Curated comparison · theories
Feminism and postcolonialism
Two critical approaches that ask whose experience mainstream theory treats as universal: feminism foregrounds gender, postcolonialism empire and race, and postcolonial feminism questions both.
Framing the comparison
Feminism and postcolonialism entered political theory and international relations as critical approaches in the last decades of the twentieth century. Feminist political theory, from Carole Pateman's critique of the social contract to bell hooks, and feminist IR, from J. Ann Tickner and Cynthia Enloe in the late 1980s, asked where women were in theories of the state, war and economy. Postcolonial theory took shape with Edward Said's Orientalism (1978), the Subaltern Studies collective founded by Ranajit Guha in 1982 and the work of Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak and Homi Bhabha, building on Fanon and the experience of decolonisation; decolonial thinkers such as Walter Mignolo extend it.
Both are families rather than single theories, and both criticise the false universality of mainstream knowledge: the "rational man" of liberal theory, the sovereign state of realism, the history of Europe presented as the history of the world. Both link knowledge to power and centre the marginalised. The IB guide lists both among the critical theories students should review, and PSIR names post-colonial and feminist theories of the state.
Side by side
Central question
- Feminist approaches
How does gender structure politics, and what changes when we ask, with Enloe, "where are the women?"
- Postcolonial approaches
How did empire shape the modern world and the knowledge we use to understand it, and who can speak for the colonised?
Key categories
- Feminist approaches
Gender as a social construction of masculinity and femininity; patriarchy; the public/private divide; care and social reproduction.
- Postcolonial approaches
Empire, race and coloniality; the construction of the "Other"; subalternity; hybridity.
Critique of mainstream theory
- Feminist approaches
Realism's rational, autonomous actor and its separation of politics from morality reflect masculine ideals; liberal contract theory presupposes women's subordination in the family.
- Postcolonial approaches
The discipline universalises a European history of sovereign states and hides the imperial and racial origins of IR, as scholars such as Robert Vitalis and John Hobson have argued.
The state
- Feminist approaches
Liberal feminists see the state as a potential ally; radical feminists such as Catharine MacKinnon see it as male in its norms; Pateman traces a sexual contract beneath the social contract.
- Postcolonial approaches
The post-colonial state inherits colonial institutions of control: Hamza Alavi's "overdeveloped" state, Fanon's national bourgeoisie, Partha Chatterjee's passive revolution.
Knowledge and power
- Feminist approaches
Standpoint epistemology holds that knowledge built from women's lives reveals what dominant perspectives miss; research must be reflexive about the researcher's position.
- Postcolonial approaches
Western knowledge of others is bound up with domination (Said's Orientalism), and Spivak's "Can the Subaltern Speak?" (1988) asks whether the subaltern can be represented at all.
Security and violence
- Feminist approaches
Security must include freedom from gendered and structural violence; militarism depends on gender norms; Security Council Resolution 1325 (2000) institutionalised part of this agenda.
- Postcolonial approaches
Colonialism was founded on violence (Fanon); the security problems of post-colonial states are often internal legacies of empire; the "war on terror" revived Orientalist images.
Agency and resistance
- Feminist approaches
Women's movements, transnational advocacy networks and gender mainstreaming, from the Beijing conference of 1995 onward.
- Postcolonial approaches
Anti-colonial nationalism, subaltern resistance studied by Guha and his colleagues, and projects to decolonise knowledge and curricula.
Indian applications
- Feminist approaches
The report Towards Equality (1974) revealed women's declining status after independence; later struggles produced reservation in local bodies, the Vishaka guidelines and debates on personal law.
- Postcolonial approaches
Subaltern Studies rewrote Indian history from below; Ashis Nandy's The Intimate Enemy (1983) showed how colonialism reshaped Indian ideas of masculinity, a bridge to feminist analysis.
Main limitations
- Feminist approaches
Risk of universalising the experience of Western, middle-class women and of treating "women" as a single category, as Chandra Talpade Mohanty argued.
- Postcolonial approaches
Critics such as Aijaz Ahmad and Vivek Chibber charge it with textualism and neglect of political economy; it can romanticise the native and overlook gender.
Internal variants
- Feminist approaches
Liberal feminism seeks equal rights and opportunities within existing institutions; socialist and Marxist feminism links patriarchy to capitalism and social reproduction; radical feminism treats sexual domination as the root form of power; postmodern and queer feminism question the category 'woman' itself.
- Postcolonial approaches
Marxist strands, including the early Subaltern Studies and Aijaz Ahmad, stress capitalism and class; post-structuralist strands, Said, Spivak and Bhabha, stress discourse, representation and hybridity; decolonial thinkers such as Mignolo locate the problem in a 'coloniality' of knowledge dating from 1492.
What they share
The two approaches share more than a critical temper. Both deny that mainstream theory is neutral: the 'individual' of liberalism and the 'state' of realism were built from particular experiences, of propertied European men and of European states, and then presented as universal. Both hold that knowledge and power are connected, so that the question of who produces knowledge, from where and for whom, is part of the analysis rather than a preface to it. Both begin from those at the margins, women and the colonised, and from places the discipline ignored: the household, the plantation, the factory floor, the colonial archive.
Both grew out of political movements, the women's movements and the anti-colonial struggles, and both keep an emancipatory purpose: they study domination in order to change it. Both are families of positions rather than single theories, each with liberal, Marxist and post-structuralist strands, and both have been accused of the same fault from the other side, of speaking for those whose experience they claim to recover. That shared ground is why their disagreement matters: each is the other's most searching critic.
The real disagreement
The sharpest tension concerns universalism. Feminists often make universal claims, that women's rights are human rights, while postcolonial critics suspect that universal language has served empire. Spivak's phrase about "white men saving brown women from brown men", written about the British abolition of sati, captures how feminist arguments can license imperial rule; similar arguments accompanied the intervention in Afghanistan in 2001. Mohanty's essay "Under Western Eyes" criticised Western feminist scholarship for presenting "Third World women" as passive victims. The tension runs the other way as well: anti-colonial nationalism often postponed women's emancipation, and Chatterjee described how Indian nationalists "resolved" the women's question by locating women in an inner, spiritual domain of tradition.
The assumptions underneath
What each side takes for granted about human nature, knowledge, history or the state, and why the disagreement follows from it.
The disagreements rest on different assumptions about five things.
- The primary axis of domination. Feminism treats gender as a basic structure of power present in every society; postcolonialism treats empire and race as the structures that made the modern world. Intersectional theorists deny that either can be ranked first, holding that they constitute each other.
- Experience and representation. Standpoint feminism assumes that the experience of the oppressed can ground better knowledge. Post-structuralist postcolonial theory, especially Spivak, doubts that the experience of the subaltern can be represented without being reshaped by whoever does the representing, including the sympathetic scholar.
- History. Feminist accounts of patriarchy often reach back across many societies and centuries; postcolonial accounts are anchored in a specific modern history of European expansion, so that 'coloniality' names a feature of modernity itself.
- Universalism and the Enlightenment. Liberal feminism inherits the Enlightenment language of rights and equal humanity; postcolonial critics see the same language accompanying conquest and the 'civilising mission', though Fanon and Said both ended by calling for a renewed humanism rather than abandoning universal claims.
- Agency and the state. Liberal feminism tends to equate agency with autonomy and resistance, and to see the state as an instrument of reform. Saba Mahmood (Politics of Piety, 2005) and Lila Abu-Lughod ('Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving?', 2002) argued that this misreads women whose agency takes religious or communal forms. Postcolonial thinkers also value sovereignty as a hard-won defence against outside rule, while feminists are wary of a sovereignty that has often been exercised by men in the name of the nation.
Using the comparison in an answer
The two approaches meet in postcolonial feminism (Mohanty, Spivak, Uma Narayan) and in intersectionality, the term Kimberlé Crenshaw introduced in 1989 for the way race and gender compound each other. bell hooks' Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center (1984) made a similar case from Black American experience, and decolonial feminists speak of the coloniality of gender. In India, Gopal Guru's argument that Dalit women "talk differently" extended the critique to caste. For analysis, the combined lens is especially useful in the IB course's attention to the most affected groups and in PSIR answers on feminist and post-colonial theories of the state: it asks not only who holds power but whose experience the categories of analysis were built from.
Practice questions
- Q1PSIR style20 marks· 250 words
Compare the feminist and post-colonial theories of the state.
How to approach it
Set out liberal, radical and socialist feminist views and the overdeveloped-state and passive-revolution arguments; identify common ground in critiques of neutrality; apply to India.
- Q2PSIR style15 marks· 200 words
"Can the subaltern speak?" Discuss Spivak's question and its implications for feminist politics in post-colonial societies.
How to approach it
Explain the problem of representation and the sati example; connect to Mohanty and Dalit feminism; assess the implications for policy and advocacy.
- Q3IB Paper 2 style15 marks
To what extent do feminist and postcolonial perspectives reveal power relations that mainstream theories overlook?
How to approach it
Apply both lenses to one case, such as a conflict, a development project or a migration issue; compare with realist or liberal analysis; evaluate the limits of each critical lens.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Sources
- 01Edward W. Said, Orientalism (1978)
- 02Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, 'Can the Subaltern Speak?' (1988)
- 03Chandra Talpade Mohanty, 'Under Western Eyes: Feminist Scholarship and Colonial Discourses' (1984)
- 04J. Ann Tickner, Gender in International Relations (1992)
- 05Cynthia Enloe, Bananas, Beaches and Bases (1989)
- 06Carole Pateman, The Sexual Contract (1988)
- 07Ashis Nandy, The Intimate Enemy (1983)
- 08Saba Mahmood, Politics of Piety: The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject (2005)
- 09Lila Abu-Lughod, 'Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving?', American Anthropologist (2002)
- 10Uma Narayan, Dislocating Cultures: Identities, Traditions, and Third World Feminism (1997)
Last reviewed