Section K · Governance
Public Policy
How policy is made, implemented and judged in India: the institutions of policy-making after the Planning Commission, the main theories of the policy process, and the persistent gap between what is announced and what reaches citizens.
Overview
Thomas Dye defined public policy as 'whatever governments choose to do or not to do' (Understanding Public Policy, 1972), a definition that includes inaction as a choice. Policy studies ask how problems reach the agenda, how options are chosen, how decisions are carried out and how results are judged. 'Public policy' appears by name in the Prelims syllabus, and in GS-II it underlies every question on government interventions and their design.
In India policy is made by many hands: the Union Cabinet and ministries, NITI Aayog, the states, federal bodies such as the GST Council and the Finance Commission, Parliament and its committees, and the courts through public interest litigation. The recurring diagnosis, from the Planning Commission's own evaluations to present-day studies, is that India designs policies better than it implements them.
Constitutional and legal provisions
- Articles 73, 77, 162 and 166
- The executive power of the Union and the states, and the rules of business through which ministries and departments allocate and transact work.
- Article 37
- Directive Principles are fundamental in the governance of the country and the state must apply them in making laws, though they are not enforceable in court.
- Articles 263, 279A and 280
- Forums of federal policy coordination: the Inter-State Council, the GST Council (101st Amendment, 2016) and the Finance Commission.
- Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy, 2014
- Draft legislation should be published, with a summary, for at least 30 days of public comment before it is sent to Cabinet; compliance is uneven.
The policy process: stages and their limits
The textbook 'policy cycle', descended from Harold Lasswell, runs from agenda-setting through formulation, decision and implementation to evaluation. It is a useful checklist but a poor description, since real policy moves back and forth between stages. John Kingdon's multiple-streams framework (Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies, 1984) explains agenda-setting better: a problem stream, a policy stream of available solutions and a politics stream of moods and elections run independently until a 'policy window' opens and an entrepreneur couples them. India's RTI Act fits the model: a solution drafted by activists, a problem made visible by corruption scandals, and a window when a new coalition came to power in 2004.
Rationality, incrementalism and planning
Herbert Simon's Administrative Behavior (1947), the source of the idea of bounded rationality, holds that decision-makers satisfice rather than optimise, because information and attention are limited. Charles Lindblom's 'The Science of "Muddling Through"' (1959) argued that most policy proceeds by small adjustments negotiated among interests, which is not a failure of rationality but a way of avoiding large errors. Amitai Etzioni's 'mixed scanning' (1967) combined broad review with incremental steps. Indian planning began in the comprehensive mode of the Five-Year Plans; since NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission in 2015, the style has mixed long-term 'visions' with incremental schemes and occasional sudden, large decisions taken with little consultation.
Who makes policy after the Planning Commission
The Planning Commission, set up by a Cabinet resolution in March 1950, combined advice with control over plan grants to states. NITI Aayog, created by resolution on 1 January 2015, is a think tank without financial powers; its Governing Council brings the Prime Minister and Chief Ministers together, and its Development Monitoring and Evaluation Office evaluates schemes. Fiscal transfers now run mainly through the Finance Commission and ministries' centrally sponsored schemes. Parliament's role in scrutiny has weakened as fewer bills are referred to committees, which moves deliberation from the legislature to the executive and, when it fails there, to the street or the courts.
Implementation: the policy that reaches the citizen
Jeffrey Pressman and Aaron Wildavsky's Implementation (1973) showed how a programme fails as the number of agencies whose agreement it needs multiplies. Michael Lipsky's Street-Level Bureaucracy (1980) located policy in the discretion of teachers, health workers and revenue clerks, who ration time and benefits under pressure. Akhil Gupta's Red Tape (2012) describes the arbitrariness that results for India's poor, while Akshay Mangla's Making Bureaucracy Work (2022) shows that bureaucratic norms, more than resources, explain why similar schemes succeed in one state and fail in another. Implementation is therefore not a technical afterthought but a second round of policy-making.
Evidence and evaluation
India created a Programme Evaluation Organisation in 1952, and outcome budgets have been published since 2005. Randomised evaluations have influenced programmes in education and welfare delivery, and the Economic Survey of 2018–19 drew on behavioural economics to argue for 'nudges'. The politics of evidence is also visible: in 2019 the Union decided not to release the 2017–18 consumer expenditure survey, citing data quality, which left a gap from 2011–12 to 2022–23 in official household consumption data, the basis of poverty estimates. Good evaluation needs independent agencies, published data and a willingness to close schemes that do not work.
Debates
Should courts make policy when legislatures and executives fail?
Public interest litigation produced the Vishaka guidelines on sexual harassment, midday meals and the right to food, and forest and pollution regimes, filling gaps left by inactive governments. Pratap Bhanu Mehta's 'The Rise of Judicial Sovereignty' (Journal of Democracy, 2007) warned that courts lack the expertise, accountability and capacity to implement policy, and that judicial policy-making weakens the incentive for democratic institutions to act. The case-by-case answer turns on whether a fundamental right is at stake and whether the court can supervise what it orders.
Evidence-based policy: better decisions or depoliticised ones?
Rigorous evaluation reveals what works and saves money on what does not. Angus Deaton and Nancy Cartwright (2018) cautioned that randomised trials tell us what worked in one setting, not why or whether it will work elsewhere, and critics add that 'evidence' can be used to present value choices as technical findings. Evidence informs policy best when it is plural, public and joined to democratic deliberation.
Commissions and committees
Second Administrative Reforms Commission, 13th Report: Organisational Structure of Government of India2009
Recommended grouping ministries into coherent clusters, separating policy-making from implementation and strengthening coordination.
Committee of Secretaries: Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy2014
Adopted the rule that draft bills be published for at least 30 days of public comment.
Prelims points
- Thomas Dye: public policy is 'whatever governments choose to do or not to do'.
- Charles Lindblom's incrementalism: 'The Science of "Muddling Through"' (1959).
- John Kingdon's multiple-streams framework appeared in 1984.
- Michael Lipsky coined 'street-level bureaucracy' (1980).
- The Planning Commission was set up by Cabinet resolution in March 1950; NITI Aayog on 1 January 2015.
- NITI Aayog's Governing Council includes the Prime Minister and the Chief Ministers of all states.
- The GST Council (Article 279A) decides by three-fourths of weighted votes: the Union one-third, the states two-thirds.
- The Pre-Legislative Consultation Policy (2014) asks for 30 days of public comment on draft bills.
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Most policy failures in India are failures of implementation rather than design. Critically examine with examples.
How to approach it
Use Pressman–Wildavsky and Lipsky; give examples where implementation failed and where design itself was flawed; show how design anticipates implementation; conclude that the two are inseparable.
- Q2UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Has NITI Aayog changed how policy is made in India's federal system? Assess.
How to approach it
Compare it with the Planning Commission; examine the Governing Council, evaluation and indices; weigh its advisory character against the Finance Commission and centrally sponsored schemes.
- Q3UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Explain Kingdon's multiple-streams framework and apply it to any one major Indian policy reform.
How to approach it
Define the three streams, the window and the entrepreneur; apply to the RTI Act or GST.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.
Explore further
Concept
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 73 · Extent of executive power of the Union
- Article 77 · Conduct of business of the Government of India
- Article 162 · Extent of executive power of State
- Article 166 · Conduct of Business of the Government of a State
- Article 37 · Application of the principles contained in this Part
- Article 263 · Provisions with respect to an inter-State Council
- Article 279A · Goods and Services Tax Council
- Article 280 · Finance Commission
Amendment
Judgment
Sources
- 01The Constitution of India (as amended) (opens in a new tab). Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice
- 02NITI Aayog (opens in a new tab)
- 03Thomas R. Dye, Understanding Public Policy (Prentice Hall, 1972)
- 04John W. Kingdon, Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies (Little, Brown, 1984)
- 05Michael Lipsky, Street-Level Bureaucracy (Russell Sage Foundation, 1980)
- 06Akshay Mangla, Making Bureaucracy Work: Norms, Education and Public Service Delivery in Rural India (Cambridge University Press, 2022)
- 07Pratap Bhanu Mehta, 'The Rise of Judicial Sovereignty', Journal of Democracy 18(2) (2007)