Curated comparison · thinkers
Marx and Gramsci
The founder of historical materialism and his most original twentieth-century reinterpreter, compared on the state, ideology, revolution and the place of culture in the reproduction of capitalism.
Framing the comparison
Gramsci did not reject Marx; he asked a question Marx's own predictions forced on Marxists. If capitalism generates the contradictions that make revolution likely, why did revolution succeed in backward Russia and fail in the advanced West, where workers instead supported reformist parties and even fascism? Gramsci's answer was that rule in developed capitalist societies rests on consent organised through civil society as well as on coercion. Comparing the two is therefore a way of asking how far Marxism must change to explain the stability of the societies it criticises.
The comparison should not be made into a contrast between an 'economic' Marx and a 'cultural' Gramsci. Marx wrote subtle political history, and Gramsci's concept of the historic bloc insists on the unity of economy and ideology.
Side by side
Base and superstructure
- Marx
The economic structure is the real foundation on which legal and political superstructures rise; social being determines consciousness, though Engels later said only 'in the last instance'.
- Gramsci
The historic bloc unites structure and superstructure; ideologies are material forces that organise masses, and politics is not a reflex of economics.
The state
- Marx
An organ of class rule, a committee of the bourgeoisie in the Manifesto, capable of relative autonomy when classes are balanced, as under Bonaparte.
- Gramsci
The integral state: political society plus civil society, hegemony protected by the armour of coercion. The state educates as well as coerces.
Ideology and consent
Civil society
Strategy of revolution
Agents of change
Intellectuals
Determinism and agency
- Marx
Men make their own history, but not as they please, under circumstances transmitted from the past; read by the Second International as economic inevitability.
- Gramsci
Rejects fatalism: collective will and political organisation decide outcomes within structural limits; 'pessimism of the intellect, optimism of the will'.
Philosophy and method
- Marx
Historical materialism and the critique of political economy: the laws of motion of capitalism, analysed in Capital, explain its crises and its political forms.
- Gramsci
The 'philosophy of praxis': an absolute historicism that reads ideas, institutions and strategies in their historical setting, and studies culture, education and language as fields of political struggle.
What they share
Gramsci called Marxism the 'philosophy of praxis', and he never doubted its core. Both thinkers analyse society through class: capitalism rests on the exploitation of labour, the state is not a neutral arbiter, and the end of class rule is the goal of politics. Both reject the liberal separation of politics from the economy, and both hold, with Marx's sixth thesis on Feuerbach, that the human essence is the ensemble of social relations, not a fixed nature. Both join theory to practice in the spirit of the eleventh thesis, that the point is not only to interpret the world but to change it: Marx in the Communist League and the First International, Gramsci in the factory councils and the Communist Party of Italy.
Both also reject a purely mechanical history. Marx's political writings, from The Eighteenth Brumaire onwards, show politics and ideas shaping outcomes, and he wrote that theory becomes a material force once it grips the masses, a line Gramsci developed. Their disagreement is therefore within one tradition: about the relative weight of economy, politics and culture, and about what the failure of revolution in the West required Marxists to rethink.
The real disagreement
The fault line is where the decisive struggle takes place and what holds an unjust order together. For Marx, the core of capitalist domination is located in the relations of production, and political and ideological forms, though important, are ultimately explained by them; the contradictions of capitalism create the conditions for its overthrow. For Gramsci, domination in advanced societies is secured above all through hegemony in civil society, so that economic crisis alone will not produce revolution and may produce reaction. Gramsci shifts the burden from historical necessity to political and cultural construction. Critics from both sides press the point: Althusser and structuralists thought Gramsci dissolved Marxist science into historicism, while Abercrombie, Hill and Turner argued that subordinate classes are held in place more by economic compulsion than by ideological consent.
The assumptions underneath
What each side takes for granted about human nature, knowledge, history or the state, and why the disagreement follows from it.
The differences rest on different assumptions, several of them historical.
- The epoch. Marx analysed the competitive capitalism of the mid-nineteenth century, with narrow suffrage, small states and weak mass organisations. Gramsci wrote after the arrival of mass parties, mass schooling, a mass press, trade unions and Fordist industry, in which the institutions of civil society had multiplied, and much of his innovation follows from that change.
- Knowledge. Marx presented his work as a science of history and a critique of political economy. Gramsci, shaped by Croce and Labriola, held a historicist view in which truth is tied to historical practice and Marxism is itself the self-consciousness of a class, a view Althusser later attacked.
- Causation. Marx's 1859 Preface gives the economic structure a foundational role, qualified by Engels as determination 'in the last instance'. Gramsci treats structure and superstructure as a reciprocal unity, the historic bloc, in which ideologies are themselves material forces.
- The state. For Marx the state is primarily the coercive and administrative organ of class rule. Gramsci assumes an expanded, educative state that reaches into schools, churches and culture, so that its power cannot be located in government alone.
- Will and consciousness. Both see human beings as historical, but Gramsci, closer to Croce and Sorel, gives greater weight to will, organisation and the formation of a collective consciousness, which is why the party and intellectuals carry so much weight in his account.
Using the comparison in an answer
Use the comparison to answer questions on the Marxist theory of the state, ideology and hegemony, and on the PSIR unit on power. A strong answer shows continuity (class analysis, the critique of the liberal state, the goal of socialism) before difference (consent, civil society, intellectuals and strategy). In Indian applications, Marx's political economy informs the debates on agrarian class relations and planning, while Gramsci's concepts power Subaltern Studies, Partha Chatterjee's reading of the post-colonial state as passive revolution and analyses of how caste and religious nationalism become common sense. In international relations, the neo-Gramscian reading of hegemony as consensual leadership complements the Marxist theory of imperialism.
Practice questions
- Q1PSIR style20 marks· 250 words
"Gramsci's concept of hegemony fills a gap in Marx's theory of the state." Examine.
How to approach it
Marx's instrumental and Bonapartist accounts; Gramsci's integral state; consent and coercion; Anderson's antinomies; whether the gap was real.
- Q2PSIR style15 marks· 200 words
Compare Marx and Gramsci on the role of ideology in sustaining capitalism.
How to approach it
Ruling ideas and fetishism; hegemony and common sense; intellectuals; the dominant ideology critique.
- Q3PSIR style10 marks· 150 words
Why did Gramsci argue that revolution in the West required a war of position?
How to approach it
East and West; civil society as trenches; contrast with Marx's and Lenin's expectations; an example.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Sources
- 01Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, The German Ideology and Manifesto of the Communist Party
- 02Karl Marx, Preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (1859)
- 03Antonio Gramsci, Selections from the Prison Notebooks (1971)
- 04Perry Anderson, 'The Antinomies of Antonio Gramsci' (1976)
- 05Nicholas Abercrombie, Stephen Hill and Bryan S. Turner, The Dominant Ideology Thesis (1980)
Last reviewed