, who are by nature free and in some important sense equal. Legitimate authority rests on their agreement, real or hypothetical, and its purpose is to secure goods they cannot secure alone: life, above all, and for Locke and Rousseau liberty and the conditions of equality.
All three use the state of nature as an analytical device, a way of asking what government adds and what it may legitimately demand, even when they also present it as history. All three think in terms of sovereignty, the supreme authority of a single political community, and all three tie obligation to the protection or freedom that authority provides. They share blind spots too: each treats the family and the authority of men within it as largely outside the contract, and each wrote in a Europe whose colonial expansion supplied images of 'natural' peoples. That common ground is what makes their disagreements so instructive: the same method, applied to different premises, yields absolute sovereignty, limited government and popular self-legislation.
The real disagreement
The real fault line is what people are like before government and therefore what government is for. If the natural condition is war, as for Hobbes, any government is better than none and the only question is how to make it strong enough. If the natural condition is a moral order with inconveniences, as for Locke, government is a limited remedy, bound by rights that precede it. If the natural condition was innocent and society itself is the source of corruption, as for Rousseau, the question is not how to protect what people have but how to transform social relations so that dependence and inequality give way to self-legislation. The three also divide on whether the subject of the contract is the individual who keeps rights against the state (Locke), the individual who gives them up to escape fear (Hobbes), or the citizen who exists only within the community the contract creates (Rousseau).
The assumptions underneath
What each side takes for granted about human nature, knowledge, history or the state, and why the disagreement follows from it.
Each conclusion follows from assumptions that are worth stating separately.
- Psychology. Hobbes builds on a mechanistic psychology of appetite and aversion in which fear of violent death is the strongest passion. Locke combines an empiricist account of the mind, formed by experience, with a theistic rationalism in which reason discloses God's law. Rousseau historicises human nature: through perfectibility, human beings acquire their passions in society, so that what Hobbes took as nature is the product of history.
- Method. Hobbes models political science on geometry, resolving society into its elements and recomposing it by deduction. Locke reasons from natural law, scripture and observation. Rousseau proceeds by conjectural history, 'setting aside the facts' to reconstruct how inequality could have arisen.
- History. For Hobbes the state of nature is a permanent possibility, visible in civil war and in relations between sovereigns. For Locke it is partly historical and still exists between sovereigns and in America. For Rousseau the movement out of it is a history of corruption, and the contract is a remedy for what society has done.
- Theology. Locke's argument depends on God's ownership of his creatures; Hobbes treats the laws of nature as theorems of reason that bind fully only within a commonwealth; Rousseau joins a natural religion of conscience to a civil religion for citizens.
- The state. Hobbes's sovereign is an artificial person authorised to act for all; Locke's government is a trustee bound by its purpose; Rousseau's sovereign is the people itself, a moral body that transforms its members into citizens.
Using the comparison in an answer
Build answers dimension by dimension rather than thinker by thinker: a short table of human nature, state of nature, contract, sovereignty and resistance shows the logic of the tradition in a few lines. Then connect each to a modern problem. Hobbes frames emergency powers and the anarchy of the international system; Locke frames the rule of law, property rights and judicial review, and his property theory is the hinge of the Rawls–Nozick debate; Rousseau frames participatory democracy and majoritarianism. Add the critiques that apply to all three: Hume's attack on consent, Pateman's sexual contract and the postcolonial critique of the settler contract. In Indian answers, the basic structure doctrine, the history of the right to property and the gram sabha each illustrate one of the three.
Practice questions
- Q1PSIR style20 marks· 250 words
"The social contract theorists agree on method and disagree on everything else." Discuss with reference to Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau.
How to approach it
State of nature, reasons for contract, terms and resulting sovereign for each; show how premises produce conclusions; note shared assumptions (consent, individualism) and common critiques.
- Q2PSIR style15 marks· 200 words
Compare the concepts of sovereignty in Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau.
How to approach it
Absolute and indivisible; popular in reserve with legislative trust; inalienable general will; implications for representation and resistance.
- Q3PSIR style15 marks· 200 words
Which of the three contract theorists offers the most adequate account of political obligation? Justify your answer.
How to approach it
Protection and obedience; consent and trust; self-legislation; Hume's and Pateman's objections; reasoned choice with acknowledgement of costs.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Sources
- 01Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan (1651)
- 02John Locke, Two Treatises of Government (1689)
- 03Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Discourse on Inequality (1755) and The Social Contract (1762)
- 04Michael Lessnoff, Social Contract (1986)
- 05Carole Pateman, The Sexual Contract (1988)
- 06David Hume, 'Of the Original Contract' (1748)
Last reviewed