Curated comparison · thinkers
Plato and Aristotle
Teacher and student on the same questions, justice, the best regime, property and the claims of the many, answered from opposite starting points: knowledge of the ideal, and the study of what cities actually are.
Framing the comparison
The contrast between Plato and Aristotle is usually put as idealism against realism. That is a starting point, not an answer. Aristotle also describes an ideal city in Books VII and VIII of the Politics, and Plato's Laws designs a practicable second-best regime governed by law. The deeper difference concerns where political knowledge comes from: from philosophical insight into an unchanging Form of the Good, which ordinary opinion cannot reach, or from the practical wisdom of experienced citizens and the comparative study of many constitutions.
Aristotle wrote the Politics partly as a critique of the Republic, so the comparison has a textual basis that most comparisons lack. Use it in answers on justice, the ideal state, property, the rule of law and democracy.
Side by side
Method
- Plato
Deductive and dialectical: begin from the question 'what is justice?' and construct a city in speech to answer it. Knowledge of the Forms grounds political judgement.
- Aristotle
Inductive and comparative: collect the constitutions of many cities, begin from reputable opinions, and refine them. Politics is a practical science of the probable, not a demonstrative one.
Human nature and the city
- Plato
The city arises from need and the division of labour; souls differ in their dominant part, reason, spirit or appetite, and so people suit different functions.
- Aristotle
The human being is by nature a political animal, fulfilled only in the polis. The city exists for the good life, and speech makes moral partnership possible.
Justice
- Plato
Justice is harmony: each part of the soul and each class of the city does its own work. It is an internal order before it is a rule of conduct.
- Aristotle
Justice is proportionate equality: distributive justice by merit, corrective justice by arithmetical restoration. Each constitution embodies a disputed idea of who deserves what.
The best regime
- Plato
The ideal city ruled by philosopher-guardians, realisable only if philosophers rule; in the Laws, a second-best mixed constitution under law.
- Aristotle
The absolutely best regime presupposes ideal conditions; the best for most cities is the polity, a mixture of oligarchy and democracy resting on a strong middle class.
Property and family
Knowledge or law
Democracy and the many
- Plato
Democracy confuses freedom with licence, flatters the crowd and ends in tyranny. Political skill is expertise, like navigation, and most people lack it.
- Aristotle
The many may judge better collectively than the few, as a feast with many contributors surpasses one paid for by a single host. Democratic institutions belong in a balanced constitution.
Unity of the city
Women and slaves
- Plato
Women of the guardian class receive the same education and offices as men, a radical proposal that serves the unity of the city rather than women's freedom.
- Aristotle
Women have the deliberative faculty but without authority; some people are slaves by nature. The exclusions follow from his teleology.
Education
- Plato
A state-directed education in music, gymnastics, mathematics and dialectic selects and forms the guardians; poetry that misrepresents the gods or encourages vice is censored.
- Aristotle
Education must be public and suited to the constitution, since citizens should be formed in its spirit; Politics VIII discusses music and gymnastics as training for leisure and character.
Change and decline
- Plato
The ideal city decays through a fixed sequence, timocracy, oligarchy, democracy and tyranny, as each regime's principle corrupts the soul of its citizens (Republic VIII–IX).
- Aristotle
Revolutions arise from disputes about equality and from particular causes such as profit, honour, fear and disproportionate growth; in Politics V he criticises the Republic's sequence as too schematic and too little attentive to actual cases.
What they share
Teacher and student agree on the questions that make their answers comparable. Both hold that politics exists for the sake of living well, the cultivation of virtue, and not merely for security or exchange; both reject the sophist Thrasymachus's claim that justice is the interest of the stronger, and the view, which Aristotle attributes to Lycophron, that law is only a guarantee of mutual claims. Both treat the city as an educative community whose laws and upbringing form the character of its citizens, so that education is a central political question for each.
Both think teleologically, judging things by the ends they serve, and both rank constitutions by who rules and in whose interest: the classification of correct and deviant regimes that Aristotle developed appears already in Plato's Statesman. Both distrust democracy as rule by the poor, and both regard tyranny as the worst regime. And both accept that human beings differ in their capacity for reason, so that full participation in rule is not open to all, although they draw the line in different places. Their disagreement is the more instructive because it takes place within this shared framework.
The real disagreement
The fault line is the status of practical judgement. For Plato, politics needs a kind of knowledge that ordinary citizens cannot have, so the rule of opinion, whether of the many or the rich, is always a corruption, and the task of politics is to subordinate opinion to wisdom. For Aristotle, political knowledge is practical wisdom (phronesis), formed by experience and exercised among equals, so the opinions of citizens are the material of political judgement, not its enemy. This is why Plato values unity and Aristotle plurality, why Plato distrusts law and Aristotle prefers it, and why Plato can only tolerate democracy as a symptom of decline while Aristotle builds democratic elements into his best practicable constitution.
The assumptions underneath
What each side takes for granted about human nature, knowledge, history or the state, and why the disagreement follows from it.
Their differences follow from different assumptions.
- Knowledge and reality. Plato holds that true knowledge is of unchanging Forms, above all the Form of the Good, which only philosophers can grasp; opinion, however widely shared, is not knowledge. Aristotle rejects separate Forms: form exists in things, ethics and politics are practical sciences, and, as the Nicomachean Ethics puts it, one should seek only the precision the subject allows.
- The soul. Plato's tripartite soul, in which reason, spirit or appetite rules, grounds his classes of rulers, auxiliaries and producers. Aristotle also distinguishes rational and non-rational parts but stresses habituation: virtue is formed by practice under good laws, and practical wisdom is acquired by experience.
- Experience. Plato wrote after Athens lost the Peloponnesian War, suffered the Thirty Tyrants and then, under restored democracy, executed Socrates in 399 BCE; his distrust of rule by opinion reflects that history. Aristotle, a resident alien who studied many constitutions, wrote from the comparative observation of cities that worked tolerably well.
- Household and city. Plato's Statesman treats the knowledge of the statesman, king, master and household manager as one; Aristotle opens the Politics by rejecting that view, distinguishing rule over equals from rule in the household. That distinction underlies his defence of plurality, private property and the rule of law.
- Method. Plato reasons dialectically towards an ideal and judges actual cities by their distance from it; Aristotle begins from reputable opinions and existing constitutions and asks what is best in the circumstances.
Using the comparison in an answer
In an answer, avoid the slogan 'Plato the idealist, Aristotle the realist'. Show that both seek the good life and both rank regimes, then locate the difference in method and in the place of knowledge in rule. Use the Laws to show Plato's movement towards law and mixture, and Politics VII–VIII to show Aristotle's ideal. Bring the comparison forward: Plato is the ancestor of arguments for expert rule and epistocracy, Aristotle of arguments for the wisdom of the many, the rule of law and the mixed constitution. On property, the contrast frames later debates from Marx to Indian land reform; on justice, Aristotle's proportionate equality underlies the jurisprudence of reasonable classification and substantive equality.
Practice questions
- Q1PSIR style15 marks· 200 words
Examine Aristotle's critique of Plato's communism of property and family.
How to approach it
Plato's purpose (unity and incorruptibility); Aristotle's arguments on unity, care and affection; private ownership with common use; a modern parallel.
- Q2PSIR style15 marks· 200 words
"Plato wanted the rule of wisdom; Aristotle settled for the rule of law." Discuss.
How to approach it
Philosopher-ruler and the Statesman's second-best; Aristotle's law as reason without passion and equity; whether 'settled' understates Aristotle's positive case.
- Q3PSIR style20 marks· 250 words
Compare the views of Plato and Aristotle on democracy. Which is more persuasive today?
How to approach it
Ship of state and degeneration; the wisdom of the many and polity; epistocracy and deliberative democracy as modern heirs; a reasoned judgement.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Sources
- 01Plato, Republic, Statesman and Laws
- 02Aristotle, Politics and Nicomachean Ethics
- 03Ernest Barker, Greek Political Theory: Plato and His Predecessors (1918)
- 04Malcolm Schofield, Plato: Political Philosophy (2006)
- 05Richard Kraut, Aristotle: Political Philosophy (2002)
Last reviewed